Key points
- The MMMA offers two protections: section 4 gives registered cardholders broad immunity, and section 8 gives patients generally, registered or not, an affirmative defense for medical use.[1]
- Section 4 immunity is decided by the judge before trial after an evidentiary hearing, and the defendant must prove each element by a preponderance of the evidence.[2]
- The section 8 defense must be raised in a pretrial motion to dismiss; if material facts are disputed, it goes to the jury, and if the motion is denied outright, the jury does not hear it.[3][4]
- A registered patient who exceeds section 4's limits loses that immunity but may still raise section 8, whose quantity test is what is reasonably necessary.[5][6]
- Neither protection covers the conduct listed in section 7(b), such as smoking in a public place or driving under the influence.[7][8]
The Michigan Medical Marihuana Act (MMMA) provides two separate protections in criminal cases: section 4 gives registered cardholders broad immunity from prosecution, civil penalties and discipline, and section 8 gives patients generally, registered or not, an affirmative defense to marijuana charges for medical use.[1] The two have different requirements and procedures, and the Michigan Supreme Court has set out how each works.[2][3]
This page explains those rules. It does not assess any particular case. For the background law, see Michigan's medical marijuana law (MMMA); for other defenses to drug charges, see defenses to drug charges.
The two protections side by side
| Section 4 immunity | Section 8 defense | |
|---|---|---|
| Who may use it | Registered patients and caregivers who hold registry cards[1] | Patients generally, registered or not, and their caregivers[1][6] |
| Quantity test | Fixed limits, such as a combined 2.5 ounces per patient[9][10] | No more than reasonably necessary for uninterrupted availability[6] |
| When raised and who decides | Judge decides before trial, after an evidentiary hearing[2] | Pretrial motion to dismiss and evidentiary hearing; the jury decides disputed facts[3][4] |
| Burden | Defendant proves each element by a preponderance of the evidence[2] | Defendant proves the defense by a preponderance of the evidence; the defense is presumed valid where the evidence shows the elements[11][7] |
Section 4 immunity
Section 4 protects a registered patient who possesses no more than a combined 2.5 ounces of usable marijuana and equivalents and, if no caregiver has been designated to grow, 12 plants in an enclosed, locked facility.[9] In People v Hartwick (2015), the Michigan Supreme Court listed the elements a defendant must show, as of the time of the charged offense:[10]
- the defendant was issued and possessed a valid registry identification card;[10]
- the defendant complied with the volume limits of section 4(a);[10]
- any marijuana plants were stored in an enclosed, locked facility; and[10]
- the defendant was engaged in the medical use of marijuana.[10]
A cardholder within the limits is presumed to be engaged in medical use, though the presumption can be rebutted with evidence that the conduct was not for alleviating the patient's condition.[12] Hartwick also held that immunity is a question of law for the trial court to decide before trial, after an evidentiary hearing, with the defendant bearing the burden of proving each element by a preponderance of the evidence.[2]
The privilege from arrest applies only if the patient presents both the registry card and a valid driver's license or government-issued identification card bearing the patient's photograph.[13] The rules for getting and carrying a card are on the registry card page.
Section 8: the medical-purpose defense
Under section 8, a patient and the patient's caregiver may assert the medical purpose for using marijuana as a defense to any marijuana prosecution, and the defense is presumed valid where the evidence shows three things:[7][6]
- A physician, after a full assessment in the course of a bona fide physician-patient relationship, stated that the patient is likely to benefit from medical use.[6]
- The patient and caregiver together possessed no more marijuana than was reasonably necessary to ensure uninterrupted availability for treating the patient's condition.[6]
- They were engaged in acquiring, possessing, growing, making, using, delivering, transferring or transporting marijuana or paraphernalia to treat or alleviate the patient's condition.[6]
The Supreme Court has explained several of these elements:
- Timing of the physician's statement. The defendant must have obtained the physician's statement after the MMMA was enacted and before the alleged offense; in Kolanek, the requirement was not met where the physician's statements were made before the MMMA was enacted and six days after the arrest.[14]
- Proof of the relationship. There must be proof of an actual and ongoing physician-patient relationship when the certification was issued, and a registry card on its own is not enough to prove it.[15]
- Caregivers. A caregiver must establish the physician element for each patient the caregiver is alleged to have supplied.[15]
- Registered patients over the limits. A registered patient who does not meet section 4's stricter requirements loses section 4 immunity but may raise section 8 on the same footing as an unregistered patient.[5]
How the section 8 defense is raised and decided
The statute allows a person to assert the medical purpose in a motion to dismiss, and the charges must be dismissed after an evidentiary hearing if the person shows the elements.[3] In People v Kolanek (2012), the Supreme Court held that the defense cannot be raised for the first time at trial; it must be raised in a pretrial motion to dismiss and for an evidentiary hearing.[3] According to the Michigan Judicial Institute's benchbook, the Supreme Court in Hartwick placed the burden on the defendant to prove the defense by a preponderance of the evidence.[11]
Three outcomes are possible after the hearing:
- If the defendant proves the elements by a preponderance of the evidence and no questions of fact exist, the charges are dismissed.[3][11]
- If the defendant presents prima facie evidence of every element but material facts are disputed, dismissal is not appropriate and the defense goes to the jury.[4]
- If the defendant does not present evidence from which a reasonable jury could find the elements, the motion is denied and the defendant may not present the section 8 defense at trial; the defendant may apply for leave to appeal that ruling before trial.[4][11]
In People v Cook (2018), the Court of Appeals held that an unconditional guilty plea waives the section 8 defense.[16] Issues about how evidence was gathered are separate and are covered in motions to suppress drug evidence.
