Key points
- Michigan courts define false imprisonment as the unlawful restraint of a person's liberty or freedom of movement, by physical seizure or its equivalent in personal coercion.[1]
- A false arrest is an illegal or unjustified arrest; an arrest supported by probable cause is not a false arrest even if the person turns out to be innocent.[2]
- If the store had probable cause and believed the person stole, MCL 600.2917 bars mental-anguish and punitive damages unless the person proves unreasonable force, unreasonable length of detention, unreasonable disregard of rights, or intent to injure.[3]
- Suits for assault, battery or false imprisonment generally must be filed within 2 years, and libel or slander within 1 year.[4][5]
- A store that only gives information to police who act on their own judgment is not liable for false arrest on that basis, under Lewis v Farmer Jack.[2]
A person who is detained by a store and believes the stop was wrongful may bring civil claims such as false imprisonment, false arrest, assault and battery, or slander against the store, its agents or its security contractor.[3] MCL 600.2917 limits those claims: if the store had probable cause and believed the person committed the theft, damages for mental anguish and punitive damages are barred, unless the person proves unreasonable force, an unreasonable length of detention, unreasonable disregard of rights or sensibilities, or intent to injure.[3]
This page explains how Michigan courts define each claim, how the damages limit works, and the deadlines for filing. It does not predict whether any claim would succeed; that turns on facts a court or jury decides. It is meant to be useful to people who were stopped and to stores that want to understand their exposure. For the sequence of a stop itself, see what happens when a store stops someone.
The claims at a glance
| Claim | How Michigan courts describe it | Filing period |
|---|---|---|
| False imprisonment | Unlawful restraint of a person's liberty or freedom of movement, by seizure or its equivalent in personal coercion.[1] | 2 years.[4] |
| False arrest | An illegal or unjustified arrest; the person's innocence is not what decides it.[2] | MCL 600.5805 does not use the words "false arrest"; it names false imprisonment (2 years). Which period a court applies to a false-arrest claim is not settled by the text.[6] |
| Assault and battery | Battery is a wilful, harmful or offensive touching of the person or of an object attached to and practically identified with the person's body.[7] | 2 years.[4] |
| Slander or libel | A public accusation can be publication; the accusation may be subject to a common-law qualified privilege.[8] | 1 year.[5] |
| Malicious prosecution | Four elements, including a prosecution that ended in the person's favor and a lack of probable cause.[9] | 2 years.[10] |
| Civil rights (Elliott-Larsen Act) | Denial of full and equal enjoyment of a store's goods and services because of a protected characteristic.[11] | Not covered on this page. |
False imprisonment: what counts as being held
In Clarke v K mart Corp (1992), the Court of Appeals quoted the Michigan Supreme Court's definition: false imprisonment is "the unlawful restraint of an individual's personal liberty or freedom of locomotion."[1] A physical seizure is not necessary, but there must be a seizure "or its equivalent in some form of personal coercion."[1]
- Holding belongings can count. Clarke applied the rule that a store owner who, without privilege, keeps a customer's purse so that she reasonably believes she can leave only by giving it up "has confined" her.[12]
- Being free to walk around is not the end of the question. The trial court in Clarke dismissed the claim because the shopper was not held in an office and was free to roam the store; the Court of Appeals called that "an unduly narrow view of this tort" and reversed.[12]
- Agreeing to stay is different. There is no false arrest if the person voluntarily agrees to stay, as in Bonkowski, where the shopper returned to the store and agreed to a purse inspection.[13]
Clarke did not find the store liable. It reversed the dismissal because whether the store meant to hold the shopper, or only her merchandise, turned on the credibility of its employees and could not be decided without a trial.[12]
False arrest: legality, not innocence
The Michigan Supreme Court defined false arrest in Lewis v Farmer Jack Division (1982) as "an illegal or unjustified arrest."[2] In that case police acted on a store employee's information and identification, had probable cause, and made a legal arrest, even though the charges were later dismissed.[2] The Court held that employees who telephoned police and pointed out a suspect "did no more ... than provide information," and the store was not liable where police used their own judgment; it left open whether withholding information from police could create liability.[2]
Questioning and searches during a stop raise different rules, covered on the loss prevention page. An "arrest" by store staff also requires an intent to take the person into custody. In Bonkowski, a guard who called a shopper back and looked in her purse with her permission did not arrest her, because there was no proof he intended to take her into custody.[8]
Assault and battery
Clarke described a battery as "a wilful, harmful, or offensive touching" of the person or of an object "attached to [the plaintiff] and practically identified with" the person's body.[7] Because the shopper said employees snatched a bag out of her hands, while the store said they took it from her cart, the court held that if her account was true there would be a prima facie case of assault and battery.[7] Unreasonable force is also one of the exceptions that removes the MCL 600.2917 damages limit.[3]
Slander and libel
In Bonkowski the Court held that a guard's loud accusation near the store door within hearing of others, and accusatory gestures within sight of others, can be "publication" for a slander claim.[8] The majority analyzed the claim under the qualified privilege that, at common law, those charged with slander enjoy; where the occasion is privileged, the person suing must prove that the statement was false and made with actual malice. Three justices wrote separately that the store must first prove that the privilege applies.[8]
How MCL 600.2917 limits damages
The statute covers suits against a merchant, a library, their agents, and an independent contractor providing security.[3] When the store had probable cause for believing, and did believe, that the person committed or helped commit the theft or retail fraud, the person cannot recover damages for mental anguish or punitive, exemplary or aggravated damages.[3] That bar does not apply if the person proves any of the four exceptions: unreasonable force, an unreasonable length of detention, unreasonable disregard of the person's rights or sensibilities, or intent to injure.[3]
The limit is not a complete defense. Bonkowski held that a person suing a merchant for slander may recover no more than compensatory damages unless he or she also proves one of the exceptions.[8] Clarke held that even if there was probable cause, the person may still maintain a false-imprisonment action, though damages may be reduced.[12] The page on Michigan's merchant law explains the statute from the store's side.
