Key points
- MCL 600.2953 lets a store, or an agent of the store, send a written demand for money to a person it believes committed retail fraud, separate from any criminal case.[1][2]
- Except for a sole proprietorship, a manager other than the person who first detained the shopper must evaluate the accusation and approve it in writing before the demand is issued.[2]
- The statute prescribes the letter's text, including that the recipient is "not required to respond" and that the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution."[2]
- A store can recover civil-demand money only if a formal police report was filed with the local law enforcement agency for the place where the incident happened.[3]
A civil demand letter is a written demand for money that a store, or someone acting for the store, may send to a person it believes committed retail fraud (shoplifting).[2] The authority comes from MCL 600.2953, which makes a person who commits an act that could be charged as retail fraud liable to the merchant "in addition to applicable penal sanctions," so the letter belongs to a civil (money) track that runs apart from any criminal case.[1]
This page explains what the statute behind the letter says, who may send one, the wording the law prescribes, and the conditions a store must meet before it can collect. How much a store may ask for, whether a person has to pay, how the letter relates to the criminal case, and letters addressed to parents each have their own page.
The law behind a civil demand letter
Michigan's civil demand statute is MCL 600.2953, part of the Revised Judicature Act. It was added by 1988 PA 50 and amended once, by 1998 PA 313, effective January 1, 1999, and no later amendment appears as of November 2026.[4]
The statute ties civil liability to "an act for which he or she could be charged with retail fraud in the first, second, or third degree," and makes that person liable to "the merchant who is the victim of the act."[1] The liability covers the full retail price of property that was not recovered or that came back in unsalable condition, plus civil damages of 10 times the retail price, but not less than $50 and not more than $200.[1] The civil demand amount page works through that formula with examples.
Michigan's Penal Code also says that leaving out a civil remedy in the criminal statutes does not affect a victim's right to recover civil damages for the same act.[5] The civil demand statute is one of those civil remedies; the statutory conversion and treble damages page covers another.
Who may send a civil demand
The statute names two possible senders: "The merchant who is the victim of retail fraud in the first, second, or third degree, or an agent of the merchant."[2] Because an agent may make the demand, a letter can arrive from a law firm or a recovery company rather than from the store's own office.
Before a store other than a sole proprietorship issues a demand, one internal check is required. Except for a sole proprietorship, "a member of management, other than the initial detaining person, shall evaluate the validity of the accusation" and approve it in writing before the written demand is issued.[2] The employee who stopped the shopper cannot be the person who signs off.
The statute says the demand "may be delivered" by first-class mail.[2] The mailing date matters, because the statute's 30-day period for paying and ending civil liability runs from the date the demand was mailed, not the date it arrived.[6] The envelope's postmark is one record of that date.
The wording the statute prescribes
MCL 600.2953(2) says "The text of the written demand shall be as follows," and then sets out the letter.[2] The table below lists each part of the prescribed text in the order it appears.
| Part of the letter | What the statutory text says |
|---|---|
| The accusation | "We have cause to believe that on (date) you, or your minor child (child's name), committed retail fraud in the first, second, or third degree by (description of action and property involved) in our store or in its immediate vicinity."[2] |
| What is demanded | Up to three check boxes, "as applicable": return of the property in salable condition or payment of its full retail price; payment of the full retail price of recovered property not in salable condition; and civil damages of 10 times the retail price, not less than $50 or more than $200.[2] |
| The 30-day offer | "If you return any unrecovered property and pay the amounts indicated above to us within 30 days after the date this notice was mailed, we will not take any further civil action against you."[2] |
| No duty to respond | "You are not required to respond to this demand if you believe that you or your minor child are not guilty of committing retail fraud or if you choose not to respond."[2] |
| The lawsuit warning | If the demand is not met, the merchant is "authorized by state law to bring a civil action" to determine legal responsibility, plus "the cost of the action, including reasonable attorney fees."[2] |
| The criminal case | "These civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud."[2] |
The prescribed text calls itself "a formal demand for return of the property involved, if applicable, and the payment of the amounts indicated above."[2] A letter can be compared with the law by setting it beside this table. The statute does not say what follows if a letter departs from the prescribed text.
