Key points
- Even the lowest level of retail fraud is a misdemeanor with up to 93 days in jail, although for misdemeanors other than serious misdemeanors there is a rebuttable presumption of a non-jail, non-probation sentence.[1][2]
- Leaving the store is not required; any movement of the merchandise can satisfy the taking element, but intent to steal must still be proved.[3][4]
- Complying with a store's civil demand within 30 days after it was mailed ends further civil liability to the store for that act; the required letter says the civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution.[5][6]
- Stores are not immune from suits over a detention, but probable cause limits some kinds of damages unless an exception is proved.[7]
- The State Police list all three degrees of retail fraud as eligible for automatic set-aside, and set-aside by application is also available after a waiting period, subject to limits and conditions.[8][9][10]
Some beliefs about shoplifting in Michigan are out of date, borrowed from other states, or only half right. In Michigan, the crime people call shoplifting is "retail fraud" in the first, second or third degree, under MCL 750.356c and 750.356d.[11] Below are 20 beliefs checked against the statutes, court decisions and model jury instructions, each with the page that explains the rule in full.
The myths cover all sides: people accused of retail fraud, parents, store owners, loss-prevention staff and employers. Each entry states what the law says, not what will happen in a particular case; practice varies by court.
Myths about the charge itself
Myth 1: "Taking something small is just a ticket, not a real crime."
The belief. A low-value shoplifting case is handled like a traffic infraction.
The law. Third-degree retail fraud, for amounts under $200, is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days in jail and a fine of up to $500 or 3 times the value, whichever is greater.[12][1] Police may release a person with an appearance ticket, but that ticket is a complaint or written notice to appear in a criminal court at a set time.[13][14]
Detailed guide: third-degree retail fraud.
Myth 2: "It isn't shoplifting until you walk out the door."
The belief. Nothing counts until the person gets past the registers or out of the building.
The law. Michigan's model jury instruction says any movement of the property is enough, and it does not matter whether the property got past the cashier or out of the store.[3] The prosecutor still must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the person intended to steal, meaning to take the property permanently without the store's consent.[4][15]
Detailed guide: elements of retail fraud.
Myth 3: "The fine can never be more than the dollar figure in the statute."
The belief. Each degree has a fixed fine ceiling that does not change with the amount taken.
The law. For every degree of retail fraud, the maximum fine is the stated cap or 3 times the value involved, whichever is greater.[16] On a larger theft, the fine ceiling can exceed the stated dollar figure.[16]
Detailed guide: first-offense penalties.
Myth 4: "Any earlier shoplifting conviction makes the next one a felony."
The belief. Once someone has a record, every new case is automatically treated at the top level.
The law. Priors work in steps. A third-degree case with a qualifying prior becomes second degree, a 1-year misdemeanor.[17][18] A second-degree case becomes a first-degree felony only with a prior from a narrower list: first- or second-degree retail fraud, larceny, larceny in a building or false pretenses, not counting under-$200 larceny or false pretenses convictions.[19] That list does not name third-degree retail fraud or a local ordinance conviction.[19] When the prosecutor seeks a higher degree because of a prior, the prior must be listed on the charging papers, and the judge decides whether it exists, without a jury.[20]
Detailed guide: prior convictions and retail fraud.
Myth 5: "Small thefts can always be added up into one big charge."
The belief. A prosecutor can total every incident ever alleged to reach a higher degree.
The law. For retail fraud, values from separate incidents may be added together only if they were part of a scheme or course of conduct within any 12-month period.[21] Embezzlement is different: if the scheme targets one person or entity, such as one employer, there is no time limit on adding amounts together.[22]
Detailed guide: the 12-month aggregation rule.
Myth 6: "Shoving past a security guard on the way out is still just shoplifting."
The belief. A struggle at the door does not change what the case is about.
