SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Self-defense law

Who Started It? Initial Aggressors, Withdrawal and Mutual Combat in Michigan Self-Defense Law

Key points

  • The Michigan Supreme Court describes an initial aggressor as "one who is the first to use deadly force against the other" and says that person is generally not entitled to use deadly force in self-defense.[1]
  • Under the model jury instruction on non-deadly force, a defendant who only used words is not barred from claiming self-defense if he or she was then attacked.[2]
  • A person who started an assault with deadly force or a dangerous or deadly weapon cannot claim self-defense unless he or she genuinely stopped and clearly let the other person know he or she wanted to make peace; if the other person then kept fighting or started again, the right returns.[3]
  • At common law, a willing participant in a fight that turns deadly must take any reasonable and safe avenue of retreat before using deadly force, except when attacked in his or her own dwelling.[4][5]
  • Whether the defendant was the initial aggressor is a question for the jury once there is sufficient evidence of self-defense, and the prosecutor must then disprove self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt.[6][7]

Starting a confrontation can limit or remove the right to claim self-defense in Michigan, but it does not always end it. The Michigan Supreme Court says a person who is "the first to use deadly force against the other" is generally not entitled to use deadly force in self-defense, while the model jury instructions say a person who started a non-deadly confrontation "does not lose all right to self-defense."[1][8] Words alone do not bar the claim, an aggressor who genuinely withdraws can regain the right, and whether someone was the aggressor is generally for the jury to decide.[2][3][6]

This page sets out those rules as the cases and model jury instructions state them; it does not say when force is justified. The general standards are on the pages about Michigan self-defense law for gun owners and deadly and non-deadly force.

What "initial aggressor" means

The phrase comes from case law. In People v Riddle (2002), the Supreme Court described an initial aggressor as "one who is the first to use deadly force against the other" and said such a person "is generally not entitled to use deadly force in self-defense."[1] The Court quoted that description again in People v Rajput (2020).[1] The same limit applies to defending others: in People v Leffew (2022) the Court said defense of others "is generally not available to a person who is the initial aggressor."[9]

Aggressor status is tied to the confrontation at hand. In People v Townes (1974), the Supreme Court said: "Appellant may only be held legally accountable as an aggressor for responsive conduct by another that is reasonably attributable to appellant's own conduct."[10] It approved an older rule that the disqualifying wrong "must relate to the assault in resistance of which the assailant was killed."[10]

Words alone do not make someone the aggressor

The model instruction on non-deadly force, M Crim JI 7.22, tells jurors that the person claiming self-defense "must not have acted wrongfully and brought on the assault."[2] It then adds that if the defendant "only used words, that does not prevent" him or her "from claiming self-defense" if attacked.[2]

Words can still matter when the response is deadly. M Crim JI 7.16 lists insulting someone with words as one way a defendant can start a non-deadly confrontation, along with assaulting someone with fists or a weapon that is not deadly, trespassing on someone else's property, and trying to take someone else's property in a nonviolent way.[8] Such a defendant "does not lose all right to self-defense," but if someone else assaults him or her with deadly force, the defendant "may act in self-defense but only if" he or she "retreated where it would have been safe to do so."[8]

That rule used to be a separate instruction, M Crim JI 7.19 ("Nondeadly Aggressor Assaulted with Deadly Force"), which was combined with M Crim JI 7.16 in May 2023.[11] Older articles that cite 7.19 are describing the same rule.

Starting a fight with deadly force: withdrawal

M Crim JI 7.18 covers a person who "started an assault on someone else" with deadly force or with a dangerous or deadly weapon.[3] That person cannot claim self-defense unless he or she "genuinely stopped" fighting "and clearly let the other person know" that he or she "wanted to make peace."[3] If the other person then "kept on fighting or started fighting again later," the defendant "had the same right to defend" himself or herself "as anyone else and could use force to save" himself or herself "from immediate physical harm."[3]

Mutual combat: when both people are willing

In Riddle, the Supreme Court said the law "imposes an affirmative obligation to retreat upon a nonaggressor only in one narrow set of circumstances": a willing participant in a "sudden affray" or "chance medley" must "take advantage of any reasonable and safe avenue of retreat before using deadly force against his adversary, should the altercation escalate into a deadly encounter."[4] Rajput quoted the same rule in 2020.[4]

