Key points
- Store owners, employees, agents and security contractors may arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, even if they did not see it happen.[1]
- A store employee who makes an arrest must hand the person to a peace officer without unnecessary delay; neither that rule nor the merchant damages statute sets a number of minutes.[2][3]
- Since April 1, 2021, police must generally issue an appearance ticket and release a person arrested for a misdemeanor punishable by 1 year or less, which covers second- and third-degree retail fraud, subject to listed exceptions.[4][5][6]
- A store owner, occupant or their agent may forbid a person to come back, and entering without lawful authority after being forbidden is trespass punishable by up to 30 days in jail, a $250 fine, or both.[7][8]
- A civil demand letter can arrive later by mail, but the merchant can recover only if a formal police report was filed.[9][10]
When store staff suspect someone of shoplifting, Michigan law lets the merchant, its employees, its agents or its security contractor arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, and requires them to hand that person to a peace officer without unnecessary delay.[1][2] What follows can include police questioning, an appearance ticket or an arrest, a notice forbidding the person to return, and a civil demand letter in the mail later.[4][7][9]
This page walks through those steps in order, with the law that governs each one, and links to the page that covers each step in depth. The sequence is not fixed: what happens depends on the store, the police agency, the person's age and the facts, and several steps are choices the law leaves to store staff, officers and prosecutors. "Retail fraud" is the legal name for shoplifting in Michigan, and it covers taking goods, misrepresenting prices and false refunds or exchanges, in three degrees.[11][12]
The steps at a glance
- The stop. A merchant, employee, agent or security contractor may arrest for retail fraud committed "in that store" on reasonable cause, regardless of whether they saw it.[1] See what Michigan's merchant law allows.
- Holding the person. Neither statute that governs store stops sets a time limit. The tests are whether a detention was for "an unreasonable length of time" under MCL 600.2917 and the duty to deliver an arrested person to police "without unnecessary delay."[3][2]
- Questions and searches by store staff. The Michigan Supreme Court held that store security acting on their own, without police instigation or help, need not give Miranda warnings.[13] See loss prevention searches and questioning.
- Police. An officer may arrest for retail fraud without a warrant on reasonable cause, even if the officer did not see it happen.[14] See when police are called.
- Ticket or custody. For second- and third-degree retail fraud an appearance ticket is the default since April 1, 2021, with listed exceptions.[4][15] See appearance tickets.
- Fingerprints and booking photos. These are collected on arrest for a felony or a state-law misdemeanor punishable by more than 92 days, which by its terms includes third-degree retail fraud's 93-day maximum; a second subsection requires collection for 93-day offenses, including matching local ordinances, if it was not already done.[16][17][18][6] See booking and fingerprints.
- Trespass notice. The store may forbid the person to return; entering after that is a separate misdemeanor.[7][8] See being banned from a store.
- Civil demand letter. The merchant or its agent may mail a written demand for statutory amounts.[9] See civil demand letters.
- The criminal case. After a ticket, the officer must file a complaint in the court named on the ticket at or before the court date.[19] See the court process step by step.
Step 1: the stop and the store's legal authority
Two different laws apply to a store stop. MCL 764.16(d) is an arrest power: it lets store staff and security contractors arrest for retail fraud in that store on reasonable cause.[1] MCL 600.2917 is not an arrest power; it limits the kinds of damages a person can recover in a later lawsuit against the store if the store had probable cause and believed the person committed the theft.[3] In a 1970 case, Bonkowski v Arlan's Department Store, the Michigan Supreme Court also relied on a common-law rule that a person who reasonably believes another has taken goods from the premises, or failed to pay, may detain that person on the premises, without arresting, for the time needed for a reasonable investigation of the facts.[20]
Those limits matter on both sides. The damages limit does not apply if the person suing proves that the store used unreasonable force, held the person for an unreasonable length of time, acted with unreasonable disregard of the person's rights or sensibilities, or intended to injure.[3] The state civil rights law also bars a store from denying anyone full and equal enjoyment of its goods and services because of religion, race, color, national origin, age, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or marital status.[21]
Step 2: how long a store can hold someone
Michigan law answers this with standards, not a clock. A detention for "an unreasonable length of time" removes the store's damages protection, and a private person who has made an arrest must deliver the person to police "without unnecessary delay."[3][2] In Grand Rapids v Impens (1982), the Michigan Supreme Court case on store questioning, three men were in a store security office for about 15 minutes before police arrived and issued appearance tickets, and the Court, deciding whether Miranda warnings were required, said the detention did not last an unreasonably long time.[13] That was one case on its facts; it does not set a limit for others.
Step 3: questions, statements and searches
Store staff acting on their own are treated as private persons, so the constitutional rules that restrain police do not apply to them in the same way.[13] The Court of Appeals held in 1978 that the Fourth Amendment does not govern searches by private security guards, and the Supreme Court cited that decision with approval in 1982.[22][23] Statements made to store staff can be offered against the person who made them, although an involuntary statement can still be challenged.[24][25] The loss prevention page linked above covers the details, including when guards working with police are treated differently.
What happens during a stop can also affect the charge. Using force or violence against a person present, during flight or to keep the property, can make the offense robbery, a felony punishable by up to 15 years.[26] The Court of Appeals held that struggling to break free from a loss-prevention officer's grasp was "force" for that statute.[27]
Steps 4 and 5: police, a ticket or an arrest
Police may arrest for any degree of retail fraud without a warrant when they have reasonable cause to believe the offense happened and that the person committed it, whether or not it happened in front of them.[14] For second-degree retail fraud (up to 1 year) and third-degree retail fraud (up to 93 days), the appearance-ticket rule generally requires the officer to issue a ticket and release the person.[4][5][6] The officer may instead take the person before a magistrate for reasons the statute lists, such as refusing reasonable instructions, not giving satisfactory identification, or a request by the person, and must write down the reason.[15][28] First-degree retail fraud is a felony punishable by up to 5 years, so the ticket rule does not cover it.[29][4]
A person held under this rule instead of being ticketed must be charged or released by 3 p.m. on the next day arraignments can be held.[30] Interim bond and release are covered on the booking page linked in the list above.
