SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Self-defense law

Guns and Defense of Property: What Michigan Law Says

Key points

  • Section 2 of Michigan's Self-Defense Act authorizes force only against threats to people: imminent death, great bodily harm, sexual assault or the imminent unlawful use of force. It has no provision for protecting property as such.[1]
  • In Pond v People (1860) the Michigan Supreme Court said there is no justification for homicide to stop a felony that is not violent or forcible, such as picking pockets.[2]
  • The model instruction on "Use of Deadly Force in Defense of the Home" covers deadly force against someone forcibly entering a home intending to steal or to harm someone, but its committee says there is "a substantial question" whether that defense survives the 2006 statutes.[3][4][5]
  • For vehicles, the castle-doctrine presumption applies only to an unlawful attempt to remove someone from an occupied vehicle; its list of triggers does not mention stealing or breaking into a car.[6]
  • Setting a spring gun, or any trap or device that fires a gun or explosive, and leaving it without a competent person present is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 1 year in county jail, and a death it causes is manslaughter.[7]

Michigan's self-defense statutes speak only of threats to people. Section 2 of the Self-Defense Act allows deadly force to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm or sexual assault, and other force to defend against the imminent unlawful use of force by another person; it contains no provision for using force to protect property as such.[1] What remains on property is older law: an 1860 Supreme Court decision, a model jury instruction on defending a home whose survival is in doubt, and a statute against booby traps.[2][4][5][7]

This page describes those sources. It takes no position on what the law should be and does not say when force is justified in any situation. The general rules are in the self-defense overview and on stand your ground and the duty to retreat.

What the Self-Defense Act covers

The Act, 2006 PA 309, took effect on October 1, 2006, and none of its four sections has been amended since.[8] Its deadly-force rule requires an honest and reasonable belief that deadly force "is necessary to prevent the imminent death of or imminent great bodily harm to" the person or another individual, or to prevent an imminent sexual assault.[9][10] Its non-deadly-force rule requires an honest and reasonable belief that force is necessary "to defend himself or herself or another individual from the imminent unlawful use of force by another individual."[11] Each of those is a threat to a person.[1]

The model instruction on deadly force says the same thing from the jury's side: a person "may not kill or seriously injure another person just to protect" himself or herself against "what seems like a threat of only minor injury," and the defendant "must have been afraid of" death, serious physical injury or sexual assault.[12] The Act also does not diminish the common-law right of self-defense as it existed on October 1, 2006.[13]

The old common-law rule: Pond v People (1860)

In Pond v People, the Michigan Supreme Court said: "Where a felonious act is not of a violent or forcible character, as in picking pockets, and crimes partaking of fraud rather than force, there is no necessity, and therefore no justification, for homicide, unless possibly in some exceptional cases."[2] Even against a forcible felony, the Court said, "Life may not properly be taken under this rule where the evil may be prevented by other means within the power of the person who interferes against the felon."[2]

The decision is more than 160 years old, but the committee that writes the model jury instructions still cites it for the defense of the home.[5] No modern Michigan appellate decision squarely about deadly force to protect property alone turned up in the sources reviewed for this guide.

Defense of the home: M Crim JI 7.17

The model instruction titled "Use of Deadly Force in Defense of the Home," adopted March 1, 2020, states the common-law defense of habitation.[4][3] It requires two beliefs, each honest and reasonable, at the time the defendant acted:

  1. that the person killed or injured used force to enter the home, or was forcibly attempting to enter it, and had no right to enter; the instruction adds that "[t]he use of any force may be sufficient, including opening a door or raising a window"; and[4]
  2. that the person intended to steal property from the home, to injure the defendant or someone else lawfully in the home, or to commit a sexual assault.[4]

The defendant must also have honestly and reasonably believed the action was immediately necessary, and "a person may only use as much force as [he / she] thinks is necessary at the time to defend [his / her] home."[14] Where the defense is raised, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not have a reasonable belief that the person was forcibly entering intending to steal or to injure or sexually assault someone lawfully in the home.[14]

