Key points
- Retail fraud is a specific-intent crime, and the prosecutor must prove intent beyond a reasonable doubt; the defendant does not have to prove anything.[1][2]
- Taking property because of an honest belief in a right to take or use it is not larceny, even if the belief was mistaken.[3]
- Voluntary intoxication is not a defense to any crime, with a narrow exception for unexpected effects of properly used medication.[4][5]
- Retail fraud, larceny and embezzlement charges must be filed within 6 years, and time the accused lived outside Michigan does not count.[6][7][8]
A defense to a retail fraud or theft charge is a legal reason the prosecutor cannot prove the crime, or a rule that bars the charge or the evidence. Because the prosecutor must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt and the defendant is not required to prove anything, several of the defenses below work by showing that an element, such as intent, value or identity, has not been proved.[2]
This page describes the defenses Michigan law recognizes for these charges and the rules behind them. It does not say which defense fits a given case or predict how any case will come out; those are questions for the defendant and a lawyer. The elements themselves are explained on the elements page.
Lack of intent
The use notes to all three retail fraud jury instructions state that the statutory language makes the offense a specific-intent crime.[1] For retail fraud by theft, the prosecutor must prove the defendant intended to steal the property, meaning to take it permanently from the store without its consent.[9] For price switching, the defendant must have intended to pay less than the price or nothing, and for false exchange, to defraud or cheat the store.[10][11]
For larceny, the prosecutor must prove that at the time of the taking the defendant intended to permanently deprive the owner of the property, which includes keeping it without a purpose to return it within a reasonable time.[12][13] Moving property is a separate element from intent: the retail fraud instruction says any movement is enough for the movement element, so the question of intent still has to be proved on its own.[14][9]
Claim of right and honest mistake
Under Michigan's model instruction, taking property because the person honestly believes he or she has the right to take or use it is not larceny, even if the person was mistaken.[3] In bad check cases, the instructions likewise tell jurors to acquit if the defendant had good reason to believe the check would be paid or made an honest mistake about the account balance.[15]
Some theft statutes list their own affirmative defenses. For example, for the identity theft offense of concealing, withholding or misrepresenting one's own identity to use another person's identifying information to obtain credit, goods, services, money or property, the statute lets a defendant prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that he or she acted with the consent of the person whose information was used, unless that person knew it would be used unlawfully.[16]
Identity: who took the property
The prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant, and not someone else, did what each element describes, such as taking the property.[2][9] A person who was only present, even knowing a theft was planned or happening, is not guilty as an aider and abettor unless he or she did something to assist with the required intent.[17] See aiding and abetting retail fraud.
When identity rests on store video, the recording must be authenticated, and the Court of Appeals has held that a police officer testifying as a lay witness should not have been allowed to identify the defendant in a video when nothing about the images, such as poor quality or a disguise, made that opinion necessary.[18][19] A confession needs independent evidence that a crime occurred before it can be admitted, though that independent proof need not show who did it.[20] The evidence page covers these rules.
Value disputes that change the degree
Apart from prior convictions, the dollar amount sets the degree of retail fraud: $1,000 or more is first degree, $200 to under $1,000 is second degree, and under $200 is third degree.[21][22][23] What is measured depends on the method: the price difference for price switching, the store's offered price for theft, and the amount obtained or attempted for refund fraud.[24] Larceny uses fair market value at the time and place of the offense.[25][26]
Separate incidents can be added together only if they were part of a scheme or course of conduct within a 12-month period, and the jury decides whether the required amount was proved beyond a reasonable doubt.[27][28] See how value is measured.
When a higher degree rests on prior convictions, some priors do not count: misdemeanor-level false pretenses and larceny priors under listed subsections do not raise second-degree retail fraud to first degree.[29] A misdemeanor conviction entered without a lawyer, for a defendant entitled to an appointed one who did not waive it, cannot be used to enhance a later charge.[30] The judge decides whether priors exist, at or before sentencing.[31]
Charging limits and related rules
- A person who commits first-degree retail fraud may not be prosecuted under the 10-year larceny tier, MCL 750.356(2), or under the false pretenses tier in MCL 750.218(5); the statute does not mention the higher false pretenses tiers.[32]
- Second- and third-degree retail fraud may not be prosecuted as larceny in a building, a 4-year felony.[33]
- Possession alone does not prove that a defendant charged with receiving stolen property knew it was stolen; other facts must support that inference.[34]
Suppression of evidence from an unlawful police search
Evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment is generally inadmissible in criminal proceedings, and the rule also reaches evidence that is the product of an illegal search.[35] Suppression is not automatic: there are exceptions, and the question turns on police conduct and whether exclusion would deter it.[36]
The Fourth Amendment restrains government officers, and in a 1978 decision the Court of Appeals held it does not extend to searches by private security guards who are not acting under color of law.[37] The Michigan Supreme Court noted decisions holding that guards who receive direct help from police, or work in close connection with them, may be acting under color of state law.[38] The loss prevention page covers store searches, and the domestic violence guide's page on motions to suppress explains the procedure.