The law. Using force or violence against a person present, or putting the person in fear, during a larceny, including during flight or an attempt to keep the property, is robbery, a felony punishable by up to 15 years.[23] The Court of Appeals held in People v Passage (2007) that struggling with loss-prevention staff to escape was "force" supporting a robbery conviction.[24]
Detailed guide: charges that can accompany retail fraud.
Myths about stores, police and the civil demand letter
Myth 7: "Paying the store's civil demand makes the criminal case go away."
The belief. Settling with the store ends everything.
The law. The letter Michigan law requires states that the civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged retail fraud.[6] Paying within 30 days after the demand was mailed ends further civil liability to the merchant for that act, which is a separate matter from any criminal charge.[5]
Detailed guide: civil demand and the criminal case.
Myth 8: "A civil demand letter is either a scam or a bill that must be paid."
The belief. The letter is either junk to throw away or an ordinary bill.
The law. A merchant or its agent may make a written demand under MCL 600.2953.[6] The required text says the recipient is not required to respond if he or she believes that he or she (or his or her minor child) is not guilty of retail fraud, or chooses not to respond.[6] It also warns that if the demand is not met, the merchant is authorized to file a civil lawsuit for the amounts demanded plus the cost of the action, including reasonable attorney fees.[6] The merchant can recover only if a formal police report was filed.[25]
Detailed guide: do you have to pay a civil demand.
Myth 9: "Store security has to read you your rights."
The belief. Statements to loss-prevention staff cannot be used without Miranda warnings.
The law. In Grand Rapids v Impens (1982), the Michigan Supreme Court held that statements to private store security who are not acting at police instigation, and work without police assistance, do not need Miranda warnings and are admissible.[26] The court noted that guards who receive direct help from police or work in close connection with them may be treated as acting for the state, and found no such cooperation in that case.[26]
Detailed guide: loss prevention searches and questioning.
Myth 10: "Only police can arrest a shoplifter."
The belief. Store employees can watch and call police, but cannot detain anyone.
The law. A merchant, the merchant's employee or agent, or a security contractor for the store may arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, whether or not they saw it happen.[27] Police may also arrest for retail fraud without a warrant on reasonable cause, even if the officer did not see it.[28]
Detailed guide: can a store detain you.
Myth 11: "Miss the court date on a ticket and a warrant issues automatically."
The belief. Any missed appearance leads straight to an arrest warrant.
The law. Since April 1, 2021, when a person fails to appear on an appearance ticket, there is a rebuttable presumption that the court must issue an order to show cause why the person failed to appear, instead of a warrant.[29] Because the presumption is rebuttable, a warrant is still possible.[29]
Detailed guide: appearance tickets.
Myths about court, sentencing and records
Myth 12: "A 17-year-old caught shoplifting is charged as an adult."
The belief. Older teens who shoplift go straight to adult criminal court.
The law. Since October 1, 2021, the family division of circuit court has exclusive original jurisdiction over law violations by juveniles under 18.[30] Before that date, "juvenile" generally meant a person under 17.[31] There are exceptions: for example, if a child 14 or older is charged with a felony, the family court may, on the prosecutor's motion, waive jurisdiction so the child can be tried in adult court.[32]
Detailed guide: juvenile retail fraud charges.
Myth 13: "A retail fraud conviction means jail."
The belief. Every conviction comes with time behind bars.
The law. For a misdemeanor that is not a "serious misdemeanor," there is a rebuttable presumption of a fine, community service or another non-jail, non-probation sentence, in effect since March 24, 2021.[2][33] The statutory list of serious misdemeanors does not name retail fraud.[34] The same list also counts a violation charged as a "crime" and later reduced to or pleaded to as a misdemeanor, and the Court of Appeals held in People v Williams (2026) that this reaches any felony-level charge pleaded down to a misdemeanor, so a felony retail fraud charge reduced to second or third degree is a serious misdemeanor.[35][36] The presumption can be overcome, and the statutory maximums still apply.[2][18][1]
Detailed guide: retail fraud sentencing.
Myth 14: "HYTA is only for ages 17 to 21."