The home is the exception. Riddle said a person attacked in his or her dwelling "is never required to retreat where it is otherwise necessary to exercise deadly force in self-defense," and that "[t]his is true even where one is a voluntary participant in mutual combat."[5] Since October 1, 2006, MCL 768.21c has also provided that, where the Self-Defense Act does not apply, there is no duty to retreat before using deadly force in one's own dwelling "or within the curtilage of that dwelling."[12]

As the model instruction lists them, the Self-Defense Act's no-retreat rule has three conditions: the person was not engaged in the commission of a crime when the force was used, had a legal right to be where he or she was, and had the required honest and reasonable belief.[13][14] Outside the Act, Michigan's common law on the duty to retreat, as it stood on October 1, 2006, still governs, subject to the own-dwelling rule in MCL 768.21c.[15][12] See stand your ground and the duty to retreat and the castle doctrine.

Committing another crime at the time

The Act protects only a person who "has not or is not engaged in the commission of a crime" when using deadly or non-deadly force, and it does not define "commission of a crime."[13][16][17] The Act also "does not diminish" the common-law right of self-defense as it existed on October 1, 2006.[18]

For common-law self-defense, the committee that writes the model instructions says that where a defendant was committing some other crime when he or she used deadly force, the court may have a basis to tell the jury that the defendant does not lose the right to self-defense "if the commission of that other offense was not likely to lead to the other person's assaultive behavior."[19] The committee "expresses no opinion" where the other offense may lead to assaultive behavior.[19] In People v Allen (2025), known for this guide only through the state criminal benchbook's quotations, the Court of Appeals said a felon in possession of a handgun was not entitled to an instruction under the Act but was entitled to a common-law self-defense instruction on the murder charge.[20] How these rules apply to gun-possession charges is covered in self-defense and gun-possession charges.

Attacked by more than one person

M Crim JI 7.24 tells jurors that a defendant attacked by more than one person, or by one person with others helping and encouraging, "has the right to act in self-defense against all of them."[21] Before using deadly force against any one attacker, however, the defendant "must honestly and reasonably believe" that he or she is in imminent danger of death, great bodily harm or sexual assault "by that particular person."[21]

Who decides whether someone was the aggressor

In Rajput, the Supreme Court held that the Court of Appeals engaged in improper fact-finding when it decided the defendant was an initial aggressor and could have fled; because the defendant presented sufficient evidence of self-defense, those issues were "for the jury to decide."[6] The Court has also said instructions "cannot exclude the theory of self-defense" if there is evidence to support it.[22] The defendant's burden of producing some evidence "is not a heavy one," and even weak evidence of doubtful credibility requires the instruction.[23]

Once there is some evidence, the defendant does not have to prove self-defense; the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense.[24][7] In Allen, as quoted in the benchbook, the Court of Appeals said the trial court "usurped the role of the jury" by deciding the defendant was not credible, and that "it was for the jury to decide whether his version of events was more believable."[20]

The model instructions do not have the force of a court rule, but MCR 2.512(D) requires courts to use them unless an instruction misstates the law or the case requires a variance or additions.[25] The burden and instruction rules are explained further on raising self-defense in a gun case.

Evidence of the other person's past violence

Under M Crim JI 7.23, if there is evidence the complainant or decedent committed violent acts in the past that the defendant knew about, jurors may consider it in deciding whether the defendant honestly and reasonably feared for his or her safety; evidence of a reputation for cruelty or violence may also be considered.[26] In a homicide case where self-defense is an issue, Michigan Rule of Evidence 404(a)(2)(B) lets the defendant offer evidence of the alleged victim's trait for aggression; if it is admitted, the prosecution may answer with evidence of the defendant's same trait and of the alleged victim's peacefulness "to rebut evidence that the alleged victim was the first aggressor."[27]

Excluding a defendant's own account of a threat can matter too. In People v Nelson (2025), a felonious-assault and felony-firearm case, the Supreme Court ordered a new trial because the trial court blocked the defendant's testimony that her boyfriend had threatened to kill her before she retrieved her gun.[28]

Common misunderstandings

  • "If you started it, you can never claim self-defense." The instructions say otherwise: words alone do not bar the claim, a non-deadly aggressor met with deadly force keeps the right if he or she retreated where it was safe, and a deadly aggressor can regain it by genuinely withdrawing.[2][8][3]
  • "A concealed pistol license changes these rules." The self-defense statutes state their rules for "an individual" and do not mention a license.[29]

For incidents between family or household members, the domestic violence guide covers dual arrests and who started it. Defending another person who is being attacked is covered in defense of others.