Statute of limitations
Except for listed offenses, a charge must be filed within 6 years after the offense, and retail fraud, larceny and embezzlement are not among the listed exceptions.[6][7] Filing a complaint or warrant within that time is enough.[39] Any period when the accused did not usually and publicly reside in Michigan is not counted.[8] See time limits for theft charges.
Intoxication is not a defense
It is not a defense to any crime that the defendant was under the influence of alcohol, a drug or another substance that he or she voluntarily and knowingly consumed.[4] The only exception is an affirmative defense to a specific-intent crime, which the defendant must prove by a preponderance of the evidence: that he or she took a legally obtained and properly used medication or other substance and did not know, and reasonably should not have known, that it would cause intoxication or impairment.[5]
Whether any defense applies depends on the evidence in the case. How the defenses above are presented to jurors is on the trial and jury instructions page.
Common questions
Is it a defense that I never left the store?
Not by itself. The retail fraud instruction tells jurors that any movement of the property is enough and that it does not matter whether the property got past the cashier or out of the store. The prosecutor must still prove, as a separate element, that the defendant intended to steal, meaning to permanently take the property without the store's consent.[14][9]
Is being drunk or high a defense to shoplifting?
No. Michigan law says it is not a defense to any crime that the defendant was impaired by alcohol or a drug voluntarily and knowingly consumed. There is a narrow affirmative defense to specific-intent crimes, which the defendant must prove by a preponderance, for unexpected impairment from a legally obtained and properly used medication.[4][5]
How long does the prosecutor have to charge retail fraud?
The general limit is 6 years after the offense, and retail fraud, larceny and embezzlement are not among the listed exceptions. Filing a complaint or warrant within that time is enough, and any time the accused did not usually and publicly live in Michigan is not counted.[6][7][39][8]
Can evidence be thrown out if the police searched me illegally?
Evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment is generally inadmissible, along with its products, but suppression is not automatic and there are exceptions. The Fourth Amendment does not govern searches by private security guards acting on their own, as opposed to guards working in concert with police.[35][36][37][38]
I was with a friend who took items. Am I guilty too?
Aiding and abetting requires proof that the defendant did something before or during the crime to assist it, and at that time intended the crime, knew the other person intended it, or that the crime was a natural and probable consequence of a crime the defendant intended. The model instruction tells jurors that mere presence is not enough, even if the defendant knew the crime was planned or happening.[17]
Sources
- M Crim JI 23.13 Use Note; M Crim JI 23.14; M Crim JI 23.15 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 3.2 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 22.3 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 768.37(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 768.37(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 767.24(10) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 767.24(1)-(10) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 767.24(11) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 23.14 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 23.15 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 23.1 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 23.1 Use Note; People v Harverson, 291 Mich App 171 (2010) (as quoted) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 23.13(3) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 29.2; M Crim JI 29.3 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 445.65(2)(a)-(d) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 8.1(3); M Crim JI 8.5 — Michigan Courts
- MRE 901(a), (b)(1), (b)(4) — Michigan Courts
- People v Perkins, 314 Mich App 140, 160-162 (2016) — Michigan Courts
- People v Washington, 514 Mich 583, 605 (2024); People v Burns, 250 Mich App 436, 438 (2002) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1)(b); M Crim JI 23.13(6); M Crim JI 23.1(6) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 22.1 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356c(3); MCL 750.356d(6) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 23.13(7); M Crim JI 23.14(6); M Crim JI 23.15(6) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356c(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.610(G)(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356c(4); MCL 750.356d(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(5); MCL 750.356(2); MCL 750.218(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(3), (5); MCL 750.360 — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 26.3 — Michigan Courts
- MJI Criminal Proceedings Benchbook Vol. 1, §11.9(A) (quoting In re Forfeiture of $176,598, 443 Mich 261, 265 (1993); Mapp v Ohio, 367 US 643 (1961); People v Bogucki (2025)) — Michigan Courts
- MJI Criminal Proceedings Benchbook Vol. 1, §11.9(A) (quoting People v Lucynski (Lucynski III), ___ Mich ___ (2024)) — Michigan Courts
- People v Holloway, 82 Mich App 629 (1978) — Caselaw Access Project
- Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 761.1(g) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.