Key points
- Self-defense can be a defense to felony firearm: in People v Goree (2012) the Court of Appeals vacated a felony-firearm conviction because jurors were told self-defense could not apply to that count.[1]
- The Michigan Supreme Court held in People v Dupree (2010) that self-defense may be raised to a felon-in-possession charge, and M Crim JI 7.25 sets out when possessing a firearm to defend oneself or another is justified.[2][3]
- The model instruction for carrying a concealed weapon says self-defense is not a defense, but People v Triplett (2016) allows it where the concealed item is a dangerous weapon only because it was used as one.[4][5]
- A jury may acquit of the underlying felony yet convict of felony firearm; in People v Kilgore (2024), a Kent County case, that split led to a vacated felony-firearm conviction because no self-defense instruction was requested on that count.[6][7]
- In Kilgore the Court of Appeals called it "an open question" whether a man who had been carrying concealed was entitled to a Self-Defense Act instruction, while saying common-law instructions were available either way.[8]
Self-defense can answer more than an assault or homicide charge in Michigan. The courts have held it available against felony firearm, against felon in possession of a firearm, and against carrying a concealed weapon (CCW) where the concealed item is a weapon only because it was used as one.[1][2][5] Each charge has its own rule, and the model instruction for CCW still tells jurors that self-defense is not a defense to that charge.[4] The cases reviewed for this guide do not decide whether self-defense excuses carrying a pistol without a required license.
Why possession charges raise a separate question
Self-defense law is mostly about the use of force: the model instruction tells jurors that a person who acts in lawful self-defense is "justified" and "not guilty."[9] Possession charges punish having or carrying the gun itself, as with carrying a pistol concealed without a license or possessing a firearm while committing a felony.[10][11] The Self-Defense Act's no-retreat rule applies only to a person who "has not or is not engaged in the commission of a crime" when using deadly or non-deadly force, and in People v Allen (2025), as quoted in the state criminal benchbook, the Court of Appeals treated a felon's possession of a handgun as such a crime.[12][13][14]
Losing the Act does not end self-defense. The Act "does not diminish" the common-law right of self-defense as it existed on October 1, 2006.[15] Where the Act does not apply, MCL 768.21c still removes the duty to retreat before using deadly force in one's own dwelling or within its curtilage.[16] In People v Leffew (2022) the Supreme Court also said that the defense of others is not limited to assault charges: "The applicability of the defense must be determined on the particular facts of each case, not the charges the prosecution brings."[17]
Felony firearm: self-defense applies
Felony firearm, MCL 750.227b, makes it a separate felony to carry or possess a firearm while committing or attempting a felony, with a fixed 2-year term for a first conviction.[11] In People v Goree (2012), a jury acquitted a concealed-pistol permit holder of the assault charges but convicted him of felony firearm after the judge told jurors self-defense could not apply to that count.[1] The Court of Appeals vacated the conviction, saying a violent crime "may be excused when the defendant acts to protect himself or others, as may a firearm-possession charge."[1]
M Crim JI 11.34c, "Felony Firearm - Self-Defense," adopted in May 2012, restates the Self-Defense Act's deadly-force and non-deadly-force rules for a felony-firearm count.[18]
A jury may convict of felony firearm even if it acquits of the underlying felony.[6][19] In People v Kilgore (2024), a Kent Circuit Court case, the jury acquitted the defendant of first- and second-degree murder but convicted him of felony firearm predicated on murder.[7] Because his lawyer had not asked for self-defense and defense-of-others instructions on that count, the Court of Appeals found ineffective assistance and vacated the felony-firearm conviction and sentence.[7] It added that on any retrial he "would be entitled to, at least, common-law self-defense and defense-of-others instructions."[8]
In People v Ogilvie (2022), a pointed-gun case, the Court of Appeals reversed both felonious-assault and felony-firearm convictions because the jury should have been told about non-deadly force.[20] The elements of the charge are on the felony firearm page, and felony firearm alongside drug charges is covered in the drug crimes guide.
Felon in possession: possessing a gun to defend against an attack
Michigan bars a person convicted of a felony from possessing a firearm until 3 years after fines, imprisonment and probation or parole are complete; for a "specified felony" the wait is 5 years and the person's rights must also be restored under MCL 28.424.[21][22] A violation is a felony punishable by up to 5 years, a fine of up to $5,000, or both.[23] The waiting periods are explained in can a felon own a gun in Michigan.
