Key points
- Federal immigration law, not Michigan's label, decides what counts as a conviction: a guilty plea plus any court-ordered punishment can count even where a judgment of guilt is withheld.[1]
- The Board of Immigration Appeals has held that a theft offense with intent to deprive the owner permanently, or substantially erode the owner's rights, is a crime involving moral turpitude.[2]
- A theft offense with a prison or jail term of at least one year, even if suspended, is an aggravated felony under federal immigration law.[3][1]
- A Michigan set-aside does not remove a conviction for immigration purposes, according to USCIS.[4]
- The Michigan criminal benchbook, citing Padilla v Kentucky (2010), says defense counsel is constitutionally required to tell a client that a plea may carry a risk of adverse immigration consequences.[5]
For a person who is not a U.S. citizen, a Michigan retail fraud or theft case raises a second set of questions that the criminal court does not answer. Federal immigration law has its own definition of "conviction," its own list of crimes that can block a visa or green card, and its own rules for deportation.[1][6][7] A charge that looks minor under Michigan law can matter a great deal under federal law, and the reverse is also possible.
This page explains the general federal rules as of November 2026. It cannot tell any one person what will happen. Immigration outcomes turn on immigration status, the exact statute and subsection, the record of conviction and the sentence, which are questions an immigration lawyer can answer before a plea, HYTA request or diversion agreement is final.
What counts as a "conviction" for immigration purposes
Federal law defines "conviction" broadly. It covers a formal judgment of guilt, and it also covers a case where adjudication of guilt is withheld if the person pleaded guilty or no contest (or admitted enough facts for a finding of guilt) and the judge ordered some form of punishment, penalty or restraint on liberty.[1] Any reference to a sentence includes jail or prison time the court ordered, even if the court suspended it.[1]
That definition matters for Michigan's second-chance options:
- HYTA. Michigan law says an assignment to youthful trainee status is not a conviction.[8] But HYTA is available only when the person pleads guilty, and the court then places the trainee on probation or, for a felony-level charge, another term the statute lists.[9][10][11][12] Under the federal definition, a guilty plea plus a court-ordered restraint may be enough; no federal decision on Michigan HYTA was reviewed for this guide.[1] See HYTA in retail fraud cases.
- Delayed sentence. A Michigan court may delay sentencing for up to 1 year so the defendant can show eligibility for probation or other leniency.[13] Whether a particular delayed-sentence outcome counts federally depends on what plea or finding came first and what the court ordered.[1] See delayed sentences.
- Prosecutor diversion. Whether a program involves a plea, a finding of guilt or an admission of facts matters, because the federal definition turns on that and on whether a judge ordered some punishment, penalty or restraint.[1] USCIS says a pretrial diversion program that requires no admission or finding of guilt may not count as a conviction, and that a deferred case with a finding or confession of guilt counts only if punishment was imposed.[14] See prosecutor diversion programs.
Theft as a "crime involving moral turpitude"
A noncitizen convicted of, or who admits the essential elements of, a crime involving moral turpitude (abbreviated CIMT) is inadmissible to the United States, subject to the exceptions the statute lists.[6] Inadmissibility grounds are the reasons federal law can bar a noncitizen from being admitted to the United States.[6]
In Matter of Diaz-Lizarraga (2016), the Board of Immigration Appeals held that a theft offense is a CIMT if it involves taking or controlling another person's property without consent and with intent to deprive the owner permanently, or under circumstances where the owner's property rights are substantially eroded.[2] The Board held that Arizona's shoplifting statute is categorically a CIMT.[2] Whether each Michigan retail fraud subsection meets that test (for example, price-switching compared with concealment) depends on the statute's elements and federal case law, and no decision on the Michigan statute was reviewed for this guide.[2]
The petty offense exception
The moral-turpitude bar does not apply to a person who committed only one crime if the maximum possible penalty did not exceed 1 year and the sentence imposed was not more than 6 months, whether or not the person served it.[15] USCIS describes the condition as the petty offense being the only crime involving moral turpitude the person has ever committed.[16] A separate exception covers a single crime committed under age 18, where the crime and any release from confinement for it came more than 5 years before the application.[15]
