SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · When a store stops someone

Can a store detain you for shoplifting? Michigan's merchant law

Key points

  • MCL 764.16(d) lets a merchant, its employees and agents, and a security contractor arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, even if they did not see it.[1]
  • MCL 600.2917 is not an arrest power. It limits a detained person's recovery of mental-anguish and punitive damages when the store had probable cause and believed the person stole.[2]
  • The damages limit falls away if the person proves unreasonable force, an unreasonable length of detention, unreasonable disregard of rights or sensibilities, or intent to injure.[2]
  • Store staff who make an arrest must deliver the person to a peace officer without unnecessary delay.[3]
  • Struggling to break free from loss-prevention staff while keeping merchandise can be charged as robbery, a 15-year felony.[4][5]

Yes, within limits. Michigan law lets a merchant, its employees and agents, and an independent contractor providing its security arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, even if they did not see it happen.[1] A separate statute, MCL 600.2917, does not grant any arrest power; it limits the kinds of damages a person can recover in a later lawsuit against a store that had probable cause, unless the store used unreasonable force or time or acted in other listed ways.[2]

This page explains both laws, who may use them, how long a detention may last, and where the protections for the person stopped come in. It is written to be fair to stores and to the people they stop. It does not tell anyone how to conduct, avoid or resist a stop.

Two laws that do different jobs

LawWhat it doesKey words
MCL 764.16(d)Lets store staff and security contractors arrest for retail fraud in that store.[1]"reasonable cause"; "in that store"; "regardless of whether the violation was committed in the presence of the private person"
MCL 764.16(a)-(c)Lets any private person arrest for a felony committed in their presence, for a felony the person has in fact committed, or when summoned by a peace officer to help.[6]Felonies only, apart from subsection (d)
Common-law shopkeeper's privilegeRecognized in Bonkowski v Arlan's Department Store: detention on the premises, without arresting, for the time needed for a reasonable investigation.[7]"reasonably believes"; "reasonable investigation"
MCL 600.2917Limits mental-anguish and punitive damages in a lawsuit against the store when the store had probable cause and believed the person stole.[2]"probable cause for believing and did believe"
MCL 764.14Requires a private person who has made an arrest to deliver the person to a peace officer without unnecessary delay.[3]"without unnecessary delay"

MCL 764.16 was last amended effective June 1, 1988, the same date the retail fraud offenses took effect.[8]

What MCL 600.2917 actually does

MCL 600.2917 applies to lawsuits for false imprisonment, unlawful arrest, assault, battery, libel or slander against a merchant or library, its agent, or a security contractor, when the claim arises out of conduct involving a person suspected of shoplifting or retail fraud.[2] It also covers libraries, museums and archives.[9] If the store or its agent had probable cause for believing, and did believe, that the person committed or helped commit the theft, the person suing cannot recover damages for mental anguish or punitive, exemplary or aggravated damages.[2]

That is a limit on damages, not immunity. Applying an earlier version of the statute with the same four exceptions, the Michigan Supreme Court held in Bonkowski v Arlan's Department Store (1970) that a person suing a merchant for slander may recover no more than compensatory damages unless one of the exceptions is proved.[7] The Court of Appeals held in Clarke v K mart Corp that even if a store had probable cause, the person may still maintain a false-imprisonment action, though damages may be reduced.[10] The statute was last amended in 1992.[11] The civil claims themselves are explained on the page about false arrest and false imprisonment claims.

The four exceptions

The damages limit in MCL 600.2917 does not apply if the person proves any one of the following.[2]

  • The store or its agent used unreasonable force.[2]
  • The person was detained an unreasonable length of time.[2]
  • The store or its agent acted with unreasonable disregard of the person's rights or sensibilities.[2]
  • The store or its agent acted with intent to injure the person.[2]

How long a store can hold someone

Neither MCL 600.2917 nor MCL 764.14 sets a number of minutes. MCL 600.2917 asks whether the detention lasted "an unreasonable length of time," and the common-law privilege recognized in Bonkowski covers the time necessary for a reasonable investigation.[2][7] Once store staff have made an arrest, MCL 764.14 requires them to deliver the person to a peace officer without unnecessary delay, and the officer then takes the person before a magistrate without unnecessary delay.[3]

In Grand Rapids v Impens, store detectives took three men to a security office, had them sign a "Loss Prevention Department Voluntary Statement," and called police, who issued appearance tickets; the men were there about 15 minutes, and the Michigan Supreme Court, deciding whether Miranda warnings were required, said the detention did not last an unreasonably long time.[12] The same opinion described store security's role as an extension of the common-law privilege to detain a suspected thief "for a reasonable period of time."[12]

Who can make a store arrest

The arrest power in MCL 764.16(d) belongs to a merchant, a merchant's agent or employee, or an independent contractor providing security for the store, and it is limited to retail fraud "in that store."[1] The retail fraud statutes themselves cover conduct "in a store or in its immediate vicinity," wording that differs from the arrest provision; see the store and immediate-vicinity element.[13] Where the suspected offense is first-degree retail fraud, a felony, the general private-person felony arrest rules in MCL 764.16(a)-(c) also exist.[6][14]

  • In-house guards. Security guards employed to protect their own employer's property and employees do not need a state license.[15]
  • Licensed private security police. A properly licensed private security police officer may arrest without a warrant on the same grounds as a public peace officer, but only on the employer's premises, during working hours, and in the employer's full uniform.[16]
  • Definitions. A "private security guard" offers, for hire, to protect property on the premises of another; "private security police" is the part of a business responsible for protecting its own premises.[17]
  • Impersonation. Falsely claiming to be an agent of a licensed private security guard, private security police officer, private college security force officer or alarm contractor is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days, a $500 fine, or both.[18]