The instruction is about a forcible entry into the home, not property elsewhere. It is the only model self-defense instruction that names a place or thing being defended, and none is titled as a defense of personal property.[3]

Whether the defense still exists is an open question. The committee's note says "there exists a substantial question whether that defense survives the promulgation of the Presumption Regarding Self-Defense, particularly MCL 780.951, and the Self-Defense Act," and that "[r]esolution of that question is beyond the scope of the charge of the Committee."[5]

How the castle-doctrine presumption differs

The 2006 presumption statute, MCL 780.951, is the basis of Michigan's castle-doctrine presumption. It creates a rebuttable presumption that a person who used force under the Self-Defense Act had an honest and reasonable belief that "imminent death of, sexual assault of, or great bodily harm to" himself, herself or another would occur.[15] The presumption is triggered when the other person is breaking and entering or committing home invasion of a dwelling or business premises, has done so and is still there, or is unlawfully attempting to remove someone from a dwelling, business premises or occupied vehicle, and the person using force honestly and reasonably believes that is happening.[6][16]

So the presumption concerns the defender's belief about a threat to a person, triggered by an intrusion.[15] The prosecutor can overcome it by proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not have that belief.[17] "Dwelling" and "business premises" each include an attached appurtenant structure.[18] The exceptions and details are on the castle doctrine page.

Cars and car thieves

"Vehicle" in the presumption statute means "a conveyance of any kind, whether or not motorized, that is designed to transport people or property."[19] But for a vehicle the only trigger is an unlawful attempt "to remove another individual from a dwelling, business premises, or occupied vehicle against his or her will"; the statute's list does not mention stealing or breaking into a vehicle.[6]

In People v Thigpen (2023), as quoted in the state criminal benchbook, the Court of Appeals upheld a refusal to give the presumption instruction to a driver because the only evidence of a removal attempt was his statement that the other man grabbed at or jiggled the door handle; the standard self-defense instructions were still given.[20] The Act's own no-retreat rule applies "anywhere" a person "has the legal right to be," including a vehicle, but its force rules still turn on threats to people.[21][1]

Spring guns and booby traps

MCL 750.236 makes it a misdemeanor to "set any spring or other gun, or any trap or device operating by the firing or explosion of gunpowder or any other explosive," and leave it "except in the immediate presence of some competent person."[7] The penalty is up to 1 year in county jail or a fine of up to $500, and "the killing of any person by the firing of a gun or device so set shall be manslaughter."[7] Manslaughter is punishable by up to 15 years, a fine of up to $7,500, or both.[22] A conviction for setting a spring gun is also on the list of misdemeanors that block a concealed pistol license for 8 years.[23]

Where property and self-defense overlap

A property dispute can still affect a self-defense claim. Under M Crim JI 7.16, a defendant who trespassed on someone else's property, or tried to take someone else's property in a nonviolent way, "does not lose all right to self-defense," but if then assaulted with deadly force may act in self-defense only after retreating where it would have been safe.[24] The aggressor rules are explained in who started it.

The presumption does not apply when the person against whom force is used, "including an owner, lessee, or titleholder," has the legal right to be in the dwelling, business premises or vehicle, unless there is a domestic-violence injunction, or a written pretrial supervision, probation or parole order of no contact, against that person.[25] Losing the presumption is not losing self-defense; the general rules of the Act and the common law still apply.[26]

Michigan's trespass statute also protects land and premises: entering another's land or premises after being forbidden, or staying after being told to leave, is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 30 days in jail, a $250 fine, or both.[27] Firing at a dwelling or potentially occupied structure is a felony unless done in self-defense or defense of another, and careless discharge that damages property is a misdemeanor.[28][29] See shooting at a building and warning shots and discharge charges.