When a theft conviction can lead to deportation
For a person already admitted to the United States, including a lawful permanent resident, three federal deportation grounds can apply in theft cases:
- One CIMT committed within 5 years after admission (10 years for people who became permanent residents under one special provision, 8 USC 1255(j)), if a sentence of one year or longer may be imposed for the crime. The test is the possible sentence, not the sentence actually given.[7]
- Two or more CIMTs at any time after admission, not arising from a single scheme, regardless of whether the person was confined and regardless of whether they were tried together.[17] If both offenses are CIMTs, a second theft conviction can matter for this reason alone.[17]
- An aggravated felony at any time after admission. A "theft offense (including receipt of stolen property)" with a term of imprisonment of at least one year is an aggravated felony.[3] Because a suspended term counts, a 365-day jail sentence on a misdemeanor theft can qualify.[3][1] An offense involving fraud or deceit with a victim loss over $10,000 is a separate aggravated-felony category.[18]
How Michigan theft penalties line up with the federal tests
The table compares Michigan maximum penalties with the two federal tests that turn on the length of a possible sentence. It does not decide whether any offense is a CIMT, which is a separate question.[15][7]
| Michigan offense | Maximum | Maximum within the petty offense limit (1 year or less)? | Meets the "one year or longer may be imposed" deportation test? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Third-degree retail fraud | 93 days, $500 or 3 times the value[19] | Yes[15] | No[7] |
| Second-degree retail fraud | 1 year, $2,000 or 3 times the value[20] | Yes[15] | Yes[7] |
| First-degree retail fraud (felony) | 5 years, $10,000 or 3 times the value[21] | No[15] | Yes[7] |
| Larceny under $200 | 93 days[22] | Yes[15] | No[7] |
| Larceny of $200 to under $1,000 | 1 year[23] | Yes[15] | Yes[7] |
| Larceny of $1,000 to under $20,000 (felony) | 5 years[24] | No[15] | Yes[7] |
The petty offense exception also requires that the sentence imposed was 6 months or less, and it covers only one crime.[15] The aggravated-felony test looks at the term the court ordered, counting any suspended part, not the maximum.[3][1] USCIS treats a later state-court change to that sentence as relevant only if it rests on a procedural or substantive defect in the criminal case.[25] The penalties chart lists the full range of Michigan theft penalties.
Set-asides do not solve immigration problems
USCIS says an expunged record of conviction does not remove the underlying conviction, and it cites the Board of Immigration Appeals for the rule that a state action to expunge, dismiss or vacate a conviction under a state rehabilitative statute has no effect for immigration purposes.[4] A Michigan set-aside still has effects under Michigan law, but USCIS does not treat it as removing the conviction.[26][4] A conviction vacated for cause, because of a constitutional or statutory defect or a pre-conviction error affecting guilt, is different: USCIS does not count it as a conviction, and it gives the example of a conviction vacated because the criminal court failed to advise the defendant of a plea's immigration consequences.[27] A dismissal after a rehabilitative period, or one granted to avoid immigration consequences, still counts.[27] Separately, the deportation statute says its moral-turpitude and aggravated-felony grounds do not apply to a conviction for which the person later received a full and unconditional pardon from the President or a state Governor; that waiver is written into the deportation grounds only.[28] The set-aside effects page explains the difference.
Naturalization and good moral character
A green card holder applying for citizenship has to show good moral character for a set period. A person who committed and was convicted of (or admits) a CIMT during that period cannot be found to have good moral character, although USCIS applies the same one-crime petty offense exception.[16] A theft case can therefore affect the timing of a citizenship application even where it does not lead to removal.[16]
Plea decisions and the right to advice
The Michigan criminal benchbook, citing Padilla v Kentucky (2010), says defense counsel is constitutionally required to tell a client that a plea "may carry a risk of adverse immigration consequences," such as deportation.[5] The same passage says criminal defendants generally may not withdraw a guilty plea because they did not know about its collateral effects.[5] The plea agreements page explains how theft pleas work, and the questions to ask a lawyer list includes immigration questions.
Questions worth raising with both lawyers include:
- Which statute and subsection is charged, and what are the elements?
