SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

Drug Trials and Jury Instructions in Michigan

Key points

  • A defendant has the right to a jury trial and may waive it only with the prosecutor's consent and the court's approval.[1][2]
  • Circuit court juries have 12 members unless the parties stipulate to fewer, district court juries have 6, and the verdict must be unanimous.[3][4]
  • For possession, the prosecutor must prove the defendant possessed the controlled substance and knew it was a controlled substance, plus, for a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic or cocaine, the weight of the mixture.[5]
  • The amount is an element of a delivery offense, but the prosecutor does not have to prove the defendant knew the amount.[6]
  • Expert drug-profile testimony is not admissible as substantive evidence of a defendant's guilt.[7]

In a Michigan drug trial, the jury decides whether the prosecutor has proved each element of the charged offense beyond a reasonable doubt, and Michigan's model criminal jury instructions set out those elements for each drug offense.[8][5][9][10]

This page explains the jury, the general instructions every jury hears, the elements of the main drug charges, and how weight, lab results and expert testimony come into a drug trial.

Jury trial or trial by the judge

In a felony case, the court rule gives the defendant the right to be tried by a jury, or, with the consent of the prosecutor and the approval of the court, to waive that right and be tried by the judge.[1] A statute applies the same consent-and-approval requirement to jury waivers in all criminal cases, and except in minor offenses a jury waiver must be in writing, signed by the defendant, and made in open court after arraignment and an opportunity to consult a lawyer.[2] Before accepting a waiver in a felony case, the court must advise the defendant in open court of the constitutional right to a jury trial and confirm, by speaking to the defendant personally, that the defendant understands the right and is giving it up voluntarily.[11]

A jury in circuit court has 12 members unless the parties, with the court's consent and the defendant's personal waiver on the record, stipulate to fewer, and the verdict must be unanimous.[3] In district court, the jury has 6 people and the court may receive only a unanimous verdict.[4] The choice between the two kinds of trial is discussed on the domestic violence guide's page on bench trial or jury trial.

Instructions every jury hears

  • Presumption of innocence. Jurors are told that a person accused of a crime is presumed to be innocent, and the instruction must be given in every case.[8]
  • Proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The prosecutor must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt, and if any element is not proven, jurors must find the defendant not guilty; a reasonable doubt is a fair, honest doubt growing out of the evidence or lack of evidence.[8]
  • The right not to testify. If the defense asks for it, jurors are told every defendant has the absolute right not to testify and that they must not consider the fact that the defendant did not testify; if the defense asks that it not be given, it is not given.[12]

The elements of the main drug charges

The model instructions break each charge into elements, the parts the prosecutor must prove:[5][9][10][13]

ChargeElements in the model instruction
Possession (M Crim JI 12.5)The defendant possessed the named controlled substance; knew he or she possessed a controlled substance; and, for a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic or cocaine, that the substance or mixture weighed the stated amount.[5]
Delivery (M Crim JI 12.2)The defendant delivered the controlled substance; knew he or she delivered a controlled substance; and, for a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic or cocaine, that the substance or mixture weighed the stated amount.[9]
Possession with intent to deliver (M Crim JI 12.3)The defendant possessed the controlled substance; knew it was a controlled substance; intended to deliver it to someone else; and, for a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic or cocaine, that the substance or mixture weighed the stated amount.[10]
Manufacture (M Crim JI 12.1)The defendant manufactured a controlled substance; what the substance was; and that the defendant knew he or she was manufacturing it; for a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic or cocaine, that the mixture weighed the stated amount; and, only when some evidence raises the issue, that the defendant was not legally authorized and was not preparing the substance for his or her own use.[13]

Possession does not necessarily mean ownership. Under the model instruction, possession means actual physical control, or the right to control the substance even though it is in a different room or place; it may be sole or joint, and merely knowing about the substance is not enough.[14] More detail is on what counts as drug possession.

A note to the delivery instruction cites the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in McFadden v United States (2015) as holding that the prosecutor need not prove the defendant intended to deliver any particular controlled substance, only some controlled substance.[15] The Michigan Supreme Court held in People v Mass that the amount of a controlled substance is an element of a delivery offense, but knowledge of the amount is not.[6]

The Michigan Supreme Court explained in People v Wolfe that actual delivery is not required to prove intent to deliver, and that intent to deliver has been inferred from the quantity of drugs, the way they are packaged, and other circumstances surrounding the arrest.[16] See possession with intent to deliver and drug delivery charges.

