SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process in weapons cases

Raising Self-Defense in a Michigan Gun Case: Burden of Proof and Jury Instructions

Key points

  • The defendant does not have to prove self-defense; once there is some evidence of it, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense.[1][2]
  • The burden of producing some evidence 'is not a heavy one,' and even weak evidence of doubtful credibility requires the instruction.[3]
  • Jury instructions cannot exclude self-defense if there is evidence to support it, and whether that evidence is enough is for the jury to decide.[4]
  • A prosecutor who believes a use of force was unjustified under the Self-Defense Act may charge the person, but must present evidence that the force was not justified at warrant issuance, at any preliminary examination and at any trial.[5]
  • In People v Leffew the Supreme Court ordered a new trial because defense lawyers did not request a defense-of-others instruction, and in People v Kilgore the Court of Appeals vacated a felony-firearm conviction because counsel did not request self-defense instructions to which the defendant was entitled.[6][7]

In a Michigan gun case, self-defense is raised by putting some evidence of it before the court, and the prosecutor then has to disprove it. The model jury instruction says: "The defendant does not have to prove that [he / she] acted in self-defense. Instead, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense."[1] The Michigan Supreme Court has reaffirmed that once the defendant meets the initial burden of production, the prosecution bears the burden of disproving self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt.[2] This page covers those procedural rules: who must show what, when the jury is instructed, and what evidence can come in. The substantive law of when force is justified is on the self-defense laws page and the deadly force page. This guide describes the law; it is not a statement that any particular use of force was or would be lawful.

Two different burdens

BurdenWho carries itWhat it requires
Burden of productionThe defendant"Some evidence" on the elements of the defense; the burden "is not a heavy one"[3]
Burden of proofThe prosecutorProof beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense[1][2]

In People v Leffew (2022), the Supreme Court said a defendant who puts forward some evidence supporting an affirmative-defense theory is entitled to an instruction on it, and that "even when the supporting evidence is weak or of doubtful credibility its presence requires an instruction on the theory of defense."[3]

Before trial: the prosecutor's evidence duty

Michigan has a separate statute, MCL 780.961, about charging decisions in self-defense cases. A person who uses force in compliance with section 2 of the Self-Defense Act, and who was not engaged in the commission of a crime at the time, "commits no crime" in using it.[8] If a prosecutor believes the force was unjustified, the prosecutor may still charge the person, but "shall present evidence" establishing that the person's actions were not justified to the judge or magistrate at warrant issuance, at any preliminary examination and at any trial.[5]

No Michigan statute, court rule or court decision read for this guide creates or describes a separate pretrial hearing on immunity from prosecution for self-defense; what MCL 780.961(2) requires is evidence from the prosecutor at the warrant, preliminary examination and trial stages.[5] The court process page explains those stages.

Getting the jury instruction

The burden-of-proof instruction "should be given where there is some evidence of self-defense," and if there is no evidence of self-defense, "no instructions on self-defense should be given."[9] When there is evidence, the Supreme Court said in People v Rajput (2020) that its sufficiency is "for the jury to decide under proper instructions," and the instructions "cannot exclude the theory of self-defense" if there is evidence to support it.[4]

The judge's role at this point is limited. As summarized in the Criminal Proceedings Benchbook, the Court of Appeals held in People v Allen (2025) that a trial court "usurped the role of the jury" by deciding the defendant was not credible and lacked an honest and reasonable belief, because "it was for the jury to decide whether his version of events was more believable."[10] The full opinion was not read for this guide.

Failing to ask for a supported instruction can matter on appeal. In Leffew, the Supreme Court held the defendants were entitled to a new trial because their lawyers failed to request a defense-of-others instruction.[6] In People v Kilgore (2024), defense counsel did not ask for self-defense and defense-of-others instructions on a felony-firearm charge even though the defendant was entitled to them; given that there was no strategic reason for the omission and that the jury had acquitted on the murder charges but convicted on felony firearm predicated on murder, the Court of Appeals found a reasonable probability of a different result on that count and vacated the felony-firearm conviction and sentence.[7]

Self-defense and the weapons charges

A gun case can include possession charges alongside an assault or homicide charge, and the instructions differ by charge.[11][12]

  • Felony firearm: People v Goree held the trial court erred by telling the jury that self-defense does not apply to a felony-firearm charge, and M Crim JI 11.34c now covers it.[11][13]
  • Felon in possession: People v Dupree held self-defense may be raised to this charge, and the model instruction must be read together with the self-defense burden-of-proof instruction.[14][15]
  • Brandishing: a 2024 model instruction says a person who brandishes a firearm in lawful self-defense or defense of others is not guilty of brandishing.[16]
  • Carrying a concealed weapon: the model instruction says self-defense is not a defense to that charge, while People v Triplett allowed it where the concealed item is a dangerous weapon only because it was used as one.[12][17]

Defense of others can also apply to charges that are not assaultive crimes; the Supreme Court said in Leffew that its applicability "must be determined on the particular facts of each case, not the charges the prosecution brings."[18] The self-defense and possession charges page covers these rules in detail.

The intruder presumption at trial

Where the statutory presumption for break-ins and home invasions applies, the model instruction tells the jury it is presumed the defendant had an honest and reasonable belief that imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault would occur, and the prosecutor can overcome that presumption only by proof beyond a reasonable doubt.[19] Losing the presumption does not by itself end a self-defense claim; the Act states it does not diminish the common-law right of self-defense as it existed on October 1, 2006.[20] See the castle doctrine page.