- What is the maximum possible sentence, and would any plea or sentence reach one year, even suspended?[7][3][1]
- Does HYTA, a delayed sentence or a diversion program in this court involve a plea or an admission?[1]
- Are there any earlier convictions, anywhere, that could make this a second CIMT?[17]
Related situations
International students and other visa holders face the same federal rules; the college students page covers campus issues. Travel to Canada is governed by Canadian law, under which a foreign conviction that would be an indictable offense in Canada can make a visitor inadmissible.[29] That topic is covered in traveling to Canada with a theft conviction. Readers facing more than one kind of charge can compare the drug guide's page on drug convictions and immigration.
Common questions
Is shoplifting a crime involving moral turpitude?
It can be. The Board of Immigration Appeals held in 2016 that a theft offense involving intent to deprive the owner permanently, or under circumstances that substantially erode the owner's property rights, is a crime involving moral turpitude, and it found Arizona's shoplifting statute categorically fits that test.[2] No decision on Michigan's retail fraud subsections was reviewed for this guide, so the answer for a particular Michigan charge is a question for an immigration lawyer.
Does HYTA keep a theft case from counting for immigration?
Not necessarily. Michigan says a youthful trainee assignment is not a conviction, but HYTA starts with a guilty plea.[8][9][10] Federal immigration law counts a guilty plea followed by any punishment, penalty or restraint on liberty, even when a judgment of guilt is withheld.[1] No federal decision on Michigan HYTA was reviewed for this guide, so how HYTA is treated in a particular case is a question for an immigration lawyer.
Can a misdemeanor shoplifting case be an aggravated felony?
It is possible. Federal law treats a theft offense as an aggravated felony when the term of imprisonment is at least one year, and a suspended term still counts at the length the court ordered.[3][1] Second-degree retail fraud carries up to 1 year in jail, so a sentence at that maximum, even suspended, could reach the one-year line; third-degree retail fraud, with a 93-day maximum, cannot.[20][19] Whether a given Michigan retail fraud subsection is a "theft offense" under federal law was not determined for this guide.
Will setting aside the conviction fix the immigration problem?
No, according to USCIS. Its policy manual says an expunged record of conviction does not remove the underlying conviction for immigration purposes, citing Board of Immigration Appeals decisions on state rehabilitative statutes.[4] Michigan's rule that a set-aside person is treated as not previously convicted does not control federal immigration decisions.[26][4] USCIS treats a conviction vacated because of a legal defect in the criminal case differently from one cleared for rehabilitation.[27]
Does a defense lawyer have to warn about immigration consequences?
The Michigan criminal benchbook, citing Padilla v Kentucky (2010), says defense counsel is constitutionally required to tell a client that a plea may carry a risk of adverse immigration consequences such as deportation.[5] The same passage notes that defendants generally may not withdraw a plea on the ground that they did not know about its collateral effects.[5]
Sources
- 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A), (B) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Matter of Diaz-Lizarraga, 26 I&N Dec 847 (BIA 2016) — justice.gov
- 8 USC 1101(a)(43)(G); 8 USC 1227(a)(2)(A)(iii); 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(B) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 12, Part F, Ch. 2, § 8 ("Expunged Records") — U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
- MJI Criminal Proceedings Benchbook Vol. 1, §6.30(C) (withdrawal of plea after sentencing), citing People v Haynes, 256 Mich App 341, 349 (2003) and Padilla v Kentucky, 559 US 356, 369 (2010) — Michigan Courts
- 8 USC 1182(a)(2)(A)(i)(I) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 8 USC 1227(a)(2)(A)(i) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- MCL 762.14(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 762.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 762.11(2); People v Dash, 216 Mich App 412 (1996) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 762.13(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 762.13(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 771.1(2) — Michigan Legislature
- USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 12, Part F, Ch. 2, § C.1 and § C.4 ("Deferrals of Adjudication") — U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
- 8 USC 1182(a)(2)(A)(ii) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 8 USC 1101(f)(3); USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 12, Part F, Ch. 5 — U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
- 8 USC 1227(a)(2)(A)(ii) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 8 USC 1101(a)(43)(M)(i) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 12, Part F, Ch. 2, § C.9 ("Change in Sentence") — U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
- MCL 780.622(1) — Michigan Legislature
- USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 12, Part F, Ch. 2, § C.5 ("Vacated Judgments") — U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
- 8 USC 1227(a)(2)(A)(vi) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (Canada), s 36(2)(b), 36(3)(a) — laws-lois.justice.gc.ca
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.