Key points
- Under Michigan's Self-Defense Act, a person not engaged in a crime may use deadly force where he or she honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault.[1][2]
- The Court of Appeals defines deadly force as acts whose natural, probable and foreseeable consequence is death; pointing a loaded gun without firing was held to be a threat of deadly force, not its use.[3][4]
- Jurors judge the conduct by how things appeared to the defendant at the time, and an honest and reasonable mistake about how much danger there was does not defeat the defense.[5][6]
- Threats of future harm are not imminent danger, and a person may not kill or seriously injure another just to protect against what seems like a threat of only minor injury.[7][8]
- A person may use only as much force as he or she thinks necessary at the time; the non-deadly-force instruction adds that the right lasts only as long as it seems necessary.[9][10]
Michigan's Self-Defense Act allows a person who is not engaged in the commission of a crime to use deadly force where he or she honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death, imminent great bodily harm or imminent sexual assault to himself, herself or another individual.[1][2] The model jury instructions break the deadly-force standard into parts: the kind of danger, the honesty and reasonableness of the belief, whether the force was immediately necessary, and how much force was used.[6][8][9]
This page explains each part and who decides it. It describes the legal standard only; whether force was justified in a given case is decided by a jury on the evidence, not in advance.
What counts as deadly force
The Self-Defense Act does not define "deadly force," "great bodily harm" or "sexual assault."[11] The Court of Appeals uses its long-standing definition: deadly force is where the defendant's acts are such that the natural, probable and foreseeable consequence of the acts is death.[3]
The line matters with firearms. In People v Ogilvie (2022), a defendant pointed a loaded gun at a neighbor without firing; the Court of Appeals held that he threatened deadly force but did not use deadly force, so the jury should have been instructed on the non-deadly-force standard, and it reversed his felonious-assault and felony-firearm convictions and ordered a new trial.[4][12] The court added that it did not rule out that, in an appropriate case, whether force was deadly could be a question of fact for the jury.[13] Pointing, brandishing and warning shots are covered on brandishing or a warning shot in self-defense and pointing a gun at someone.
An honest and reasonable belief
For deadly-force self-defense, the defendant must have honestly and reasonably believed he or she was in danger of being killed, seriously injured or sexually assaulted.[6] The belief has two parts. It must be honest, meaning actually held, and it must be reasonable, which depends on what an ordinarily prudent and intelligent person would do on the basis of the defendant's perceptions.[6][14]
Jurors are told to judge the defendant's conduct according to how the circumstances appeared to the defendant at the time he or she acted.[5] If the belief was honest and reasonable, the defendant could act immediately even if it later turned out he or she was wrong about how much danger there was.[6]
Imminent danger, not future threats
The danger must be imminent. The Michigan Supreme Court has described the general rule: killing in self-defense by one who is free from fault is justifiable if, under all the circumstances, the person honestly and reasonably believes he is in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm and that deadly force is necessary.[15] Threats of future harm do not amount to imminent danger.[7] In People v Guajardo (2013), once the other man had abandoned the fight, retreated to his room and closed the door, the court held he did not pose an imminent threat, and deadly force was not necessary.[7]
Fear of serious harm, not minor injury
A person may not kill or seriously injure another just to protect against what seems like a threat of only minor injury; the defendant must have been afraid of death, serious physical injury or sexual assault.[8] In deciding whether the defendant had that fear, jurors may consider:
- The condition of the people involved, including their relative strength.[8]
- Whether the other person was armed or had some other means of injuring the defendant.[8]
- The nature of the other person's attack or threat.[8]
- Whether the defendant knew about any previous violent acts or threats by the other person.[8]
Immediately necessary, and only as much force as needed
The defendant must have honestly and reasonably believed that what he or she did was immediately necessary, and may use only as much force as he or she thinks necessary at the time.[9] Jurors may consider whether the defendant knew of other ways to protect himself or herself, and how the excitement of the moment affected the choice the defendant made.[9]
Under the common law, the necessity element normally requires a person to try to avoid deadly force if he or she can safely and reasonably do so, for example by using non-deadly force or an obvious and safe avenue of retreat.[15] The Self-Defense Act removes the duty to retreat for people who meet its conditions, but not the requirement that the force be honestly and reasonably believed necessary.[1] The retreat rules are covered on Michigan's stand-your-ground law, and the home presumption on Michigan's castle doctrine.
