SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

Arraignment and bond in retail fraud cases

Key points

  • At a misdemeanor arraignment the court must give the name of the offense, the maximum sentence and the rights to a lawyer and a jury trial; at a felony arraignment on the complaint it may not ask for a plea.[1][2]
  • An indigent defendant charged with a misdemeanor has a right to an appointed lawyer whenever the court might impose jail, even suspended.[3]
  • Unless the defendant is ordered held without bail, release on personal recognizance or an unsecured appearance bond is the default unless the court finds it will not reasonably ensure appearance or will present a danger to the public.[4]
  • Release conditions can include staying out of specified premises or areas and limiting contact with named people.[5][6]

The arraignment is the first court hearing on a retail fraud or theft charge: the court tells the defendant what the charge is and what rights apply, takes up the question of a lawyer, and decides whether and on what terms the defendant is released.[1][7] In a misdemeanor case a guilty or no-contest plea can be taken at arraignment; at a felony arraignment on the complaint the court may not ask for a plea.[8][2]

This page explains the rules that apply to second- and third-degree retail fraud (district court misdemeanors) and to first-degree retail fraud and other felony theft charges. It does not cover release by appearance ticket or interim bond at the jail, which are on the pages about appearance tickets and booking and release.

Arraignment on a misdemeanor retail fraud charge

Different court rules govern misdemeanor and felony cases, and only listed Chapter 6 rules apply in district court misdemeanors.[9] At a district court arraignment the court must tell the defendant the name of the offense, the maximum sentence, and the rights to a lawyer at all proceedings, to an appointed lawyer when that right applies, and to a jury trial; the court can give this information in writing.[1]

A person who was arrested is entitled to a lawyer at arraignment unless he or she makes an informed waiver, or the court releases on a personal bond and will not take a guilty or no-contest plea at that hearing.[8] The court may allow a not-guilty plea, or standing mute, without a formal arraignment through a written statement signed by the defendant and any lawyer, and may require a bond first.[10]

If the defendant offers a guilty or no-contest plea, the court must first find the plea understanding, voluntary and accurate; for a no-contest plea it may not question the defendant about participation and relies on other information.[11] A district court magistrate may set bail but may not take a plea and sentence in a retail fraud or larceny case.[12][13] The choice between pleas is discussed on the plea agreements page.

Arraignment on a felony theft charge

At an arraignment on a felony complaint, the court must tell the accused the nature of the offense, its maximum prison sentence and any mandatory minimum, and the right to a lawyer at all court proceedings.[14] If the accused has no lawyer there, the court must also explain the right to remain silent, that anything said can be used in court, the right to have a lawyer present during any questioning the accused agrees to, and that the local indigent defense system will appoint a lawyer for someone who cannot afford one.[14]

The district court must also tell a felony defendant about the right to a preliminary examination and the right to consideration of pretrial release, and an unrepresented defendant's waiver of the examination is accepted only if freely, understandingly and voluntarily given.[15] The court sets a probable cause conference 7 to 14 days later and a preliminary examination 5 to 7 days after that, and it may not question the accused about the offense or ask for a plea.[2] What follows is on the preliminary examination page.

Appointed lawyers and indigency screening

In a district court misdemeanor case, an indigent defendant has a right to an appointed lawyer whenever the offense requires a minimum jail term or the court might impose jail, even suspended; without a lawyer or a waiver, the court may not sentence to jail.[3] If a defendant entitled to an appointed lawyer was neither represented nor waived the right, the conviction cannot be used later to enhance a charge or sentence.[16]