In People v Dupree (2010), the Supreme Court held "that the traditional common law affirmative defense of self-defense may be interposed to a charge of being a felon in possession of a firearm."[2] Dupree testified that he took the gun from an intoxicated, armed man of about 300 pounds.[2] Once a defendant produces some evidence of self-defense, the prosecution must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt.[24]
M Crim JI 7.25 now tells jurors that a person "may possess a firearm to defend" himself, herself or another person "under certain circumstances, even where it would otherwise be unlawful."[3] The instruction requires:
- an honest and reasonable belief that possessing the firearm was needed to protect against the imminent unlawful use of force;[3]
- that possession was "necessary at the time" to protect against danger of death or serious injury, and appropriate to the attack; and[3]
- where the facts support it, that the defendant "must not have been engaged in a criminal act that would tend to provoke a person to try to defend" himself or herself from the defendant.[3]
The court must also read the burden-of-proof instruction, M Crim JI 7.20.[3] The committee's note gives examples for the third element: it is "usually unwarranted" where the defendant was in a drug transaction and defended against an unprovoked attack by the other party, but "would apply" to a defendant who robbed someone who then reacted with force.[25]
Felons and the Self-Defense Act: Guajardo and Allen
Two Court of Appeals decisions address the Act itself. In People v Guajardo (2013), the court held that "a felon possessing a firearm is not precluded from raising self-defense under the SDA when there is evidence" that the criminal possession was justified by an honest and reasonable belief that deadly force was necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault; on its facts, Guajardo was not entitled to the instruction.[26] In Allen (2025), known for this guide only through the state criminal benchbook's quotations, the court said a felon who was in possession of a handgun when he fired was not entitled to an instruction under the Act, but that refusing a common-law self-defense instruction on the murder charge was error.[14] Neither decision sets out one rule for every case.
Carrying a concealed weapon: the general rule and Triplett
MCL 750.227 makes it a felony to carry a pistol concealed on or about the person, or in a vehicle the person operates or occupies, without a license, except in one's dwelling house, place of business or other land one possesses; the penalty is up to 5 years or a fine of up to $2,500.[10][27] The model instruction for CCW, M Crim JI 11.8, says: "It does not matter if the defendant was carrying the weapon for [his / her] own protection. Self-defense is not a defense to this charge."[4]
The Supreme Court made an exception in People v Triplett (2016): common-law self-defense "is available to a defendant charged with CCW for concealing an instrument which is a dangerous weapon only because it is used as a weapon."[5] The item there was a utility knife, and the Court vacated the CCW conviction.[5] Triplett did not involve a pistol. In Kilgore, the trial judge told the jury "Self defense is not a defense to carrying a concealed weapon," defense counsel conceded the CCW count, and the Court of Appeals called that concession understandable.[28]
CCW also cannot be the predicate felony for a felony-firearm charge: MCL 750.227b excludes sections 223, 227, 227a and 230.[11] The full offense is covered on the carrying a concealed weapon page.
Carrying without a license and the "commission of a crime" condition
The Self-Defense Act and the castle-doctrine presumption both turn in part on whether the person using force was engaged in the commission of a crime.[29][30] Neither statute mentions a concealed pistol license; they state their rules for "an individual."[31] A CPL authorizes carrying a concealed pistol anywhere in Michigan and carrying a pistol in a vehicle, subject to the pistol-free zones and other law.[32]
Kilgore shows how timing can matter. The Court of Appeals said it was "arguable that, once defendant was out of his vehicle and no longer concealing the weapon, he was not committing a CCW at that time," that it was "therefore, an open question" whether he was entitled to an instruction under the Act, and that "in any event, defendant would still be entitled to an instruction under the common-law."[8] In Leffew the Supreme Court said section 2 of the Act is "only a statutory precondition to standing one's ground under the SDA" and that, aside from limiting the duty to retreat, the statute "did not modify or abrogate the common-law defenses of self-defense or defense of others."[33]
Sentencing on a possession count after a self-defense acquittal
Kilgore also addressed sentencing. After the murder acquittal on self-defense and defense-of-others theories, the trial court imposed an upward-departure sentence on the CCW conviction.[34] The Court of Appeals held that "the trial court erred by considering acquitted conduct when setting the departure sentence" and vacated it.[34] Guidelines scoring is covered in sentencing guidelines in weapons cases.