Common questions

If I started an argument, can I still claim self-defense in Michigan?

Words alone do not end the right. The model instruction on non-deadly force says a defendant who "only used words" is not prevented from claiming self-defense if attacked.[2] A separate instruction says a defendant who insulted someone and was then assaulted with deadly force may act in self-defense, but only if he or she retreated where it would have been safe to do so.[8] Whether a defendant was the aggressor is generally a question for the jury.[6]

What does "initial aggressor" mean in Michigan?

The Michigan Supreme Court has described an initial aggressor as "one who is the first to use deadly force against the other" and said that person "is generally not entitled to use deadly force in self-defense."[1] In People v Townes (1974) the Court limited aggressor status to the other person's response that is "reasonably attributable" to the defendant's own conduct.[10] In People v Leffew (2022) the Court said defense of others is likewise generally not available to an initial aggressor.[9]

Can someone who started a fight get the right to self-defense back?

Under M Crim JI 7.18, a person who started an assault with deadly force or a dangerous weapon can claim self-defense only if he or she genuinely stopped and clearly let the other person know he or she wanted to make peace.[3] If the other person then kept fighting or started again, the defendant had "the same right to defend" himself or herself "as anyone else."[3]

Who decides whether a defendant was the aggressor, the judge or the jury?

Generally the jury. In People v Rajput (2020) the Supreme Court held that the Court of Appeals engaged in improper fact-finding when it decided the defendant was an initial aggressor and could have fled; those were issues "for the jury to decide" because the defendant presented sufficient evidence of self-defense. The Court reversed the holding that he was not entitled to the instruction and sent the case back to the Court of Appeals.[6] Jury instructions cannot leave out self-defense if there is evidence to support it.[22]

What happens to self-defense when both people agreed to fight?

At common law a willing participant in a fight is not barred from self-defense, but if the fight escalates into a deadly encounter he or she must take any reasonable and safe avenue of retreat before using deadly force.[4] The Supreme Court said that rule gives way in one's own dwelling, where there is no duty to retreat "even where one is a voluntary participant in mutual combat."[5]

Sources

  1. People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 120 n 8 (2002); People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7 (2020), slip op at 4 — Caselaw Access Project
  2. M Crim JI 7.22(6) — Michigan Courts
  3. M Crim JI 7.18 — Michigan Courts
  4. People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 120 (2002); People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7 (2020), slip op at 4 — Caselaw Access Project
  5. People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 120-121 (2002) — Caselaw Access Project
  6. People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7 (2020), slip op at 3-5, 7 — Michigan Courts
  7. People v Dupree, 486 Mich 693, 709-710, 712 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
  8. M Crim JI 7.16(1) (second alternative) — Michigan Courts
  9. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 10 — Michigan Courts
  10. People v Townes, 391 Mich 578, 592-593 (1974) — Caselaw Access Project
  11. M Crim JI, chapter 7 table of contents; M Crim JI 7.19 — Michigan Courts
  12. MCL 768.21c(1) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 780.972(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  14. M Crim JI 7.16(3) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCL 780.973 — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 780.972(2) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 780.971–780.974 — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 780.974 — Michigan Legislature
  19. M Crim JI 7.15 and 7.16, Use Notes (citing People v Townes, 391 Mich 578, 593 (1974)) — Michigan Courts
  20. People v Allen, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
  21. M Crim JI 7.24 — Michigan Courts
  22. People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7, 10-11 (2020), slip op at 3 — Michigan Courts
  23. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 15 — Michigan Courts
  24. M Crim JI 7.20 — Michigan Courts
  25. M Crim JI, introduction; MCR 2.512(D) — Michigan Courts
  26. M Crim JI 7.23(1)-(2) — Michigan Courts
  27. MRE 404(a)(2)(B) — Michigan Courts
  28. People v Nelson, ___ Mich ___ (2025) (Docket No. 166297, decided March 28, 2025) — Michigan Courts
  29. MCL 780.972; MCL 780.951; MCL 600.2922b — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.