SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Retail fraud (shoplifting)

How Value Is Measured in Retail Fraud: The $200 and $1,000 Lines

Key points

  • The retail fraud degrees turn on two dollar lines: under $200 (third degree), $200 to under $1,000 (second degree) and $1,000 or more (first degree).[1][2][3]
  • What is measured depends on the act: the store's offered price for stealing, the resulting price difference for price switching, and the amount obtained or attempted for refund fraud.[4]
  • For the stealing act, retail fraud uses the price at which the store offered the property, while the general larceny instruction uses fair market value.[5]
  • The amount is an element the jury decides, and the prosecutor must prove it beyond a reasonable doubt.[6][7]
  • The $200 and $1,000 lines date from 1998 PA 311, effective January 1, 1999, and the retail fraud sections have not been amended since.[8]

The degree of a Michigan retail fraud charge turns on two dollar lines. An amount under $200 is third degree, $200 or more but under $1,000 is second degree, and $1,000 or more is first degree, the felony level.[1][2][3] What gets measured against those lines depends on which of the three retail fraud acts is charged.[4]

This page covers the three measures, how retail fraud's "price" differs from the fair market value used in larceny, who decides the amount, and where the dollar figure matters beyond the degree. Two other routes to a higher degree have their own pages: adding up separate incidents and prior convictions.

The three measures in the statute

ActWhat is measuredStatute's words (first-degree version)
StealingThe price at which the store offered the property for sale"steals property of the store that is offered for sale at a price of $1,000.00 or more"[3][4]
Price switchingThe resulting difference in price: in the jury instruction's words, the difference between the sale price and the price the defendant intended to pay"if the resulting difference in price is $1,000.00 or more"[3][4][9]
Refund or exchange fraudThe money or property value obtained or attempted"if the amount of money or the value of the property obtained or attempted to be obtained is $1,000.00 or more"[3][10]

The second- and third-degree versions use the same words with the $200-to-under-$1,000 and under-$200 bands.[2][1]

"Price," not market value

For the stealing act, the statute and the model instruction both use the store's price: the jury is asked whether "the price of the property" was in the charged band.[5][7] The general larceny instruction asks a different question, whether the property "had a fair market value at the time it was taken" in the charged range.[5]

Fair market value has its own definition in the jury instructions: the price the property would have sold for in the open market at that time and place, between a willing seller and a willing buyer, neither forced to deal and both reasonably informed.[11] That test belongs to larceny and related offenses. A person charged with larceny instead of retail fraud may face a different measure of value for the same item.[5] The larceny page covers that statute.

Price switching: the difference, not the full price

When the charge is price misrepresentation, the statute measures "the resulting difference in price."[4] The jury instruction asks whether "the difference between the sale price and the price the defendant intended to pay" was in the charged band.[9]

As simple arithmetic on those words: if a $250 item is rung up after its tag is replaced with a $40 tag, the resulting difference is $210, which falls in the second-degree band even though the item's price is $250.[4][2] If the defendant intended to pay nothing, the instruction's "price the defendant intended to pay" would be zero, so the difference is the full sale price.[9] The price-switching page covers this act.

Refund fraud: obtained or attempted

For refund or exchange fraud, the measure is "the amount of money or the value of the property obtained or attempted to be obtained."[10] A refund that was refused at the counter is measured by the amount sought, the same as one that was paid out.[10] The jury instruction adds that it does not matter whether the defendant tried to exchange the property for money or for other property.[12] The return and exchange fraud page covers this act.

Who decides the amount, and how it is proved

The amount is an element of the offense, so it is the jury's question and must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.[6] The theft instruction lists three bands, $1,000 or more, $200 or more but less than $1,000, and less than $200, and directs the judge to give only one "unless instructing on lesser offenses."[7]

Store records offered to prove a price, such as receipts, are subject to the ordinary rules of evidence. Under the business records exception, a record made at or near the time by someone with knowledge and kept in the course of a regularly conducted business activity is not excluded by the rule against hearsay, unless the opponent shows that the source or the way it was prepared indicates a lack of trustworthiness.[13] Receipts, photos and video must be authenticated by evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the offering side claims.[14] The evidence page covers these rules.

