SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

The evidence in a retail fraud case

Key points

  • Store video and photos must be authenticated with evidence sufficient to support a finding that they are what the offering party claims.[1]
  • A store record is not excluded by the rule against hearsay as a business record if it was made at or near the time in the regular course of business, unless the source or circumstances show a lack of trustworthiness; other rules, such as authentication, still apply.[2][1]
  • A defendant's own statement offered by the prosecution is defined as not hearsay, but a confession still needs independent proof that a crime occurred.[3][4]
  • On request, the prosecutor must provide exculpatory information, police reports, the defendant's recorded statements and search warrant papers.[5]

The proof in a retail fraud case can include store surveillance video, loss-prevention reports and receipts, statements the defendant made to store staff or police, and the merchandise itself. Each item has to meet the Michigan Rules of Evidence before a jury or judge can rely on it, and each side can get much of the other side's evidence before trial through discovery.[1][2][6]

This page explains the rules that apply to each kind of evidence. It does not cover how store security may stop, search or question a person, which is on the page about loss prevention searches and questioning, and it does not give advice about any particular case.

Surveillance video and photos

Video, photos and receipts must be authenticated: the party offering them must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what it is claimed to be, for example through a witness with knowledge or through distinctive characteristics taken with all the circumstances.[1]

  • Originals and copies. To prove what a recording shows, the original is required unless a rule or statute says otherwise; for electronically stored information any accurate printout or readable output counts as an original, and an accurate duplicate is admissible unless there is a genuine question about authenticity or unfairness.[7]
  • Lost recordings. Other evidence of the contents is allowed if all originals were lost or destroyed and not by the offering party acting in bad faith.[7]
  • Identification from video. The Court of Appeals held that letting a police officer testifying as a lay witness identify the defendant in a clear surveillance video invaded the jury's role, although the error was harmless in that case.[8]
  • Completeness. If one side introduces part of a recording or written statement, the other side can require the rest of it, or a related recording, to be considered at the same time when fairness calls for it.[9]

Store records and police reports

A loss-prevention report or other store record is not excluded by the rule against hearsay as a business record if it was made at or near the time by someone with knowledge, kept in the course of a regularly conducted business activity, and made as a regular practice, as shown by a custodian, another qualified witness or a certification.[2] It stays out if the opponent shows that the source of the information or the way it was prepared indicates a lack of trustworthiness.[2]

The hearsay exception for public records does not cover, in a criminal case, matters observed by law enforcement personnel.[10] A police report is still something the defense can obtain in discovery.[5]

Statements and admissions

A statement the defendant made, offered against the defendant by the prosecution, is defined as not hearsay; so are statements the defendant adopted and statements by the defendant's agent or employee within the scope of that job.[3] That definition answers only the hearsay question; the confession rule below and the limits on involuntary statements still apply.[4][11]

  • Confessions need independent proof. A confession may not be admitted unless independent evidence shows the specific injury and some criminal agency as its source, by a preponderance; proof of who did it is not required.[4] The rule covers confessions, not admissions of only some facts.[12]
  • Statements to store security. The Michigan Supreme Court held that store security acting on their own, without police instigation or assistance, need not give Miranda warnings.[13] In the same opinion the Court quoted with approval a California decision saying the guarantee against self-incrimination keeps the state from using involuntary answers as evidence, whether they were obtained by government or by private conduct.[11]

The merchandise and other recovered property

Any person making an arrest must take incriminating articles from the arrested person and deliver them to the sheriff, the police chief or the magistrate.[14] In felony cases covered by the Crime Victim's Rights Act, the investigating police agency must promptly return the victim's property, keeping an item as evidence only if, among other exceptions, the prosecutor certifies a need to retain it rather than a photograph or other record of it.[15] That rule is written for felony cases, such as first-degree retail fraud.[15]

Property seized under a search warrant must be listed on a tabulation given to the person searched (or left at the place searched) and kept as long as needed as evidence for trial, and stolen or embezzled property must be returned to its owner as soon as practicable.[16] At a larceny trial, jurors may, but need not, infer that a person who possessed recently stolen property committed the theft.[17]

Lost or missing evidence

To win a due process claim based on a failure to preserve evidence, a defendant must prove the missing evidence was exculpatory or that law enforcement acted in bad faith, and the trial court, not the jury, decides bad faith.[18] The quoted standard speaks of law enforcement; the separate rule on proving the contents of a lost recording looks at whether the offering party acted in bad faith.[18][7]

