SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Retail fraud (shoplifting)

The Elements of Retail Fraud: What the Prosecutor Must Prove in Michigan

Key points

  • The prosecutor must prove every element of retail fraud beyond a reasonable doubt, and the model jury instructions list the elements for each of the three acts.[1][2][3]
  • All three forms of retail fraud are specific-intent crimes under the model instructions: stealing, price switching and false exchange.[4]
  • For stealing, any movement of the property is enough; leaving the store or passing the cashier is not required, but intent to permanently take it must be proved.[1][5]
  • The jury decides whether the price or amount falls in the charged dollar band; prior convictions are decided by the judge, not the jury.[6][7][8]

To convict someone of retail fraud in Michigan, the prosecutor must prove each element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. The elements come from the two retail fraud statutes and from the model criminal jury instructions, which set out separate element lists for stealing, price switching and false exchange.[1][2][3] Michigan courts are required to use the model instructions unless the court finds that one does not accurately state the law or the case calls for a variation.[9]

Every retail fraud charge, at any degree, has four building blocks: a place (a store or its immediate vicinity), one of three prohibited acts, the intent the statute attaches to that act, and a dollar amount in the band the statute sets.[10][11] When a prior conviction raises the degree, the act itself still falls in the lower degree's band, and the prior is decided by the judge rather than the jury.[12][13][7] This page takes each in turn. Where and when the act happened gets its own page on "open to the public" and "immediate vicinity", and how the dollar amount is measured is covered on the value page.

The three acts and their elements side by side

ActWhat must be doneRequired intentWhere and whenAmount that sets the degree
Stealing (M Crim JI 23.13)Took property the store offered for sale and moved itIntended to permanently take it without the store's consentInside the store or the immediate area around it, while open to the publicThe price of the property[1]
Price switching (M Crim JI 23.14)Altered or switched a price tag, or otherwise misrepresented the priceIntended to pay less than the actual price, or nothingInside the store or the immediate area around it, while open to the publicDifference between the sale price and the price the defendant intended to pay[2]
False exchange (M Crim JI 23.15)Exchanged or tried to exchange unpaid store property for money or other propertyIntended to defraud or cheat the storeDuring store hours, inside the store or the immediate area around itMoney or property value obtained or attempted[3]

Retail fraud by stealing

The model instruction for retail fraud by theft lists five elements, each of which the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt:[1]

  1. The defendant took some property that the store offered for sale.[1]
  2. The defendant moved the property. The instruction adds: "Any movement is enough. It does not matter whether the defendant actually got the property past the cashier or out of the store."[5]
  3. The defendant intended to steal the property, which the instruction defines as intending "to permanently take the property from the store without the store's consent."[1]
  4. This happened inside the store or in the immediate area around the store, while the store was open to the public.[1][14]
  5. The price of the property was in the band for the degree charged.[1][6]

Movement alone is not the offense. The intent element must also be proved, and the instruction's notes say that when intent to permanently deprive is contested, the court may expand on that phrase using the definitions in the general larceny instruction.[4][15] Those definitions, quoting the Court of Appeals in People v Harverson, include keeping property without the purpose of returning it within a reasonable time, or keeping it with the intent to return it only if the owner pays for its return.[16] The concealment page looks at the stealing act more closely, including whether a person has to leave the store first.

Retail fraud by price switching

The statute's first act covers anyone who, while a store is open to the public, "alters, transfers, removes and replaces, conceals, or otherwise misrepresents the price at which property is offered for sale."[17] It must be done with the intent not to pay for the property or to pay less than the offered price.[10]

The model instruction puts the elements this way: the defendant altered or switched a price tag, or in some other way misrepresented the price; did so intending to pay less than the actual price or nothing at all; did so inside the store or in the immediate area around it while it was open; and the difference between the sale price and the price the defendant intended to pay was in the charged band.[2] The price-switching page covers how this act differs from false pretenses.

Retail fraud by refund or exchange

The third act covers anyone who, "with intent to defraud, obtains or attempts to obtain money or property from the store as a refund or exchange for property that was not paid for and belongs to the store."[18] Because the statute says "obtains or attempts to obtain," a failed attempt is covered by the act itself, and the degree is set by the amount obtained or attempted.[18]

The model instruction requires proof that the defendant exchanged or tried to exchange property that had not been paid for and belonged to the store, with the intent to defraud or cheat the store, during store hours in or around the store, and that the amount was in the charged band.[3] One wording difference matters: the statute's price and stealing acts begin "While a store is open to the public," but the refund act does not, although the instruction for it asks whether it happened "during store hours."[19] The return and exchange fraud page covers this act.

