SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Retail fraud (shoplifting)

Charged for What Someone Else Took: Aiding and Abetting Retail Fraud in Michigan

Key points

  • Under MCL 767.39, a person who procures, counsels, aids or abets an offense may be prosecuted and punished as if he or she directly committed it.[1]
  • To convict as an aider and abettor, the prosecutor must prove the crime was committed, the defendant did something to assist before or during it, and the defendant intended the crime, knew the other person intended it, or the crime was a natural and probable consequence of the crime intended.[2]
  • Being present is not enough: even if the defendant knew the crime was planned or happening, mere presence does not prove that he or she assisted.[3]
  • Conspiracy is a separate crime that requires a knowing agreement and specific intent; for a target offense punishable by less than 1 year, such as third-degree retail fraud, conspiracy carries up to 1 year.[4][5][6]

Yes, a person can be charged with retail fraud for merchandise someone else took. Michigan law says every person "concerned in the commission of an offense", whether he or she directly commits the act or "procures, counsels, aids, or abets in its commission", may be prosecuted and punished as if he or she committed the offense directly.[1] The limit is just as important: being present, even with knowledge of what was happening, is not enough to prove that a person assisted.[3]

This page explains the statute, the elements in the model jury instruction, the line between helping and being present, how the rules apply to common group situations, and how conspiracy differs. For the elements of the underlying retail fraud act, see the elements of retail fraud.

The statute: helpers are tried as principals

The text of MCL 767.39 is short:

"Every person concerned in the commission of an offense, whether he directly commits the act constituting the offense or procures, counsels, aids, or abets in its commission may hereafter be prosecuted, indicted, tried and on conviction shall be punished as if he had directly committed such offense."[1]

This means a person found to have aided and abetted retail fraud can be convicted of that retail fraud offense itself and may be punished as if he or she had committed it directly.[1][2] The model instruction puts it this way: anyone who intentionally assists someone else in committing a crime "is as guilty as the person who directly commits it".[2]

The three elements

The model jury instruction, M Crim JI 8.1, requires the prosecutor to prove each of these beyond a reasonable doubt:[2]

  1. The crime was actually committed, either by the defendant or someone else. It does not matter whether anyone else has been convicted of it.[2]
  2. Before or during the crime, the defendant did something to assist in committing it.[2][3]
  3. At that time, the defendant intended the crime to be committed, or knew the other person intended it, or the crime was a natural and probable consequence of the crime the defendant intended.[2]

A related instruction adds that it does not matter how much help, advice or encouragement the defendant gave, but jurors must decide whether the defendant intended to help and whether the help actually helped.[7] Because the first element requires that the retail fraud was actually committed, it includes the specific intent that every form of retail fraud requires.[8][2]

Where the law draws the line: presence is not assistance

The model instruction on mere presence reads: "Even if the defendant knew that the alleged crime was planned or was being committed, the mere fact that [he / she] was present when it was committed is not enough to prove that [he / she] assisted in committing it."[3]

Two points follow from the instructions. Knowledge alone is not assistance; the second element requires that the defendant did something to assist before or during the crime.[3][2] And assistance alone is not enough either; the third element requires the intent or knowledge described above at the time.[2] Both are facts the jury decides from the evidence, which can be direct or circumstantial.[9]

Group situations the instructions address

Some retail fraud allegations involve more than one person. The rules above apply to each person separately. The descriptions below show how the instructions frame common situations; they do not predict any outcome.

  • Someone who was there but did nothing to help. The mere-presence instruction applies: presence, even with knowledge, does not prove assistance.[3]
  • Someone who is said to have kept watch. The Use Note to M Crim JI 8.3 gives a lookout as its example of aider liability during a criminal enterprise: as the note describes People v Poplar (1969), a defendant who acted as a lookout during a breaking and entering was found liable as an aider and abettor for a nonfatal shooting by codefendants.[10] The same three elements still have to be proved for each charge.[2]
  • A different crime committed by someone else in the group. Where a person is charged as an aider for a crime committed during a common unlawful activity, the prosecutor must prove the person intended to help commit the charged offense, not just the common activity, and there is no liability for a crime not fairly within that activity.[11]
  • Someone who drove or waited outside. The question is the same as for anyone else in the group: whether the person did something to assist before or during the crime, with the required intent or knowledge.[2][7]
  • Someone who helped only afterward. Aiding and abetting requires help before or during the crime; an accessory after the fact, as the instructions define it, knowingly helps a felon avoid discovery, arrest, trial or punishment.[12]

When the person who takes the goods passes them to another, the person who receives them may face a different charge: buying, receiving, possessing or concealing stolen property knowing, or having reason to know or believe, that it was stolen.[13] See receiving and concealing stolen property.