Malicious prosecution
Malicious prosecution concerns the criminal case itself rather than the stop. Under Matthews v Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Michigan (1998), the person suing must prove that the defendant initiated a criminal prosecution, that it ended in the person's favor, that the private person who started or kept it going lacked probable cause, and that it was done with malice or, in the Court's words, a purpose "other than bringing the offender to justice."[9] The prosecutor's independent decision to charge is a complete defense for the private party who reported the matter, unless the information given was known to be false and was what the prosecutor acted on.[9] A separate statute, MCL 600.2907, makes a person who maliciously causes another to be arrested or prosecuted liable for three times the damages and expenses found, and makes the conduct a misdemeanor punishable by up to 6 months in jail.[14] The filing period is 2 years.[10]
Deadlines
- Assault, battery or false imprisonment: 2 years.[4]
- Libel or slander: 1 year.[5]
- Malicious prosecution: 2 years.[10]
- Injury to a person or property, unless another period applies: 3 years.[15]
These periods come from MCL 600.5805.[4][10] When a period starts to run, and which one fits a particular set of facts, are questions this page does not answer. Anyone weighing a claim can use the page of questions to ask a lawyer to prepare.
Fair to both sides
The same body of law protects stores that act carefully, as the store owners' guide explains from the merchant's side. A store with probable cause gets the damages limit in MCL 600.2917, and a store that only reports information to police who act on their own judgment is not liable for false arrest on that basis.[3][2] Knowingly making a false report of a crime is itself a crime, a misdemeanor if the false report is of a misdemeanor and a felony punishable by up to 4 years if it is of a felony.[16] On the precedent question, a Court of Appeals panel must follow published Court of Appeals decisions issued on or after November 1, 1990, such as Clarke (1992), while earlier published decisions do not bind later panels in that way.[17]
A civil claim against a store is separate from the store's own civil demand for payment and from the criminal case. See civil demand and the criminal case and, if a charge was dismissed, clearing the arrest record.
Common questions
Can I sue a store for wrongly accusing me of shoplifting in Michigan?
Michigan law recognizes civil claims such as false imprisonment, false arrest, assault and battery, and slander against a store, its agents and its security contractors. If the store had probable cause and believed the person stole, MCL 600.2917 bars damages for mental anguish and punitive damages unless one of four exceptions is proved, but the Court of Appeals held the person may still maintain the action.[3][12]
The charge was dismissed. Does that mean the arrest was a false arrest?
Not by itself. In Lewis v Farmer Jack the Michigan Supreme Court defined false arrest as an illegal or unjustified arrest and held that police who had probable cause from a store employee's information made a legal arrest, even though the charges were later dismissed. Malicious prosecution is a different claim with its own elements.[2][9]
How long do I have to file a lawsuit after a store detention?
Under MCL 600.5805, the period is 2 years for an action charging assault, battery or false imprisonment, 1 year for libel or slander, and 2 years for malicious prosecution. Personal-injury and property-injury claims not covered by a specific period generally have 3 years. When a period starts and which one applies to a given claim are questions for the court.[4][5][10][15]
Can I sue the store if it called the police and the police arrested me?
In Lewis v Farmer Jack, store employees phoned police and pointed out a man as a suspect; the Court held they did no more than provide information, and the store was not liable for false arrest because police acted on their own judgment with probable cause. The Court left open whether withholding information from police could create liability.[2]
Is a store employee's public accusation of shoplifting slander?
It can be. In Bonkowski v Arlan's Department Store, the Court held that a guard's loud accusation near the store door, within hearing of others, and accusatory gestures in sight of others, can be publication for a slander claim. The majority treated the accusation as subject to the common-law qualified privilege, under which the person suing must prove that the statement was false and made with actual malice; three justices wrote that the store must first prove the privilege applies.[8]
Sources
- Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992) (quoting Stowers v Wolodzko, 386 Mich 119, 134 (1971), and Tumbarella v Kroger Co, 85 Mich App 482, 489 (1978)) — Caselaw Access Project
- Lewis v Farmer Jack Div, Inc, 415 Mich 212 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 600.2917(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.5805(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.5805(11) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.5805(2)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
- Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992) (quoting Espinoza v Thomas, 189 Mich App 110, 119 (1991)) — Caselaw Access Project
- Bonkowski v Arlan's Dep't Store, 383 Mich 90 (1970) — Caselaw Access Project
- Matthews v Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Michigan, 456 Mich 365 (1998) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 600.5805(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 37.2302(a); Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992) — Michigan Legislature
- Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
- Clarke v K mart Corp, 197 Mich App 541 (1992); Bonkowski v Arlan's Dep't Store, 383 Mich 90, 96-97 (1970) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 600.2907 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.5805(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.411a(1)(a)-(e) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 7.215(J)(1) — Michigan Courts
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.