  • Screening. If the defendant asks for a lawyer and says he or she cannot afford one, the court refers the defendant for indigency screening to the appointing authority named in the local Michigan Indigent Defense Commission (MIDC) compliance plan, where there is one, and being able to post bond does not make the defendant ineligible.[17]
  • The statutory test. A defendant is indigent if unable to hire competent counsel without substantial financial hardship, which is presumed for people receiving food assistance, TANF, Medicaid or disability insurance, living in public housing, or earning less than 140 percent of the federal poverty guideline.[18]
  • The MIDC standard. The MIDC's standard, approved in 2021, presumes a defendant indigent who earns a net income under 200 percent of the poverty guidelines or is under 18.[19] For a teen whose case is in the family division rather than adult court, the Juvenile Code's own rules on appointing a lawyer apply.[20]
  • Partial indigency. A defendant who can pay part of the cost may be required to contribute, subject to judicial review.[21]
  • Giving up a lawyer. In a misdemeanor case, the right to a lawyer is not waived unless the defendant was told of the right and waived it in writing for the file or orally on the record.[22] In a felony case, before accepting a first waiver of counsel, the court must explain the charge, the maximum prison sentence, any mandatory minimum and the risks of self-representation.[23]

The MIDC explains that a defendant who needs an appointed lawyer will be given a financial form at court to fill out and return right away.[24] General background on choosing between appointed and retained counsel is in the domestic violence guide's page on court-appointed and hired lawyers.

How release and bond are decided

A person accused of a crime is entitled to bail except as otherwise provided by law, the amount may not be excessive, and the court must make findings on the record about the seriousness of the offense, protection of the public, the person's record and the likelihood of appearing.[25] If the defendant is not ordered held under the rule's limited no-bail provisions, the court must release the defendant on personal recognizance or an unsecured bond, on the conditions that the defendant appear, not leave Michigan without permission and commit no crime, unless that will not reasonably ensure appearance or will endanger the public.[4]

In choosing the terms, the court considers the defendant's record, history of appearing in court, substance use, mental condition, the seriousness of the charge, employment and finances as they relate to posting money bail, and ties to the community, and it may not base release on economic status.[26] If the court orders money bail, it must state its reasons on the record, and the defendant may then choose a surety bond for 1/4 of the amount, a 10 percent cash deposit, the full amount in cash, or property with the court's consent, unless the court requires the full amount.[27] For a misdemeanor arrest, the court may take the defendant's valid driver's license instead of other security.[28]

Release conditions in theft cases

When personal recognizance alone is not enough, the court may add conditions it finds reasonably necessary, including:

  • not entering specified premises or areas;[5]
  • restrictions on personal associations, place of residence, place of employment or travel;[5]
  • limiting or barring contact with named people, a condition the court can make effective immediately when needed to protect the case or a named person;[6]
  • reporting to a court agency, not using alcohol or illegal drugs, substance testing or treatment, a curfew, and continuing to look for work or attend school.[5]

In a felony case, violating a bond condition after a plea and before sentencing can cost the defendant the benefit of a sentence agreement.[29] The domestic violence guide's page on bond conditions explains how conditions work in general, and the trespass notice page covers bans issued by a store itself.

Changing or reviewing the bond

A party may ask the court with appellate jurisdiction to review a release decision, with no filing fee.[30] Before the arraignment on the information (the circuit court arraignment in a felony case), the court handling the case may modify a release decision on finding a substantial reason; at and after that arraignment it may decide the question fresh.[30] In a felony case, the probable cause conference also gives the defendant a chance to ask the magistrate for a bond modification.[31]

A defendant held in jail awaiting trial for 28 days on a misdemeanor, or 180 days on a felony, must be released on personal recognizance unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is likely not to appear or is a danger; some delays are not counted.[32] If a defendant who is ordered to pay the minimum state costs and the crime victim assessment posted a cash bond or bail deposit, the court must order them collected out of it.[33]

Arraignment schedules, video hearings and the forms used to request a lawyer vary by court. In Kent County, which office appoints the lawyer depends on the court and on whether the charge is a misdemeanor or a felony.[34]

Common questions

Can a judge order me to stay away from the store as part of bond?

