Key points
- The letter text set by MCL 600.2953 says "These civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud."[1]
- A merchant's civil claim depends on a police report having been filed, "regardless of the outcome of any criminal action," so a dismissal or acquittal does not by itself end it.[2]
- A criminal court must still order full restitution to the victim on conviction, and restitution is not open to plea bargaining.[3][4]
- The Michigan Court of Appeals has held that a civil settlement with the victim did not relieve the sentencing court of its duty to order restitution, and by statute restitution actually paid is set off against later civil damages.[5][6]
Paying a civil demand does not, by itself, stop a criminal retail fraud case. The text Michigan law prescribes for the demand letter says so directly: "These civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud."[1] The civil demand and the criminal case are separate tracks with separate decision-makers: the merchant pursues the civil claim under MCL 600.2953, while a criminal warrant or summons generally requires a written authorization signed by the prosecuting attorney, or security for costs.[1][7]
This page explains how the two tracks touch each other: what paying does and does not do, what a criminal outcome does to the civil claim, how restitution fits in, and which evidence rules are involved. It does not describe how any prosecutor treats a payment, because no statute sets that and practice varies.
Two tracks, side by side
| Question | Civil demand (MCL 600.2953) | Criminal retail fraud case |
|---|---|---|
| Who starts it | The merchant, or an agent of the merchant, by written demand[1] | A warrant or summons generally needs the prosecuting attorney's signed written authorization, or security for costs[7] |
| What it can lead to | Retail price of unrecovered or unsalable goods plus civil damages of $50 to $200, and costs and fees if a lawsuit is needed[8][9] | Penalties set by the retail fraud statutes, such as up to 93 days and a fine of up to $500 or 3 times the value for the third degree, plus mandatory restitution[10][3] |
| Effect of the other track | Recovery allowed "regardless of the outcome of any criminal action" if a police report was filed[2] | The civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution"[1] |
| What ends it early | Complying within 30 days after mailing ends further civil liability to the merchant[11] | Charging decisions are the prosecutor's; in a felony case, the court cannot accept a plea to an offense other than the one charged without the prosecutor's consent[12] |
The civil demand statute itself places the civil liability "In addition to applicable penal sanctions."[8] Neither track is a substitute for the other.
What paying the civil demand does and does not do
Complying with the demand within 30 days after it was mailed means the person "shall incur no further civil liability to the merchant from the act of retail fraud."[11] That sentence is about civil liability to the merchant, and the letter's last sentence separately says the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution."[11][1]
The decision whether to bring or continue charges does not belong to the store. A court generally may not issue a warrant or summons without the prosecuting attorney's written authorization (or security for costs), and the Michigan Supreme Court has described the choice of the charging statute as an executive function of the prosecutor, not the court.[7][12] A store's payment receipt is not a dismissal order.
In a felony case, such as first-degree retail fraud, the prosecutor must offer "the victim" an opportunity to consult before finalizing any negotiation that may lead to a dismissal, plea or sentence bargain, or pretrial diversion.[13] In that part of the Crime Victim's Rights Act, "victim" is defined as an individual, and businesses are added only for specified restitution subsections, so whether a store has the consultation right is not stated in the statute.[14] What the statute provides is an opportunity to consult so the prosecutor can obtain the victim's views about the disposition of the case.[13]
What a dismissal or acquittal does to the civil claim
The civil demand statute ties liability to "an act for which he or she could be charged with retail fraud."[8] Its recovery condition, a formal police report filed with the local law enforcement agency, applies "regardless of the outcome of any criminal action."[2] So a dismissed charge, an acquittal or a decision not to charge does not, by the statute's text, cancel the merchant's civil claim.[2]
The civil claim still has to be proved if the merchant sues: subsection (4) makes liable "A person who commits an act described in subsection (1) and who fails to comply with a written demand."[9] The letter describes that lawsuit as one "to determine your legal responsibility."[1]
The same holds at the far end of a criminal case. A set-aside (expungement) of a conviction does not affect a crime victim's right to bring or defend a civil action for damages.[15]
Restitution and the civil demand
Restitution is the criminal court's order to repay the victim's loss, and it is not optional. When sentencing for any felony or misdemeanor, the court must order full restitution to any victim of the defendant's course of conduct that gave rise to the conviction, and a store or other business counts as a victim for restitution.[3][16] The Court of Appeals has held restitution is not open to negotiation in plea or sentence bargaining.[4]
Several rules govern the overlap between restitution and private payments:
- The court "shall not order restitution to be paid to a victim or victim's estate if the victim or victim's estate has received or is to receive compensation for that loss."[17]
- A civil settlement between an employee who embezzled and the employer did not relieve the sentencing court of its duty to order restitution, the Court of Appeals held in People v Bell (2007).[5]
- An unpaid civil judgment does not reduce restitution; having both a judgment and a restitution order is not a double recovery, the Court of Appeals held in People v Dimoski (2009).[18]
- Restitution actually paid is set off against compensatory damages the victim later recovers in a civil case.[6]
How a civil-demand payment is handled at a particular sentencing is for the sentencing court. Any dispute about the amount or type of restitution is decided by the judge by a preponderance of the evidence, and the prosecutor bears the burden of proving the victim's loss.[19] No Michigan statute or appellate decision reviewed for this guide says whether a civil-demand payment reduces the restitution amount.[6]
The two systems also measure loss differently. The civil demand uses the full retail price plus fixed-range civil damages, while restitution for lost property is return of the property or the greater of its fair market value on the date of loss or of sentencing.[8][20] The restitution page explains the restitution rules in full.