The belief. The Holmes Youthful Trainee Act (HYTA) covers only teenagers and very young adults.
The law. Beginning October 1, 2021, the court may assign HYTA status for an offense committed on or after the 18th birthday but before the 26th birthday.[37] For an offense committed at 21 or older, the prosecutor must also consent.[37] The 17 to 20 range ended when 2015 PA 31 took effect on August 18, 2015, and the 17 to 23 range applied until October 1, 2021.[38] HYTA requires a guilty plea; the benchbook reports Court of Appeals decisions holding that no-contest pleas and trial convictions are not eligible.[39]
Detailed guide: HYTA and retail fraud.
Myth 15: "Restitution can be bargained away, or skipped with HYTA."
The belief. A plea deal or a diversion outcome ends any duty to repay the victim.
The law. The Court of Appeals explained in People v Ronowski (1997) that restitution has been mandatory since May 1, 1994, and is no longer open to plea or sentence bargaining.[40] Restitution must still be ordered when a case ends in HYTA status, a delayed sentence or a deferral.[41]
Detailed guide: restitution in theft cases.
Myth 16: "A shoplifting conviction stays on your record forever."
The belief. Nothing can be done about an old retail fraud conviction.
The law. A misdemeanor other than a serious misdemeanor, a first drunk-driving offense or an assaultive crime may be set aside by application 3 or more years after sentencing or completion of jail or probation, whichever is latest.[9] An application for one felony, such as first-degree retail fraud, or for serious misdemeanors may be filed 5 or more years after the latest of sentencing, probation, parole or any prison or jail term.[10] The State Police's Clean Slate lookup lists all three degrees of retail fraud as eligible for automatic set-aside, which comes 7 years after sentencing for a misdemeanor punishable by 93 days or more and 10 years after the later of sentencing or prison release for a felony, subject to limits and conditions.[8][42][43] A misdemeanor that resulted from a reduced felony charge is a serious misdemeanor, as described in Myth 13, which changes the waiting periods.[35][36]
Detailed guide: automatic set-aside.
Myths held by stores, employers and victims
Myth 17: "Stores are immune from lawsuits when they stop a suspected shoplifter."
The belief. A merchant who detains someone cannot be sued over it.
The law. MCL 600.2917 applies to suits for false imprisonment, unlawful arrest, assault, battery, libel or slander arising from a shoplifting stop.[7] If the store had probable cause to believe, and did believe, that the person took goods or committed retail fraud, the person suing cannot recover damages for mental anguish or punitive, exemplary or aggravated damages.[7] That limit does not apply if the person proves unreasonable force, an unreasonable length of detention, unreasonable disregard of rights, or intent to injure.[7]
Detailed guide: false arrest claims after a detention.
Myth 18: "If the person turns out to be innocent, the store that called police is automatically liable."
The belief. Reporting a suspect is risky for a store whenever the case falls apart.
The law. In Lewis v Farmer Jack (1982), a robbery case, the Michigan Supreme Court held that store employees who called police and pointed out a suspect did no more than provide information, and the store was not liable for false arrest where police acted on their own judgment with probable cause, even though the man turned out to be innocent.[44] The court described a false arrest as an illegal or unjustified arrest.[44] In Matthews (1998), a case about an insurer's fraud report, the court held that the prosecutor's independent decision to prosecute is a complete defense to a malicious-prosecution suit against the person who reported, unless that person knowingly gave false information that the prosecutor acted on.[45]
Detailed guide: store owners' guide.
Myth 19: "An employer can take missing money out of the employee's paycheck."
The belief. An employer who suspects theft can recover it through payroll.
The law. Apart from deductions required or expressly allowed by law or a union contract, a Michigan employer may not deduct any amount from wages without the employee's full, free and written consent, obtained without intimidation or fear of discharge.[46] A deduction for the employer's benefit needs written consent for each paycheck and may not bring gross pay below the Michigan minimum wage.[47]
Detailed guide: employers' guide to employee theft.
