Key points
- Michigan's Self-Defense Act removes the duty to retreat anywhere a person has a legal right to be, but only for someone not engaged in a crime who honestly and reasonably believes force is necessary.[1][2]
- No duty to retreat does not make force automatically justified: deadly force must still be honestly and reasonably believed necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault.[1][3][4]
- Where the Act does not apply, the common law governs, and it still requires retreat in some situations, such as a willing participant in a fight that turns deadly.[5][6]
- Under the common law, a person never has to retreat if attacked in his or her own home, if the attacker is reasonably believed about to use a deadly weapon, or if the attack is sudden, fierce and violent.[7]
- The model instruction letting jurors weigh a failure to retreat safely is given only if there is a dispute about whether the defendant had a duty to retreat.[8]
Michigan's stand-your-ground rule is in the Self-Defense Act. A person who is not engaged in the commission of a crime may use deadly force, "with no duty to retreat," anywhere he or she has the legal right to be, if he or she honestly and reasonably believes the force is necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to himself, herself or another.[1] The rule has conditions, and where they are not met the older common-law rules on retreat still apply.[2][5]
"Michigan is a stand-your-ground state, so there is never a duty to retreat" is a misreading. This page explains what the statute removes, what it leaves in place and who decides how it applies. It does not say whether retreat or force would be appropriate in any situation.
What the statute says
MCL 780.972 sets two no-retreat rules:
- Deadly force. No duty to retreat before using deadly force if the person honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault to himself, herself or another.[1][3]
- Non-deadly force. No duty to retreat before using other force if the person honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to defend himself, herself or another from the imminent unlawful use of force.[9]
The rule applies "anywhere" the person "has the legal right to be," which by its words is not limited to a home.[10] The Act took effect on 1 October 2006 and has not been amended since.[11]
The three conditions
The model jury instruction lists the conditions separately. The person must (a) not have been, and not be, engaged in the commission of a crime when the force is used; (b) have a legal right to be where he or she is; and (c) have the required honest and reasonable belief.[2]
- Not committing a crime. How this condition applies when a person's possession of the gun is itself charged as a crime is covered on self-defense and gun possession charges. The Act does not define "commission of a crime."[12]
- A legal right to be there. In People v Leffew (2022), the Michigan Supreme Court said that kicking down a door and entering a home without permission does not give a person legal rights there for purposes of the Act.[13] The court described the "legal right to be" condition as only a precondition to standing one's ground under the Act.[14]
- An honest and reasonable belief. Reasonableness depends on what an ordinarily prudent and intelligent person would do based on the person's perceptions.[15] Threats of future harm do not amount to imminent danger.[16]
No duty to retreat is not the same as justified
The statute removes a duty to retreat; it does not remove the requirement that the force be honestly and reasonably believed necessary.[1] People v Richardson (2011) shows the difference. The Supreme Court treated a defendant who was on his porch as having no duty to retreat, yet affirmed his assault convictions because the jury could find that deadly force was not necessary.[4] The model instruction also tells jurors that a person may not kill or seriously injure another just to protect against what seems like a threat of only minor injury.[17] What counts as necessary is covered on deadly force and self-defense with a firearm.
When the Act does not apply: the common-law retreat rules
Except for section 2, the Act does not change Michigan's common law on the duty to retreat as it existed on 1 October 2006, and a person who cannot use the Act may still rely on common-law self-defense.[5][18] Under the common law, the necessity element normally requires a person to try to avoid deadly force if he or she can safely and reasonably do so, for example by using non-deadly force or an obvious and safe avenue of retreat.[19] The common law also has its own no-retreat situations:
- A person never has to retreat if attacked in his or her own home, if he or she reasonably believes an attacker is about to use a deadly weapon, or if subjected to a sudden, fierce and violent attack.[7]
- A person attacked in his or her dwelling is never required to retreat where deadly force is otherwise necessary, even after voluntarily joining in mutual combat.[20]
- By statute, where the Act does not apply, a person in his or her own dwelling or within its curtilage has no duty to retreat before using deadly force.[21]
The common law also imposes a duty in some situations. A willing participant in a fight, called a "sudden affray" or "chance medley," must take any reasonable and safe avenue of retreat before using deadly force if the fight escalates into a deadly encounter; willing participants are not barred from self-defense, but must retreat if they safely can.[6] A person who started a non-deadly confrontation and is then met with deadly force may act in self-defense only if he or she retreated where it was safe to do so.[22] Those aggressor rules are covered on initial aggressors in self-defense cases.
