Key points
- Since October 1, 2021, the family division of circuit court has exclusive original jurisdiction over a juvenile under 18 accused of breaking a state law or local ordinance; before then, "juvenile" generally meant under 17.[1][2]
- An officer who takes a child into custody must immediately try to notify a parent and, unless immediate detention is needed, must release the child to a parent who promises in writing to bring the child to court.[3][4]
- Only the prosecuting attorney may file a petition asking the court to take jurisdiction for a law violation, and the court may then deny it, refer it to diversion, use the consent calendar or put it on the formal calendar.[5][6]
- At a juvenile trial the Michigan Rules of Evidence and proof beyond a reasonable doubt apply, but the case is, except as otherwise provided, not a criminal proceeding.[7][8]
- Restitution is ordered, but since October 1, 2024 the court may not order the juvenile or a parent to pay court costs or assessments related to the case.[9][10]
This page explains how a Michigan retail fraud or theft accusation against a minor moves through juvenile court: which court hears it, custody, the petition, adjudication and what the court can order. Diversion and records have their own pages. Parents can also start with the parents' guide to teen shoplifting.
Which court hears the case
The family division of circuit court has "exclusive original jurisdiction" over a juvenile under 18 found within the county who has violated a municipal ordinance or a state or federal law.[11] That version of the law, from 2019 PA 113, took effect October 1, 2021.[1] Before that date, the term juvenile "generally referred to a person less than 17 years of age."[2]
Except as otherwise provided in MCL 600.606, a child under 18 who is arrested must be taken immediately before the family division of the county where the offense is alleged to have happened.[12] If a criminal court learns during a case that the defendant is under 18, it must transfer the case to the family division, except as provided for certain serious charges in circuit court.[13] If the juvenile turns 18 after the petition is filed, the court's jurisdiction continues and it may still hear and decide the petition.[14]
When police take a child into custody
A police officer may, without a court order, take into custody a child found violating any law or ordinance, and "shall immediately attempt to notify the parent or parents, guardian, or custodian."[3] While waiting for a parent, a child under 18 may not be held in a jail or other detention facility unless completely isolated from any contact with adult prisoners.[15]
Unless the child requires immediate detention, the officer "shall accept the written promise" of the parent to bring the child to court at a fixed time, and the child is then released to the parent.[4] Under the court rules, an officer who does not warn and release the juvenile or refer the case to diversion may instead issue a citation and release the juvenile, release the juvenile to a parent on a written promise, or take the juvenile into custody and ask the prosecutor to file a petition in listed situations.[16]
Holding a juvenile before a hearing is limited to listed categories, such as home conditions that make immediate removal necessary, a record of unexcused failures to appear, or an offense so serious that release would endanger public safety.[17] A detention screening tool has to be used before a juvenile is placed in a secure facility.[17] If a juvenile is in court custody, the preliminary hearing must begin within 24 hours, excluding Sundays and holidays, or the juvenile must be released.[18]
On questioning, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a child's age, if known to the officer or objectively apparent, is part of deciding whether the child was in custody for Miranda purposes.[19] The Michigan Court of Appeals has suggested that a juvenile must ask for a parent or other adult before that person's absence weighs against the voluntariness of a confession.[20] Store detentions and questioning are covered on the loss prevention questioning page.
The petition and the court's first look
"Only the prosecuting attorney may file a petition requesting the court to take jurisdiction" over a juvenile for a law violation.[5] At the preliminary inquiry, the court may:
- Deny authorization of the petition.[6]
- Refer the matter to an agency providing services under the Juvenile Diversion Act.[6]
- Have the juvenile and parent notified to appear for further informal inquiry.[6]
- Proceed on the consent calendar.[6]
- Place the matter on the formal calendar.[6]
The diversion and consent calendar routes are explained on the juvenile diversion page. Once a petition is authorized, the court must check whether the juvenile's biometric data was collected as MCL 28.243 requires and, if not, order it collected.[21] The adult fingerprinting rules are on the booking and fingerprints page.