Steps 7 and 8: the trespass notice and the civil demand letter
It is trespass to enter a store after being forbidden by the owner, occupant or their agent, or to stay after being told to leave; the penalty is up to 30 days in jail, a fine of up to $250, or both.[7][8]
The civil demand is a separate track from the criminal case. Under MCL 600.2953 a person who commits an act that could be charged as retail fraud is civilly liable to the merchant in addition to any criminal penalty.[31] The merchant or its agent may make a written demand and send it by first-class mail, after a manager other than the detaining employee approves the accusation in writing, except in a sole proprietorship.[9] Paying within 30 days after the demand is mailed ends further civil liability to the merchant, but the statutory letter itself says the civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution.[32][9] Whether to pay is covered on the page do you have to pay a civil demand.
When the person stopped is a teenager
Since October 1, 2021, a child under 18 who is arrested goes to the family division of circuit court rather than adult court, except for a statutory list of serious offenses that does not include retail fraud, although it can bring along other charges from the same incident; for a child 14 or older charged with a felony, such as first-degree retail fraud, the prosecutor may ask the court to waive jurisdiction so the case can be tried in adult court.[33][34] An officer who takes a child into custody must immediately try to reach a parent, and the child may not be held where adult prisoners can see or hear them.[35][36] Police and court intake workers may also divert a minor's case before any petition is filed.[37] See juvenile retail fraud charges.
Common misunderstandings
- "Store security must read you your rights." Not when acting on their own, under Grand Rapids v Impens; the exceptions involve guards working in concert with police and involuntary statements.[13][25]
- "Police can't arrest for a misdemeanor they didn't see." Retail fraud has its own provision allowing a warrantless arrest on reasonable cause, regardless of presence.[14]
- "Paying the store's letter ends the case." The statutory letter says civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution.[9]
- "The store can keep you as long as it wants." The legal tests are an unreasonable length of time and delivery to police without unnecessary delay.[3][2]
Keeping track of what happened
A stop can produce several papers on different timelines: a ticket with a court date, a store notice, and a letter from the store or its agent.[38][9] Keeping every document, noting dates, and writing down names while memory is fresh makes it easier to follow each track. The page on documents to keep lists them, and first steps after a shoplifting charge puts the deadlines in order.
Common questions
Can a store employee arrest me for shoplifting in Michigan?
Yes, within limits. MCL 764.16(d) lets a merchant, a merchant's agent or employee, or a security contractor arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, whether or not they saw it happen. The person arrested must then be delivered to a peace officer without unnecessary delay.[1][2]
Does the store have to call the police?
If store staff made an arrest, MCL 764.14 says the person arrested must be delivered to a peace officer without unnecessary delay. Separately, a store can recover money under the civil demand statute only if a formal police report was filed with the local police agency where the incident happened, regardless of the outcome of any criminal case.[2][10]
Will I be taken to jail or given a ticket?
For a misdemeanor punishable by 1 year or less that is not a serious misdemeanor, assaultive crime, domestic violence offense or drunk driving offense, the officer generally must issue an appearance ticket and release the person. The officer may still take the person before a magistrate for listed reasons, such as refusing reasonable instructions or not giving satisfactory identification. First-degree retail fraud is a felony and is outside this rule.[4][15][29]
Why did a letter demanding money arrive after the stop?
Michigan's civil demand statute lets the merchant or its agent make a written demand for payment and deliver it by first-class mail. Except for a sole proprietorship, a manager other than the person who first detained the shopper must approve the accusation in writing before the demand is issued. The statutory letter says the civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution.[9]
What happens if the person stopped is under 18?
A child under 18 who is arrested must be taken immediately before the family division of circuit court, and the arresting officer files a petition; the statute's exceptions (a list of serious offenses such as armed robbery, which can bring along other charges from the same incident, and a possible waiver to adult court for a child 14 or older charged with a felony) do not reach a second- or third-degree retail fraud charge on its own. An officer who takes a child into custody must immediately try to notify a parent, and unless the child needs immediate detention the officer must accept a parent's written promise to bring the child to court and release the child to the parent.[33][34][35][39]
Sources
- MCL 764.16(d) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.14 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2917(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9c(4); MCL 764.9c (History: Am. 2020, Act 393, Eff. Apr. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.552(1)(a)-(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.552(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(8) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c; MCL 750.356d — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c); MCL 750.356d(1)(a)-(c), (4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 764.15(1)(m) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9c(5)(a)-(f) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.243(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.241a(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.243(2); MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9d(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- Bonkowski v Arlan's Dep't Store, 383 Mich 90 (1970) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 37.2302(a); Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Holloway, 82 Mich App 629 (1978) — Caselaw Access Project
- Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) (quoting People v Holloway, 82 Mich App 629, 633 (1978)) — Caselaw Access Project
- MRE 801(d)(2)(A)-(D) — Michigan Courts
- Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) (quoting In re Deborah C, 30 Cal 3d 125, 132 (1981)) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 750.530(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Passage, 277 Mich App 175 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 764.9c(6) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9c(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.27; MCL 764.27 (History: Am. 2019, Act 103, Eff. Oct. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.27; MCL 600.606(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.14(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.14(1); MCR 3.933(D) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.823(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9f(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.14(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.