Key points
- Possession means actual control or the right to control a substance; merely knowing about drugs, or being present where they are found, is not enough.[1][2]
- For possession, the prosecutor must prove the defendant knew he or she possessed a controlled substance, plus the weight for schedule 1 or 2 narcotics and cocaine.[3][4]
- A person claiming a prescription or other exemption has the burden of proving it, and a prescription is not a defense to possession with intent to deliver.[5][6]
- The Court of Appeals has held that separate deliveries on different occasions cannot be added together to support a conviction for delivering a larger amount.[7]
- Some defenses are decided by the judge rather than the jury, including suppression motions, medical marijuana immunity and entrapment.[8][9][10]
The defenses on this page are of three kinds. Some challenge whether the prosecutor can prove each element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.[3] Some rely on a legal rule that keeps evidence out or requires dismissal.[11][12] And some exemptions, such as a prescription, work differently because the law puts the burden of proving them on the person who claims them.[5]
This page is an overview. It explains what the law says about each kind of defense and links to the page that covers it in depth. Which defenses, if any, fit a particular case depends on its facts, and this guide does not assess individual cases.
The elements the prosecutor must prove
Every drug charge has elements, and the prosecution must prove each one. For possession, Michigan's model jury instruction requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant possessed the named controlled substance and knew that he or she possessed a controlled substance, and for schedule 1 or 2 narcotics and cocaine, that it weighed the amount charged.[3][4] For delivery, the instruction requires proof that the defendant delivered the substance and knew it was a controlled substance, with the weight for schedule 1 or 2 narcotics and cocaine.[13] Possession with intent to deliver adds proof that the defendant intended to deliver the substance to someone else.[14]
The statute itself covers only knowing or intentional possession.[15] The sections below look at those elements one at a time.
Possession: control, not presence or ownership
Under the jury instruction, possession "does not necessarily mean ownership."[1] It means actual physical control, or the right to control the substance even if it is in a different room or place, either alone or together with someone else.[1] The same instruction says "[i]t is not enough if the defendant merely knew about" the substance.[1]
The Michigan Supreme Court has held that "a person's presence, by itself, at a location where drugs are found is insufficient to prove constructive possession," and that some additional connection must be shown.[2] For joint possession, the Court of Appeals has held that "[s]omething more than mere association must be shown."[16] The full explanation, with examples, is in what counts as drug possession.
Knowledge
Michigan courts define possession as control over the drug "with knowledge of its presence and character."[17] Knowledge has limits as a defense, though. For delivery, the jury instruction committee notes that, under McFadden v United States, a federal case, the prosecutor need not prove the defendant intended to deliver any particular controlled substance, only some controlled substance.[18] And while the amount is an element of a delivery offense, knowledge of the amount is not.[19]
Intent to deliver
Intent to deliver does not require an actual delivery; the Michigan Supreme Court has said it can be inferred from the quantity of drugs, the way they are packaged, and other circumstances surrounding the arrest.[20] The Court of Appeals has held that expert testimony about "drug profiles" is not admissible as substantive evidence of a defendant's guilt.[21] See possession with intent to deliver.
Weight, mixtures and lab evidence
Weight can decide the charge for narcotics and cocaine. The possession tiers for those drugs are set by the weight of "any mixture containing" the substance.[4] The Court of Appeals in People v Barajas said it is the weight of the entire mixture that sets the penalty, "without regard to purity."[22] The MJI benchbook reports that the same court held that a mixture "must be reasonably homogeneous or uniform."[23] In that case the court treated a 26-gram rock of cocaine as the mixture, separately from more than a kilogram of baking soda in the same package.[24] In affirming, the Michigan Supreme Court said the Court of Appeals' analysis was "limited strictly to the facts of this case," so Barajas is a fact-specific holding rather than a general rule.[23] The Court of Appeals has also held that separate deliveries on different occasions "may not be aggregated" to support a conviction for a larger amount.[7]
The identity of the substance must be proved as well. If the defense files a timely written objection, a lab report is not admissible under the court rule that otherwise lets it in as if the analyst had testified, and the Confrontation Clause bars a testimonial lab certificate unless the analyst testifies or the defendant had a prior opportunity to cross-examine the analyst.[25][26] See lab testing and chain of custody and drug weight thresholds.
