SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Self-defense law

Defense of Others With a Firearm in Michigan

Key points

  • Michigan's Self-Defense Act protects force used to defend 'another individual,' not only the person using the force.[1]
  • Deadly force in defense of another requires an honest and reasonable belief that the other person was in danger of being killed, seriously injured or sexually assaulted, and that the action was immediately necessary.[2][3]
  • In People v Leffew (2022), the Supreme Court held that defense of others is not limited to assaultive crimes; whether it applies, including to the home invasion charges in that case, depends on the facts.[4][5]
  • The defendant does not have to prove defense of others; the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in defense of the other person.[6]
  • Defense of others, like self-defense, is generally not available to an initial aggressor.[7]

Michigan law treats force used to protect another person much like force used in self-defense. The Self-Defense Act allows deadly force if a person who is not engaged in a crime honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault to himself, herself or "another individual."[8][9][1] The defense is decided by a jury under model instructions, and the prosecutor bears the burden of disproving it.[6][10]

This page explains the legal standard, the leading Supreme Court decision and who decides. It does not say whether force would be justified in any particular situation.

The statute covers "another individual"

Both subsections of section 2 of the Self-Defense Act protect force used to defend "another individual," not only the person using the force.[1] That means:

  • Deadly force is covered where the person honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent the imminent death of, or imminent great bodily harm to, another individual.[8]
  • Deadly force is also covered where the belief concerns the imminent sexual assault of another individual.[9]
  • Non-deadly force is covered where the person honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to defend another individual from the imminent unlawful use of force.[11]

The same conditions apply as in self-defense: the person must not be engaged in the commission of a crime and must have a legal right to be where he or she is.[12] Those conditions, and the retreat rules that apply when they are not met, are explained on Michigan's stand-your-ground law and Michigan self-defense laws for gun owners.

The jury instruction for deadly force in defense of another

The model criminal jury instruction, M Crim JI 7.21, tells jurors that a person may use force, or even take a life, to defend someone else if he or she honestly and reasonably believed the other person was in danger of being killed, seriously injured or sexually assaulted, and that what he or she did was immediately necessary.[2][3] Its parts:

  • How things appeared at the time. The defendant's conduct is judged by how the circumstances appeared to the defendant when he or she acted.[3]
  • An honest and reasonable belief. If the belief was honest and reasonable, the defendant could act at once to defend the other person, even if it later turned out the defendant was wrong about how much danger the other person was in.[3]
  • Serious danger, not minor injury. Fear of only a minor injury to the other person does not justify killing or seriously injuring the attacker.[2]
  • Factors. Jurors may consider the condition of the people involved, including relative strength; whether the attacker was armed or had other means of injuring the other person; the nature of the attack or threat; and whether the defendant knew about the attacker's previous violent acts or threats.[3]
  • Necessity and amount of force. The defendant must have honestly and reasonably believed the action was immediately necessary and may use only as much force as he or she thinks necessary to protect the other person; jurors may consider other ways the defendant knew of to protect that person, and the excitement of the moment.[3]

For non-deadly force, the defendant must have honestly and reasonably believed force was needed to protect against the imminent unlawful use of force by another; the force must be appropriate to the attack as the defendant saw it, and the right lasts only as long as it seems necessary.[13][14][15] The deadly-force standard is explained in more detail on deadly force and self-defense with a firearm.

People v Leffew (2022)

The Michigan Supreme Court addressed defense of others at length in People v Leffew (2022).[7][4] Its main points:

  • The basic rule. One may use force in defense of another when he or she reasonably believes the other person is in immediate danger of harm and force is necessary to prevent it; deadly force is permitted to repel an attack that reasonably appears deadly.[7]
  • Not limited to assault charges. The defendants were charged with home invasion and testified that they broke into a home to rescue a woman they believed was being held against her will.[5] The Court held that defense of others is not unavailable just because the charge is a non-assaultive crime; whether it applies depends on the facts of each case, not on the charges the prosecution brings.[4]
  • The Act and the common law. Section 2 of the Self-Defense Act removed the common-law duty to retreat for people not committing a crime and lawfully present, but otherwise did not modify or abrogate common-law self-defense or defense of others.[16]
  • Legal right to be there. Kicking down a door and entering a home without permission does not give a person legal rights there for purposes of the Act.[17] The Court described the "legal right to be" condition as only a precondition to standing one's ground under the Act.[16]
  • The result. The defendants were entitled to a new trial because their lawyers failed to request a defense-of-others instruction that the evidence supported.[18][5]

Initial aggressors

As with self-defense, defense of others is generally not available to an initial aggressor.[7] The Supreme Court has defined an initial aggressor as "one who is the first to use deadly force against the other."[19] How the aggressor rules work is covered on initial aggressors in self-defense cases.

