SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Sentencing and restitution

Restitution in Michigan Theft and Retail Fraud Cases: What It Covers and How It Is Paid

Key points

  • When sentencing for a felony or a misdemeanor, a Michigan court must order full restitution to any victim of the defendant's course of conduct that gave rise to the conviction, and stores and other businesses that suffer direct physical or financial harm count as victims.[1][2]
  • Restitution is also ordered when a case ends in HYTA status, a delayed sentence or a deferral, or any other way that is not an acquittal or unconditional dismissal.[3]
  • Disputes over the amount are decided by the judge by a preponderance of the evidence, and the prosecutor must prove the loss.[4]
  • A restitution order is a judgment and lien that lasts until paid in full, and it is not erased by early discharge from probation or by a set-aside.[5][6][7]

Restitution is the part of a criminal sentence that repays the victim's loss. In Michigan it is mandatory: when sentencing a defendant convicted of a crime, the court "shall order" that the defendant "make full restitution to any victim of the defendant's course of conduct that gives rise to the conviction."[1] For restitution purposes, "victim" includes a sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation or other legal entity that suffers direct physical or financial harm, so a store can be a restitution victim.[2]

This page explains where the duty comes from, what "full" restitution covers, how the amount is decided, how it is paid and enforced, and how it relates to civil claims such as a store's civil demand. Fines and court costs are a separate topic, covered on the fines and costs page.

Where the restitution duty comes from

Three statutes impose the same core rule: MCL 780.766 in the Crime Victim's Rights Act for felonies, MCL 780.826 for misdemeanors, and the general restitution statute, MCL 769.1a.[1] The misdemeanor section applies to any misdemeanor or ordinance violation, including second- and third-degree retail fraud.[8] The Michigan Judicial Institute's criminal benchbook adds that victims have a state constitutional right to restitution.[9]

Restitution is ordered even when a case does not end in an ordinary conviction. For an offense resolved by youthful trainee (HYTA) status, a delayed sentence or deferred judgment, "or in another way that is not an acquittal or unconditional dismissal," the court "shall order the restitution required."[3] The Court of Appeals has held that because restitution is mandatory, it is not open to negotiation in plea or sentence bargaining.[10]

What "full restitution" covers

Complete and maximal, but tied to the conviction

In People v Garrison (2014), the Michigan Supreme Court read "full" to mean "complete; entire; maximum," so courts must order restitution that is "maximal and complete."[11] The court applied that reading to allow restitution for a victim's reasonable travel expenses incurred while securing stolen property and attending restitution hearings.[12]

The loss must come from the conduct behind the conviction. In People v McKinley (2014), the Supreme Court held that MCL 780.766(2) "does not authorize trial courts to impose restitution based solely on uncharged conduct."[13] A defendant can expressly agree in a plea bargain to pay restitution on dismissed or uncharged counts, according to a Court of Appeals decision described in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook.[14][15]

Stolen property: return first, then value

For property that was taken, the order first requires return of the property to the owner.[16] If return is impossible, impractical or inadequate, the defendant pays the greater of the property's fair market value on the date of the loss or on the date of sentencing, less the value of any part returned.[16][17] This differs from a store's civil demand, which covers the full retail price of goods that were not recovered or are no longer salable, plus civil damages.[18]

Insurers and others who paid the victim

The court must also order restitution to an insurer or other entity that compensated the victim, to the extent of what it paid, but the victim must be paid first.[19] The court "shall not order restitution to be paid to a victim" for a loss the victim "has received or is to receive compensation for."[20]

How the amount is decided

In a felony case, the court rule says the presentence report includes information about the harm suffered by any victim, "including the restitution needs of the victim."[21] Any dispute about the amount or type of restitution "shall be resolved by the court by a preponderance of the evidence," and "The burden of demonstrating the amount of the loss" is on the prosecuting attorney.[4] After an order is entered, the prosecutor, the victim or the defendant may ask the court to amend it based on new information about the loss.[22] The preparing for sentencing page covers the presentence process.