The same lines in other theft laws, and where they differ

Several related offenses use the same $200 and $1,000 lines. Larceny is a 93-day misdemeanor under $200, a 1-year misdemeanor from $200 to under $1,000, and a 5-year felony from $1,000 to under $20,000.[15][16][17] Embezzlement, false pretenses and receiving or concealing stolen property follow the same first two lines.[18][19][20][21][22]

Other theft laws use different numbers. Bad-check penalties turn on $100 and $500, and so do the tiers for knowingly using a revoked or canceled card.[23][24] Retail fraud has no tier above $1,000; larceny has a further 10-year tier at $20,000 or more.[25][3]

Where the dollar figure matters beyond the degree

  • The fine. Every degree's maximum fine is the stated cap or 3 times the value involved, "whichever is greater."[26]
  • Felony sentencing. Offense variable 16 adds 5 points for property worth $1,000 to $20,000 and 10 points above $20,000.[27] See the guidelines page.
  • Restitution. If stolen property cannot be returned, restitution is figured from its fair market value on the date of loss or of sentencing, whichever is greater, less the value of anything returned.[28]
  • Civil demand. A merchant's civil claim uses the full retail price of unrecovered or unsalable goods, plus civil damages of 10 times the retail price, at least $50 and no more than $200.[29]

Amounts in effect since January 1, 1999

Retail fraud became a separate offense under 1988 PA 20, effective June 1, 1988. The current $200 and $1,000 lines and penalties come from 1998 PA 311, effective January 1, 1999, and neither section has been amended since, as of the statute text current through 2026 PA 114.[8] Articles or forms written before 1999 may describe the law before that act took effect. The theft law changes timeline tracks those amendments.

Common questions

Is the value the store's price or what the item is really worth?

For retail fraud by stealing, the statute and the jury instruction use "the price" at which the store offered the property for sale.[5] General larceny is different: its instruction asks for the property's fair market value, the price it would have sold for in the open market between a willing seller and a willing buyer.[5][11]

How is the amount figured when a price tag is switched?

For price switching, the statute measures "the resulting difference in price."[4] The jury instruction asks whether the difference between the sale price and the price the defendant intended to pay falls in the charged band.[9] The full price of the item is not the measure for this act.

Does a return that failed still count toward the amount?

Yes. The refund or exchange act covers anyone who "obtains or attempts to obtain" money or property, and the degree is set by the amount "obtained or attempted to be obtained."[10] The jury instruction asks whether the defendant exchanged or tried to exchange unpaid store property.[12]

Have the $200 and $1,000 lines changed recently?

No. The current amounts come from 1998 PA 311, which took effect on January 1, 1999, and the statute history shows no later amendment to either retail fraud section through the text current to 2026 PA 114.[8] Material written before 1999 may describe the law as it stood before 1998 PA 311 took effect; this page relies on the current statute text.

Who decides whether the amount crosses the $1,000 line?

The jury, as one of the elements. The theft instruction lists the price bands, and the judge gives only the charged band unless the jury is also instructed on lesser offenses.[7] Each element must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.[6] Prior convictions are different: the judge decides them without a jury.[30]

Sources

  1. MCL 750.356d(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 750.356d(1)(b); M Crim JI 23.13(6); M Crim JI 23.1(6) — Michigan Courts
  6. M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
  7. M Crim JI 23.13(6) — Michigan Courts
  8. MCL 750.356c (History); MCL 750.356d (History); 1998 PA 311, enacting section 2 — Michigan Legislature
  9. M Crim JI 23.14 — Michigan Courts
  10. MCL 750.356c(1)(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(c), (4)(c) — Michigan Legislature
  11. M Crim JI 22.1 — Michigan Courts
  12. M Crim JI 23.15 — Michigan Courts
  13. MRE 803(6) — Michigan Courts
  14. MRE 901(a), (b)(1), (b)(4) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCL 750.356(5) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 750.356(4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 750.356(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 750.174(2) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 750.174(3)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 750.174(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 750.218(2)-(4) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 750.535(2)(a), (3)(a), (4)(a), (5) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 750.131(3)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 750.157s(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 750.356(2)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 750.356d(1), (4) — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCL 777.46(1)(d)-(g) — Michigan Legislature
  28. MCL 780.766(3); MCL 780.826(3) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
  30. MCL 750.356c(4); MCL 750.356d(7) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.