SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

Retail fraud trials and jury instructions

Key points

  • A district court jury in a criminal case has 6 members and must reach a unanimous verdict; a circuit court jury has 12 unless the parties stipulate to fewer.[1][2]
  • A defendant may give up a jury and be tried by the judge only with the prosecutor's consent and the court's approval.[3]
  • Jurors are told the defendant is presumed innocent and the prosecutor must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt.[4]
  • Whether prior convictions raise the retail fraud degree is decided by the judge at sentencing, not by the jury.[5][6]

A retail fraud or other theft charge can be tried by a jury. In district court the jury has 6 members and must be unanimous; in circuit court it has 12 unless the parties stipulate to fewer, and that verdict must also be unanimous.[1][2] The defendant can choose a trial by the judge alone only with the prosecutor's consent and the court's approval.[3]

At the end of the trial the judge reads the jurors instructions on the law. Michigan's Model Criminal Jury Instructions are not court rules, but a court rule requires their use unless the court finds an instruction inaccurate or the case calls for a change.[7] This page summarizes the instructions used in theft trials; the elements page covers each element in depth.

Jury trial or bench trial

A Michigan statute that applies in all criminal cases lets a defendant waive a jury and be tried by the court, with the prosecutor's consent and the court's approval; the felony court rule says the same.[3][8] Except in cases of minor offenses, the statute requires the waiver to be in a signed writing filed in the case, made in open court after the defendant has been arraigned and had an opportunity to consult a lawyer.[3]

CourtJury sizeVerdict
District court (second- and third-degree retail fraud, misdemeanor larceny)6 jurors[1]Unanimous[1]
Circuit court (felonies such as first-degree retail fraud)12 jurors, unless the parties stipulate to fewer with the court's consent[2]Unanimous[2]

Whether a jury or a judge is the better choice in a given case is a question for the defendant and a lawyer. The domestic violence guide's page on bench and jury trials describes the general differences.

The burden of proof and the defendant's rights at trial

In every criminal case, the jurors are told that a person accused of a crime is presumed innocent, that the prosecutor must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt, and that the defendant is not required to prove innocence or to do anything.[4] Proof beyond a reasonable doubt is defined as proof that leaves the jurors firmly convinced of guilt; a reasonable doubt is a fair, honest doubt growing out of the evidence or the lack of evidence.[4]

If the defendant does not testify, the jurors can be told that every defendant has the absolute right not to testify and that they must not consider it; that instruction is given or left out according to the defense's request.[9]

The retail fraud instructions

The use notes to all three retail fraud instructions state that the statutory language makes the offense a specific-intent crime.[10] Each has its own instruction:

FormWhat the prosecutor must prove, in summary
Theft (M Crim JI 23.13)The defendant took property the store offered for sale, moved it, intended to steal it (to take it permanently without the store's consent), inside the store or the immediate area while it was open, and the price was in the charged range.[11]
Price switching (M Crim JI 23.14)The defendant altered or switched a price tag or otherwise misrepresented the price, intending to pay less or nothing, and the difference between the sale price and the price the defendant intended to pay was in the charged range.[12]
False exchange (M Crim JI 23.15)The defendant exchanged or tried to exchange unpaid store property for money or other property, intending to defraud the store, during store hours in or near the store, and the amount was in the charged range.[13]

For the theft form, the instruction tells jurors that any movement of the property is enough and that it does not matter whether the property got past the cashier or out of the store.[14] Intent to steal is still a separate element.[11] More is on the page about concealment and leaving the store.

Larceny and embezzlement instructions

For larceny, the prosecutor must prove the defendant took someone else's property without consent, moved it, intended at the time to permanently deprive the owner of it, and that its fair market value was in the charged range.[15][16] The committee note explains that intent to permanently deprive includes keeping property without a purpose to return it within a reasonable time.[17]

Other instructions that can apply in a theft trial include:

  • Claim of right. Taking property because the person honestly believes he or she has the right to take or use it is not larceny, even if mistaken.[18]
  • Recently stolen property. If jurors find the defendant possessed recently stolen property, they may infer the defendant committed the theft, but they do not have to.[19]
  • Larceny in a building. The property only has to have been "worth something"; there is no minimum dollar amount.[20]
  • Aiding and abetting. Mere presence is not enough to prove the defendant assisted, even if the defendant knew the crime was planned or happening.[21]