A lawyer and a jury
In a delinquency case the court "shall advise the child that he or she has a right to an attorney at each stage of the proceeding."[22] The court must appoint an attorney if any of these apply:
- The child's parent refuses or fails to appear and take part.[22]
- The child's parent is the complainant or victim.[22]
- The child and family cannot afford an attorney and the child does not waive the right.[22]
- Those responsible for the child's support refuse or neglect to hire one and the child does not waive the right.[22]
- The court decides the child's or the public's best interests require it.[22]
A child's waiver must be made in open court and found voluntary and understanding, and a child may not waive if a parent or guardian ad litem objects or if the court appointed the attorney because the child's or the public's best interests require it.[22] Except as otherwise provided in the statute, in a juvenile hearing other than a criminal trial, a person interested in the hearing may demand a jury of 6, or the court may order one.[23]
Plea or trial: reaching an adjudication
A juvenile may offer a plea of admission or no contest with the court's consent, and the court "shall not accept a plea to an offense unless the court is satisfied that the plea is accurate, voluntary, and understanding."[24] Before accepting it, the court must tell the juvenile the possible dispositions and that a plea gives up trial rights, including a jury, the presumption of innocence and having the prosecutor "prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt."[24]
If the case goes to trial, it must be held within 6 months after the petition is authorized unless adjourned for good cause, and a detained juvenile whose trial has not started within 63 days, for reasons not caused by the defense, must be released pending trial.[7] "The Michigan Rules of Evidence and the standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt apply at trial," and the verdict is guilty or not guilty of the offense charged or a lesser included offense.[7] If the court finds the juvenile is not within its jurisdiction, it must dismiss the petition.[25]
Except as otherwise provided, these "are not criminal proceedings."[8] Evidence about a juvenile's disposition may not be used against that juvenile in any other judicial proceeding except a later juvenile case.[26]
Disposition: what the court can order
The dispositional hearing decides "what measures the court will take" once the juvenile has been found to have committed an offense; for a detained juvenile it must be held within 35 days except for good cause.[27] The victim may attend and make an impact statement, and the court considers a risk and needs assessment before entering a disposition.[27]
The court must return the juvenile to the parent if that would not cause a substantial risk of harm to the juvenile or society, and it may also order dispositions that include:[25]
- Warning the juvenile or parents and dismissing the petition.[25]
- Probation, or supervision in the juvenile's own home or the home of a relative.[25]
- Placement in a foster care home under court supervision.[25]
- Placement in or commitment to a licensed private institution or agency.[25]
- Community service, without fees or costs for it.[25][10]
Restitution is part of the case. The court "shall order the juvenile or the juvenile's parent to pay restitution" as the Juvenile Code and the Crime Victim's Rights Act provide.[9] If restitution is a probation condition, the juvenile must also do community service or services for the victim, or keep a paid job and pay from those earnings.[9] A juvenile "must not be placed outside of his or her home solely based on nonpayment of restitution or inability to perform community service."[9] A court may order a parent to pay restitution the juvenile cannot pay, after notice and a chance to be heard.[28] The page on civil demands sent to parents covers the store's separate money claim.
Costs are treated differently from restitution. Since October 1, 2024, the court may not order a juvenile or parent to pay "the costs of care, services, court-appointed attorney representation, or other costs or assessments related to the juvenile's court proceeding," and may not order fines for a law violation when another disposition has been ordered.[10]
When a juvenile case can be handled like an adult case
For a retail fraud or larceny accusation, two routes exist, and neither is automatic:
- Waiver: if a juvenile 14 or older is accused of an act that would be a felony for an adult, the family court may waive jurisdiction on the prosecutor's motion, after finding probable cause and holding a best-interests hearing.[29]
- Designation: for an offense other than a specified juvenile violation, the prosecutor may ask the family court to designate the case so the juvenile is tried "in the same manner as an adult," and the court decides after a hearing, giving greater weight to the seriousness of the offense and the juvenile's prior record.[30]
Second- and third-degree retail fraud are misdemeanors, and first-degree retail fraud is a felony, so only a felony-level charge fits the waiver statute.[31][29] Retail fraud and larceny are not on the specified juvenile violation lists.[32][33] If jurisdiction is waived, the Holmes Youthful Trainee Act (HYTA) chapter can apply to a person over 14 whose case was waived.[34] See the HYTA page and the third-degree retail fraud page for the adult side.