Lesser offenses

Generally, when an offense has degrees, the jury, or the judge in a bench trial, may find the defendant not guilty of the charged degree but guilty of a lower degree or of an attempt.[17] The Michigan Court of Appeals held in People v Robar (2017), as the Controlled Substances Benchbook reports, that simple possession is a lesser included offense of possession with intent to deliver.[18] The benchbook adds that this is so where the two charges involve the same amount; if they involve differently categorized statutory amounts, possession is treated as a cognate lesser offense.[19]

For charges under the (i) and (ii) tiers of the narcotic and cocaine delivery and possession statutes, which today are 1,000 grams or more and 450 to under 1,000 grams, or conspiracy, the statute is stricter.[17][20][21][22][23] The jury may convict of a lower degree only if it is a major controlled substance offense, is not instructed on other lesser offenses involving the same drug or on attempt, and is told to return a verdict of not guilty if the evidence does not establish a major controlled substance offense involving that drug.[17]

Weight, lab results and the analyst

For a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic or cocaine, the model instructions make the weight of the substance or mixture an element the jury must find.[5][9] The weight tiers are explained on drug weight thresholds.

The prosecutor must serve the forensic lab report on the defense within 14 days after receiving it.[24] If the prosecutor intends to offer the report at trial, notice must come with it; the defense may file and serve a written objection within 14 days of receiving the notice, and if it does, the report is not admissible under the rule's shortcut; without a timely objection, the report is admissible as if the analyst had testified.[25]

Under the U.S. Supreme Court's decisions in Melendez-Diaz v Massachusetts (2009) and Bullcoming v New Mexico (2011), sworn lab certificates stating that seized material was a certain quantity of drugs are testimonial and cannot be admitted unless the analysts testify or the defendant had an earlier chance to cross-examine them, and the in-court testimony of a scientist who did not sign the report or perform or observe the test is not enough.[26] Testing and chain of custody are covered on drug lab testing and chain of custody.

Drug-profile testimony and informant witnesses

The Michigan Court of Appeals held in People v Hubbard (1995) that expert testimony of drug profiles is not admissible as substantive evidence of a defendant's guilt.[7] The Controlled Substances Benchbook adds that intent to deliver may not be inferred from the fact that a defendant matches a drug-dealer profile, but that under People v Murray (1999), profile evidence is admissible in certain circumstances to prove background or modus operandi, meaning how a crime is carried out.[27]

When a witness is an informant who is addicted to drugs, the model instruction tells jurors to examine that testimony closely and be very careful about accepting it, and to consider whether other evidence supports it, while also saying there is nothing wrong with the prosecutor using such a witness and that jurors may convict on that testimony alone if it proves guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.[28] When a witness made an agreement with the prosecutor about his or her own charges in exchange for testimony, jurors are told to consider that only as it relates to the witness's credibility and possible bias or self-interest.[29] See confidential informants in drug cases.

Defenses that reach the jury

Under the Michigan Medical Marihuana Act, the section 8 medical-purpose defense is raised in a pretrial motion to dismiss, and the charges must be dismissed after an evidentiary hearing if the defendant shows its elements; the Michigan Supreme Court held in People v Kolanek that the defense cannot be raised for the first time at trial.[30] If the defendant presents evidence of every element but material facts are disputed, the defense goes to the jury; if the motion to dismiss is denied, the defendant may not present the defense to the jury.[31] See medical marijuana immunity and defense.

Where the defendant claims a valid prescription or other authorization, the model instruction tells the jury that the defendant has the burden of proving it by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not); if the jury finds it proved, it must find the defendant not guilty, and if not, it must still decide whether the prosecutor proved the elements beyond a reasonable doubt.[32] Other defenses are surveyed on defenses to drug charges.

Motions during trial, and the right to appeal

In circuit court, after the prosecutor rests or after all the evidence, the court on the defendant's motion must direct a verdict of acquittal on any charged offense for which the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction.[33] After a felony conviction at trial, the court must tell the defendant at sentencing that he or she is entitled to appellate review, that a lawyer will be appointed if the defendant cannot afford one, and that the request for a lawyer must be filed within 42 days after the judgment of sentence to appeal by right.[34] The steps around the trial are on the drug case court process.

Common questions

Does the prosecutor have to prove I knew which drug it was?

