SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

Plea Agreements in Michigan Drug Cases

Key points

  • A felony plea agreement, which may include a specific sentence or range, must be stated on the record or put in writing signed by the parties.[1]
  • In a felony case, if a judge chooses not to follow a sentence agreement, the defendant must be allowed to withdraw, but a judge's refusal to follow a prosecutor's recommendation does not give that right.[2]
  • When a felony plea involves the judge's own statement of the sentence, any guidelines range discussed is a preliminary estimate, and the judge must say whether that range is part of the plea.[3]
  • After a felony plea, any appeal from the conviction and sentence is by application for leave to appeal, not by right.[4]
  • For the 1,000-gram and 450-gram narcotic and cocaine charges, the court may accept a plea only to a listed narcotic or cocaine felony, with the prosecutor's consent on the record.[5][6]

A plea agreement is a deal between the prosecutor and the defendant in which the defendant pleads guilty or no contest in exchange for agreed terms, which can include a sentence agreement or a prosecutor's sentence recommendation; in a felony case it must be stated on the record or put in writing signed by the parties.[1][2] Before accepting any plea, the judge must be satisfied that it is understanding, voluntary and accurate.[7][8]

This page explains how pleas work in district and circuit court, what a sentence agreement does, when a plea can be withdrawn, and the plea terms that come up in drug cases. It does not recommend whether to plead or go to trial, and it does not describe what offers are common; offers depend on the prosecutor and the case.

What the judge must do before accepting a plea

Before accepting a felony plea, the judge must place the defendant under oath and explain the maximum possible prison sentence, any mandatory minimum, and that by pleading the defendant gives up the rights of a trial, including a jury trial, the presumption of innocence, proof beyond a reasonable doubt, questioning the prosecution's witnesses, having defense witnesses ordered to appear, remaining silent, and testifying.[7]

The judge must also ask whether a plea agreement exists, ask what its terms are, and confirm them with the other lawyer and the defendant.[1] The judge must warn, on the record and in writing on a state form, that if the defendant engages in misconduct before sentencing, the court will not be bound by any sentencing agreement or evaluation.[9]

Guilty plea or no-contest plea

For a guilty plea, the judge must question the defendant to establish support for a finding of guilt.[10] For a no-contest plea (nolo contendere), the judge may not question the defendant about participation in the crime, must state why a no-contest plea is appropriate, and must hold a hearing, unless there has been one, that establishes support for a finding of guilt.[10] The two kinds of plea are compared on the domestic violence guide's page on guilty and no-contest pleas.

Misdemeanor pleas in district court

District court follows its own plea rule. The judge must determine that the plea is understanding, voluntary and accurate, and must advise of any mandatory minimum jail sentence, the maximum possible penalty, and the trial rights the defendant gives up.[8] The court must make the plea agreement part of the record, determine that the parties agree on all its terms, and accept, reject or indicate on what basis it accepts the plea.[11]

Sentence agreements, recommendations and estimates

A felony plea agreement may include a sentence to a specific term or within a specific range.[1] When the agreement calls for a specified sentence or range, or a prosecutor's sentence recommendation, the court may reject it, accept it after reading the presentence report and then sentence as agreed, accept it without the report, or take it under advisement.[1] What happens next depends on the kind of term:[2][12]

  • Sentence agreement. If the court accepts a sentence agreement without the presentence report, or takes it under advisement, and then chooses not to follow it, the defendant will be allowed to withdraw from the plea agreement.[2]
  • Prosecutor's recommendation. A judge's decision not to follow a sentence recommendation does not entitle the defendant to withdraw the plea.[2]
  • The judge's own stated sentence. If the plea involved the judge's statement that it would sentence to a specified term or range and the judge then says it cannot, the defendant is entitled to withdraw the plea.[12]

When the judge states at the plea what sentence it will impose, it must say that any sentencing guidelines range discussed is a preliminary estimate and the final range may differ, say whether that range is part of the plea, and give a numerically quantifiable term or range.[3] Guidelines and the sentencing hearing are covered on drug sentencing.

