SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

The preliminary examination in felony theft cases

Key points

  • The preliminary examination is held only in felony cases; there is none for a misdemeanor tried in district court.[1]
  • The examination is set 5 to 7 days after the probable cause conference, which is set 7 to 14 days after arraignment.[2]
  • If the court finds probable cause that a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it, the defendant is bound over to circuit court; if not, the defendant is discharged or the charge is reduced.[3][4]
  • A defendant may waive the examination only with the prosecutor's consent, and a waiver leads to bindover on the charge in the complaint.[5][6]

The preliminary examination is a hearing in district court where the prosecutor must show probable cause that a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it. If the court finds probable cause, it binds the defendant over to circuit court for trial; if it does not, it discharges the defendant or reduces the charge to a non-felony.[3][4]

The examination happens only in felony cases, so it applies to first-degree retail fraud and to felony larceny, embezzlement and similar charges, but not to second- or third-degree retail fraud.[1][7] This page sets out the timing, the standard and the possible results. The court process overview shows where it fits in the whole case.

Which theft charges reach a preliminary examination

Only a felony charge leads to an examination; there is none for a misdemeanor tried in district court.[1] Felony theft charges include:

  • first-degree retail fraud, where the price or amount is $1,000 or more, punishable by up to 5 years;[8][9]
  • first-degree retail fraud charged because second-degree conduct is combined with a qualifying prior conviction;[10]
  • larceny of property worth $1,000 to under $20,000, punishable by up to 5 years;[11]
  • larceny from a person, a felony at any value;[12]
  • larceny in a building, a felony that lists stores among the covered buildings;[13]
  • embezzlement of $1,000 to under $20,000.[14]

Second- and third-degree retail fraud cannot be prosecuted as larceny in a building.[15] The full list of levels is in the penalties chart, and the page Is shoplifting a felony in Michigan? explains the line between the levels.

Timing: the arraignment, the conference and the examination

At arraignment on the felony complaint, the court sets a probable cause conference 7 to 14 days later and the preliminary examination 5 to 7 days after the conference.[2] The same dates appear in the statute, MCL 766.4.[2] What the court tells the defendant at that arraignment, including the right to a preliminary examination, is on the arraignment and bond page.[16]

The probable cause conference comes first. By statute it includes plea discussions among the prosecuting attorney, the defendant and the defense lawyer, bail discussions with a chance to ask for a bond change, and discussion of stipulations; the prosecutor and the defense lawyer can agree to waive it.[17] On the prosecutor's request, the examination can start at the conference date solely to take and preserve the victim's testimony, if the victim is there and the defendant is present or has waived presence; the rest of the examination then goes ahead on the original date.[18]

Unless the court adjourns it, the examination must be held on the date set at arraignment.[19] The court may adjourn it for a reasonable time if the parties agree; over an objection it needs a finding of good cause on the record, and a violation is harmless unless the defendant shows actual prejudice.[19]

How the examination is run

A verbatim record is made, and the court must let both the prosecutor and the defendant subpoena and call witnesses, offer proofs, and examine and cross-examine witnesses.[20] The examination follows the Michigan Rules of Evidence, except that a statute lets certain reports and records in without testimony from their author or keeper, such as certified court and state agency records, business reports other than police reports, and reports by an officer or public agency other than the police investigative report.[5][21] Either side may ask to subpoena and call the person behind such a report on a showing that live testimony will be relevant to probable cause.[21] If the court decides that evidence being offered is excludable, it must exclude it on motion or objection; that ruling does not stop either side from asking the trial court to decide the question again.[22]

How the defense uses the hearing is a strategy question for the defendant and a lawyer; this guide does not address it. The evidence page describes the kinds of proof found in theft cases, and the domestic violence guide's page on the preliminary examination covers the same court rules from another angle.

The standard: probable cause

The court binds the defendant over for trial if it finds probable cause to believe both that a felony (an offense the district court cannot try) was committed and that the defendant committed it.[4] By statute the magistrate binds the defendant to appear for arraignment in circuit court within 14 days.[3]

The Michigan Supreme Court describes probable cause as evidence sufficient to cause a person of ordinary prudence and caution to conscientiously entertain a reasonable belief of the accused's guilt; the magistrate considers all the evidence, including the credibility of the witnesses, as it stands at the end of the examination.[23] At trial, by contrast, the jury is told the prosecutor must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt, meaning proof that leaves the jurors firmly convinced of guilt.[24]

Value and prior convictions at the examination

In retail fraud, the dollar amount sets the degree, and it is measured differently by method: the price difference for price switching, the store's offered price for theft, and the amount obtained or attempted for refund fraud.[25] For larceny, the jury instruction measures value as fair market value at the time and place of the offense.[26] Values from separate incidents within any 12-month period can be added together if part of a scheme or course of conduct.[27]

If the evidence shows probable cause only for an offense the district court can try, such as a lower degree of retail fraud, the court proceeds as if that offense had been charged from the start.[4] More on value is in how value is measured.