Myth 20: "The state victim fund will repay stolen merchandise."
The belief. A business can file with the state to recover the value of stolen goods.
The law. Michigan's crime victim compensation program requires a personal injury, and a crime that causes bodily harm or a threat of injury or death; a theft with no injury or threat does not qualify.[48] Awards are limited to out-of-pocket loss resulting from the personal injury, such as medical care and psychological or grief counseling, plus lost earnings or support, with a total cap of $45,000 per claimant.[49] In the criminal case, the court must order full restitution to any victim of the conduct that gave rise to the conviction.[50]
Detailed guide: theft victim rights for businesses.
Common questions
Is shoplifting a felony in Michigan?
It depends on the amount and on prior convictions. Retail fraud of $1,000 or more is first degree, a felony punishable by up to 5 years.[51][52] A second-degree offense from $200 to under $1,000 also becomes first degree when the person has a qualifying prior conviction.[19] Second and third degree are misdemeanors.[18][1]
Does a store need a police report to collect a civil demand?
Yes, to recover. A merchant may recover civil-demand amounts only if a formal police report was filed with the local law enforcement agency that has jurisdiction where the incident happened, setting out facts alleging retail fraud or a matching local ordinance violation, regardless of the outcome of any criminal case.[25] The statute also requires a member of management, other than the employee who made the stop, to approve the accusation in writing before a demand is sent, except in a sole proprietorship.[6]
Can a store hold a suspected shoplifter until police arrive?
Store staff may arrest a person they have reasonable cause to believe committed retail fraud in that store, whether or not they saw it.[27] A person arrested by a private person must be turned over to a peace officer without unnecessary delay.[53] Short of an arrest, the Michigan Supreme Court in Bonkowski (1970) relied on a rule that a person who reasonably believes goods were taken may detain the suspect on the premises for the time needed for a reasonable investigation.[54] If a person proves the store detained him or her for an unreasonable length of time, the statute's limit on damages does not apply.[7]
Sources
- MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 769.5(3) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 23.13(3) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 23.13 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2917(1) — Michigan Legislature
- Michigan State Police, Clean Slate MCL Search (queried 17 November 2026) — mclsearch.msp.state.mi.us
- MCL 780.621d(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621d(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c; MCL 750.356d — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9f(1) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 23.13, Use Note 1; M Crim JI 23.14, Use Note; M Crim JI 23.15, Use Note — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 750.356d(1), (4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(4); MCL 750.356d(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(3); MCL 750.356d(6) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(8) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.530(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Passage, 277 Mich App 175 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 600.2953(8) — Michigan Legislature
- Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 764.16(d) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.15(1)(m) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.9e(2); MCL 764.9e (History) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2(a)(1); MCL 712A.2 (History: Am. 2019, Act 113, Eff. Oct. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.1(1)(i); 2019 PA 113 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 764.27 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 769.5 as amended by 2015 PA 216; MCL 769.5(3) and History — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.811(1)(a); MCL 769.5(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.811(1)(a)(xxiii) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Williams, ___ Mich App ___ (2026) (Docket No. 370658, decided April 13, 2026) — michbar.org
- MCL 762.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 762.11(1); MJI Criminal Proceedings Benchbook vol 2, §9.10 n 64 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 762.11(2); People v Dash, 216 Mich App 412 (1996) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
- People v Ronowski, 222 Mich App 58 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621g(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621g(2) — Michigan Legislature
- Lewis v Farmer Jack Div, Inc, 415 Mich 212 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
- Matthews v Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Michigan, 456 Mich 365 (1998) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 408.477(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 408.477(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 18.351(c)(i), (i), (k) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 18.361(1)-(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2); MCL 769.1a(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.14 — Michigan Legislature
- Bonkowski v Arlan's Dep't Store, 383 Mich 90 (1970) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 712A.28(2)-(3), (5)(d) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.18t(1), (11) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.