Paying restitution

  • Timing: restitution is due immediately unless the court sets a payment period or installments.[23]
  • Probation: paying restitution is a mandatory condition of probation.[24]
  • Missed payments: when restitution is a probation condition, the court orders an employed defendant to make regularly scheduled payments, and if the defendant misses 2 or more of them, the court shall order a wage assignment.[25]
  • Changing the plan: a defendant who is not in willful default may at any time petition the sentencing judge to change the method of payment.[26]
  • Order of payments: 50% of money collected from a person who owes victim payments goes to those payments before fines, costs and fees.[27]
  • Bail: when bond or bail is discharged, the court shall order restitution and other amounts it has ordered collected out of cash bail the defendant personally deposited (MCL 765.15(2)).[28]

When payments fall behind

A defendant "shall not be imprisoned, jailed, or incarcerated" for failing to pay restitution unless the court determines the defendant has the resources to pay and has not made a good-faith effort.[29] In deciding whether to revoke probation, the court must consider employment status, earning ability, financial resources and the willfulness of the failure to pay.[30]

Restitution can also keep probation going. If a probationer has made a good-faith effort to pay restitution and is otherwise eligible for early discharge, the court may grant early discharge or keep the probationer on probation, up to the maximum term for the offense, with continued restitution payments as the only condition.[6] Before granting early discharge to someone who still owes restitution, the court must consider the effect on the victim.[6] The probation violations page covers the hearing process.

Enforcement after sentencing

A restitution order "remains effective until it is satisfied in full," is "a judgment and lien against all property of the defendant," and may be enforced by the prosecuting attorney, the victim or anyone else named in the order "in the same manner as a judgment in a civil action or a lien."[5] The court may not charge the victim a fee for enforcing it.[31] If the person entitled to restitution cannot be located, refuses to claim it within 2 years, or refuses to accept it, the money goes to the crime victim's rights fund, but that person may still claim it any time by applying to the court that ordered and collected it.[32]

Neither early discharge nor a set-aside ends the obligation. Early discharge does not relieve a probationer of court-ordered financial obligations, and the set-aside statute "does not relieve any obligation to pay restitution owed to the victim of a crime."[6][7] For a conviction set aside automatically, the court shall reinstate it, on a motion by a person owed restitution or on its own motion, if it determines the person has not made a good-faith effort to pay restitution, after notice and an opportunity to be heard.[33][34] See what a set-aside does.

Restitution and civil claims

  • Restitution paid is set off against compensatory damages the victim later recovers in a civil case.[35]
  • A civil settlement between the defendant and the victim did not relieve the sentencing court of its duty to order restitution, the Court of Appeals held in People v Bell (2007).[36]
  • An unpaid civil judgment does not reduce restitution, the Court of Appeals held in People v Dimoski (2009).[37]

A store's civil demand under MCL 600.2953 is civil liability "In addition to applicable penal sanctions."[18] No Michigan statute or appellate decision reviewed for this guide says whether money already paid on a civil demand reduces the restitution amount; the sentencing court decides.[38] The restitution statute bars ordering restitution to a victim for a loss the victim "has received or is to receive compensation for."[20] The civil demand and criminal case page discusses that overlap.

Special cases

Organized retail crime: the court "shall order" a person found guilty of organized retail crime to make restitution to any retail merchant victim under the Crime Victim's Rights Act, and to reimburse the governmental entity for its expenses.[39] See the organized retail crime page.

Juveniles: if the court determines that a juvenile is or will be unable to pay all of the restitution ordered, it may, after notice to the parents and an opportunity for them to be heard, order the parent or parents who had supervisory responsibility at the time to pay any outstanding portion; a foster parent is not a "parent" for this rule.[40][41]

Businesses: stores and employers can find their side of these rules, including notice and impact statements, on the victim rights page for businesses.

Common questions

Does a store get restitution if it got the merchandise back?