Conditions a store must meet before it can collect
A formal police report
A merchant "may recover the amount for which a person is civilly liable under this section only if a formal police report is filed with a local law enforcement agency that has jurisdiction over the location where the violation took place."[3] The report must set out facts alleging retail fraud, or a violation of a local ordinance substantially corresponding to sections 218, 356, 356c or 356d of the Michigan Penal Code (the false pretenses, larceny and retail fraud sections).[3]
The same subsection ends with the words "regardless of the outcome of any criminal action."[3] A store's ability to pursue the civil claim therefore does not depend, under the statute's text, on whether a prosecutor files charges or how a criminal case ends.[1][3] The civil demand and the criminal case page explains how the two tracks interact.
The price-marking exception and its outdated cross-reference
Subsection (9) says a merchant "shall not recover civil damages" for retail fraud involving a particular item if the merchant violated MCL 445.353 with regard to that item and the person accused did not cause the violation.[7] MCL 445.353 was the item-pricing section of a 1976 law; it was repealed effective September 1, 2011 by 2011 PA 15, while the civil demand statute, last amended in 1998, still names MCL 445.353 in subsection (9).[8][7][4]
2011 PA 15, the act that repealed it, treats a price as "displayed" if it is marked on the item or shown by signage, an electronic reader, or any other method that clearly conveys the current price where the item is located.[9] Whether a court would read subsection (9) as now referring to that newer duty is an open question, so this guide does not say the exception clearly applies or clearly does not.
What a civil demand letter is not
- It is not a court judgment. The prescribed text says that if the demand is not met, the merchant may "bring a civil action against you to determine your legal responsibility," which means a court decides liability only if the store sues.[2]
- It is not a criminal charge. The letter itself says the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution," and a court generally needs the prosecuting attorney's signed written authorization, or security for costs, before issuing a warrant or summons in a criminal case.[2][10]
- Its statutory text does not threaten prosecution. Michigan's extortion statute makes it a felony to maliciously threaten to accuse someone of a crime to extort money; the statutory demand text does not threaten prosecution and instead says civil proceedings do not prevent it.[11][2]
Where the next questions are answered
- How the amount is calculated, including the $50 floor and $200 cap: how much a store can demand.[1]
- What happens if the demand is paid within 30 days, or not paid: do you have to pay a civil demand.[6][12]
- Letters naming "your minor child": the statute lets a merchant recover from the parents of an unemancipated minor who lives with them, covered on the parents of minors page.[13][2]
- Where a store's lawsuit can be filed: small claims or any other court with jurisdiction, explained on the small claims page.[14]
- Restitution ordered by a criminal court is a different thing measured differently, explained on the restitution page.[15][1]
For the full sequence of events after a store stop, including detention, police and trespass notices, see what happens when a store stops someone. Store managers and loss-prevention staff will find the merchant's side of these rules on the guide for store owners.
Common questions
Is a shoplifting civil demand letter legal in Michigan?
Yes. Michigan's civil demand statute, MCL 600.2953, allows the merchant that was the victim of retail fraud, or the merchant's agent, to make a written demand for payment.[2] The statute also sets the wording the demand shall use, requires written management approval before any store other than a sole proprietorship issues one, and allows recovery only if a formal police report was filed.[2][3]
Why did the letter come from a law firm or a company I have never heard of?
The statute lets "an agent of the merchant" make the written demand, so the letter may come from someone acting for the store rather than from the store itself.[2] The text it prescribes still refers to "our store," because the claim belongs to the merchant that was the alleged victim.[2]
Does a civil demand letter mean I have been charged with a crime?
No. The letter is a civil demand for money, and the statutory text itself says "These civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud."[2] A criminal case is a separate matter: a court generally cannot issue a warrant or summons for a misdemeanor or felony without a written authorization signed by the prosecuting attorney, or security for costs.[10]
Can a store send a civil demand if the police were never called?
The statute's police-report condition is written as a limit on recovery: a merchant may recover the civil-demand amount "only if a formal police report is filed" with the local law enforcement agency that has jurisdiction over the place where the alleged retail fraud happened.[3] The report must set out facts alleging retail fraud or a matching local ordinance violation, and the condition applies "regardless of the outcome of any criminal action."[3]
Has Michigan changed the civil demand law recently?
No. MCL 600.2953 was added in 1988 and amended once, by 1998 PA 313, effective January 1, 1999; no later amendment appears in the Legislature's text current through PA 114 of 2026.[4] Pages that quote other states' civil-demand amounts or procedures are not describing Michigan law.
Sources
- MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(8) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953, History — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.4 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(9) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 445.353 (repealed); 2011 PA 15, enacting section 1; MCL 600.2953(9) — Michigan Legislature
- 2011 PA 15, sec 2(e) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.1(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.213 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(6) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(3); MCL 780.826(3) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.