For embezzlement, the prosecutor must prove a relationship of trust with the owner (such as employee or agent), possession or control because of that relationship, a dishonest disposal or conversion without consent, intent to defraud, and a value in the charged range.[22]

Value as a question for the jury

When value sets the charge, it is an element the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt.[11][4] Retail fraud measures it by the store's offered price, while the larceny instruction uses fair market value at the time it was taken.[16] Fair market value is the price the property would have sold for in the open market at that time and place between a willing buyer and a willing seller.[23]

When separate incidents are charged together, the instruction tells jurors they may add the amounts if the incidents were part of a scheme or course of conduct within a 12-month period.[24] The value thresholds page explains the dollar lines, and the aggregation page covers adding incidents together.

Prior convictions work differently. The former retail fraud instruction on priors was deleted because the judge decides, at or before sentencing and without a jury, whether priors raise the degree.[5][6] See the prior convictions page.

The model instructions are updated from time to time; this summary reflects the version updated August 31, 2026.[7] Defenses that bear on these elements are collected on the defenses page, and the kinds of proof used at trial are on the evidence page.

Common questions

How many jurors hear a misdemeanor retail fraud trial?

Six. Michigan law sets the jury in a district court criminal case at 6 people and allows only a unanimous verdict. Second- and third-degree retail fraud are district court misdemeanors, so a jury trial on those charges uses a 6-person jury.[1][25]

Can I choose to have the judge decide my case instead of a jury?

Only if the prosecutor consents and the court approves. Except in cases of minor offenses, the statute requires the waiver to be in a writing signed by the defendant and made in open court after arraignment and a chance to consult a lawyer.[8][3]

Do I have to testify at my trial?

No. The model instruction tells jurors that every defendant has the absolute right not to testify and that they must not consider it in any way. The defense decides whether the court gives that instruction. The burden instruction also says the defendant is not required to prove innocence or to do anything.[9][4]

Does the jury decide the value of what was taken?

Yes, when value sets the charge. The price or amount in the charged range is one of the elements the prosecutor must prove to the jury, and when separate incidents are added together the jurors are told they may add them when deciding whether that amount was proved beyond a reasonable doubt.[11][26]

Does the jury hear about my prior shoplifting convictions?

Not to decide the degree. When the prosecutor seeks a higher degree based on priors, they must be listed on the complaint and information, and the judge decides whether they exist, without a jury, at sentencing or at a separate hearing before sentencing. The former jury instruction on retail fraud priors was deleted for that reason.[5][6]

Sources

  1. MCL 600.8355 — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCR 6.410(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCL 763.3(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  4. M Crim JI 3.2 — Michigan Courts
  5. M Crim JI 23.16 — Michigan Courts
  6. MCL 750.356c(4); MCL 750.356d(7) — Michigan Legislature
  7. M Crim JI introduction; MCR 2.512(D) — Michigan Courts
  8. MCR 6.401 — Michigan Courts
  9. M Crim JI 3.3 — Michigan Courts
  10. M Crim JI 23.13 Use Note; M Crim JI 23.14; M Crim JI 23.15 — Michigan Courts
  11. M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
  12. M Crim JI 23.14 — Michigan Courts
  13. M Crim JI 23.15 — Michigan Courts
  14. M Crim JI 23.13(3) — Michigan Courts
  15. M Crim JI 23.1 — Michigan Courts
  16. MCL 750.356d(1)(b); M Crim JI 23.13(6); M Crim JI 23.1(6) — Michigan Courts
  17. M Crim JI 23.1 Use Note; People v Harverson, 291 Mich App 171 (2010) (as quoted) — Michigan Courts
  18. M Crim JI 22.3 — Michigan Courts
  19. M Crim JI 23.2 — Michigan Courts
  20. M Crim JI 23.4 — Michigan Courts
  21. M Crim JI 8.1(3); M Crim JI 8.5 — Michigan Courts
  22. M Crim JI 27.1 — Michigan Courts
  23. M Crim JI 22.1 — Michigan Courts
  24. MCL 750.356c(3); MCL 750.356d(6); MCL 750.356(7); M Crim JI 23.13(7) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 750.356d(1), MCL 750.356d(4), MCL 750.356c(1), MCL 600.8311(a) — Michigan Legislature
  26. M Crim JI 23.13(7); M Crim JI 23.14(6); M Crim JI 23.15(6) — Michigan Courts

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.