When a higher retail fraud degree rests on prior convictions, the prosecutor must list the priors on the complaint and information, and the court decides whether they exist, without a jury, at sentencing or at a separate hearing before sentencing.[28] The prior convictions page covers which priors count.

Waiving the examination

A defendant may waive the preliminary examination only with the prosecuting attorney's consent, and the court then binds the defendant over on the charge in the complaint or any amended complaint.[5][6] If a defendant without a lawyer waives the examination, the court must first make sure the waiver is freely, understandingly and voluntarily given.[16]

Whether to waive is a decision for the defendant with legal advice, and the guide takes no position on it.

Possible results

FindingWhat happens next
Probable cause for a felonyBindover to circuit court; a district judge may hold the circuit arraignment right away, and the prosecutor then files the information.[4][29][30]
Probable cause only for a district court offenseThe case stays in district court as if that offense had been charged.[4]
No probable causeDischarge without prejudice to a new prosecution, or a reduction to a non-felony; a new examination goes before the same judicial officer with additional evidence.[31]

A party who disputes the bindover decision must raise it before any guilty or no-contest plea or before trial.[32] On a proper motion, the circuit court must dismiss the information or send the case back to district court if it finds the rules on conducting the examination, excluding evidence or the probable cause finding were violated.[33]

In Kent County, after bindover all later hearings in a felony case are held in the 17th Circuit Court in downtown Grand Rapids.[34] Scheduling of examinations varies by district court.

Common questions

Is the preliminary exam a trial?

No. The question at the examination is probable cause: whether there is enough evidence to believe that a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it. The magistrate weighs all the evidence, including witness credibility, on that question. Guilt beyond a reasonable doubt is decided later, at trial, if the case gets that far.[3][4][23][24]

Can the prosecutor recharge me if the case is dismissed at the exam?

Yes. When the court finds no probable cause, it discharges the defendant without prejudice to a later prosecution for the same offense. Except as another court rule provides, the new examination must be held before the same judicial officer, and the prosecutor must bring additional evidence.[31]

Can a felony theft case be reduced to a misdemeanor at the exam?

Yes. If the court finds no probable cause for the felony, it may reduce the charge to an offense that is not a felony, and if it finds probable cause only for an offense the district court can try, the case continues in district court as if that had been the charge from the start.[3][4]

Can I plead guilty before the preliminary exam?

A plea can be discussed at the probable cause conference, and a district judge has authority to accept a felony plea when the parties reach an agreement. A circuit judge, whose name must be available before the plea, does the felony sentencing.[17][35]

Can the exam be postponed?

The court may adjourn it for a reasonable time if both sides agree. Over an objection, it may adjourn only after finding good cause on the record, and a violation is treated as harmless unless the defendant shows actual prejudice.[19]

Sources

  1. MCL 600.8311(e) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCR 6.104(E)(4)-(5); MCL 766.4(1) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCL 766.13 — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCR 6.110(E) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCR 6.110(A), MCR 6.110(C) — Michigan Courts
  6. MCR 6.110(A) — Michigan Courts
  7. MCL 750.356d(1), MCL 750.356d(4), MCL 750.356c(1), MCL 600.8311(a) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 750.356c(2) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 750.356(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 750.357 — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 750.360 — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 750.174(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 750.356d(3), (5); MCL 750.360 — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCR 6.610(I) — Michigan Courts
  17. MCL 766.4(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCR 6.110(B)(2) — Michigan Courts
  19. MCR 6.110(B)(1) — Michigan Courts
  20. MCR 6.110(C) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCL 766.11b(1)-(2); MCR 6.110(D)(1) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCR 6.110(D)(2) — Michigan Courts
  23. People v Anderson, 501 Mich 175, 178, 184 (2018), quoting People v Yost, 468 Mich 122, 126 (2003), as quoted in MJI Criminal Proceedings Benchbook Vol. 1, § 7.17 — Michigan Courts
  24. M Crim JI 3.2 — Michigan Courts
  25. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  26. M Crim JI 22.1 — Michigan Courts
  27. MCL 750.356c(3); MCL 750.356d(6) — Michigan Legislature
  28. MCL 750.356c(4); MCL 750.356d(7) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCR 6.111(A) — Michigan Courts
  30. MCR 6.112(B), (D) — Michigan Courts
  31. MCR 6.110(F) — Michigan Courts
  32. MCR 6.008(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
  33. MCR 6.110(H) — Michigan Courts
  34. Kent County, Public Defender — Defendant FAQs ("What is bind over/bound over?") — kentcountymi.gov
  35. MCL 766.4(3) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.