Burden of proof and who decides

The defendant does not have to prove defense of others; the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in defense of the other person.[6] To get the instruction, the defendant must produce "some evidence" on the elements of the defense, a burden that "is not a heavy one"; even weak evidence of doubtful credibility requires the instruction.[20] Whether the evidence is sufficient is then for the jury, under proper instructions.[10] The trial steps are on raising self-defense in a gun case.

When someone else fired

A person charged as an aider and abettor is relieved of liability if the person who actually used the force acted in self-defense.[21] In People v Rajput (2020), the Supreme Court said a defendant who says someone else did the shooting in self-defense may still be entitled to a self-defense instruction.[21]

Civil immunity and the home presumption

A person who uses deadly or non-deadly force in defense of another in compliance with section 2 of the Self-Defense Act is immune from civil liability for damages to the person against whom the force was authorized.[22] The castle presumption in MCL 780.951 also extends to a belief that imminent death, sexual assault or great bodily harm would occur to "another," when its triggering conditions are met.[23] That presumption, including its exception for some domestic relationships, is covered on Michigan's castle doctrine.

Defending a family or household member raises its own issues, covered in the domestic violence guide's page on defense of others and property. Protecting property, rather than a person, falls under different rules, covered on guns and defense of property.

Common questions

Can you use a gun to defend someone else in Michigan?

The Self-Defense Act covers force used to defend another person in the same provisions that cover self-defense. It allows deadly force by a person not engaged in a crime who honestly and reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault to 'another individual.'[8][1] Whether the standard was met in a particular case is for the jury.[10]

Does the person I defended have to be a family member?

No. The Self-Defense Act protects force used to defend 'another individual,' and the model jury instruction speaks of the right to defend 'someone else' without limiting who that person is.[1][2] The instruction leaves a blank for the name of the person defended, and asks whether the defendant honestly and reasonably believed that person was in danger of being killed, seriously injured or sexually assaulted.[3]

What if I was wrong about the danger to the other person?

The model instruction says that if the defendant honestly and reasonably believed the other person was in danger of being killed, seriously injured or sexually assaulted, the defendant could act at once to defend that person, even if it later turned out the defendant was wrong about how much danger the other person was in.[3]

Can defense of others be a defense to breaking into a house?

It can be raised. In People v Leffew, the defendants were charged with home invasion after testifying that they broke into a home to rescue a woman they believed was being held against her will.[5] The Supreme Court held that defense of others is not unavailable just because the charge is a non-assaultive crime; whether it applies depends on the facts of each case, not on the charges the prosecution brings.[4] The Court also said kicking down a door and entering without permission gives no legal rights there, and treated the Act's legal-right-to-be-there condition as only a precondition to its no-retreat rule.[17][16]

Sources

  1. MCL 780.972(1)(a)-(b), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  2. M Crim JI 7.21(1)-(5) — Michigan Courts
  3. M Crim JI 7.21(2)–(5) — Michigan Courts
  4. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 14 — Michigan Courts
  5. Criminal Proceedings Benchbook, Vol. 1 (Revised Ed.), § 12.12, p 12-107, describing *People v Leffew*, 508 Mich 625, 644-645 (2022) — Michigan Courts
  6. M Crim JI 7.21(6) — Michigan Courts
  7. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 10 — Michigan Courts
  8. MCL 780.972(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 780.972(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  10. People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7, 10-11 (2020), slip op at 3 — Michigan Courts
  11. MCL 780.972(2) — Michigan Legislature
  12. M Crim JI 7.16(3) — Michigan Courts
  13. M Crim JI 7.22(3) — Michigan Courts
  14. M Crim JI 7.22(4) — Michigan Courts
  15. M Crim JI 7.22(5) — Michigan Courts
  16. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625, 641 (2022), slip op at 12-13 — Michigan Courts
  17. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 13 — Michigan Courts
  18. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022) — Michigan Courts
  19. People v Riddle, 467 Mich 116, 120 n 8 (2002); People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7 (2020), slip op at 4 — Caselaw Access Project
  20. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 15 — Michigan Courts
  21. People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7 (2020), slip op at 4 — Michigan Courts
  22. MCL 600.2922b(a) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 780.951(1) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.