SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Retail fraud (shoplifting)

Concealing or Taking Merchandise: Do You Have to Leave the Store to Commit Retail Fraud?

Key points

  • Leaving the store is not an element of retail fraud by theft: the model jury instruction says any movement of the property is enough and it does not matter whether it got past the cashier or out of the store.[1]
  • Movement alone is not the offense; the prosecutor must also prove the defendant intended to steal, meaning to permanently take the property from the store without its consent.[2][3]
  • The theft act does not list concealing merchandise as an element; evidence about concealment is circumstantial evidence the jury may weigh along with everything else.[4][5]
  • Possessing a bag or device meant to shield merchandise from theft detectors, or removing a security tag before purchase, with intent to commit larceny, is a separate crime under MCL 750.360a.[6][7][8]

No, a person does not have to leave the store to be charged with retail fraud in Michigan. The model jury instruction for retail fraud by theft says "Any movement is enough. It does not matter whether the defendant actually got the property past the cashier or out of the store."[1] What the prosecutor has to add to that movement is proof of intent: that the person meant to permanently take the property from the store without the store's consent.[2]

This page covers the "steals" act in the retail fraud statutes, the elements the jury instruction lists, why leaving the store is a common myth, how concealment fits in as evidence, and the separate crime of using shielding bags or tag-removal tools. It describes the law only. For the other two acts, see price switching and return fraud.

The theft act in the statute

Each degree of retail fraud includes a person who, in a store or its immediate vicinity, "While a store is open to the public, steals property of the store that is offered for sale".[4][9] Two conditions come with that wording: the store has to be open to the public, and the property has to be property of the store that it offers for sale.[10][2] Theft from a closed store, or of property the store does not offer for sale, falls outside these words.[4][10] The page on where and when retail fraud applies discusses the boundaries and the other statutes that apply.

The degree depends on the price at which the store offered the property: less than $200 is third degree, $200 or more but less than $1,000 is second degree, and $1,000 or more is first degree.[11][12][13][14] Third degree is a misdemeanor with up to 93 days in jail, second degree a misdemeanor with up to 1 year, and first degree a felony with up to 5 years.[15][16][17] Prior convictions and the 12-month aggregation rule can raise the degree.[18][19][20]

The five elements of retail fraud by theft

The model jury instruction for this act, M Crim JI 23.13, requires the prosecutor to prove each of these beyond a reasonable doubt:[2]

  1. The defendant took some property that the store offered for sale.[2]
  2. The defendant moved the property; any movement is enough.[1]
  3. The defendant intended to steal the property, which the instruction defines as intending "to permanently take the property from the store without the store's consent".[2]
  4. This happened inside the store or in the immediate area around it, while the store was open to the public.[2]
  5. The price of the property was in the range for the degree charged.[2]

The use notes say the statutory language makes retail fraud a specific-intent crime.[3] So each element matters on its own. Movement without the intent to steal does not meet the instruction, and intent without any taking or movement does not either.[2] Where a taking is interrupted, the separate rules for attempts may come into play; see attempted retail fraud.

Why "you have to leave the store" is a myth

Under the model instruction, walking past the registers or out the door is not required: it does not matter whether the property got past the cashier or out of the store.[1] The general larceny instruction takes the same approach, telling jurors that it does not matter whether the defendant kept the property or whether it was taken off the premises.[21]

The flip side is just as important. Because any movement satisfies the movement element, the remaining elements, including the intent to steal, still have to be proved.[2][3] The instruction puts that on the prosecutor, who has to prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt.[2] For how lack of intent and mistake are raised, see legal defenses to retail fraud and theft charges.

Where concealment fits

The word "conceals" appears in the retail fraud statutes, but in the price act, where its object is the price: a person who "conceals, or otherwise misrepresents the price at which property is offered for sale".[22] The theft act uses the word "steals" and does not list concealment of merchandise as an element.[4]

Concealment still comes up in theft cases as evidence. Michigan's instructions tell jurors that facts can be proved by circumstantial evidence, meaning evidence that normally or reasonably leads to other facts, and that circumstantial evidence alone or combined with direct evidence can prove the elements of a crime.[5] Intent is one of those elements, so evidence about what a person did with merchandise can be offered on that question.[2][5] The jury decides what the evidence shows; concealment is not itself a separate element that settles the case.[2]

Evidence in theft cases can include store video, receipts, loss-prevention reports and witness testimony. Video and photos have to be authenticated by evidence sufficient to support a finding that they are what the offering party claims.[23] The evidence page covers the rules for each kind.

A separate crime: shielding bags and tag-removal tools (MCL 750.360a)

Since July 1, 2002, Michigan has had a separate statute aimed at theft-detection devices.[8] It is a crime to possess a laminated or coated bag or device intended to shield merchandise from an electronic or magnetic theft detection device, with intent to commit or attempt to commit larceny, and to make, sell or distribute such bags knowing or reasonably believing they will be used to commit or attempt larceny.[6] It is also a crime to deactivate or remove a theft detection device from merchandise in a retail establishment before buying it, or to possess a tool designed for that, with the same intent, and to make or sell such tools knowing or reasonably believing they will be used for larceny.[7]

MCL 750.360a violationClassificationMaximum penalty
First violationMisdemeanor1 year, a $1,000 fine, or both[8]
With a prior conviction under subsection (1)Felony4 years, a $4,000 fine, or both[8]

Each part of the section requires either intent to commit or attempt larceny or knowledge or reasonable belief that the item will be used for it.[6][7] The Organized Retail Crime Act separately lists removing, destroying, deactivating or knowingly evading an antishoplifting or inventory control device, to prevent its activation or to help another person commit an organized retail crime, as one way to commit that felony.[24][25] See organized retail crime and charges that can be filed alongside retail fraud.

