Key points
- The retail fraud statutes apply to "a person" and do not mention store employees, so they are written broadly enough to reach an employee as well as a customer.[1][2]
- Embezzlement under MCL 750.174 is aimed at agents, servants and employees who convert or dispose of an employer's money or property that came into their possession or control because of the job.[3][4]
- Embezzlement tiers run higher than retail fraud: retail fraud tops out at a 5-year felony for $1,000 or more, while embezzlement reaches 10, 15 and 20 years at $20,000, $50,000 and $100,000.[5][6][7][8]
- Embezzled amounts from one scheme against one employer may be added together with no time limit, while retail fraud and larceny aggregation is limited to a 12-month period.[9][10][11]
When the person accused of taking from a store is an employee, three groups of Michigan statutes can be in play: retail fraud, larceny, and embezzlement. Which one fits depends on the elements each requires, and choosing which statute to charge is the prosecutor's decision, not the court's.[12] The main dividing line is the employee's relationship to the property: embezzlement covers an employee who converts or disposes of the employer's money or property that came into the employee's possession or control because of the job.[3]
This page compares the statutes, their value tiers and their aggregation rules, and shows how common workplace situations line up with the statutory words. It does not cover workplace interviews, repayment agreements or the job itself; those are on accused of stealing from your employer. Employers can find their side on employee theft and embezzlement: a guide for employers.
Retail fraud: the statutes do not exclude employees
Each degree of retail fraud applies to "A person who does any of the following in a store or in its immediate vicinity".[1] The sections do not mention employees, receipts or checkout methods.[2] So the three acts are not limited to customers:
- Misrepresenting the price of property offered for sale while the store is open, with intent not to pay or to pay less.[2]
- Stealing property of the store that is offered for sale while the store is open.[2]
- With intent to defraud, obtaining or attempting to obtain money or property from the store as a refund or exchange for unpaid store property.[2]
Each act has its own conditions. The price and theft acts require that the store be open to the public, and the theft act covers property "of the store that is offered for sale".[2][13][14] Retail fraud is a specific-intent crime.[15] The retail fraud law also bars prosecuting second- or third-degree retail fraud as larceny in a building, even though a store is one of the buildings that statute lists.[16][17]
Embezzlement: the elements
MCL 750.174 reaches a person who, as the agent, servant or employee of another, fraudulently disposes of or converts to his or her own use, or takes or hides with intent to convert, without the principal's consent, money or personal property of the principal that came into his or her possession or control because of that relationship.[3] The model jury instruction, M Crim JI 27.1, breaks this into elements:[4]
- The money or property belonged to the principal, such as the employer.[4]
- The defendant had a relationship of trust with the principal, such as being its employee.[4]
- The defendant obtained possession or control of the money or property because of that relationship.[4]
- The defendant dishonestly disposed of it, converted it, or took or hid it intending to convert it without consent.[4]
- At that time the defendant intended to defraud or cheat the principal.[4]
- The value was in the range charged.[4]
"Conversion" in the instructions means using or keeping someone else's property without that person's permission.[18] The Use Note says embezzlement is a specific-intent crime and that an intent to return or replace the money later is not a defense.[19] Failing to pay, deliver or refund entrusted money or property on demand is prima facie proof of intent to embezzle; the jury may, but does not have to, draw that inference if the facts are not explained.[20]
Larceny, larceny in a building and larceny by conversion
General larceny requires that the defendant took someone else's property without consent, with some movement, intending at the time to permanently deprive the owner of it.[21] Larceny in a building, MCL 750.360, lists stores among the covered buildings, carries the default felony maximum of 4 years, and requires only that the property was "worth something".[17][22][23] As noted above, second- and third-degree retail fraud may not be prosecuted under that section.[16]
Larceny by conversion, MCL 750.362, covers a person to whom property was delivered who embezzles or fraudulently converts it or hides it with intent to do so; the instruction requires that the property was voluntarily transferred to the defendant and that the defendant intended to defraud the owner of it permanently.[24] The larceny by conversion page covers that offense.
Value tiers side by side
| Statute | Under $200 | $200 to under $1,000 | $1,000 to under $20,000 | $20,000 and up |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retail fraud (MCL 750.356c, 750.356d) | 93-day misdemeanor | 1-year misdemeanor | 5-year felony | 5-year felony (no higher tier)[25][26][5] |
| Larceny (MCL 750.356) | 93-day misdemeanor | 1-year misdemeanor | 5-year felony | 10-year felony[27][28][29][30] |
| Embezzlement by an agent or employee (MCL 750.174) | 93-day misdemeanor | 1-year misdemeanor | 5-year felony | 10 years under $50,000; 15 years under $100,000; 20 years at $100,000 or more[31][32][33][6][7][8] |
| Larceny in a building (MCL 750.360) | 4-year felony at any value; not available for second- or third-degree retail fraud[22][23][16] | |||
Each tier also carries a maximum fine, generally a stated dollar amount or 3 times the value, whichever is greater.[34][33] Prior convictions can move a charge up a tier under the retail fraud, larceny and embezzlement statutes, and embezzlement from a nonprofit or charitable organization moves up a tier too.[35][36][32][33] The felony tiers have sentencing guideline classes: first-degree retail fraud is Class E, and felony embezzlement by an agent runs from Class E to Class B as the amount rises.[37][38]
How common workplace situations line up with the statutes
Terms like "sweethearting", "under-ringing" or "discount abuse" are workplace labels; the statutes speak in terms of acts and intent. The descriptions below match situations to statutory words. They are not predictions of how any case will be charged.