The possession and delivery instructions require proof that the defendant knew he or she possessed or delivered a controlled substance.[5][9] For delivery, a note to the delivery instruction cites the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in McFadden v United States as holding that the prosecutor need not prove the defendant intended to deliver any particular controlled substance, only some controlled substance.[15] For delivery, the amount is an element but knowledge of the amount is not.[6]

Can someone be convicted of possession if the drugs were not on them?

The model instruction says possession means either actual physical control or the right to control the substance, even if it is in a different room or place, and possession may be shared by two or more people.[14] It also says that merely knowing about the substance is not enough; the defendant must have had control of it or the right to control it.[14] Whether the evidence shows that is for the jury.

Does the lab analyst have to testify at a drug trial?

Under Melendez-Diaz and Bullcoming, a sworn lab certificate identifying a drug is testimonial and cannot come in unless the analyst testifies or the defendant had a prior chance to cross-examine, and a substitute scientist who did not perform or observe the test is not enough.[26] Under Michigan's court rule, if the defense does not file a timely written objection to the notice, the report is admissible as if the analyst had testified.[25]

How many jurors decide a drug case in Michigan?

It depends on the court. In circuit court, where felonies are tried, a jury that decides a case must have 12 jurors unless the parties stipulate, with the court's consent and the defendant's personal waiver, to fewer.[3][35] In district court, the jury consists of 6 persons.[4] In both courts the verdict must be unanimous.[3][4]

Can a jury convict of a lesser drug charge?

Generally yes: when an offense has degrees, the jury may find the defendant not guilty of the charged degree but guilty of a lower degree or an attempt.[17] The Court of Appeals has held that simple possession is a lesser included offense of possession with intent to deliver.[18] For the 1,000-gram and 450-gram narcotic and cocaine charges, a lesser verdict is allowed only if it is itself a major controlled substance offense.[17]

Sources

  1. MCR 6.401 — Michigan Courts
  2. MCL 763.3(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCR 6.410(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
  4. MCL 600.8355 — Michigan Legislature
  5. M Crim JI 12.5 and Use Note 2 — Michigan Courts
  6. People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 626–627 (2001) — Caselaw Access Project
  7. People v Hubbard, 209 Mich App 234, 241 (1995) — Caselaw Access Project
  8. M Crim JI 3.2 and Use Note — Michigan Courts
  9. M Crim JI 12.2 — Michigan Courts
  10. M Crim JI 12.3 — Michigan Courts
  11. MCR 6.402(B) — Michigan Courts
  12. M Crim JI 3.3 and Use Note — Michigan Courts
  13. M Crim JI 12.1 and Use Notes 3–4 — Michigan Courts
  14. M Crim JI 12.7 — Michigan Courts
  15. M Crim JI 12.2, Use Note; McFadden v United States, 576 US 186 (2015) — Michigan Courts
  16. People v Wolfe, 440 Mich 508, 524 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
  17. MCL 768.32(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  18. People v Robar, 321 Mich App 106, 131 (2017) — Michigan Courts
  19. People v Robar, 321 Mich App 106, 130 (2017), as reported in MJI Controlled Substances Benchbook § 2.7 — Michigan Courts
  20. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(i) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(ii) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 333.7401(2)(a)(i) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 333.7401(2)(a)(ii) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCR 6.202(A)–(B) — Michigan Courts
  25. MCR 6.202(C)(1)–(4) — Michigan Courts
  26. Melendez-Diaz v Massachusetts, 557 US 305, 307–308, 311, 329 (2009); Bullcoming v New Mexico, 564 US 647, 651–652, 661–664 (2011) — Michigan Courts
  27. People v Hubbard, 209 Mich App 234, 238, 241–243 (1995); People v Murray, 234 Mich App 46, 54–55 (1999) — Michigan Courts
  28. M Crim JI 5.7 and Use Note; People v Griffin, 235 Mich App 27, 40 (1999) — Michigan Courts
  29. M Crim JI 5.13 — Michigan Courts
  30. MCL 333.26428(b); People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 411, 415 (2012) — Michigan Legislature
  31. People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 416 (2012); People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 227 (2015) — Michigan Courts
  32. M Crim JI 12.4a (adopted June 2018, citing People v Robar, 321 Mich App 106 (2017)) — Michigan Courts
  33. MCR 6.419(A) — Michigan Courts
  34. MCR 6.425(F)(1), (2) — Michigan Courts
  35. Kent County, "District Courts in Kent County"; Barry County, Circuit Court — kentcountymi.gov

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.