Common misunderstandings

  • "You can use deadly force to protect your property." The Act speaks only of threats to people, the 1860 common law denied homicide for non-violent property crimes, and the defense-of-home instruction requires a forcible entry into the home with intent to steal or harm and may not survive the 2006 statutes.[1][2][4][5]
  • "The castle doctrine covers anyone breaking into your car." The vehicle trigger is an unlawful attempt to remove someone from an occupied vehicle.[6][20]
  • "A booby trap is a lawful way to guard an empty building." Setting one that fires a gun or explosive and leaving it without a competent person present is a crime, and a death it causes is manslaughter.[7]

Defending another person is a separate subject, covered in defense of others and, for domestic settings, in the domestic violence guide's page on defense of others and property. The deadly-force standard is on deadly and non-deadly force.

Common questions

Can you shoot someone for stealing property in Michigan?

Michigan's Self-Defense Act authorizes force only against threats to people, not to protect property as such.[1] The model deadly-force instruction says a person may not kill or seriously injure another just to protect against a threat of only minor injury; the defendant must have been afraid of death, serious physical injury or sexual assault.[12] In 1860 the Supreme Court said homicide is not justified to stop a non-violent felony such as picking pockets.[2] The model defense-of-the-home instruction covers deadly force against a forcible entry into the home with intent to steal, injure or sexually assault, but its committee questions whether that defense survives the 2006 statutes.[4][5]

Does Michigan's castle doctrine cover a car?

Only in one situation. The presumption covers a vehicle when the other person is unlawfully attempting to remove someone from an occupied vehicle against his or her will.[6] In People v Thigpen (2023), as quoted in the state criminal benchbook, evidence that a man grabbed at or jiggled the driver's door handle was not enough for the presumption instruction, though the standard self-defense instructions were given.[20]

Is defense of habitation still the law in Michigan?

It is unsettled. M Crim JI 7.17, adopted in 2020, states the common-law defense of the home for deadly force against a forcible entry with intent to steal, injure or sexually assault.[4] The instruction committee notes "a substantial question whether that defense survives" the 2006 presumption statute and the Self-Defense Act, and says resolving it is beyond its charge.[5]

Are booby traps legal to protect a home or cabin in Michigan?

Not if the device fires a gun or an explosive. MCL 750.236 makes it a misdemeanor to set a spring gun or any trap or device that fires a gun or explosive and leave it except in the immediate presence of a competent person, punishable by up to 1 year in county jail or a $500 fine.[7] If such a device kills someone, the killing is manslaughter.[7]

Who has to prove defense of the home at trial?

The prosecutor. Where the defendant says he or she used deadly force to defend the home, M Crim JI 7.17 tells jurors the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not have a reasonable belief that the person was forcibly entering intending to steal or to injure or sexually assault someone lawfully in the home.[14]

Sources

  1. MCL 780.972(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  2. Pond v People, 8 Mich 150, 177-178 (1860) — Caselaw Access Project
  3. M Crim JI, chapter 7 table of contents; M Crim JI 7.19 — Michigan Courts
  4. M Crim JI 7.17(3) — Michigan Courts
  5. M Crim JI 7.17, Use Note — Michigan Courts
  6. MCL 780.951(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 750.236 — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 780.971 — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 780.972(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 780.972(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 780.972(2) — Michigan Legislature
  12. M Crim JI 7.15(4) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCL 780.974 — Michigan Legislature
  14. M Crim JI 7.17(4)-(5) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCL 780.951(1) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 780.951(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  17. M Crim JI 7.16a(1) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 780.951(3)(b)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 780.951(3)(g) — Michigan Legislature
  20. People v Thigpen, 349 Mich App 437, 449-451 (2023) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCL 780.972(1)-(2); MCL 780.951(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 750.317; MCL 750.321; MCL 750.316(1) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 28.425b(7)(h)(ix) — Michigan Legislature
  24. M Crim JI 7.16(1) (second alternative) — Michigan Courts
  25. MCL 780.951(2)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 780.951(2); MCL 780.974 — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCL 750.552(1)(a), (b), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  28. MCL 750.234b(1)-(5), (7) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCL 752.862 — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.