The non-deadly force standard
Force short of deadly force has a lower threshold. A person not engaged in a crime may use non-deadly force if he or she honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to defend against the imminent unlawful use of force by another.[16] The model instruction says an honest and reasonable belief is enough even if the defendant later turns out to have been wrong about the danger.[17] The force must still fit: a person may use only the degree of force that seems necessary at the time, and the kind of force must be appropriate to the attack and the circumstances as the defendant saw them.[18]
How long the right lasts
The model instruction for non-deadly force tells jurors that the right to defend oneself or another lasts only as long as it seems necessary for the purpose of protection.[10] The deadly-force instruction has no separate paragraph on duration; it requires that, at the time the defendant acted, he or she honestly and reasonably believed the action was immediately necessary.[9]
Deadly and non-deadly force compared
| Element | Deadly force | Non-deadly force |
|---|---|---|
| Danger that must be feared[1][2][16] | Imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault | Imminent unlawful use of force |
| Belief[6][17] | Honest and reasonable; a mistake about the degree of danger does not defeat it | Honest and reasonable; a mistake about the danger does not defeat it |
| Amount of force[9][18] | Only as much as the person thinks necessary at the time | Only the degree that seems necessary, appropriate to the attack |
| Minor-injury threats[8] | Not enough | Not part of that instruction |
| Duration[9][10] | No separate paragraph; the action must have been believed immediately necessary | Only as long as it seems necessary |
Who decides
The jury decides whether the evidence of self-defense is sufficient, under proper instructions, and the instructions cannot exclude a self-defense theory the evidence supports.[19] The defendant does not have to prove self-defense; the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense.[20] A person who acts in lawful self-defense is justified and not guilty.[21] The same standards apply when the person being protected is someone else, covered on defense of others with a firearm, and the trial procedure is on raising self-defense in a gun case.
Common questions
When is deadly force legal in Michigan?
The Self-Defense Act allows deadly force by a person not engaged in a crime, anywhere he or she has a legal right to be, if he or she honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault to himself, herself or another.[1][2] Whether that standard was met in a particular case is decided by the jury under the model instructions.[19]
Is pointing a gun at someone deadly force in Michigan?
In People v Ogilvie (2022), the Court of Appeals held that a defendant who pointed a loaded gun at a neighbor, without firing, threatened deadly force but did not use it, so the jury should have been instructed on non-deadly force.[4][12] The court said whether force was deadly could, in an appropriate case, be a question of fact for the jury.[13]
Can you use deadly force because someone threatened to hurt you later?
Threats of future harm do not amount to imminent danger for self-defense.[7] In People v Guajardo, once the other man had abandoned the fight, retreated to his room and closed the door, the court held he did not pose an imminent threat, and deadly force was not necessary.[7]
What if I was wrong about how dangerous the situation was?
The model instruction says that if the belief was honest and reasonable, the defendant could act immediately even if it later turned out he or she was wrong about how much danger there was.[6] Reasonableness is measured by what an ordinarily prudent and intelligent person would do on the basis of the defendant's perceptions.[14]
Who has to prove that deadly force was or was not justified?
The defendant does not have to prove self-defense. Once there is some evidence of it, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense.[20][22] A person who acts in lawful self-defense is justified and not guilty.[21]
Sources
- MCL 780.972(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.972(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Ogilvie, 341 Mich App 28, 38 (2022) — Michigan Courts
- People v Ogilvie, 341 Mich App 28, 38-41 (2022) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.15(2) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.15(3) — Michigan Courts
- People v Guajardo, 300 Mich App 26, 42-43 (2013) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 7.15(4) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.15(5) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.22(5) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.971–780.974 — Michigan Legislature
- Criminal Proceedings Benchbook, Vol. 1 (Revised Ed.), § 12.12, describing *People v Ogilvie*, 341 Mich App 28, 37, 39, 45 (2022) — Michigan Courts
- People v Ogilvie, 341 Mich App 28, 40 n 9 (2022) — Michigan Courts
- People v Guajardo, 300 Mich App 26, 42 (2013) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 119 (2002) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 780.972(2) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 7.22(3) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.22(4) — Michigan Courts
- People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7, 10-11 (2020), slip op at 3 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.20 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.15(1) — Michigan Courts
- People v Dupree, 486 Mich 693, 709-710, 712 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.