Protections and duties during a stop

  • Holding property. Clarke applied the rule that keeping a customer's purse, without privilege, so that she reasonably believes she can leave only by giving it up, confines her.[10]
  • Agreeing to stay. There is no false arrest when the person voluntarily agrees to stay, as in Bonkowski, where the shopper returned and agreed to let a guard look in her purse.[19] Searches and questioning are covered on the loss prevention page.
  • Discrimination. Under the Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act a store may not deny full and equal enjoyment of its goods and services because of protected characteristics, and Clarke held a customer need not show an outright denial of access to bring the claim.[20]
  • Items taken at arrest. Any person making an arrest must take offensive weapons or incriminating articles from the arrested person and deliver them to the sheriff, chief of police or magistrate.[21]

When a stop turns physical

The law treats force during a stop seriously on both sides. For the store, unreasonable force removes the MCL 600.2917 damages limit.[2] For the person stopped, using force or violence against a person present during flight, or to keep the property, can make the offense robbery under MCL 750.530, punishable by up to 15 years.[4] In People v Passage the Court of Appeals held that physically struggling with a Meijer loss-prevention officer to escape was "force," and that store staff authorized to arrest under MCL 764.16(d) were engaged in the "administration of justice" for sentencing purposes.[5][22] Robbery is an "assaultive crime," so an appearance ticket must not be issued for it.[23]

What people get wrong

  • "The shopkeeper statute gives stores immunity." It only bars mental-anguish and punitive damages when the store had probable cause and believed the person committed the theft, and the four exceptions can remove even that bar.[2][10]
  • "Store employees can only make a citizen's arrest for a felony." MCL 764.16(d) covers every degree of retail fraud committed in the store, even if staff did not see it.[1]
  • "A store can hold you until police arrive, however long that takes." The tests are an unreasonable length of time and delivery to police without unnecessary delay.[2][3]

For what happens after the stop, see what happens when a store stops someone and when police are called. A store's power to ban someone from coming back is a separate question, covered on the page about trespass notices. Store owners will find a merchant-facing summary in the store owners' guide.

Common questions

Does store security have to see me take something before stopping me?

No. The merchant arrest provision, MCL 764.16(d), allows an arrest on reasonable cause to believe the person committed retail fraud in that store, regardless of whether the violation was committed in the presence of the person making the arrest. Separately, MCL 600.2917's limit on mental-anguish and punitive damages in a later lawsuit applies only if the store had probable cause and believed the person committed the theft, and it falls away if the person proves unreasonable force, an unreasonable length of detention, or the other listed exceptions.[1][2]

How long can a store hold me in Michigan?

Neither MCL 600.2917 nor MCL 764.14 sets a number of minutes. MCL 600.2917 asks whether the store detained the person for an unreasonable length of time, the common-law privilege the Michigan Supreme Court relied on in Bonkowski covers the time needed for a reasonable investigation, and a person who has been arrested must be handed to police without unnecessary delay. In Grand Rapids v Impens, deciding whether Miranda warnings were required, the Michigan Supreme Court said a stay of about 15 minutes in a security office did not last an unreasonably long time.[2][7][3][12]

Does MCL 600.2917 give stores immunity from lawsuits?

No. The statute bars damages for mental anguish and punitive, exemplary or aggravated damages only when the store had probable cause and actually believed the person committed the theft, and even then not if the person proves one of four exceptions. In Bonkowski, a slander case decided under an earlier version of the statute with the same four exceptions, the Michigan Supreme Court held that the person suing may recover no more than compensatory damages unless an exception is proved, and in Clarke v K mart the Court of Appeals held that a person may still sue even if there was probable cause, though damages may be reduced.[2][7][10]

Does a store security guard need a state license?

Guards employed by a store to protect its own property and employees do not need a license under the Private Security Business and Security Alarm Act. A licensed private security police officer has police-style warrantless arrest power, but only on the employer's premises, during working hours and in the employer's full uniform. Falsely claiming to be an agent of a licensed private security guard, private security police officer or alarm contractor is a misdemeanor.[15][16][18]

Can holding my purse or bag count as detaining me?

The Court of Appeals in Clarke v K mart applied the rule that a store owner who, without any privilege, keeps a customer's purse so that she reasonably believes she can leave only by giving it up has confined her. Whether a store intended to hold the person or only the merchandise was a fact question in that case, not a ruling that the store was liable.[10]

Sources

  1. MCL 764.16(d) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 600.2917(1) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 764.14 — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 750.530(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  5. People v Passage, 277 Mich App 175 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
  6. MCL 764.16(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  7. Bonkowski v Arlan's Dep't Store, 383 Mich 90 (1970) — Caselaw Access Project
  8. MCL 764.16 (History); MCL 750.356d (History) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 600.2917(2)(a)-(b) — Michigan Legislature
  10. Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
  11. MCL 600.2917 (History) — Michigan Legislature
  12. Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
  13. MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 750.356d(1), (4); MCL 764.16(d) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 338.1079(2) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 338.1080 — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 338.1052(1)(g)-(h) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 338.1067(5) — Michigan Legislature
  19. Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992); Bonkowski v Arlan's Dep't Store, 383 Mich 90, 96-97 (1970) — Caselaw Access Project
  20. MCL 37.2302(a); Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 764.25 — Michigan Legislature
  22. People v Passage, 277 Mich App 175 (2007); MCL 777.49(b) — Caselaw Access Project
  23. MCL 770.9a(3); MCL 764.9c(3)(e), (9)(a) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.