When a stop turns physical

A theft that ends in a struggle can become a different, much more serious charge. Under MCL 750.530, a person who uses force or violence against someone present, or assaults or puts the person in fear, in the course of committing a larceny commits robbery, a felony punishable by up to 15 years; "in the course of committing a larceny" includes flight or attempted flight afterward and attempts to keep the property.[26] The Court of Appeals held in People v Passage that struggling to break free from a loss-prevention officer's grasp outside the store was "force" under that statute.[27]

Civil demand after a theft allegation

Apart from any criminal case, a person who commits an act that could be charged as retail fraud is civilly liable to the merchant for the full retail price of unrecovered or unsalable property and civil damages of 10 times the retail price, between $50 and $200.[28] If the merchandise was recovered in salable condition, the retail-price part does not apply.[28] See civil demand letters.

Common misunderstandings

  • "It is not shoplifting until you leave." Any movement is enough under the instruction.[1]
  • "Moving an item proves the crime." The prosecutor also has to prove intent to steal beyond a reasonable doubt.[2][3]
  • "Concealment is an element." The theft act says "steals"; concealment is evidence the jury may weigh.[4][5]
  • "A shielding bag is only evidence." With intent to commit larceny, possessing one is its own crime under MCL 750.360a.[6][8]

More beliefs like these are collected on the Michigan shoplifting myths page.

Common questions

Can I be charged with retail fraud if I never left the store?

Yes. The model instruction for retail fraud by theft tells jurors that any movement of the property is enough and that it does not matter whether the defendant got the property past the cashier or out of the store.[1] The prosecutor still has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant intended to steal it, meaning to permanently take it from the store without the store's consent.[2]

Is putting an item in a pocket or bag a crime by itself?

The theft act in MCL 750.356c and 750.356d is written as "steals property of the store that is offered for sale"; it does not name concealment as an element.[4] The jury instruction asks whether the defendant took and moved the property intending to steal it.[2] Where concealment is part of the evidence, jurors may consider it as circumstantial evidence, together with all the other evidence they believe.[5]

Is it illegal to carry a foil-lined bag or a tag-removal tool?

Possession is a crime under MCL 750.360a when it comes with intent to commit or attempt to commit larceny: the statute covers a laminated or coated bag or device intended to shield merchandise from theft detectors and a tool designed to remove or deactivate security tags.[6][7] Without a prior conviction under that subsection, a violation is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 1 year in jail, a fine of up to $1,000, or both; with one, it is a felony punishable by up to 4 years, a fine of up to $4,000, or both.[8]

How is the value decided when the charge is taking merchandise?

For the theft act, the statute uses the price at which the store offered the property for sale, and the jury instruction asks for "the price of the property".[11][29] That differs from general larceny, where the instruction asks for fair market value.[29] Under $200 is third degree, $200 to under $1,000 is second degree, and $1,000 or more is first degree.[12][13][14]

Can store employees stop someone before the person leaves the store?

A merchant, its employees and its security contractors may arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, whether or not they saw it.[30] In Bonkowski v Arlan's Department Store, the Michigan Supreme Court relied on a privilege under which a person who reasonably believes another has taken goods without paying may detain that person on the premises, without arresting, for the time needed for a reasonable investigation.[31] The limits on these powers are covered on the page about whether a store can detain someone.

Sources

  1. M Crim JI 23.13(3) — Michigan Courts
  2. M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
  3. M Crim JI 23.13, Use Note 1; M Crim JI 23.14, Use Note; M Crim JI 23.15, Use Note — Michigan Courts
  4. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  5. M Crim JI 4.3 — Michigan Courts
  6. MCL 750.360a(1)(a)-(b) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 750.360a(1)(c)-(e) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 750.360a(2) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 750.356d(1), (4); M Crim JI 23.13(5) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); M Crim JI 23.15(4) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 750.356d(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 750.356c(3); MCL 750.356d(6) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 750.356c(2) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 750.356d(2) — Michigan Legislature
  21. M Crim JI 23.1 — Michigan Courts
  22. MCL 750.356c(1)(a); MCL 750.356d(1)(a), (4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MRE 901(a), (b)(1), (b)(4) — Michigan Courts
  24. MCL 752.1084(1)(a)-(h) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 752.1084(2) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 750.530(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  27. People v Passage, 277 Mich App 175 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
  28. MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCL 750.356d(1)(b); M Crim JI 23.13(6); M Crim JI 23.1(6) — Michigan Courts
  30. MCL 764.16(d) — Michigan Legislature
  31. Bonkowski v Arlan's Dep't Store, 383 Mich 90 (1970) — Caselaw Access Project

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.