Yes, if the court finds personal recognizance alone is not enough. The court rule lets a judge order a defendant not to enter specified premises or areas and to comply with conditions limiting or barring contact with named people. A store's own trespass notice is a separate matter from a court order.[5][6]

Can I get a free lawyer for a shoplifting charge?

In a district court misdemeanor, an indigent defendant has a right to an appointed lawyer whenever the court might sentence to jail, even suspended. If no lawyer is appointed and the right was not waived, the court may not impose jail. Kent County's indigent defense office explains that when a judge knows the sentence will be only fines or community service, there is no right to an appointed lawyer.[3][35]

Does posting bond make me ineligible for an appointed lawyer?

No. The court rule, which applies in felony and misdemeanor cases, says the ability to post bond for pretrial release does not make a defendant ineligible for appointment of a lawyer. A defendant who claims inability to pay is referred to the local appointing authority for screening, and one who can pay part of the cost may be asked to contribute.[17][21]

What is a 10 percent bond?

If the court sets money bail, the court rule lets the defendant choose among a court-approved surety bond for one quarter of the full amount, a cash deposit of the full amount, a cash deposit of 10 percent, or real property with the court's consent, unless the court orders the full amount by surety, cash or property. Money posted in cash can be used to collect the minimum state costs and the crime victim assessment.[27][33]

What happens if I turn myself in on a warrant?

If a person wanted on a bench or arrest warrant voluntarily goes to the court that issued it within one year, the court must either arraign the person, if it can within two hours, or recall the warrant and set a new date. The person is presumed not to be a flight risk when release terms are set. The rule does not apply to assaultive crimes or domestic violence offenses, or to someone who has already used it on a pending charge.[36]

Sources

  1. MCR 6.610(D)(1) — Michigan Courts
  2. MCR 6.104(E)(4)-(5); MCL 766.4(1) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCR 6.610(D)(2) — Michigan Courts
  4. MCR 6.106(B)-(C) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCR 6.106(D)(2) — Michigan Courts
  6. MCR 6.106(D)(2)(m) — Michigan Courts
  7. MCR 6.106(A) — Michigan Courts
  8. MCR 6.104(A) — Michigan Courts
  9. MCR 6.001(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
  10. MCR 6.610(D)(4) — Michigan Courts
  11. MCR 6.610(F)(1) — Michigan Courts
  12. MCL 600.8511(a), (f) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 600.8511(a), (b), (f); MCL 600.8512a(b); MCL 600.8513(1) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCR 6.104(E)(1)-(3), (6) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCR 6.610(I) — Michigan Courts
  16. MCR 6.610(G)(3) — Michigan Courts
  17. MCR 6.005(A)-(B); MCR 6.001(B) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 780.991(3)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  19. Michigan Indigent Defense Commission, Standards — "Standard for Determining Indigency and Contribution," Indigency Determination (b) — michiganidc.gov
  20. MCL 712A.17c(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCR 6.005(C); MCL 780.991(3)(a) — Michigan Courts
  22. MCR 6.610(D)(3) — Michigan Courts
  23. MCR 6.005(D) — Michigan Courts
  24. Michigan Indigent Defense Commission, FAQ ("How can I request an appointed lawyer?") — michiganidc.gov
  25. MCL 765.6(1) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCR 6.106(F)(1), MCR 6.106(F)(3) — Michigan Courts
  27. MCR 6.106(E); MCL 765.6(2) — Michigan Courts
  28. MCL 765.6(3) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCR 6.302(E)(2); MCR 6.310(B)(3) — Michigan Courts
  30. MCR 6.106(H)(1)-(2) — Michigan Courts
  31. MCL 766.4(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  32. MCR 6.004(C) — Michigan Courts
  33. MCL 769.1j(4); MCL 780.905(5) — Michigan Legislature
  34. Kent County, Public Defender — Defendant FAQs ("For which cases/courts do you appoint attorneys?") — kentcountymi.gov
  35. Kent County, Public Defender — Defendant FAQs — kentcountymi.gov
  36. MCR 6.105(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.