- Taking merchandise. The theft act covers stealing store property offered for sale while the store is open.[2] Embezzlement can reach merchandise that came into the employee's possession or control because of the job and was then converted or disposed of with intent to defraud.[3][4] General larceny requires a taking without consent with intent to permanently deprive.[21]
- Taking cash from the register. Embezzlement covers an employee who converts or disposes of the employer's money that came into the employee's possession or control because of the job.[3] Failure to pay over entrusted money on demand is prima facie proof of intent to embezzle, which the jury may, but need not, rely on if the facts are not explained.[20]
- Ringing up a friend's items at a lower price or not at all. The price act covers a person who misrepresents the price with "the intent not to pay for the property or to pay less than the price at which the property is offered for sale".[2] A person who procures, counsels, aids or abets an offense may be tried and punished as if he or she committed it directly.[39]
- Processing a refund for merchandise no one paid for. The refund act covers obtaining or attempting to obtain money or property from the store as a refund or exchange for unpaid store property, with intent to defraud.[2] Help given before or during that act is analyzed under the aiding and abetting rules.[40]
- Giving merchandise away or applying unauthorized discounts. Embezzlement includes fraudulently disposing of the principal's property, not only keeping it.[3]
- A person who receives the goods. Buying, receiving, possessing or concealing property knowing, or having reason to know or believe, that it was stolen or embezzled is a separate crime.[41]
See aiding and abetting retail fraud, return and exchange fraud and receiving and concealing stolen property.
Adding up repeated amounts
The aggregation rules differ by statute, and the difference matters for employees accused of repeated small takings. For retail fraud and larceny, values from separate incidents in a scheme or course of conduct within any 12-month period may be added together.[10][11] For embezzlement, the same 12-month rule applies, but if the scheme is directed against only one person or entity, such as one employer, no time limit applies.[9] The embezzlement page covers the full statute.
Consequences beyond the criminal case
A business that suffers direct financial harm counts as a victim for restitution, and the court must order full restitution at sentencing.[42][43] Separately, a person damaged by another's stealing, embezzling or converting property may sue for 3 times the actual damages plus costs and attorney fees, although the Court of Appeals left the decision to treble damages to the fact-finder.[44][45] An employer may not deduct a suspected loss from wages without the employee's full, free and written consent.[46]
The records consequences also differ. Felony embezzlement under MCL 750.174 is a "crime of dishonesty" for Michigan's automatic set-aside law, and crimes of dishonesty are excluded from automatic set-aside, although they may still be set aside by application.[47][48][49][50] See automatic set-aside of theft convictions.
Common questions
Can a store employee be charged with retail fraud?
Nothing in the retail fraud statutes excludes employees. Each degree applies to "A person who does any of the following in a store or in its immediate vicinity", and the sections do not mention employees.[1][2] The charged act, its conditions and its intent element still have to be proved.[2][15]
What is the difference between embezzlement and retail fraud for an employee?
Retail fraud is defined by three acts in a store: misrepresenting a price, stealing property offered for sale, and refund or exchange fraud.[2] Embezzlement turns on a relationship of trust: the defendant got possession or control of the employer's money or property because of that relationship and then dishonestly disposed of it, converted it, or took or hid it intending to convert it, with intent to defraud.[4]
Is intending to pay the money back a defense to embezzlement?
The embezzlement jury instruction's Use Note says it is not: "The defendant's intent to return or replace the money at a later time does not provide a defense," citing a 1901 Michigan Supreme Court case.[19] Separately, failing to pay over, deliver or refund entrusted money or property on demand is prima facie proof of intent to embezzle, which jurors may, but need not, rely on if the facts are not explained.[20]
Can small amounts taken over several years be added together?
For embezzlement, yes when the scheme is aimed at one person or entity: amounts from separate incidents may be aggregated, and no time limit applies if the scheme targets only one victim.[9] Retail fraud and larceny aggregation is limited to separate incidents in a scheme or course of conduct within any 12-month period.[10][11]
Can my employer deduct a suspected loss from my paycheck?
Not without consent. Except for deductions required or expressly permitted by law or a collective bargaining agreement, a Michigan employer may not deduct any amount from wages without the employee's full, free and written consent, obtained without intimidation or fear of discharge.[46] The employee guide covers repayment questions in more detail.
Sources
- MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 750.356d(1), (4); M Crim JI 23.13(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(1) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 27.1 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(5)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(6) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(8) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(3); MCL 750.356d(6) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.301(D); Genesee Prosecutor v Genesee Circuit Judge, 386 Mich 672 (1972) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); M Crim JI 23.15(4) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 23.13, Use Note 1; M Crim JI 23.14, Use Note; M Crim JI 23.15, Use Note — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356d(3), (5); MCL 750.360 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.360 — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 22.11 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 27.1, Use Note 4 (citing People v Butts, 128 Mich 208 (1901)) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.174(10); M Crim JI 27.2 — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 23.1 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.503; MCL 777.16r — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 23.4(6) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.362; M Crim JI 23.10 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(2)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(3)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 750.356d(1), (4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(3)(b); MCL 750.356(2)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.16r — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.16i — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 767.39 — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 8.1(2)-(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.535(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2); MCL 769.1a(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(1); MCL 780.826(1)(b); MCL 769.1a(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2919a(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- Aroma Wines & Equipment, Inc v Columbian Distribution Services, Inc, 303 Mich App 441, 449-450 (2013), lv den in part 497 Mich 864 (2014), as described in 497 Mich 337 (2015) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 408.477(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621g(15) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621g(10) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621d(2) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.