What neither protection covers
Section 8 begins with the words "Except as provided in section 7(b)," and section 7(b) lists conduct the act never authorizes.[7][8] That list includes possessing or using marijuana on a school bus, on the grounds of a preschool, primary or secondary school, or in a correctional facility; smoking it on public transportation or in any public place; operating a vehicle while under the influence; and use by a person without a serious or debilitating condition.[8] In People v Carlton, the Court of Appeals held that a registered patient who smoked in his car in a business parking lot open to the public could not rely on section 4 immunity or the section 8 defense.[17]
The kinds of transactions matter too. In People v Bylsma (On Remand) (2016), the Court of Appeals held that the section 8 defense is not available for patient-to-patient transactions, caregiver-to-caregiver transactions, or transactions that do not involve the defendant's own patient or caregiver.[18] A registered patient or caregiver who sells to someone not allowed medical use loses the card and commits a felony punishable by up to 2 years.[19] See medical marijuana caregivers.
Protections beyond the criminal charge
- If a patient or caregiver demonstrates medical purpose under section 8, neither may be disciplined by a licensing board or have property forfeited for the patient's medical use.[20]
- Marijuana, paraphernalia and lawful property used in connection with medical use allowed by the act may not be seized or forfeited.[21] Forfeiture generally is covered in drug asset forfeiture.
- Possessing or applying for a registry card is not probable cause or reasonable suspicion and may not be used to support a search.[22]
Local ordinances and federal law
In Ter Beek v City of Wyoming, the courts held that a city ordinance banning uses contrary to federal law was preempted by section 4(a) and could not be enforced against registered medical marijuana users, and that section 4 is not preempted by the federal Controlled Substances Act because its immunity applies only to state action.[23] The courts described that immunity as not purporting to interfere with federal enforcement of the Controlled Substances Act.[23] Federal law is covered in federal marijuana law in Michigan.
Related protections in other settings
The Michigan Supreme Court held in People v Koon (2013) that registered patients may not be prosecuted under the Vehicle Code's zero-tolerance rule for internally possessing marijuana, but remain subject to prosecution for driving under the influence.[24] The Court of Appeals held in People v Thue (2021) that revoking probation for MMMA-compliant use is a prohibited penalty; in 2026 the Michigan Supreme Court declined to decide whether Thue means a court may never limit such use.[25][26] See marijuana use on probation or bond and the legal guide for patients and caregivers.
Common questions
What is the difference between section 4 immunity and the section 8 defense?
Section 4 grants registered cardholders broad immunity from criminal prosecution, civil penalties and disciplinary actions, while section 8 provides patients generally an affirmative defense to marijuana charges for medical use.[1] Section 4 is decided by the judge before trial, with the defendant proving each element by a preponderance of the evidence.[2] Section 8 is raised in a pretrial motion to dismiss followed by an evidentiary hearing.[3]
Can the medical marijuana defense apply without a registry card?
Section 8 applies to patients generally, registered or not.[1] The defendant must have obtained the physician's statement after the MMMA was enacted but before the alleged offense.[14] The physician's statement must have followed a full assessment in a bona fide physician-patient relationship, and the amount must have been no more than reasonably necessary to ensure uninterrupted availability for treatment.[6]
What if a registered patient has more than 2.5 ounces?
In People v Kolanek (2012), the Michigan Supreme Court held that a registered patient who does not meet section 4's stricter requirements cannot claim its immunity but may assert the section 8 defense, just like an unregistered patient.[5] Section 8's quantity test asks whether the amount was not more than reasonably necessary to ensure uninterrupted availability for treating the patient's condition.[6]
Does a judge or a jury decide the medical marijuana defense?
Both can play a role. Section 4 immunity is a question of law for the judge before trial.[2] For section 8, if the evidentiary hearing produces prima facie evidence of every element but material facts are disputed, the defense goes to the jury; if the motion is denied, the defendant may not present the defense at trial.[4]
Does a guilty plea affect the section 8 defense?
In People v Cook (2018), the Court of Appeals held that an unconditional guilty plea waives the section 8 defense, because guilty pleas waive the rights and challenges associated with a trial.[16] The court described section 4 immunity differently, as going to the very authority of the state to bring the defendant to trial, although section 4 immunity was not at issue in that case.[16]
Sources
- People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 394-396, 401 n 41 (2012) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 212, 216-217 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.26428(b); People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 411, 415 (2012) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 416 (2012); People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 227 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 401-403 (2012) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.26428(a)(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26428(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26427(b)(1)-(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26424(a) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 217-218 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 227, 228 n 69 (2015); People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 416 (2012); MCL 333.26428(b) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.26424(e) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26424(a), (b) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 404-410, 416 (2012) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 230-232 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Cook, 323 Mich App 435, 450-451 (2018) — Michigan Courts
- People v Carlton, 313 Mich App 339, 342-343, 348-351 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Bylsma (On Remand), 315 Mich App 363, 384 (2016) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.26424(l) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26428(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26424(i) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26426(g), (h)(1)-(4) — Michigan Legislature
- Ter Beek v City of Wyoming, 297 Mich App 446 (2012), aff'd 495 Mich 1 (2014) — Michigan Courts
- People v Koon, 494 Mich 1, 3, 6-7, 9 (2013) — Michigan Courts
- People v Thue, 336 Mich App 35, 37, 46-48 (2021) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hess, ___ Mich ___ (2026), slip op at 13 n 7, 16-17 n 8 — Michigan Courts
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.