SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Diversion, HYTA and delayed sentences

Ways a retail fraud case can end without a conviction: an overview

Key points

  • HYTA lets a court, without entering a conviction, assign a person who pleads guilty to an offense committed on or after the 18th birthday and before the 26th birthday to youthful trainee status.[1][2]
  • A delayed sentence postpones sentencing for up to 1 year; the statute itself does not provide for dismissing the charge.[3][4]
  • The drug-possession (7411) and domestic-violence (769.4a) deferrals do not cover theft offenses.[5]
  • Drug, mental health and veterans treatment courts can, with the prosecutor's agreement, dismiss the case of a first-time participant who completes the program.[6][7][8]

A Michigan retail fraud or theft case can end without a conviction on the person's record through a few routes: the Holmes Youthful Trainee Act (HYTA), a dismissal after a drug, mental health or veterans treatment court, or a pretrial diversion program where a prosecutor's office offers one. A delayed sentence is sometimes grouped with these, but the statute only postpones sentencing and does not itself provide for a dismissal.[1][9][7][8][10][11][3][4]

Availability varies by court and by prosecutor's office, and each route depends on the court's discretion, the prosecutor's agreement, or both. This page compares them; each has its own page with the details. Two well-known Michigan deferrals, for drug possession (MCL 333.7411) and for assault on a family or dating partner (MCL 769.4a), do not cover theft offenses.[5]

The options side by side

OptionLegal basis and who decidesWho can use itResult if completed
HYTAMCL 762.11-762.15; the court decides, and the prosecutor must consent if the offense was committed at 21 or older.[1][2]A person who pleads guilty to an offense committed from the 18th to before the 26th birthday (since October 1, 2021); theft offenses are not on the exclusion list.[2][12][13]Discharge and dismissal; not a conviction; records closed to the public but open to courts, police and prosecutors.[14][15]
Delayed sentenceMCL 771.1(2); the court decides.[3]Any case in which probation is allowed, which includes theft offenses.[3][16]Sentencing is postponed up to 1 year; the statute has no dismissal provision.[3][4]
Drug treatment courtMCL 600.1060-600.1088; the prosecutor must approve admission where dismissal is possible, and must agree to the dismissal.[17][6]An adult charged with an offense related to the abuse, illegal use or possession of a controlled substance or alcohol, who pleads guilty on the record.[9][17]A one-time discharge and dismissal, not a conviction, with records closed to the public.[18]
Mental health courtMCL 600.1090 and following; the court decides admission, and dismissal needs the prosecutor's agreement.[19][7]A person with a diagnosed serious mental illness or similar condition who is admitted after screening.[20][19]Discharge and dismissal for a first-time participant who completes the program.[7]
Veterans treatment courtMCL 600.1209; dismissal needs the prosecutor's agreement.[8]A first-time participant who completes the program and is not charged with a traffic offense.[8]A one-time discharge and dismissal, not a conviction, with records closed to the public.[8]
Prosecutor diversionA program set up by a prosecutor's office; in felony cases the prosecutor must first offer the victim a chance to give views on pretrial diversion.[10]Set by each office's program.Set by each office's program.

HYTA

Under HYTA, a court may, with the young person's consent and without entering a judgment of conviction, assign a person who pleads guilty to youthful trainee status.[1] The assignment is discretionary, and the benchbook quotes the Court of Appeals that the seriousness of the offense weighs equally with age.[21] If the status is not revoked, the court discharges the person and dismisses the case at the end.[14] The HYTA page covers the age rules, terms and revocation.

Delayed sentence

In any case where probation is allowed, the court may delay sentencing for up to 1 year so the defendant can prove eligibility for probation or other leniency, and must enter an order stating the reason.[3] The statute gives participation in a drug treatment court as one example of that leniency.[3] The court keeps the power to sentence at any time during the delay.[3] The delayed sentence page explains the fees and conditions.

Plea under advisement

In a felony case, the court rule lets a court take a plea, or a plea agreement with a sentence term, under advisement, with a verbatim record of the plea.[22][23] The rule does not say what happens at the end of the advisement period.[22] That rule is not among the court rules that apply to district court misdemeanor cases.[24] What a particular court does with a plea under advisement depends on that court and on the terms the parties put on the record.

Specialty courts: drug, mental health and veterans treatment courts

A drug treatment court can take a person charged with an offense related to the abuse, illegal use or possession of a controlled substance or alcohol; an adult must plead guilty on the record.[9][17] With the prosecutor's agreement, it can dismiss the case of a first-time participant who completes the program, is not required by law to be sentenced to a correctional facility, is not charged with a traffic offense, and has not had more than one prior HYTA assignment or listed deferral dismissal.[6] That dismissal is without adjudication of guilt, is not a conviction for disqualifications, may be granted only once, and its records are closed to the public.[18]

