SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Civil demand letters and civil liability

Do You Have to Pay a Shoplifting Civil Demand in Michigan? What Happens Either Way

Key points

  • The letter Michigan law prescribes says the recipient is "not required to respond" if they believe they or their minor child are not guilty, or if they choose not to respond.[1]
  • Complying within 30 days after the demand was mailed ends any further civil liability to the merchant for that act, but not any criminal case.[2][1]
  • If the demand is not met, the merchant may sue; a person who committed the act can then owe the retail price, civil damages and the costs of the action, including reasonable attorney fees.[1][3]
  • A demand letter is not a court judgment; a default judgment can enter only in a lawsuit, for example if the defendant does not appear in small claims.[1][4]

A Michigan civil demand letter is a request, not a court order. The text the law prescribes for it says "You are not required to respond to this demand if you believe that you or your minor child are not guilty of committing retail fraud or if you choose not to respond."[1] What happens next depends on the choice: paying within 30 days after the letter was mailed ends further civil liability to the merchant for that act, while not paying leaves the merchant free to file a civil lawsuit, where a court decides liability.[2][1]

This page sets out both paths as the civil demand statute describes them. It does not recommend paying or not paying. How the amount is calculated is on the civil demand amount page, and how the letter relates to a criminal case is on the civil demand and criminal case page.

What the letter itself says about responding

The statute prescribes three sentences that bear directly on this question. The first is the 30-day offer: "If you return any unrecovered property and pay the amounts indicated above to us within 30 days after the date this notice was mailed, we will not take any further civil action against you."[1] The second is the statement that the recipient is "not required to respond."[1] The third is the warning: "If you fail to comply with this demand, we will be authorized by state law to bring a civil action against you to determine your legal responsibility."[1]

Read together, the letter is an offer to settle a civil claim before any lawsuit, paired with notice that a lawsuit is possible.[1] The letter does not, by itself, decide that anyone owes anything.

Path 1: the demand is paid within 30 days

Under subsection (3), a person who complies with the written demand "within 30 days after the date the written demand is mailed ... shall incur no further civil liability to the merchant from the act of retail fraud."[2] Three details in that sentence matter:

  • The 30 days run from the mailing date, not the date the letter arrived.[2]
  • Complying means doing what the demand asks, which can include returning unrecovered property as well as paying the amounts listed.[1]
  • The release is from further civil liability "to the merchant." The same letter says the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution."[2][1]

The letter, its envelope (which shows the mailing date) and any written confirmation of a payment are among the papers listed on the documents to keep page.

Path 2: the demand is not paid

The merchant may sue

If the demand is not met, the merchant may file a civil action in the small claims division of the district court or in any other court with jurisdiction.[1][5] A merchant can recover only if a formal police report alleging retail fraud was filed with the local law enforcement agency for the place where it happened.[6]

What a court can award

Subsection (4) makes "A person who commits an act described in subsection (1) and who fails to comply with a written demand" liable for the full retail price (unless the property was recovered in salable condition), civil damages of 10 times the retail price but not less than $50 or more than $200, "and costs of the action, including reasonable attorney fees."[3] The liability is written for a person who committed the act, so the merchant's claim depends on what the court finds.[3]

Paying after a lawsuit is filed

If a lawsuit is filed and, before trial starts, the person pays the merchant "in cash the amount demanded," subsection (4), with its costs and attorney fees, does not apply.[7]

If the case goes to small claims

Small claims is a division of the district court, and its limit has been $7,000 since January 1, 2024.[8] If a civil-demand claim is filed there, these rules shape the process:

  • The notice served on the defendant warns that failing to appear may result in a judgment, up to the small claims limit or the amount claimed, whichever is less, plus costs, and explains that even a defendant without a legal defense may appear to ask for installment payments.[9]
  • If the defendant does not appear, a judgment may be entered by default (or on the proofs the court requires).[4]
  • No lawyer (except on the lawyer's own behalf), collection agency or collection-agency employee may take part in filing or arguing the case.[10]
  • A business may be represented by an officer or employee with direct and personal knowledge of the facts in dispute.[11]
  • The hearing is informal, witnesses are sworn, and there is no jury and no verbatim record.[12]
  • Staying in small claims waives the right to a lawyer, a jury and an appeal (other than the 7-day appeal from a magistrate's decision), but either side may remove the case to the regular civil docket before trial.[13][14][15]

After a judgment

A small claims judge orders a judgment paid in a lump sum or in installments as the judge considers just and reasonable, and stays collection while the defendant complies with that order.[16] A writ of garnishment to enforce a small claims judgment may not issue until 21 days after the judgment is entered.[17] The winning party is entitled to the costs of the action, including the cost of serving the defendant.[18]

The small claims page explains filing, removal and appeals in more detail.