Intent: what the person meant to do

The model instructions say the statutory language makes all three forms of retail fraud specific-intent crimes.[4] In plain terms, the prosecutor must prove what the person intended at the time, not only what the person did. For stealing that is an intent to permanently take the property without consent; for price switching, an intent to pay less or nothing; for refund fraud, an intent to defraud or cheat the store.[1][2][3]

Intent is a state of mind, and the evidence page covers the kinds of proof offered in retail fraud cases. For the general crime of larceny, the model instructions tell jurors that taking property under an honest belief of a right to take or use it is not larceny, even if the person was mistaken.[20] How intent-based defenses work in retail fraud cases is covered on the defenses page.

The value element and who decides it

The dollar amount is part of what the jury decides. In the theft instruction it is phrased as "the price of the property," with three bands: $1,000 or more; $200 or more but less than $1,000; or some amount less than $200.[6] The instruction tells the judge to give only one band unless the jury is also being instructed on lesser offenses.[6]

When the prosecutor charges separate incidents as one offense, the instructions include an optional paragraph telling jurors they may add together amounts from separate incidents that were part of a scheme or course of conduct within a 12-month period.[21] The aggregation page explains that rule.

What is not a jury element: prior convictions

A prior conviction can raise the degree of retail fraud, but it is not proved to the jury. The prosecutor must list the prior on the complaint and information, and the court decides whether it exists, without a jury, at sentencing or at a separate hearing before sentencing.[7] The former jury instruction on retail fraud priors was deleted for this reason.[8] The prior convictions page lists which earlier convictions count.

Proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and who weighs it

Each element must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt; if any one is not, the charge as written fails.[1] A defendant has the right to a jury and, under MCL 763.3, can choose a trial before the judge alone only with the prosecutor's consent and the court's approval.[22] Second- and third-degree retail fraud are tried in district court, where a criminal jury has 6 members and only a unanimous verdict is accepted.[23][24] The trial and jury instructions page covers how a trial runs.

Common questions

Does the prosecutor have to prove the person left the store?

No. The model instruction for retail fraud by theft says any movement of the property is enough and that it does not matter whether the defendant got the property past the cashier or out of the store.[5] The prosecutor must still prove that the defendant intended to permanently take the property from the store without the store's consent.[1]

Is hiding merchandise one of the elements of retail fraud?

Not as such. The theft instruction's elements are taking property offered for sale, moving it, intending to steal it, doing so inside the store or the immediate area around it while it is open, and the price band.[1] The word "conceals" appears in the price act, where the object is the price.[17] The concealment page covers how the stealing act is proved.

What intent is needed for refund or exchange fraud?

The statute requires that the person acted "with intent to defraud" in obtaining or attempting to obtain money or property as a refund or exchange.[10] The model instruction puts it as an intent to defraud or cheat the store, and it says it does not matter whether the exchange was for money or for other property.[3]

Does the jury decide whether a prior conviction makes the charge more serious?

No. When the prosecutor seeks a higher degree based on a prior conviction, the prior must be listed on the complaint and information, and the court decides whether it exists, without a jury, at sentencing or at a separate hearing before sentencing.[7] The old jury instruction on retail fraud priors was deleted for that reason.[8]

Who decides the case, a judge or a jury?

A defendant has the right to a jury trial and, under MCL 763.3, may choose a trial before the judge alone only with the prosecutor's consent and the court's approval.[22] In district court, where second- and third-degree retail fraud are tried, a criminal jury has 6 members and the verdict must be unanimous.[24][23]

Sources

  1. M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
  2. M Crim JI 23.14 — Michigan Courts
  3. M Crim JI 23.15 — Michigan Courts
  4. M Crim JI 23.13, Use Note 1; M Crim JI 23.14, Use Note; M Crim JI 23.15, Use Note — Michigan Courts
  5. M Crim JI 23.13(3) — Michigan Courts
  6. M Crim JI 23.13(6) — Michigan Courts
  7. MCL 750.356c(4); MCL 750.356d(7) — Michigan Legislature
  8. M Crim JI 23.16 [DELETED] — Michigan Courts
  9. M Crim JI introduction; MCR 2.512(D) — Michigan Courts
  10. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 750.356c(2) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 750.356d(2) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 750.356d(1), (4); M Crim JI 23.13(5) — Michigan Legislature
  15. M Crim JI 23.13, Use Note 2 — Michigan Courts
  16. M Crim JI 23.1, Use Note 2 (quoting People v Harverson, 291 Mich App 171, 178 (2010)) — Michigan Courts
  17. MCL 750.356c(1)(a); MCL 750.356d(1)(a), (4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 750.356c(1)(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(c), (4)(c) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); M Crim JI 23.15(4) — Michigan Legislature
  20. M Crim JI 22.3 — Michigan Courts
  21. M Crim JI 23.13(7); M Crim JI 23.14(6); M Crim JI 23.15(6) — Michigan Courts
  22. MCL 763.3(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 750.356d(1), MCL 750.356d(4), MCL 750.356c(1), MCL 600.8311(a) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 600.8355 — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.