Key points
- The prosecutor must prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt, and the main carrying and possession charges require knowledge, such as knowing that a pistol was being carried or knowingly possessing a firearm.[1][2][3][4]
- Under MCL 776.20 the burden of establishing a license or other statutory exception is on the defendant, but this does not shift the burden of proof for the violation; once the court finds some evidence of a license was admitted, the jury is told the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there was no license or that its restrictions were violated.[5][6]
- Self-defense can be raised to felony firearm and felon in possession; for carrying a concealed weapon, the model instruction says it is not a defense, with an exception the Supreme Court recognized in People v Triplett.[7][8][9][10]
- For carrying a concealed pistol and for felony firearm, the jury instructions say it does not matter whether the gun could fire or was loaded; for felon in possession, the prosecutor need not prove the firearm was operable.[11][12][13]
- The weapons charges discussed here are not among the crimes the limitations statute lists separately, so they fall under its catch-all rule of 6 years after the offense, not counting time the person did not usually and publicly reside in Michigan.[14][15]
Defenses to Michigan weapons charges fall into a few groups. The first is that the prosecutor cannot prove an element, such as knowledge of the gun or a specific intent, beyond a reasonable doubt.[1][2][16] The second is that a license or statutory exception applies; the burden of establishing it is on the defendant, but the burden of proof for the violation does not shift.[5] The third is a justification such as self-defense, which Michigan courts have recognized for some weapons charges and limited for others.[7][8][9][10] This page explains each group and the rules that are not defenses, such as an unloaded gun. Whether any defense fits a particular case depends on the evidence, and nothing here predicts how a judge or jury would decide.
Missing elements: knowledge, possession and intent
Each weapons charge has its own elements in the model jury instructions. The table lists, for several charges, an element that can be contested.
| Charge | Element at issue |
|---|---|
| Carrying a concealed pistol on the person | The defendant must have known he or she was carrying a pistol; why it was carried does not matter[1] |
| Carrying concealed: what "concealed" means | Complete invisibility is not required; a pistol is concealed if it cannot easily be seen by those in ordinary contact with the defendant[17] |
| Pistol in a vehicle | The defendant knew the pistol was in the vehicle and took part in carrying or keeping it there[18] |
| Felony firearm | The defendant knowingly carried or possessed a firearm while committing or attempting a felony[3] |
| Felon in possession | The defendant knowingly possessed a firearm or ammunition in Michigan[4] |
| Prohibited weapons such as silencers | The defendant knew at the time that the item was a weapon[19] |
| Going armed with unlawful intent | A specific intent to use the weapon unlawfully against someone else[16] |
| Brandishing in public | A specific intent to make another person fearful[20] |
| Pointing or aimed discharge without malice | An intent to point the gun at or toward another person[21] |
For felony firearm, possession does not require holding the gun and can be shared: a person possesses a firearm if he or she has actual physical control of it or knows where it is and has reasonable access to it, and possession "may be joint."[22] The page on guns found in cars and homes explains possession in detail.
Licenses and statutory exceptions
Michigan's weapons statutes contain exceptions, and a special rule decides who must raise them. Under MCL 776.20, "the burden of establishing any exception, excuse, proviso or exemption" is on the defendant, "but this does not shift the burden of proof for the violation."[5] Once the court finds some evidence of a license was admitted, the jury is told the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not have a license or carried in violation of its restrictions.[5][6]
- CPL: a CPL authorizes the licensee to carry a concealed pistol anywhere in Michigan, subject to the pistol-free zones and other limits.[23] A licensee still commits the carrying offense by carrying "in a place or manner inconsistent with any restrictions upon such license."[24]
- Home, business or own land: the carrying-concealed law does not apply in the person's home, place of business or other land the person possesses, and the prosecutor must prove the weapon was carried outside those places once some evidence of the exemption is admitted.[25]
- Out-of-state license: the pistol part of the statute does not apply to a person holding a valid concealed-pistol license from his or her state of residence, except where the pistol is carried contrary to a restriction on that license.[26]
- Lawful-purpose transport: the law does not apply to a person transporting a pistol for a lawful purpose if the pistol is licensed (registered) to the vehicle's owner or an occupant and is unloaded in a closed case designed for storing firearms in the trunk, or, in a vehicle without a trunk, not readily accessible to the occupants.[27][28] When this exception is in issue, the jury is told the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was not carrying the pistol for a lawful purpose.[29]
- Exempt persons: several weapons statutes, including the carrying-concealed law, do not apply to regularly employed and paid peace officers and other listed groups such as on-duty members of the armed forces.[30]
The carrying concealed page and the transport page cover these exceptions in more depth.
Felon in possession: restored rights and set-aside convictions
For felon in possession, the waiting-period element is given to the jury only when the defendant offers some evidence that the waiting period had passed; for a specified felony, the elements that less than five years had passed and that rights were not restored are given only when the defendant offers some evidence of both.[31] The statute does not apply to a conviction that has been expunged, set aside or pardoned, unless the order or pardon expressly says the person may not possess a firearm or ammunition.[32] See the pages on felon in possession and restoring gun rights.
Self-defense and weapons charges
Michigan courts treat self-defense differently depending on the weapons charge.
- Felony firearm: in People v Goree, the Court of Appeals held the trial court erred by telling the jury that self-defense does not apply to a felony-firearm charge.[7] A model instruction, M Crim JI 11.34c, now addresses self-defense to felony firearm.[33]
- Felon in possession: in People v Dupree, the Supreme Court held that the common-law defense of self-defense may be raised to a charge of being a felon in possession.[8] The model instruction says a person is justified in possessing a firearm only when necessary at the time to protect against danger of death or serious injury.[34]
- Brandishing: the brandishing statute does not apply to a person lawfully acting in self-defense or defense of another under the Self-Defense Act.[35]
- Carrying a concealed weapon: M Crim JI 11.8 tells jurors it does not matter that the defendant carried the weapon for protection and that "Self-defense is not a defense to this charge."[9] In People v Triplett, the Supreme Court held self-defense is available to a defendant charged with carrying concealed an instrument that is a dangerous weapon only because it is used as one.[10]
How self-defense is raised at trial is covered on the self-defense burden page, and the possession charges are discussed on the self-defense and possession charges page.