What people get wrong
- "Self-defense is never a defense to a gun-possession charge." Goree (felony firearm), Dupree (felon in possession) and Triplett (CCW of an item used as a weapon) say otherwise, and model instructions exist for felony firearm, felon in possession and brandishing.[1][2][5][18][3][35]
- "Triplett made self-defense a defense to carrying any concealed weapon." Its holding concerns an instrument that is a dangerous weapon only because it was used as one.[5]
Trial procedure is on raising self-defense in a gun case; brandishing in self-defense is on displaying, pointing or firing a gun in self-defense, and the aggressor rules are on who started it.
Common questions
Is self-defense a defense to felony firearm in Michigan?
Yes. In People v Goree (2012) the Court of Appeals held that the trial court erred by telling jurors self-defense does not apply to a felony-firearm charge, and vacated that conviction.[1] M Crim JI 11.34c, adopted in May 2012, restates the Self-Defense Act's rules for a felony-firearm count.[18] In 2024 the court vacated another felony-firearm conviction because counsel did not request the instructions on that count.[7]
Can a convicted felon claim self-defense in Michigan?
A felon can raise common-law self-defense to a felon-in-possession charge, as the Supreme Court held in People v Dupree (2010).[2] M Crim JI 7.25 requires an honest and reasonable belief that possessing the gun was needed against imminent unlawful force, necessity at the time, and, where the facts support it, no provoking criminal act.[3] Whether the Self-Defense Act itself applies depends on the case.[26][14]
Is carrying a gun for protection a defense to a concealed weapon charge?
The model instruction says it is not. M Crim JI 11.8 tells jurors it "does not matter" that the defendant carried the weapon for protection and that "Self-defense is not a defense to this charge."[4] The Supreme Court's exception in People v Triplett (2016) covers an instrument that is a dangerous weapon only because it was used as one, such as the utility knife in that case.[5] The cases reviewed for this guide do not decide whether self-defense can excuse carrying a pistol concealed without a license.
Can a jury acquit of assault but still convict of felony firearm?
Yes. A jury may convict of felony firearm even if it acquits of the underlying felony.[6] That happened in Goree, where the jury acquitted on the assault charges after being told self-defense did not apply to felony firearm, and in Kilgore, where the jury acquitted of murder but convicted of felony firearm predicated on murder; both felony-firearm convictions were vacated.[1][7]
Does having a CPL matter if a gun is used in self-defense?
The self-defense statutes do not mention a license; they state their rules for "an individual."[31] Two related rules: the Act's no-retreat rule requires that the person was not engaged in the commission of a crime, and a CPL authorizes concealed carry and carry in a vehicle anywhere in Michigan, subject to the pistol-free zones and other law.[29][32]
Sources
- People v Goree, 296 Mich App 293, 294, 302 (2012) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Dupree, 486 Mich 693, 696-697, 708-709 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 7.25(1)-(5) and Use Note — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.8 and Reference Guide — Michigan Courts
- People v Triplett, 499 Mich 52, 53 (2016) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Powell, 303 Mich App 271, 274 (2013) — Michigan Courts
- People v Kilgore, ___ Mich App ___ (2024) (Docket No. 365881), slip op at 1, 5 — Michigan Courts
- People v Kilgore, ___ Mich App ___ (2024) (Docket No. 365881), slip op at 6 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.15(1) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.227(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.227b(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.972(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.972(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Allen, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.974 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 768.21c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 14 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.34c — Michigan Courts
- People v Goree, 296 Mich App 293, 304 (2012) (citing People v Lewis, 415 Mich 443, 455 (1982)) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Ogilvie, 341 Mich App 28, 38-41 (2022) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.224f(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.224f(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.224f(6) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Dupree, 486 Mich 693, 709-710, 712 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 7.25, Use Note 2 — Michigan Courts
- People v Guajardo, 300 Mich App 26, 40 (2013) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 750.227(3) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Kilgore, ___ Mich App ___ (2024) (Docket No. 365881), slip op at 3, 5 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.16(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.951(2)(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.972; MCL 780.951; MCL 600.2922b — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 28.425c(3) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625, 641 (2022), slip op at 12-13 — Michigan Courts
- People v Kilgore, ___ Mich App ___ (2024) (Docket No. 365881), slip op at 7 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.25a — Michigan Courts
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.