Withdrawing a plea

The withdrawal rules in this section, MCR 6.310 and 6.312, are felony rules; the district court rule for misdemeanors is described at the end of the section.[13][14] In a felony case, the defendant has a right to withdraw any plea until the court accepts it on the record.[15] After the court accepts the plea but before sentencing, the plea may be withdrawn on the defendant's motion only in the interest of justice, and not if withdrawal would substantially prejudice the prosecutor because of reliance on the plea.[15]

The right to withdraw when the judge cannot follow a sentence agreement can be lost. Except as the court allows for good cause, a defendant who commits misconduct after the plea is accepted and before sentencing is not entitled to withdraw on that ground; misconduct includes failing to appear for sentencing, violating bond conditions or the terms of a plea agreement, and failing to obey a court order pending sentencing.[12]

On the prosecutor's motion, the court may vacate a plea if the defendant has failed to comply with the plea agreement.[16] Once a plea is withdrawn or vacated, the case may proceed to trial on any charges that were brought or could have been brought had the plea not been entered.[16]

After sentence in a felony case, the defendant may move to withdraw the plea within the time for filing an application for leave to appeal, and a claim that the plea was not understanding, voluntary or accurate generally cannot be raised on appeal unless it was first raised in such a motion.[17]

In a district court misdemeanor case, a defendant may not challenge a plea on appeal without first moving in the trial court to withdraw it for noncompliance with the plea rules; the motion may be made before or after sentence.[14] If the court finds a deviation that affected substantial rights, it must correct it and let the defendant choose to keep or withdraw the plea; otherwise it may allow withdrawal only if that does not substantially prejudice the prosecution because of reliance on the plea.[14]

Plea terms that matter in drug cases

Section 7411 and HYTA

A section 7411 deferral can follow a guilty plea only to one of the listed possession or use offenses, and only for a person with no prior drug conviction; the list includes no delivery, manufacture or intent-to-deliver offense.[18] The court decides whether to defer, and the statute's text contains no requirement that the prosecutor consent.[18] See the section 7411 deferral.

HYTA (the Holmes Youthful Trainee Act) requires a guilty plea to an offense committed on or after the 18th birthday and before the 26th, and for an offense committed at 21 or older the prosecutor must consent.[19] HYTA does not apply to a major controlled substance offense, which includes any violation of MCL 333.7401(2)(a), the narcotic and cocaine part of the delivery statute, and possession of 25 grams or more of a narcotic or cocaine.[20][21] See HYTA for drug charges.

Drug treatment court

An adult must plead guilty on the record to enter drug court.[22] When the person would be eligible for a dismissal, a delayed sentence or a guidelines departure, the prosecutor must approve the admission.[23] A person who waived the preliminary exam and pleaded guilty as part of a drug court application, but was not admitted, must be allowed to withdraw the plea.[24]

Large-quantity narcotic and cocaine charges

For charges in the 1,000-gram and 450-gram narcotic and cocaine tiers, or conspiracy, once the defendant is arraigned on the information the court may not dismiss on the prosecutor's motion unless the dismissal is with prejudice.[5][6][25][26] The court may accept a plea only if, with the prosecutor's consent on the record, the defendant pleads to at least one listed narcotic or cocaine delivery or possession felony, or conspiracy to commit one.[6]

The medical marijuana defense

The Michigan Court of Appeals held in People v Cook (2018) that an unconditional guilty plea waives the section 8 medical-purpose defense.[27] That defense is covered on medical marijuana immunity and defense.

Immigration

In Padilla v Kentucky, a case about a guilty plea to transporting a large amount of marijuana, the U.S. Supreme Court held that when the deportation consequence is truly clear, defense counsel must give correct advice, and when it is unclear, must at least warn that the charges may carry a risk of adverse immigration consequences.[28] Federal immigration law can treat a case as a conviction even when adjudication of guilt was withheld, if there was a guilty plea and some form of punishment or restraint.[29] See immigration consequences of drug convictions.

Who has a say in a plea

The judge decides whether to accept a plea and any sentence agreement.[1][11] The prosecutor, the defendant and the defense lawyer negotiate the agreement itself, and in a felony case those discussions are part of the probable cause conference.[30] In a felony case with a victim, before finalizing any negotiation that may result in a dismissal, a plea or sentence bargain, or pretrial diversion, the prosecutor must offer the victim an opportunity to consult and give views.[31][32] A district judge can accept a felony plea, though a circuit judge does the sentencing.[33] The steps are laid out on the drug case court process.

Appeals after a plea

A felony plea may give up the right to appeal issues that could be appealed after a trial, and any appeal from a conviction and sentence on a plea is by application for leave to appeal, not by right.[4] At felony sentencing after a plea, the court must tell the defendant that a lawyer will be appointed for an appeal if the defendant cannot afford one, and that the request for that lawyer must be filed within 6 months after the judgment of sentence.[34] In a district court misdemeanor case, a plea can be challenged on appeal only after a motion to withdraw it in the trial court.[14]

Common questions

Can the judge reject a plea deal in a drug case?

