Key points
- A warrant affidavit may rely on an unnamed informant only if it shows the informant spoke with personal knowledge and either is credible or gave reliable information.[1]
- Calling an informant a "credible person" is not enough; credibility is shown by facts such as a track record, statements against penal interest, or corroboration.[2]
- The privilege to keep an informant's identity secret gives way when disclosure is relevant and helpful to the defense or essential to a fair determination, decided case by case.[3]
- On request, the prosecutor must disclose any plea agreement, grant of immunity or other agreement for testimony, in misdemeanor as well as felony cases.[4][5]
- Jurors can be told to examine an addicted informer's testimony closely and to weigh any promised reward or leniency.[6]
A confidential informant is a person who gives police information or helps with an investigation without being publicly named. Michigan law lets a search warrant rest on an informant's information if the affidavit shows the informant spoke with personal knowledge and, for an unnamed informant, that the person is credible or the information reliable.[1] The prosecution's privilege to keep an informant's identity secret is real but limited: it gives way when disclosure is relevant and helpful to the defense or essential to a fair determination.[3]
This page describes the rules courts apply to informant evidence. It does not discuss how anyone might learn who an informant is; the court rules themselves weigh the risk of harm, intimidation or threats to any person.[7]
Informant tips in search warrant affidavits
Under MCL 780.653, an affidavit may rely on information from another person:[1]
- A named informant: the affidavit must allege facts from which the judge or magistrate can conclude the person spoke with personal knowledge.[1]
- An unnamed informant: the affidavit must show personal knowledge and also either that the person is credible or that the information is reliable.[1]
Personal knowledge is meant to keep rumor and reputation out of affidavits, so it should come from the facts provided, "not merely a recitation of the informant's having personal knowledge."[8]
A bare statement that the informant is a "credible person" does not satisfy the statute.[2] The Michigan Supreme Court has pointed to facts that tend to show credibility:[2]
- A past record of supplying reliable information.[2]
- Admissions against the informant's own penal interest.[2]
- Corroboration of non-innocent details of the informant's story by reliable, independent sources or police investigation.[2]
The statute grew out of an older federal test that the US Supreme Court replaced in Illinois v Gates (1983) with a "totality of the circumstances" approach.[9] If an affidavit contains other information that by itself establishes probable cause, the informant rules may not come into play at all: in People v Keller (2007), marijuana found in the defendants' trash was itself enough to support a warrant for their home, even though an anonymous tip began the investigation.[10] Keller was decided before Michigan's adult-use marijuana law took effect on December 6, 2018, and the sources this guide relies on do not say whether marijuana found in trash would support a warrant the same way today.[11] For arrest warrants, the benchbook notes that showing an informant's credibility "does not necessarily require the affiant to reveal the identity of the informant."[12]
Search warrants generally are covered in drug search warrants.
When a warrant's informant allegations fall short
A defect in the informant allegations does not automatically exclude the evidence. In People v Hawkins (2003), the Michigan Supreme Court held that failing to meet MCL 780.653's requirements, standing alone, does not require suppression of evidence seized in reliance on the warrant.[13]
A defendant who claims the affidavit contained false statements can seek a hearing, but must first make "a substantial preliminary showing of a deliberate falsehood or reckless disregard for the truth by the affiant," which takes "more than a mere desire to cross examine."[14] Those challenges are explained in motions to suppress drug evidence.
Must the informant's identity be disclosed?
