SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Sentencing

Sentencing Guidelines in Michigan Weapons Cases: Offense Classes, OV 1 and OV 2

Key points

  • The guidelines recommend a range for the minimum sentence, found from offense variables, prior record variables and the grid for the offense's class.[1]
  • Since People v Lockridge (2015) the range is advisory, but the judge must calculate it, take it into account and justify the sentence.[2]
  • Carrying a concealed weapon, felon in possession and carrying with unlawful intent are Class E public-safety felonies with a 5-year maximum.[3]
  • OV 1 (aggravated use of a weapon) is scored for every crime group; OV 2 (lethal potential) is not scored for public-safety crimes such as carrying concealed.[4][5]
  • The statute says an intermediate sanction "shall" follow when the top of the range is 18 months or less, but since Lockridge courts have held that the judge may, and is no longer required to, impose one.[6][7]

Michigan's sentencing guidelines produce a recommended range for the minimum prison sentence in a felony case, based on offense variables, prior record variables and the grid for the offense's class.[1] Since People v Lockridge (2015) the guidelines are advisory: the judge must calculate the range and take it into account, and must justify the sentence, but is not bound by the range.[2] Several common weapons-possession felonies, including carrying a concealed weapon and felon in possession, are Class E public-safety felonies with a 5-year maximum.[3] This page explains how the scoring works. It does not predict any sentence.

Minimum and maximum: how a Michigan felony sentence is built

When a person is convicted for the first time of a felony punishable by state prison, the judge does not set a single fixed term unless the sentencing chapter provides otherwise. The court fixes a minimum term, and the maximum is the maximum penalty provided by law, which the judge states at sentencing.[8] The guidelines deal with the minimum: it may be within the range under the version of the guidelines in effect on the date of the crime.[9] No minimum sentence, including a departure, may exceed two-thirds of the statutory maximum.[10] For a 5-year felony such as carrying a concealed weapon, that cap works out to 40 months.[10][3]

Felony firearm sits outside this system: for a crime with a mandatory determinate penalty, the court imposes that penalty, and the guidelines section does not apply.[11] Its terms are fixed at 2, 5 and 10 years.[12] See the felony firearm sentencing page.

Offense classes for common weapons felonies

The guidelines assign each listed felony a crime group and a class, and the class decides which grid is used.[1] The table shows the groups, classes and statutory maximums the guidelines list for weapons-related felonies.

OffenseMCLGroup and classStatutory maximum
Carrying a concealed weapon750.227Public safety, E5 years[3]
Felon in possession of a firearm750.224f(6)Public safety, E5 years[3]
Carrying a firearm or dangerous weapon with unlawful intent750.226Public safety, E5 years[3]
Short-barreled shotgun or rifle750.224bPublic safety, E5 years[3]
Silencers, automatic weapons and similar items750.224Public safety, E5 years[3]
Using a firearm while impaired, causing serious impairment750.237(3)Person, E5 years[3]
Unlawful possession of a pistol by a licensee750.227aPublic safety, F4 years[3]
Armor-piercing ammunition; semiautomatic conversion devices750.224c; 750.224ePublic safety, F4 years[3]
Shooting at an emergency or police vehicle750.234cPublic safety, F4 years[3]
Felonious assault750.82(1)Person, F4 years[13]
False statement on a CPL application; third pistol-free-zone violation28.425b(3); 28.425o(6)(c)Public safety, F4 years[14]
Loaded firearm in or upon a vehicle750.227cPublic safety, G2 years[3]
Altering the identification mark on a firearm750.230Public safety, G2 years[3]
False statement in a firearm application750.232a(3)Public safety, G4 years[3]
Shooting from a vehicle750.234a(1)(a)Public safety, D10 years[3]
Shooting at or in a dwelling or potentially occupied structure750.234b(1), (2)Public safety, D10 years[3]
Selling a firearm to a person prohibited from possessing one750.223(3)Public order, D10 years[3]
Assault with intent to do great bodily harm750.84(1)(a)Person, D10 years[13]
Shooting from a vehicle causing injury, serious impairment or death750.234a(1)Person, C, B or A15 years, 20 years or life[3]

Every weapons offense, scored or not, appears on the penalties chart.