What is not a defense
- The gun was unloaded or did not work. For carrying a concealed pistol, the instruction says it does not matter whether the pistol could fire or was loaded,[11] and the felony-firearm instruction has a paragraph saying the same about the firearm.[12] For felon in possession, the instructions say the prosecutor need not prove the firearm was operable.[13]
- Someone else owned it. The felony-firearm instruction says possession "does not necessarily mean ownership."[22]
- The reason for carrying a pistol. For carrying a concealed pistol, the instruction says it does not matter why the defendant was carrying it.[1]
- Acquittal of the underlying felony. As the Criminal Proceedings Benchbook summarizes People v Powell, a jury may convict of felony firearm even while acquitting of the underlying felony.[36]
Time limits
Michigan's limitations statute, MCL 767.24, lists certain crimes separately, such as murder (no limit) and armed robbery or assault with intent to commit murder (10 years). The weapons charges discussed on this page are not among them, so they fall under the catch-all provision: they "may be found and filed within 6 years after the offense is committed."[14] Any period during which the person charged did not usually and publicly reside in Michigan is not counted.[15]
Evidence and search issues
Michigan's firearms chapter has its own search-warrant section: on a complaint that a pistol or other weapon is unlawfully possessed or carried, a magistrate satisfied that there is reasonable cause to believe the complaint must issue a warrant to search the described person or place and seize the weapon as evidence.[37] Whether a gun or a statement can be used as evidence depends on the rules about stops, searches and questioning, which this guide does not cover. The drug crimes guide's page on motions to suppress explains how those challenges are raised in Michigan courts.
Practical points
- Ask the defense lawyer which elements of each count are contested and which exceptions might apply.
- Gather documents that bear on an exception, such as a CPL, an out-of-state license, a set-aside order or a restoration of rights; the defendant bears the burden of establishing an exception, although this does not shift the burden of proof.[5]
- Keep a list of witnesses and records that relate to where the gun was and who had access to it.
The plea agreements page covers the other path a case can take.
Common questions
Is not knowing the gun was there a defense in Michigan?
Knowledge is an element of the main carrying and possession charges. For carrying a concealed pistol, the defendant must have known he or she was carrying it, and for a pistol in a vehicle, the defendant must have known it was there. If the jury is not convinced of that beyond a reasonable doubt, the model instruction tells it to acquit.[1][18][2]
Is having a CPL a complete defense to a carrying charge?
A CPL authorizes carrying a concealed pistol anywhere in Michigan, subject to the pistol-free zones and other limits, but a licensee still commits the offense by carrying in a place or manner inconsistent with a restriction on the license. The defendant must raise the license, and then the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there was no license or that a restriction was violated.[23][24][5][6]
Can I claim I carried the gun for protection?
The model instruction for carrying a concealed weapon says it does not matter that the defendant carried the weapon for protection and that self-defense is not a defense to that charge. In People v Triplett, the Supreme Court held self-defense is available where the concealed item is a dangerous weapon only because it was used as one.[9][10]
Is it a defense that the gun wasn't loaded?
Not for carrying a concealed pistol or felony firearm: the jury instructions for both say it does not matter whether the gun could fire or was loaded. For felon in possession, the instructions say only that the prosecutor need not prove the firearm was operable. The former defense instruction on inoperable firearms was deleted in January 2017 as an incorrect statement of the law.[11][12][13]
How long does the prosecutor have to file a weapons charge?
The limitations statute does not list carrying-concealed, felony-firearm, felon-in-possession or the other weapons charges on this page separately, so they fall under its catch-all rule: they may be filed within 6 years after the offense. Listed crimes such as armed robbery and assault with intent to commit murder have a 10-year period. Any period during which the person charged did not usually and publicly reside in Michigan does not count toward that time.[14][15]
Sources
- M Crim JI 11.1 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.7 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.34 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.38, Use Note 1 and History — Michigan Courts
- MCL 776.20; M Crim JI 11.10, 11.11; People v Henderson, 391 Mich 612 (1974) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 11.10 and Use Note — Michigan Courts
- People v Goree, 296 Mich App 293, 294, 302 (2012) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Dupree, 486 Mich 693, 696-697, 708-709 (2010) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 11.8 and Reference Guide — Michigan Courts
- People v Triplett, 499 Mich 52, 53 (2016) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 11.3(3), 11.34 n 3; People v Peals, 476 Mich 636 (2006) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.34(6) and n 3 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.38 n 3; M Crim JI 11.38a n 3; M Crim JI 11.6 [DELETED] — Michigan Courts
- MCL 767.24(10) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 767.24(11) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 11.17, 11.19 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.1(3), 11.2(3) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.1a — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.29, 11.30 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.25a — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.23, 11.24, 11.25 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 11.34b — Michigan Courts
- MCL 28.425c(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.227(2) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 11.11 and Use Note; MCL 750.227(1) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.231a(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.231a(1)(d) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.231a(1)(e) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 11.14; MCL 750.231a(1)(d)-(e) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.231(1)(a)-(h), (2) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 11.38(4); M Crim JI 11.38a(4)-(5) and Use Note 6 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.224f(9) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 11.34c — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 7.25(1)-(5) and Use Note — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.234e(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Powell, 303 Mich App 271, 274 (2013) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.238 — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.