A common belief is that police must always reveal their informants. The law is more limited. In People v Underwood (1994), the Michigan Supreme Court applied Roviaro v United States: "Where the disclosure of an informer's identity, or of the contents of his communication, is relevant and helpful to the defense of an accused, or is essential to a fair determination of a cause, the privilege must give way."[3]
There is "no fixed rule."[3] The court balances "the public interest in protecting the flow of information against the individual's right to prepare his defense."[3] The procedure the Court described works like this:[3]
- The defense asks for disclosure, and the government invokes the privilege.[3]
- If the accused can show a possible need for the informant's testimony, the judge should require the informant to be produced and hold a hearing in chambers, outside the defendant's presence.[3]
- A record of that hearing is made and sealed so that only an appellate court can see it.[3]
- The judge decides whether the informant's evidence is relevant and helpful to the defense or essential to a fair determination of guilt.[3]
The discovery rules also protect informants. On a motion and a showing of good cause, a court may enter a protective order, and in deciding good cause it must consider the parties' interests in a fair trial, the risk of harm, intimidation or threats to any person, the risk of fabricated evidence, and "the need for secrecy regarding the identity of informants."[7] The good-cause showing may be made in camera, meaning privately to the judge.[7]
Deals, rewards and discovery
The criminal discovery rule is MCR 6.201. It governs felony cases, and under MCR 6.610(E) it also applies in misdemeanor cases, except that its subrule (A) applies there only if the defendant asks for discovery under it.[15][5] Under MCR 6.201(C), on request the prosecutor must provide any exculpatory information known to the prosecutor, police reports (with limited exceptions such as material about a continuing investigation), the defendant's own recorded or written statements, any search warrant affidavit, warrant and return, and "any plea agreement, grant of immunity, or other agreement for testimony."[4] Unless the court orders otherwise, the prosecutor must comply within 21 days of the request.[4]
The constitutional rule from Brady v Maryland applies too: suppressing evidence favorable to the accused that is material to guilt or punishment violates due process, whether or not the prosecution acted in good faith.[16] The use note to Michigan's addict-informer jury instruction adds that on request the court and prosecutor must disclose any leniency or immunity granted the witness, or any reasonable expectation of leniency from contact with the prosecutor.[6] Discovery in general is covered in the domestic violence guide's page on discovery.
How informant testimony is tested at trial
An informant who testifies can be cross-examined like any witness. When the informant does not testify, an officer's account of the informant's words is limited: the Court of Appeals allowed such testimony when it explained how and why police arrested the defendant, not to prove the tip true, and found error when a detective's testimony went beyond explaining the direction of the investigation.[17]
Michigan's model jury instructions address informants directly:
- Addicted informers (M Crim JI 5.7). Jurors are told to examine the testimony of an addicted informer closely, to consider whether other evidence supports it, and to weigh questions such as whether the witness expects a reward or was promised no prosecution or a lighter sentence.[6] The instruction also says there is nothing wrong with the prosecutor using such a witness, and that the jury may convict on that testimony alone if it proves guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.[6] The use note says it is a cautionary instruction for cases where the uncorroborated testimony of an addict informant is the only evidence linking the accused to the offense.[6]
- Agreements for testimony (M Crim JI 5.13). When a witness made an agreement with the prosecutor about his or her own charges in exchange for testimony, jurors consider that agreement, and the penalty the witness faced, only as it relates to the witness's credibility and possible bias or self-interest.[18]
Model instructions are adapted to the evidence in each case. See drug trials and jury instructions.
Statements made to an informant
The US Supreme Court has held that there is no reasonable expectation of privacy in statements made to an undercover informant.[19] In People v Collins (1991), the Michigan Supreme Court held that police may electronically monitor conversations between a defendant and an informant, with the informant's consent but without a warrant, without violating the Fourth Amendment or the Michigan Constitution.[20] Miranda warnings are also not triggered by ploys used on a jailed suspect unless they rise to compulsion or coercion.[21] See Miranda rights in drug cases and controlled buys.
Informants and entrapment
What an informant did can matter to an entrapment claim. Reprehensible conduct by an informant may be attributed to police if a sufficient agency relationship exists, but police do not commit entrapment when they become involved with the informant only after the criminal transaction is complete.[22] The full test is on the entrapment defense page.
Defendants sometimes become cooperating witnesses themselves. In federal cases, a court may go below a statutory minimum sentence to reflect a defendant's substantial assistance in investigating or prosecuting another person only on the government's motion.[23] Whether to cooperate is a decision for a defendant to make with counsel; the federal process is described in federal drug charges.
Common questions
Do police have to tell me who the confidential informant is?