Conspiracy: an agreement is its own crime

Conspiracy under MCL 750.157a is a separate offense. The model instruction requires proof that the defendant and someone else knowingly agreed to commit the crime and that the defendant specifically intended to commit or help commit it.[5] Its penalty depends on the target crime:[4]

Target offenseTarget's maximumConspiracy penalty
Third-degree retail fraud93 days[6]Up to 1 year, a $1,000 fine, or both, because the target is punishable by less than 1 year[4]
Second-degree retail fraud1 year[14]The same penalty as the target offense, plus a possible additional $10,000 fine[4]
First-degree retail fraud5 years[15]The same penalty as the target offense, plus a possible additional $10,000 fine[4]

The result for third degree is worth noting: the conspiracy maximum of 1 year is longer than the 93-day maximum for the completed offense.[4][6]

Conspiracy also appears inside the Organized Retail Crime Act. Conspiring with another person to commit an organized retail crime, and organizing, supervising, financing, managing or assisting another person in committing one, are both listed ways to commit that 5-year felony.[16][17] See organized retail crime and charges that can be filed alongside retail fraud.

When the people involved are under 18

Since October 1, 2021, a child under 18 who is arrested must be taken before the family division of circuit court, subject to exceptions in MCL 600.606 and to a waiver process, on the prosecutor's motion, that can send a child 14 or older who is charged with a felony to the adult criminal court.[18][19] The juvenile process is explained on when a minor is accused of retail fraud, and parents can start with the parents' guide.

Defending against an aiding-and-abetting theory

Each element is a point the prosecutor has to prove, so each is also a point the defense can contest: whether the underlying retail fraud was committed, whether the defendant did anything to assist before or during it, and what the defendant intended or knew at the time.[2] The defenses page covers how those questions are raised.

Common questions

Can I be charged with retail fraud if I was only with a friend who took something?

Presence alone is not enough. The model instruction says that even if the defendant knew the crime was planned or being committed, the mere fact of being present does not prove he or she assisted.[3] An aider and abettor must have done something before or during the crime to assist, with the required intent or knowledge.[2]

Does the person who took the item have to be convicted first?

No. The instruction requires proof that the crime was actually committed, by the defendant or someone else, and adds that "It does not matter whether anyone else has been convicted of the crime."[2]

Does a helper face a lighter penalty than the person who took the item?

Not under the statute. MCL 767.39 says a person who procures, counsels, aids or abets an offense "shall be punished as if he had directly committed such offense."[1]

What is the difference between aiding and abetting and conspiracy?

Aiding and abetting is a way of being guilty of the crime itself, by assisting before or during it with the required intent.[2] Conspiracy is its own offense: the defendant and someone else knowingly agreed to commit a crime, and the defendant specifically intended to commit or help commit it.[5] Its penalty is tied to the target crime.[4]

What if someone only helped after the theft was over?

Aiding and abetting requires help given before or during the crime.[12] The model instruction on accessories after the fact describes someone who knowingly helps a felon avoid discovery, arrest, trial or punishment, knowing the other person committed a felony.[12] Separately, knowingly receiving or concealing stolen property is its own crime.[13]

Sources

  1. MCL 767.39 — Michigan Legislature
  2. M Crim JI 8.1(2)-(3) — Michigan Courts
  3. M Crim JI 8.1(3); M Crim JI 8.5 — Michigan Courts
  4. MCL 750.157a(a), (c) — Michigan Legislature
  5. M Crim JI 10.1 — Michigan Courts
  6. MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
  7. M Crim JI 8.4 — Michigan Courts
  8. M Crim JI 23.13, Use Note 1; M Crim JI 23.14, Use Note; M Crim JI 23.15, Use Note — Michigan Courts
  9. M Crim JI 4.3 — Michigan Courts
  10. M Crim JI 8.3, Use Note (describing People v Poplar, 20 Mich App 132 (1969)) — Michigan Courts
  11. M Crim JI 8.3 — Michigan Courts
  12. M Crim JI 8.6(1), (5); M Crim JI 8.7(2) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCL 750.535(1) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 752.1084(1)(a)-(h) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 752.1084(2) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 764.27; MCL 764.27 (History: Am. 2019, Act 103, Eff. Oct. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 764.27 — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.