How the recommended range is found

  1. Find the offense's category (crime group) and class in the guidelines' offense list.[1]
  2. Score only the offense variables listed for that crime group and add the points to get the offense variable level.[1][4]
  3. Score all the prior record variables and add the points to get the prior record level.[1]
  4. Read the recommended minimum range, shown in months or as life, where the two levels meet on the grid for the offense's class.[1]
  5. For a habitual offender, raise the top of that range by 25% for a second felony, 50% for a third, or 100% for a fourth or later.[15]

Offense variable 1: aggravated use of a weapon

OV 1 is on the list for every crime group, including public safety.[4] Its main point levels are:

What happenedOV 1 points
A firearm was discharged at or toward a human being, or a victim was cut or stabbed25[16]
A firearm was pointed at or toward a victim15[16]
The victim was touched by any other type of weapon10[16]
A weapon was displayed or implied5[16]

Every person placed in danger of injury or loss of life counts as a victim, and in a case with several offenders, if one is scored for a weapon, all receive the same points.[17] Five points are scored if an object was used to suggest a weapon or if a chemical irritant or imitation harmful device was used, but 5 points are not scored when the conviction is felonious assault or armed robbery.[18]

Offense variable 2: lethal potential of the weapon

OV 2 is "lethal potential of the weapon possessed or used."[5] It is scored by the type of weapon: 15 points for an incendiary device, an explosive device or a fully automatic weapon; 10 points for a short-barreled rifle or shotgun; and 5 points for a pistol, rifle, shotgun, or knife or other cutting or stabbing weapon.[5]

A common assumption is that a gun always adds OV 2 points. The statute says otherwise. OV 2 is scored for crimes against a person, crimes against property and controlled-substance crimes, but not for crimes against public safety or public order.[4] Carrying a concealed weapon and felon in possession are public-safety felonies, so OV 2 is not on their list, while felonious assault is a crime against a person, so it is.[3][13][4]

What the grids look like

Each class has its own grid. The ranges below run from the lowest offense and prior record levels to the highest, in months, before any habitual increase.

ClassLowest cellHighest cell
D0–6 months43–76 months[19]
E0–3 months24–38 months[20]
F0–3 months17–30 months[19]
G0–3 months7–23 months[19]

Where the range falls decides the kind of sentence

  • If the top of the range is 18 months or less, the statute says the court "shall impose an intermediate sanction" unless it states on the record reasonable grounds for county jail of up to 12 months or a prison sentence over 12 months.[6] Since Lockridge, however, the Court of Appeals has held in People v Schrauben (2016) that the court may, but is no longer required to, impose an intermediate sanction in that situation, and a prison sentence within the range is within the range authorized by law.[7]
  • An "intermediate sanction" means probation or another lawful sanction other than jail or prison, such as drug treatment or residential probation.[21]
  • If the top of the range is over 18 months and the bottom is 12 months or less, the statute lists two choices absent a departure: prison with a minimum within the range, or an intermediate sanction with or without up to 12 months in jail.[22]

Probation terms, conditions and violations are covered on the probation page.

Departures from the range

A judge may depart from the range if the departure is reasonable and the court states the reasons on the record.[23] When the sentence is outside the range, the court must articulate the reasons justifying that specific departure.[24] A judge may not use a person's gender, race, ethnicity, alienage, national origin, legal occupation, lack of employment, type of lawyer, self-representation or religion to depart, and may not rely on a factor the range already counts unless the record shows it was given inadequate or disproportionate weight.[25] Imposing a mandatory minimum sentence is not a departure.[9]

Habitual offenders

For a habitual offender, the guidelines are scored on the underlying offense, and the top of the range is increased by 25%, 50% or 100% depending on the number of prior felonies.[15] The habitual offender page explains the higher maximums and the 25-year minimum.