The statute's first remedy for stolen property is to return it to the owner. Only if return is impossible, impractical or inadequate does the court order a payment: the greater of the property's fair market value on the date of loss or on the date of sentencing, less the value of anything returned.[16] How that applies to particular goods is decided on the evidence, and the prosecutor bears the burden of proving the loss.[4]

Can restitution be negotiated away in a plea deal?

The Court of Appeals has held that because restitution is mandatory, it is no longer open to negotiation in plea or sentence bargaining, and defendants are on notice it will be part of the sentence.[10] A defendant can, however, expressly agree in a plea bargain to pay restitution on charges that are dismissed or never brought, according to a Court of Appeals decision described in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook.[14][15]

Can a court order restitution for losses that were never charged?

Not based solely on uncharged conduct. In People v McKinley (2014), the Michigan Supreme Court held that MCL 780.766(2) does not authorize restitution based solely on uncharged conduct, because only charged crimes give rise to the conviction.[13] A defendant may still expressly agree in a plea bargain to pay restitution on dismissed or uncharged counts, according to a Court of Appeals decision described in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook.[14][15]

What happens if a person cannot afford restitution payments?

A defendant may not be jailed for failing to pay restitution unless the court finds the defendant has the resources to pay and has not made a good-faith effort.[29] A defendant who is not in willful default may at any time ask the sentencing judge to change the method of payment.[26] The court can also set installments or a payment period instead of requiring payment immediately.[23]

Does restitution end when probation ends or the conviction is set aside?

No. A restitution order remains effective until it is satisfied in full and can be enforced like a civil judgment.[5] Early discharge from probation does not relieve court-ordered financial obligations, and the set-aside statute does not relieve any obligation to pay restitution.[6][7]

Sources

  1. MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2); MCL 769.1a(2) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 780.766(1); MCL 780.826(1)(b); MCL 769.1a(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 780.767(2), (4); MCR 6.425(D)(2)(b); MCR 6.610(G)(1)(e) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 780.766(13) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 771.2(4)-(5) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 780.622(7) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 780.826(1)(a), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  9. Const 1963, art 1, § 24; MCL 780.766(2); MCL 769.1a(2); People v Garrison, 495 Mich 362, 365 (2014) — Michigan Courts
  10. People v Ronowski, 222 Mich App 58 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
  11. People v Garrison, 495 Mich 362 (2014) — Caselaw Access Project
  12. People v Garrison, 495 Mich 362 (2014) — Caselaw Access Project
  13. People v McKinley, 496 Mich 410 (2014) — Caselaw Access Project
  14. People v Foster, 319 Mich App 365, 379, 383 (2017) — Michigan Courts
  15. People v Foster, 319 Mich App 365, 379, 382-383 (2017) (as described in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook, §8.9) — Michigan Courts
  16. MCL 780.766(3); MCL 780.826(3) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 780.766(3); MCL 780.826(3) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 780.766(8) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 780.766(8); MCL 769.1a(8) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCR 6.425(A)(1)-(2) — Michigan Courts
  22. MCL 780.766(22) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 780.766(10) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 771.3(1) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 780.766(18) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 780.766(12) — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCL 775.22(2)-(3), (5) — Michigan Legislature
  28. MCL 765.15(2) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCL 780.766(14); MCR 6.425(D)(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  30. MCL 780.766(11) — Michigan Legislature
  31. MCL 780.766(20); MCL 780.826(17) — Michigan Legislature
  32. MCL 780.766(21) — Michigan Legislature
  33. MCL 780.621h(2), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  34. MCR 6.451 — Michigan Courts
  35. MCL 780.766(9); MCL 780.826(9) — Michigan Legislature
  36. People v Bell, 276 Mich App 342 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
  37. People v Dimoski, 286 Mich App 474 (2009) — Caselaw Access Project
  38. MCL 780.766(9); MCL 780.826(9); MCL 769.1a(9) — Michigan Legislature
  39. MCL 752.1084(3)-(4) — Michigan Legislature
  40. MCL 780.794(15)-(16); MCL 780.766(15)-(16) — Michigan Legislature
  41. MCL 780.766(15)-(16) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.