Discovery: getting the evidence before trial

In felony cases, a party must, on request, give the other side its witness list, recorded statements of lay witnesses it may call (a defendant need not hand over his or her own statement), expert information, criminal records it may use to impeach, and a description of and chance to inspect physical evidence it may introduce, including documents and photographs, with copies on request.[6]

On request, the prosecutor must also give each defendant any exculpatory information, police reports and interrogation records (with limited redactions), recorded statements by the defendant, a codefendant or an accomplice, search warrant papers, and any plea or immunity agreement for testimony.[5]

In misdemeanor cases, the same discovery rule applies, except that the mutual disclosure list applies only if the defendant asks for it, and a defendant who asks must also comply.[19] The domestic violence guide's page on discovery covers the same rule in more depth, and the drunk driving guide's page on discovery and video evidence discusses requests for recordings.

Challenging evidence before trial

In a felony case, the court at the preliminary examination must exclude evidence it finds excludable on motion or objection, and either side can ask the trial court to decide the question again.[20] Requests to suppress evidence from an unlawful police search are covered on the defenses page, and how the evidence is presented to jurors is on the trial page.

How long a store keeps its video, and whether a particular store's report meets the business-records rule, are fact questions the rules above do not answer for every case. The page on papers to keep after a charge lists records a defendant may want to hold on to.

Common questions

Can a police officer tell the jury that the person on the store video is me?

The Court of Appeals held it was an abuse of discretion to let an officer testifying as a lay witness identify the defendant in a surveillance video when nothing about the images, such as poor quality or a disguise, made the opinion necessary, because it invaded the jury's role. In that case the error was found harmless.[8]

What if the store's video was deleted?

The rules allow other evidence of what a recording showed if all originals were lost or destroyed and not by the offering party acting in bad faith. A separate due process claim over lost evidence requires showing the evidence was exculpatory or that law enforcement acted in bad faith, and the judge decides bad faith.[7][18]

Can what I told store security be used against me?

A defendant's own statement offered by the prosecution is defined as not hearsay, which does not by itself make it admissible. The Michigan Supreme Court held that store security acting on their own, without police involvement, need not give Miranda warnings; the same opinion quoted with approval language saying involuntary answers cannot be used as evidence, whoever obtained them.[3][13][11]

How does the defense get the police report and the video?

On request, the prosecutor must give the defendant exculpatory information, police reports and interrogation records, recorded statements by the defendant, and search warrant papers, and must let the other side inspect physical evidence it may use at trial, including photographs, with copies on request. In misdemeanor cases the mutual disclosure part applies only if the defendant asks for it.[5][6][19]

Sources

  1. MRE 901(a), (b)(1), (b)(4) — Michigan Courts
  2. MRE 803(6) — Michigan Courts
  3. MRE 801(d)(2)(A)-(D) — Michigan Courts
  4. People v Washington, 514 Mich 583, 605 (2024); People v Burns, 250 Mich App 436, 438 (2002) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCR 6.201(C)(1)-(5) — Michigan Courts
  6. MCR 6.201(A)(1)-(6) — Michigan Courts
  7. MRE 1001(d)-(e); MRE 1002; MRE 1003; MRE 1004(a) — Michigan Courts
  8. People v Perkins, 314 Mich App 140, 160-162 (2016) — Michigan Courts
  9. MRE 106 — Michigan Courts
  10. MRE 803(8)(B)(i) — Michigan Courts
  11. Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) (quoting In re Deborah C, 30 Cal 3d 125, 132 (1981)) — Caselaw Access Project
  12. People v Washington, 514 Mich 583, 605-607 (2024) — Michigan Courts
  13. Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
  14. MCL 764.25 — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 780.754(1)-(4); MCL 780.752(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 780.655(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
  17. M Crim JI 23.2 — Michigan Courts
  18. Arizona v Youngblood, 488 US 51, 57 (1988); People v Hanks, 276 Mich App 91, 95 (2007); People v Cress, 466 Mich 883 (2002) — Michigan Courts
  19. MCR 6.610(E) — Michigan Courts
  20. MCR 6.110(D)(2) — Michigan Courts

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.