A demand is not a judgment, and it is not a criminal case

The prescribed letter describes any lawsuit as one "to determine your legal responsibility," which is the point at which a court, not the store, decides.[1] The letter also says the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution."[1] Whether a criminal case is filed is a separate question: a judge or magistrate generally may not issue a warrant or summons for a misdemeanor or felony without a written authorization signed by the prosecuting attorney, or security for costs.[19]

Paying does not by itself end a criminal case: the statute creates civil liability "In addition to applicable penal sanctions," so the two tracks run side by side.[1][20] The civil demand and the criminal case page covers how restitution and the civil demand relate.

If a criminal charge is pending at the same time

Michigan law says a witness in a civil case does not have to give an answer that would tend to accuse the witness of a crime.[21] But the Court of Appeals has said, in a decision quoted in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook, that the Fifth Amendment does not forbid an adverse inference against a party to a civil case who refuses to testify in response to probative evidence.[22] A court may also pause a civil case until the related criminal case is over.[23] These rules bear on testimony in a civil-demand case while a criminal charge is open.

When the letter names "your minor child"

The statutory letter is addressed to "you, or your minor child (child's name)."[1] A merchant may recover the statutory amounts from the parent or parents of an unemancipated minor who lives with them and who committed the act.[24] The parents of minors page covers those conditions and how they differ from other parental-liability rules.

What the statute requires of the store

For anyone checking whether a letter matches the law, the statute sets these requirements: a member of management other than the person who first detained the shopper must evaluate and approve the accusation in writing (except in a sole proprietorship); a formal police report must have been filed; and civil damages are limited to 10 times the retail price within the $50 to $200 range.[1][6][20] The civil demand letter page sets the prescribed text out in full. For the broader first steps after a stop or citation, see first steps after a shoplifting charge.

Common questions

Do I have to pay a shoplifting civil demand letter in Michigan?

The statute's own wording answers part of this: "You are not required to respond to this demand if you believe that you or your minor child are not guilty of committing retail fraud or if you choose not to respond."[1] The same text warns that if the demand is not met, the merchant is authorized to bring a civil action to determine legal responsibility, plus costs and reasonable attorney fees.[1] Whether to pay is a personal decision this guide does not make.

What happens if I ignore a civil demand letter?

The statute lets the merchant file a civil lawsuit, in small claims or another court, if the demand is not met.[1][5] In that lawsuit, a person who committed the act and did not comply is liable for the retail price (unless the goods were recovered in salable condition), civil damages of $50 to $200, and costs including reasonable attorney fees.[3] If the defendant does not appear in small claims, a default judgment may be entered.[4]

If I pay the civil demand, will the store drop the shoplifting charge?

Complying with the demand within 30 days after it is mailed ends only further civil liability to the merchant.[2] The statutory letter states that "These civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution for the alleged act of retail fraud."[1] Criminal charges move through the prosecuting attorney, whose written authorization (or security for costs) a court generally needs before issuing a warrant or summons.[19]

Can the store still pursue the civil demand if my criminal case was dismissed?

The statute's condition for recovery is that a formal police report alleging retail fraud was filed with the local law enforcement agency, "regardless of the outcome of any criminal action."[6] Liability is tied to an act for which a person "could be charged" with retail fraud.[20] If the merchant sues, a court decides whether the person committed the act.[1][3]

Can the store's lawyer or a collection company take me to small claims court?

No lawyer (except on the lawyer's own behalf), collection agency or collection-agency employee may take part in filing or arguing a small claims case.[10] A corporation's claim must be filed by a full-time salaried employee who knows the facts, and a business may be represented by an officer or employee with direct and personal knowledge.[11] Either side can move the case out of small claims before trial.[15]

What if I pay after the 30 days are up?

The release in the statute covers compliance "within 30 days after the date the written demand is mailed."[2] If the merchant has filed suit, a different rule applies: paying the merchant the amount demanded in cash before trial begins means the costs-and-attorney-fees subsection does not apply.[7]

Sources

  1. MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 600.2953(4) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCR 4.304(B) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCL 600.2953(6) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 600.2953(8) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 600.2953(5) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 600.8401 — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 600.8404(1); MCL 600.8405 — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 600.8408(1) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 600.8407(3); MCL 600.8408(2) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 600.8411(2) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 600.8412 — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 600.8427 — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 600.8408(4); MCR 4.306(A), (B)(3) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 600.8410(2), (5) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCR 4.305(C); MCL 600.8409(1) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 600.8421 — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 764.1(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 600.2154 — Michigan Legislature
  22. Phillips v Deihm, 213 Mich App 389, 400-401 (1995) — Michigan Courts
  23. Landis v North American Co, 299 US 248, 254-255 (1936), as applied in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook — Michigan Courts
  24. MCL 600.2953(7) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.