A mental health court is a court-supervised treatment program for people diagnosed with a serious mental illness, serious emotional disturbance, co-occurring disorder or developmental disability.[20] No one has a right to be admitted; admission is at the court's discretion after a screening and evaluation.[19] With the prosecutor's agreement, it can dismiss the case of a first-time participant who completes the program and is not required by law to be sentenced to a correctional facility.[7] In Kent County, the 17th Circuit's Treatment and Support Court is a felony mental health court.[25]

A veterans treatment court, with the prosecutor's agreement, can discharge and dismiss the case of a first-time participant who completes the program; the dismissal is not a conviction for disqualifications and only one is allowed.[8]

Effects that remain after any of these routes

  • Restitution. The court must still order restitution when a case is resolved by HYTA, a delayed sentence or a deferred judgment, or any other way short of an acquittal or unconditional dismissal.[26]
  • The crime victim assessment. It is ordered in cases resolved by HYTA or a delayed or deferred sentence: $130 for a felony, $75 for a misdemeanor.[27]
  • Later set-aside eligibility. A case deferred and dismissed under HYTA or a similar deferral law counts as a misdemeanor conviction when deciding whether the person can set aside other convictions.[28]
  • Bank jobs. Federal law treats entering a pretrial diversion program for an offense of dishonesty like a conviction for bank employment, with an exemption for shoplifting once 1 year or more has passed since the conviction or program entry.[29][30]
  • Immigration. Federal law counts a guilty plea followed by any punishment as a conviction even when a judgment of guilt is withheld.[31] See theft charges and immigration status.

Teenagers under 18 are handled differently; see juvenile diversion and the consent calendar.

Prosecutor programs are local. For example, the Kent County Prosecutor's 2024 Annual Report describes a diversion program for people charged with a non-violent offense who have no prior criminal record, naming shoplifting and many larceny offenses where the defendant admits guilt and agrees to pay full restitution; participants must take and pass a class, and a person who fails the class or does not pay restitution can be charged.[11] The prosecutor diversion programs page compares the published programs.

Common questions

Is there a first-time offense program for shoplifting in Michigan?

Michigan's deferral statutes for drug possession or use (MCL 333.7411) and for assault on a family or dating partner (MCL 769.4a) do not apply to retail fraud. The routes for theft cases described in this guide are HYTA, a delayed sentence, a specialty court, or a program run by a prosecutor's office.[5][1][3][9][11]

Does a delayed sentence mean the charge will be dismissed?

Not under the statute. MCL 771.1 lets the court delay sentencing for up to 1 year so the defendant can show eligibility for probation or other leniency, and the court can sentence at any time during the delay. The section contains no provision for dismissing or reducing the charge; any such result depends on what was agreed and what the court orders.[3][4]

Do I still have to pay the store if my case ends in HYTA or a delayed sentence?

Yes. If a case is resolved by youthful trainee status, a delayed sentence, a deferred judgment or another way that is not an acquittal or unconditional dismissal, the court must still order restitution. The crime victim assessment is also ordered in those cases.[26][27]

Can I get mental health court for a retail fraud charge?

Possibly. Admission is at the mental health court's discretion; there is no right to be admitted, and the court looks at legal or clinical eligibility after a screening and evaluation. The program is for people diagnosed with a serious mental illness, serious emotional disturbance, co-occurring disorder or developmental disability. Availability varies by court.[19][20]

Does diversion keep a theft case off my record for a bank job?

Not always. Federal law bars bank work without FDIC consent for a person who agreed to enter a pretrial diversion program for an offense of dishonesty, not only a person convicted. Since December 23, 2022, shoplifting is exempt from that bar once 1 year has passed since the conviction or program entry.[29][30]

Sources

  1. MCL 762.11(2); MCL 762.16 — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 762.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 771.1(2) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 771.1 (whole section) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 769.4a(1); MCL 333.7411(1) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 600.1076(4) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 600.1098(3) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 600.1209(4), (6) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 600.1068(1)-(2); MCL 600.1076(4) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 780.756(3) — Michigan Legislature
  11. Kent County Prosecutor's Office, 2024 Annual Report (Prosecutor's message, PDF page 3) — kentcountymi.gov
  12. MCL 762.11(2); People v Dash, 216 Mich App 412 (1996) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCL 762.11(3) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 762.14(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 762.14(4) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 771.1(1) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 600.1068(1)(b)-(d), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 600.1076(6) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 600.1093(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 600.1090(e) — Michigan Legislature
  21. People v Khanani, 296 Mich App 175 (2012); People v Bobek, 217 Mich App 524 (1996) (as quoted in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
  22. MCR 6.302(F) — Michigan Courts
  23. MCR 6.302(C)(4) — Michigan Courts
  24. MCR 6.001(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
  25. Kent County, 17th Circuit Court — Criminal; Juvenile Specialty Courts — kentcountymi.gov
  26. MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2) — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCL 780.905(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
  28. MCL 780.621(2) — Michigan Legislature
  29. 12 USC 1829(a)(1) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  30. 12 USC 1829(c)(1), (2), (3)(D); Amendments note (Pub. L. 117–263, § 5705(a)) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  31. 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A), (B) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.