Yes. When a felony plea agreement calls for a specified sentence or range, or a prosecutor's sentence recommendation, the court may reject it, accept it, or take it under advisement.[1] If the court chooses not to follow an agreed sentence, the defendant will be allowed to withdraw from the plea agreement, but not when the court only declines a recommendation.[2] In district court, the judge must accept, reject or indicate on what basis it accepts the plea.[11]

Can a guilty plea be taken back?

In a felony case, the defendant has a right to withdraw the plea until the court accepts it on the record.[15] After acceptance and before sentencing, withdrawal on the defendant's motion is allowed only in the interest of justice and not if it would substantially prejudice the prosecutor.[15] The defendant is entitled to withdraw if the judge cannot follow a sentence agreement, unless the defendant committed misconduct after the plea and the court does not allow it for good cause.[12] In a district court misdemeanor case, a different rule applies: a motion to withdraw for noncompliance with the plea rules may be made before or after sentence, and the court may otherwise allow withdrawal only if it does not substantially prejudice the prosecution.[14]

If I plead guilty to get a 7411 deferral, do I have a conviction?

Under section 7411 the court defers proceedings without entering a judgment of guilt, and if probation is completed, it must discharge the person and dismiss the case.[18] Except as otherwise provided by law, that dismissal is not a conviction for disqualifications imposed on conviction.[18] But if a condition is violated, the court may enter an adjudication of guilt and proceed as otherwise provided.[18]

Can a large heroin or cocaine charge be pleaded down to simple possession?

Not below the listed felonies. After arraignment on an information charging the 1,000-gram or 450-gram narcotic or cocaine tiers, or conspiracy, the court may accept a plea only if, with the prosecutor's consent on the record, the defendant pleads to at least one listed narcotic or cocaine delivery or possession felony, or conspiracy to commit one.[5][6]

Does a drug plea affect immigration status?

It can. Federal law makes a noncitizen convicted of almost any controlled-substance offense deportable, except a single offense of possessing 30 grams or less of marijuana for personal use.[35] In Padilla v Kentucky, the Supreme Court held that defense counsel must advise a noncitizen client about the deportation risk of a plea.[28] Immigration law can also count a deferred case with a guilty plea as a conviction, and the Sixth Circuit applied that definition to a Michigan HYTA assignment; no decision applying it to a section 7411 deferral is cited in this guide.[29][36]

Sources

  1. MCR 6.302(C)(1), (3), (4) — Michigan Courts
  2. MCR 6.302(C)(1), (4) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCR 6.302(C)(2) — Michigan Courts
  4. MCR 6.302(B)(5) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCL 333.7415(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 333.7415(1)–(2) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCR 6.302(A), (B)(1)-(3) — Michigan Courts
  8. MCR 6.610(F)(1), (3) — Michigan Courts
  9. MCR 6.302(E)(2) — Michigan Courts
  10. MCR 6.302(D)(1), (2) — Michigan Courts
  11. MCR 6.610(F)(5), (6) — Michigan Courts
  12. MCR 6.310(B)(2)(a)-(b), (3) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCR 6.001(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
  14. MCR 6.610(F)(8)(a), (b) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCR 6.310(A), (B)(1) — Michigan Courts
  16. MCR 6.310(E); MCR 6.312 — Michigan Courts
  17. MCR 6.310(C)(1)-(2), (D) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 333.7411(1) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 762.11(2) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 762.11(3)(a)-(d) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 761.2; MCL 333.7401(2)(a)(iv) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 600.1068(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 600.1068(2) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 600.1068(5) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(i) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(ii) — Michigan Legislature
  27. People v Cook, 323 Mich App 435, 450-451 (2018) — Michigan Courts
  28. *Padilla v Kentucky*, 559 U.S. 356 (2010) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  29. 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  30. MCL 766.4(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  31. MCL 780.756(3) — Michigan Legislature
  32. MCL 780.752(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  33. MCL 766.4(3) — Michigan Legislature
  34. MCR 6.425(F)(1), (2) — Michigan Courts
  35. 8 USC 1227(a)(2)(B)(i) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  36. Uritsky v Gonzales, 399 F.3d 728 (6th Cir. 2005), No. 03-4331 — Caselaw Access Project

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.