Evidence rules: settlements and no-contest pleas
Payments to settle a disputed claim
Michigan Rule of Evidence 408 says evidence of offering, paying or accepting something of value to compromise a disputed claim, and statements made in compromise negotiations, are not admissible to prove or disprove liability for, or the validity or amount of, that claim; such evidence may be admitted for other purposes, such as proving bias or an effort to obstruct a criminal investigation or prosecution.[21] Whether paying a statutory civil demand is a compromise of a "disputed claim," and how the rule would apply in a criminal retail fraud trial, is not settled by the rule's text. This guide does not say that paying is, or is not, an admission of guilt.
No-contest pleas in the criminal case
Under Michigan Rule of Evidence 410, in a civil or criminal case, evidence of a no-contest (nolo contendere) plea is generally not admissible against the defendant who made the plea, with a narrow exception that lets the plea be used in a civil case to defend against a claim brought by the person who entered it.[22] Plea types and their consequences are covered on the plea agreements page.
Testifying in a civil case while the criminal case is open
A witness in a civil case does not have to give an answer that would tend to accuse the witness of a crime.[23] The Court of Appeals has said, in a decision quoted in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook, that the Fifth Amendment does not forbid an adverse inference against a civil party who refuses to testify in response to probative evidence.[24] A court may pause a civil case until the related criminal case ends, to protect the privilege against self-incrimination.[25] The do you have to pay page explains how a civil-demand lawsuit runs.
For stores: the civil claim depends on the police report
Because the statute allows recovery only if a formal police report was filed with the local law enforcement agency, a store's civil demand and its report to police are linked.[2] Before the demand goes out, a member of management other than the detaining employee must evaluate and approve the accusation in writing, except in a sole proprietorship.[1] Restitution in the criminal case is a separate right that the court must order on conviction.[3][16] The victim rights page for businesses covers notice and impact statements, and the statutory conversion page covers a different civil remedy. For where the criminal case goes next, see the court process step by step.
Common questions
If I pay the civil demand, will the shoplifting charge be dropped?
Not because of the payment itself. The prescribed letter says the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud," and complying with the demand within 30 days after it is mailed ends only "further civil liability to the merchant."[1][11] The choice of charge has been described by the Michigan Supreme Court as an executive function of the prosecutor, not the court.[12] How any prosecutor treats a payment is not set by statute, and practice varies.
Can the store or prosecutor use my civil demand payment as proof that I stole something?
Michigan Rule of Evidence 408 says that offering or paying something to compromise a disputed claim is not admissible to prove or disprove liability for that claim, though it may be admitted for other purposes.[21] Whether paying a statutory civil demand counts as compromising a "disputed claim," and how the rule would apply in a criminal trial, is not settled by the rule's text, and no Michigan appellate decision on that point was found for this guide.[21]
Will a civil demand payment be subtracted from restitution?
The sentencing court decides; no Michigan statute or appellate decision reviewed for this guide settles whether a civil-demand payment reduces restitution.[6] The restitution statute says a court shall not order restitution to a victim for a loss the victim "has received or is to receive compensation for."[17] But a civil settlement does not relieve the court of its duty to order restitution, and disputes over the amount are decided by the judge by a preponderance of the evidence, with the prosecutor bearing the burden of proving the loss.[5][19]
I was found not guilty. Can the store still collect the civil demand?
The statute lets a merchant recover if a formal police report alleging retail fraud was filed, "regardless of the outcome of any criminal action."[2] Liability is tied to an act for which a person "could be charged" with retail fraud, and if the merchant sues, the civil court decides whether the person committed the act.[8][9]
Can the store ask the prosecutor to drop the case once it has been paid?
In felony cases, the prosecutor must offer "the victim" a chance to consult before finalizing a plea deal, dismissal or pretrial diversion.[13] In that part of the Crime Victim's Rights Act, "victim" is defined as an individual, and businesses are added only for specified restitution subsections.[14] The statute describes an opportunity to consult and give the victim's views, and the Michigan Supreme Court has described the choice of the charging statute as an executive function of the prosecutor, not the court.[13][12]
Sources
- MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(8) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2); MCL 769.1a(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Ronowski, 222 Mich App 58 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Bell, 276 Mich App 342 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 780.766(9); MCL 780.826(9); MCL 769.1a(9) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.1(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.301(D); Genesee Prosecutor v Genesee Circuit Judge, 386 Mich 672 (1972) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.756(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.752(1)(m)(i); MCL 780.766(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.622(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(1); MCL 780.826(1)(b); MCL 769.1a(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(8); MCL 769.1a(8) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Dimoski, 286 Mich App 474 (2009) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 780.767(2), (4); MCR 6.425(D)(2)(b); MCR 6.610(G)(1)(e) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(3); MCL 780.826(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MRE 408 — Michigan Courts
- MRE 410(a) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 600.2154 — Michigan Legislature
- Phillips v Deihm, 213 Mich App 389, 400-401 (1995) — Michigan Courts
- Landis v North American Co, 299 US 248, 254-255 (1936), as applied in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook — Michigan Courts
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.