Not automatically. The Michigan Supreme Court follows Roviaro v United States: there is "no fixed rule," and the privilege must give way when the informant's identity is relevant and helpful to the defense or essential to a fair determination.[3] When the accused shows a possible need for the informant's testimony, the judge should hold a hearing in chambers, outside the defendant's presence, and seal the record.[3]
Can a search warrant be based only on what an informant told police?
It can, if the affidavit meets MCL 780.653: for a named informant, facts showing personal knowledge; for an unnamed one, personal knowledge plus either credibility or reliable information.[1] Personal knowledge must come from the facts stated, not just a recital, and courts judge probable cause on the totality of the circumstances under Illinois v Gates.[8][9]
What if the warrant affidavit did not meet the informant rules?
In People v Hawkins (2003), the Michigan Supreme Court held that failing to meet the informant requirements of MCL 780.653, standing alone, does not require excluding evidence seized under the warrant.[13] A defendant can still seek a hearing on whether the affiant made a deliberate falsehood or acted with reckless disregard for the truth, on a substantial preliminary showing.[14]
Will the jury hear that the informant got a deal?
On request, the prosecutor must disclose any plea agreement, grant of immunity or other agreement for testimony; the court rule requiring this applies in misdemeanor as well as felony cases.[4][5] When a witness made an agreement with the prosecutor in exchange for testimony, the model instruction tells jurors to consider it, and the penalty the witness faced, only as it bears on the witness's credibility, bias or self-interest.[18]
Can an officer tell the jury what the informant said?
Only for a limited purpose. The Court of Appeals has allowed an officer's testimony about an informant's tip when it was offered to explain how and why police acted, not to prove the tip true.[17] In another case it found error where a detective's account of an informant's statements went beyond explaining the direction of the investigation.[17]
Sources
- MCL 780.653(a), (b) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Sherbine, 421 Mich 502, 510 n 13, 511 n 16 (1984), overruled on other grounds by People v Hawkins, 468 Mich 488 (2003) — Michigan Courts
- People v Underwood, 447 Mich 695 (1994) (opinion by Griffin, J.); Roviaro v United States, 353 US 53, 59–62 (1957); People v Stander, 73 Mich App 617, 622–623 (1977) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCR 6.201(C), (G), (I) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(E) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 5.7 and Use Note; People v Griffin, 235 Mich App 27, 40 (1999) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.201(F) — Michigan Courts
- People v Stumpf, 196 Mich App 218, 223 (1992); People v Martin, 271 Mich App 280, 302 (2006) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hawkins, 468 Mich 488, 501–502 & n 11 (2003); Illinois v Gates, 462 US 213, 238 (1983) — Michigan Courts
- People v Keller, 479 Mich 467, 477, 483 (2007) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.27951; 2018 Initiated Law 1 — Michigan Legislature
- People v Hill, 44 Mich App 308, 311–312 (1973); McCray v Illinois, 386 US 300, 307–308 (1967) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hawkins, 468 Mich 488, 510, 512 (2003) — Michigan Courts
- People v Mullen, 282 Mich App 14, 23 (2008); Franks v Delaware, 438 US 154, 155–156 (1978); People v Bogucki, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.001(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
- People v Chenault, 495 Mich 142, 149, 152, 155 (2014); Brady v Maryland, 373 US 83, 87 (1963) — Michigan Courts
- People v Chambers, 277 Mich App 1, 11 (2007); People v Henry (After Remand), 305 Mich App 127, 154 (2014) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 5.13 — Michigan Courts
- United States v White, 401 US 745, 751–753 (1971); Smith v Maryland, 442 US 735 (1979); United States v Miller, 425 US 435 (1976); Carpenter v United States, 585 US 296, 309–310 (2018); Chatrie v United States, 609 US ___ (2026) — Michigan Courts
- People v Collins, 438 Mich 8 (1991), overruling People v Beavers, 393 Mich 554 (1975) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Wade, ___ Mich App ___ (2025); Illinois v Perkins, 496 US 292, 296–297 (1990) — Michigan Courts
- People v Akhmedov, 297 Mich App 745, 754–756 (2012) — Michigan Courts
- 18 USC 3553(e) — govinfo.gov
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.