How retreat comes up at trial
Where retreat is disputed, jurors are told that force may be used only where necessary, and that if the defendant could have safely retreated but did not, they may consider that in deciding whether he or she honestly and reasonably believed force was needed.[8] The model instruction says that paragraph is given only if there is a dispute about whether the defendant had a duty to retreat.[8]
Two Supreme Court decisions limit how retreat is argued. In People v Riddle (2002), the Court held that where it is uncontested that the defendant was the victim of a sudden and violent attack, the jury should not be instructed to consider whether retreat was safe, reasonable or possible.[23] In People v Adamowicz (2018), as summarized in the state's criminal benchbook, the Court held it was error for the prosecutor to ask the jury to consider a "moral duty" to retreat from the defendant's own dwelling when it was undisputed he had no duty to retreat, and sent the case back to decide whether the errors required relief.[24]
Whether the evidence supports self-defense is for the jury, and the defendant does not have to prove it; the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense.[25][26] See raising self-defense in a gun case.
Retreat rules side by side
| Situation | Retreat rule |
|---|---|
| Not committing a crime, legally present, honest and reasonable belief[1][2] | No duty to retreat under the Act |
| Entered a home by kicking down a door, without permission[13] | No legal right to be there for purposes of the Act |
| Act does not apply, but in own dwelling or its curtilage[21] | No duty to retreat before deadly force |
| Attacker reasonably believed about to use a deadly weapon, or a sudden, fierce and violent attack[7] | Common law never requires retreat |
| Willing participant in a fight that turns deadly, outside the home[6] | Common law requires a reasonable and safe avenue of retreat to be taken |
| Started a non-deadly confrontation, then met with deadly force[22] | Self-defense only if the person retreated where safe |
Stand-your-ground and the castle rules overlap but are different laws. The home-based presumption about a defender's belief is explained on Michigan's castle doctrine, and the overall framework on Michigan self-defense laws for gun owners.
Common questions
Is Michigan a stand-your-ground state?
In part. The Self-Defense Act removes the duty to retreat anywhere a person has the legal right to be, but only if he or she is not engaged in the commission of a crime and honestly and reasonably believes the force is necessary.[1][2] Outside the Act, the common-law retreat rules still apply.[5]
Does stand-your-ground apply in a car or a parking lot in Michigan?
The Act's no-retreat rule applies 'anywhere' the person has the legal right to be, which by its words is not limited to a home.[10] The separate presumption about the defender's belief covers vehicles only when someone is unlawfully trying to remove a person from an occupied vehicle.[10][27] The other conditions still apply in every place.[2]
Can a jury hold it against me that I did not retreat?
Only in some cases. The model instruction allowing jurors to consider a failure to retreat safely is given only if there is a dispute about whether the defendant had a duty to retreat.[8] Where it was undisputed that the defendant was the victim of a sudden and violent attack, the Supreme Court held the jury should not be told to consider retreat.[23]
Do I have to retreat if I agreed to a fight that turned deadly?
Under the common law, a willing participant in a fight must take any reasonable and safe avenue of retreat before using deadly force if the fight escalates into a deadly encounter, though he or she is not barred from self-defense.[6] A person attacked in his or her own dwelling is never required to retreat, even after voluntarily joining in mutual combat.[20]
Sources
- MCL 780.972(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 7.16(3) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.972(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Richardson, 490 Mich 115, 117, 121 (2011) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 780.973 — Michigan Legislature
- People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 120 (2002); People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7 (2020), slip op at 4 — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 7.16(2); People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 119 (2002) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.16(1) and Use Note 1 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.972(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.972(1)-(2); MCL 780.951(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.971 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.971–780.974 — Michigan Legislature
- People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 13 — Michigan Courts
- People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625, 641 (2022), slip op at 12-13 — Michigan Courts
- People v Guajardo, 300 Mich App 26, 42 (2013) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Guajardo, 300 Mich App 26, 42-43 (2013) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 7.15(4) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.974 — Michigan Legislature
- People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 119 (2002) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 120-121 (2002) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 768.21c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 7.16(1) (second alternative) — Michigan Courts
- People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 119-120 (2002) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Adamowicz, 503 Mich 880 (2018) — Michigan Courts
- People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7, 10-11 (2020), slip op at 3 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.20 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.951(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.