Evidence about the other person

If there is evidence that the complainant or decedent committed violent acts in the past that the defendant knew about, the jury may consider it in deciding whether the defendant honestly and reasonably feared for his or her safety.[21] Evidence of a reputation for cruelty or violence may be considered on whether a threat was likely and whether the fear was honest and reasonable.[21]

Rules about who started a confrontation are covered on the initial aggressor page. A separate evidence rule applies in homicide cases. Under MRE 404(a)(2)(B), when self-defense is an issue, the defendant may offer evidence of the alleged victim's trait for aggression, and if it is admitted, the prosecution may answer with evidence of the defendant's same trait and of the alleged victim's peacefulness to rebut first-aggressor evidence.[22] The rule's text is limited to homicide cases.[22]

Closing arguments

As summarized in the benchbook, the Court of Appeals in People v Bacall (2025) called it misconduct for a prosecutor to tell the jury, falsely, that the defendant never claimed self-defense before trial, and said a mention of the defendant's excluded concealed-carry permit "could seriously damage a jury's willingness to believe the permit holder's claim of self-defense."[23] The outcome of that case was not read for this guide.

Common misunderstandings

  • "The defendant has to prove self-defense." The prosecutor must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt once there is some evidence.[1][2]
  • "The judge decides whether the defendant's story is believable before the jury hears self-defense." Weak evidence of doubtful credibility still requires the instruction.[3]
  • "A CPL gives a person stronger self-defense rights in court." The self-defense statutes speak of "an individual" and do not mention a license.[24]

The defenses page places self-defense alongside the other defenses to weapons charges, and the domestic violence guide's page on self-defense law covers the same rules in that setting.

Common questions

Do I have to prove I acted in self-defense in Michigan?

No. The model instruction tells jurors that the defendant does not have to prove self-defense and that the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense. The defendant only has to produce some evidence of the defense, a burden the Supreme Court has called not a heavy one.[1][3]

Can the judge refuse to give a self-defense instruction?

If there is no evidence of self-defense, no self-defense instructions should be given. If there is some evidence, instructions cannot exclude the theory, and even weak evidence of doubtful credibility requires the instruction. As summarized in the benchbook, People v Allen (2025) held a trial court usurped the jury's role by deciding the defendant was not credible.[9][4][3][10]

Does Michigan have a stand-your-ground immunity hearing before trial?

No source read for this guide describes one. MCL 780.961(2) allows a prosecutor to charge a person whose force the prosecutor believes was unjustified, but requires the prosecutor to present evidence that the force was not justified at warrant issuance, at any preliminary examination and at trial.[5]

Can self-defense be raised to a felony-firearm or felon-in-possession charge?

Yes. The Court of Appeals held in People v Goree that it was error to tell the jury self-defense does not apply to felony firearm, and the Supreme Court held in People v Dupree that self-defense may be raised to felon in possession. Model instructions exist for both charges.[11][14][13][15]

What happens if my lawyer does not ask for a self-defense instruction?

Courts have addressed this as ineffective assistance of counsel. In People v Leffew, the Supreme Court held the defendants were entitled to a new trial because their lawyers failed to request a defense-of-others instruction. In People v Kilgore (2024), the Court of Appeals vacated a felony-firearm conviction where counsel did not ask for self-defense and defense-of-others instructions on that charge, finding no strategic reason for the omission and noting the jury's inconsistent verdicts.[6][7]

Sources

  1. M Crim JI 7.20 — Michigan Courts
  2. People v Dupree, 486 Mich 693, 709-710, 712 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
  3. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 15 — Michigan Courts
  4. People v Rajput, 505 Mich 7, 10-11 (2020), slip op at 3 — Michigan Courts
  5. MCL 780.961(2) — Michigan Legislature
  6. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022) — Michigan Courts
  7. People v Kilgore, ___ Mich App ___ (2024) (Docket No. 365881), slip op at 1, 5 — Michigan Courts
  8. MCL 780.961(1) — Michigan Legislature
  9. M Crim JI 7.20, Use Note — Michigan Courts
  10. People v Allen, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
  11. People v Goree, 296 Mich App 293, 294, 302 (2012) — Caselaw Access Project
  12. M Crim JI 11.8 and Reference Guide — Michigan Courts
  13. M Crim JI 11.34c — Michigan Courts
  14. People v Dupree, 486 Mich 693, 696-697, 708-709 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
  15. M Crim JI 7.25(1)-(5) and Use Note — Michigan Courts
  16. M Crim JI 7.25a — Michigan Courts
  17. People v Triplett, 499 Mich 52, 53 (2016) — Caselaw Access Project
  18. People v Leffew, 508 Mich 625 (2022), slip op at 14 — Michigan Courts
  19. M Crim JI 7.16a(1) — Michigan Courts
  20. MCL 780.951(2); MCL 780.974 — Michigan Legislature
  21. M Crim JI 7.23(1)-(2) — Michigan Courts
  22. MRE 404(a)(2)(B) — Michigan Courts
  23. People v Bacall, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
  24. MCL 780.972; MCL 780.951; MCL 600.2922b — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.