Key points
- In a felony case, the court may not accept a plea to an offense other than the one charged, such as second-degree retail fraud on a first-degree charge, without the prosecutor's consent.[1]
- Before accepting a guilty or no-contest plea, the court must find it understanding, voluntary and accurate, and must put the plea agreement on the record.[2][3]
- Restitution is mandatory and is not open to negotiation in plea or sentence bargaining.[4]
- HYTA requires a guilty plea; the benchbook reports Court of Appeals holdings that a no-contest plea does not qualify.[5][6]
A plea agreement is a deal in which the defendant pleads guilty or no contest in exchange for terms the prosecuting attorney has agreed to, and the court then decides whether to accept it. Michigan has separate court rules for misdemeanor pleas in district court (MCR 6.610) and felony pleas (MCR 6.302), and in both the agreement must be made part of the record (in a felony case, stated on the record or put in a writing signed by the parties) and the court must be satisfied that the plea is understanding, voluntary and accurate.[2][3][7]
This page explains those rules and the terms a theft plea agreement can and cannot contain. It does not suggest whether to accept any offer, and it makes no claim about how often particular offers are made; that depends on the prosecutor, the court and the facts. The overall order of events is on the court process page.
The pleas a defendant can enter
- Not guilty. If a felony defendant refuses to plead or stands mute, the court enters a not-guilty plea, which puts every material allegation in issue.[8]
- Guilty. The court questions the defendant to establish support for a finding of guilt.[2]
- No contest (nolo contendere). The court may not question the defendant about participation and relies on other information; in a felony case the plea needs the court's consent and a stated reason why it is appropriate.[2][9][10]
- Conditional plea (felony cases). With the consent of the court and the prosecutor, a plea can preserve a specified pretrial ruling for appeal, and the defendant may withdraw the plea if that ruling is overturned; the appeal is by leave only.[11]
The domestic violence guide's page on guilty and no-contest pleas covers the general differences between the two.
What a theft plea agreement can include
A lesser charge. In a felony case, the court may not accept a plea to an offense other than the one charged without the prosecutor's consent, for example a plea to second-degree retail fraud on a first-degree charge.[1] The felony plea rule does not govern district court misdemeanors, but the Michigan Supreme Court has held that choosing the statute under which to prosecute is the prosecutor's executive function, not the court's.[12][1] A felony that ends in a plea to a misdemeanor after bindover is sentenced in circuit court.[13]
An attempt. Where no specific attempt penalty exists, an attempt to commit an offense punishable by 5 years or more is a felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison or 1 year in jail, and an attempt to commit a lesser offense is a misdemeanor, with imprisonment capped at half the maximum for the completed offense.[14] The sentencing guidelines apply to an attempt only if the attempt is itself a felony; an attempted Class E, F or G offense is then scored as Class H, and attempts at Class H offenses are not scored.[15] The attempted retail fraud page has the details.
A sentence term or recommendation (felony cases). A felony agreement may call for a specific sentence or range, or a prosecutor's recommendation.[16] The court may reject such an agreement, accept it after reading the presentence report, accept it without the report, or take it under advisement; if it will not follow an agreed sentence term or range, the defendant may withdraw, but a judge's decision not to follow a mere recommendation does not allow withdrawal.[17]
Restitution. Restitution is mandatory and not open to negotiation in plea or sentence bargaining.[4][18] The Court of Appeals has held that restitution can be part of a negotiated plea agreement, as where the defendant agreed to have charges dismissed but still pay the restitution owed on them.[19] Restitution is still ordered when a case ends in youthful trainee status or a delayed sentence.[20] See restitution in theft cases.
The misdemeanor plea procedure (district court)
Before taking a plea to second- or third-degree retail fraud, the court must tell the defendant the maximum penalty and any mandatory minimum, and that the plea gives up a trial and the rights to call and question witnesses, to testify or stay silent, and to the presumption of innocence with proof beyond a reasonable doubt.[21] The court must make the plea agreement part of the record, confirm the parties agree on its terms, and ask whether any other promises or threats were made and whether pleading is the defendant's own choice.[3]
A district court may accept a written guilty or no-contest plea without the defendant appearing if it finds the situation proper and the written waiver of rights voluntary.[22] A defendant cannot challenge a misdemeanor plea on appeal for failure to follow the plea rules without first moving in the trial court to withdraw it; if a deviation affected substantial rights, the court must correct it and let the defendant choose whether the plea stands.[23][24]
The felony plea procedure (circuit court, or district court after bindover)
The court must place the defendant under oath and explain the offense, the maximum prison sentence and any mandatory minimum, the trial rights being given up, and that any appeal will be by application for leave rather than by right.[7] If the judge states a sentence it expects to impose, it must say that any guidelines range discussed is a preliminary estimate.[16] The court may also take the plea under advisement, with a verbatim record of the proceeding.[25]
Before finalizing a felony negotiation that may lead to a dismissal, a plea or sentence bargain, or pretrial diversion, the prosecutor must offer the victim a chance to consult and give views, including about pretrial diversion.[26]
Withdrawing a plea and misconduct before sentencing
In a felony case, a defendant may withdraw a plea any time before the court accepts it on the record; after that and before sentencing, only in the interest of justice and not if withdrawal would substantially prejudice the prosecutor, with an exception when a felony court cannot follow a sentence agreement.[27] Misconduct between the plea and sentencing, such as missing court or violating bond, can free the court from a sentence agreement.[28] If a felony plea is withdrawn or vacated, the case can go to trial on any charge that was or could have been brought.[29]
What a plea can affect later
- HYTA. Youthful trainee status requires a guilty plea; the benchbook reports Court of Appeals holdings that no-contest pleas and trial convictions do not qualify.[5][6] See the HYTA page.