After the case
Since January 1, 2021, juvenile court records are not open to the general public and are open only to persons with a legitimate interest.[35] The State Police say their public ICHAT search does not include juvenile records.[36] Who can still see the record, and when it is set aside automatically, are covered on the juvenile theft records page.
Common questions
Is a 17-year-old charged with shoplifting in adult court in Michigan?
The case starts in juvenile court under current law. Since October 1, 2021, the family division of circuit court has exclusive original jurisdiction over a juvenile under 18 accused of violating a state law or ordinance.[11] Before that date, the term juvenile generally referred to a person under 17.[2] If a criminal court learns a defendant is under 18, it must transfer the case to the family division, except for listed serious offenses that the circuit court may hear, a list that does not include retail fraud charged on its own.[13][33] For a felony-level charge, the family court may waive jurisdiction on the prosecutor's motion.[29]
Does my child get a lawyer in juvenile court?
The court must advise the child of the right to an attorney at each stage.[22] It must appoint one in listed situations, including when the parent fails to appear, the parent is the victim, or the family cannot afford a lawyer and the child does not waive the right.[22] A child's waiver has to be made in open court and found voluntary, and is not allowed if a parent objects.[22]
Can a juvenile shoplifting case be sent to adult court?
Waiver to adult court is available when a juvenile 14 or older is accused of an act that would be a felony for an adult.[29] Second- and third-degree retail fraud are misdemeanors; first-degree retail fraud is a felony.[31] Separately, for an offense that is not a specified juvenile violation, the prosecutor may ask the family court to designate the case to be tried in the same manner as an adult, and the court decides after a hearing.[30]
Will we have to pay court costs in a juvenile retail fraud case?
The Juvenile Code now says the court "shall not order a juvenile or a juvenile's parent, guardian, or legal custodian to pay for the costs of care, services, court-appointed attorney representation, or other costs or assessments related to the juvenile's court proceeding."[10] That rule took effect October 1, 2024.[10] Restitution to the victim is different and is still ordered.[9][37]
Does a juvenile adjudication count as a criminal conviction?
Except as otherwise provided, proceedings under the Juvenile Code "are not criminal proceedings."[8] Evidence about a juvenile's disposition may not be used against that juvenile in any other judicial proceeding except a later juvenile case, though that rule does not cover a criminal conviction entered in a designated case.[26] Some later laws still count juvenile adjudications, which the juvenile records page explains.
Sources
- MCL 712A.2(a)(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.1(1)(i); 2019 PA 113 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 712A.14(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.14(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 3.932(A) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 3.942(A), (C), (E) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 712A.1(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.18(5)-(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.18(1)(i)-(j), (3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2(a)(1); MCL 712A.2 (History: Am. 2019, Act 113, Eff. Oct. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.27; MCL 764.27 (History: Am. 2019, Act 103, Eff. Oct. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 764.27 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.11(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.14(1); MCR 3.933(D) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 3.933(A) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 712A.15(2)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 3.935(A)(1)-(2) — Michigan Courts
- JDB v North Carolina, 564 US 261, 264, 277 (2011) — Michigan Courts
- People v Givans, 227 Mich App 113, 121-122 (1997) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 712A.11(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.17c(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.17(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 3.941(A), (C)(1), (C)(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 712A.18(1)(a)-(i) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.23 — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 3.943(A), (B), (D)(2), (E)(1) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.794(15)-(16); MCL 780.766(15)-(16) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.4(1), (3), (4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.2d(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1), (4); MCL 750.356c(1); MCL 600.8311(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 722.823(3); MCL 722.822(e); MCL 712A.2(a)(1)(A) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.606(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 762.15 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 712A.28(2), (3), (5)(d) — Michigan Legislature
- Michigan State Police, Criminal History Records page — Michigan State Police
- MCL 780.794(2) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.