At sentencing: the presentence report and the scoring

In felony cases the court must use the sentencing guidelines, and proposed scoring must accompany the presentence report; the prosecutor and the defense must get the report at least two business days before sentencing, and a side that did not get it in time is entitled, on oral motion, to an adjournment.[26] At sentencing the court must give each side a chance to challenge the accuracy or relevance of information in the report, let the defendant speak, and state the minimum and maximum sentence with any jail credit.[24] The steps from charge to sentencing are on the court process page, and plea-based sentence agreements are covered on the plea agreements page.

A practical point: the presentence report and the scoring worksheet are worth reading line by line with defense counsel before the hearing, comparing each scored variable with the facts in the record. Other resource guides cover scoring in related cases: domestic violence felonies and drug felonies.

Common questions

Are Michigan's sentencing guidelines mandatory?

No. Since People v Lockridge (2015) they are advisory, but the judge must still calculate the range, take it into account and justify the sentence imposed.[2] A judge may depart if the departure is reasonable and the reasons are stated on the record.[23] No minimum sentence, including a departure, may exceed two-thirds of the statutory maximum.[10]

What is the guidelines range for carrying a concealed weapon in Michigan?

Carrying a concealed weapon is a Class E public-safety felony with a 5-year maximum.[3] The Class E grid runs from 0 to 3 months at the lowest offense and prior record levels to 24 to 38 months at the highest, before any habitual-offender increase.[20] Where a particular case falls depends on how the variables are scored, which this page cannot predict.

Is OV 2 scored for a felon-in-possession charge?

Felon in possession is listed as a public-safety felony.[3] For crimes against public safety the statute lists offense variables 1, 3, 4, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 16, 19 and 20, so OV 2 is not on that list.[4] OV 2 is scored for crimes against a person, crimes against property and controlled-substance crimes.[4]

Can a judge sentence above the guidelines range in a gun case?

Yes, if the departure is reasonable and the judge states the reasons on the record.[23] At felony sentencing the court must articulate the reasons justifying a sentence outside the range.[24] The statute bars departures based on factors such as race, religion, lack of employment or the type of lawyer, and no minimum may exceed two-thirds of the maximum.[25][10]

Does felony firearm count in the guidelines?

Felony firearm has a mandatory determinate penalty, so the court imposes that penalty and the guidelines section does not apply to it.[11] When the guidelines are scored for the other felony, the prior record variable for concurrent convictions says not to score a felony firearm conviction.[27]

Sources

  1. MCL 777.21(1) — Michigan Legislature
  2. People v Lockridge, 498 Mich 358, 365, 392, 399 (2015) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCL 777.16m — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 777.22(1)–(5) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 777.32(1) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 769.34(4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  7. People v Lockridge, 498 Mich 358, 365 n 1 (2015); People v Schrauben, 314 Mich App 181, 194-196 (2016), overruled in part on other grounds by People v Posey, 512 Mich 317, 326 (2023); CRIMBB vol 2 §1.8 — Michigan Courts
  8. MCL 769.8(1) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 769.34(2), (2)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 769.34(2)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 769.34(5); MCL 777.16m — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 750.227b(1) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 777.16d — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 777.11b — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 777.21(3) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 777.31(1) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCL 777.31(2) — Michigan Legislature
  18. MCL 777.31(2)(c)–(e) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 777.65; MCL 777.67; MCL 777.68 — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 777.66 — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 769.31(b) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 769.34(4)(c) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 769.34(3) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCR 6.425(D)(1)(b)–(e) — Michigan Courts
  25. MCL 769.34(3)(a)–(b) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCR 6.425(B), (C) — Michigan Courts
  27. MCL 777.57(2)(b) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.