- A civil case by the store. A no-contest plea generally cannot be used against the defendant in a later civil or criminal case, and neither can statements made in plea discussions with the prosecutor that did not end in a guilty plea or ended in one later withdrawn.[30] The store's civil demand is a separate process that does not prevent criminal prosecution.[31] See civil demand and the criminal case.
- A later retail fraud charge. A retail fraud, larceny or similar conviction can raise the degree of a later third-degree retail fraud charge to second degree.[32]
- Immigration status. Defense counsel must advise that a plea may carry a risk of adverse immigration consequences.[33] Federal law counts a guilty or no-contest plea followed by any punishment as a conviction even when a judgment of guilt is withheld.[34] The immigration page covers this in more depth.
Plea practice, including whether a court allows written pleas or takes pleas under advisement, varies by court and by prosecutor's office.
Common questions
Can I plead to a lower degree of retail fraud?
In a felony case, only with the prosecutor's consent: the felony plea rule bars a court from accepting a plea to an offense other than the one charged without it. The Michigan Supreme Court has also held that choosing the statute under which to prosecute is an executive function of the prosecutor, not the court. Whether such an offer is made depends on the prosecutor and the case.[1]
Can the store's restitution be waived as part of a plea deal?
No. Because restitution has been mandatory since 1994, the Court of Appeals held it is not open to plea or sentence bargaining, and defendants are on notice that it will be part of the sentence. A negotiated agreement can, however, include paying restitution on charges that are dismissed.[4][19]
What is the difference between a guilty plea and a no-contest plea?
With a guilty plea the court questions the defendant to establish guilt; with a no-contest (nolo contendere) plea it may not ask about the defendant's participation and relies on other information. A no-contest plea generally cannot be used against the defendant in a later civil case. It does not qualify for HYTA, according to Court of Appeals decisions reported in the benchbook.[2][30][6]
Can I take back a plea after the judge accepts it?
In a felony case, a plea accepted on the record can be withdrawn before sentencing only in the interest of justice and not if the prosecutor would be substantially prejudiced, except that the defendant may withdraw if the court will not follow an agreed sentence term or range. In a misdemeanor case, the district court must let the defendant withdraw if a plea-rule error affected substantial rights; otherwise it may allow withdrawal only if the prosecution is not substantially prejudiced, and a challenge on appeal first requires that motion.[27][24][23]
Will a plea affect my immigration status?
It can. The benchbook states that defense counsel must tell a client that a plea may carry a risk of adverse immigration consequences, such as deportation, and federal law counts a guilty or no-contest plea followed by any punishment as a conviction even if a judgment of guilt is withheld.[33][34]
Sources
- MCR 6.301(D); Genesee Prosecutor v Genesee Circuit Judge, 386 Mich 672 (1972) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(1) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(5)-(6) — Michigan Courts
- People v Ronowski, 222 Mich App 58 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 762.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 762.11(2); People v Dash, 216 Mich App 412 (1996) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.301(A) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.301(B) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(D)(2) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.301(C)(2) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.001(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.008(C)-(D) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.92(2)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.19(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.302(C)(1)-(4); MCR 6.310(B)(2) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(C)(4) — Michigan Courts
- People v Bell, 276 Mich App 342 (2007), citing People v Ronowski, 222 Mich App 58 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Foster, 319 Mich App 365, 379, 383 (2017) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.610(F)(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(7) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(8)(a) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(F)(8)(a)-(b) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(F) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.756(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.310(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.302(E)(2); MCR 6.310(B)(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.312 — Michigan Courts
- MRE 410(a) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MJI Criminal Proceedings Benchbook Vol. 1, §6.30(C) (withdrawal of plea after sentencing), citing People v Haynes, 256 Mich App 341, 349 (2003) and Padilla v Kentucky, 559 US 356, 369 (2010) — Michigan Courts
- 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A), (B) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.