Prescriptions and other exemptions
Under MCL 333.7531, the state does not have to disprove any exemption or exception in the controlled substances article; "[t]he burden of proof of an exemption or exception is upon the person claiming it."[5] A person is also presumed not to hold a license or order form unless he or she proves otherwise.[27]
- A prescription, for simple possession. The lead opinion in People v Pegenau (1994) said the defendant must come forward with more than his or her own assertion of a prescription, though paper documentation is not always required.[28] The jury is instructed that the defendant must prove the prescription by a preponderance of the evidence, and that if it is not proved, the jury must still decide whether the prosecutor proved every element beyond a reasonable doubt.[29]
- A prescription, for intent to deliver. According to the benchbook's account of People v Robar (2017), a valid prescription exempts a person from simple possession but is not a defense to possession with intent to deliver.[6]
- Personal use, for manufacturing. The personal-use exception applies only to a controlled substance already in existence; it does not cover growing marijuana or making methamphetamine, and it is an affirmative defense.[30] The benchbook's marijuana case for that point, People v Pearson (1987), predates the recreational marijuana law that took effect in 2018.[30][31] That law separately allows adults 21 and older to grow marijuana for personal use, with no more than 12 plants on the premises at once.[32][33]
See prescription drug possession.
Defenses heard by the judge
| Defense | How it works |
|---|---|
| Suppression of evidence | Evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment is generally inadmissible, subject to exceptions; the motion generally must be made before trial.[11][8] |
| Medical marijuana immunity (section 4) | A question of law for the judge before trial; the defendant proves each element by a preponderance of the evidence.[9] |
| Medical marijuana defense (section 8) | Raised in a pretrial motion to dismiss with an evidentiary hearing; if the defendant presents prima facie evidence of every element but material facts are disputed, the defense goes to the jury; if not, the motion is denied and the defense cannot be presented at trial.[34][35] |
| Entrapment | Decided by the judge at a separate hearing outside the jury; the defendant proves it by a preponderance of the evidence.[10] |
Suppression
A motion to suppress can target evidence from an unlawful search and its indirect products, though the exclusionary rule is not automatic and is limited by exceptions such as good faith and inevitable discovery.[36][37][38] See motions to suppress drug evidence.
Medical marijuana
The Michigan Supreme Court has explained that section 4 of the medical marijuana law gives registered cardholders broad immunity, while section 8 gives patients generally an affirmative defense for medical use.[39] A registered patient who does not meet section 4's requirements may still raise the section 8 defense.[40] Section 4 immunity requires showing, among other things, a valid registry card, compliance with the volume limits, and plants kept in an enclosed, locked facility.[41] The recreational marijuana law does not limit any medical marijuana rights or defenses.[42] See medical marijuana immunity and defense.
Entrapment
Under People v Jade (2026), charges must be dismissed if police went beyond offering an opportunity and used tactics that could have induced a hypothetical law-abiding person in the defendant's circumstances, not otherwise ready and willing, to commit the crime, or if government conduct was so reprehensible it cannot be tolerated.[12] A separate defense, entrapment by estoppel, applies when a person reasonably and in good faith relied on a government official's statement that the conduct was legal.[43] See the entrapment defense page.
The overdose Good Samaritan law
Michigan's Good Samaritan law protects a person who seeks medical help for an overdose or other perceived medical emergency, for himself or herself or for someone else, from the possession offense when the amount was sufficient only for personal use and the evidence was obtained because of the request for help.[44][45] It does not prevent investigation, arrest, charging or prosecution for any other violation, and it is not grounds to suppress evidence in the prosecution of other charges.[46] The Court of Appeals has treated it as an affirmative defense: the defendant must present prima facie evidence of each element, and if he or she does, whether the amount was sufficient only for personal use is a question for the jury.[47] See the Good Samaritan overdose law.
Common questions
Can I be convicted of possession if the drugs were not mine?
Ownership is not the test. Under Michigan's jury instruction, possession means actual physical control or the right to control the substance, alone or with someone else, and possession "does not necessarily mean ownership."[1] At the same time, a person's presence where drugs are found is not enough by itself; the prosecution must show some additional connection between the person and the drugs.[2]
Is having a prescription a defense to a drug charge?
It can be a defense to simple possession, but the person claiming it must prove it.[27] The lead opinion in People v Pegenau said the defendant must offer more than his or her own assertion, though paper documentation is not always required, and the jury instruction places the burden on the defendant by a preponderance of the evidence.[28][29] A valid prescription is not a defense to possession with intent to deliver.[6]
Who decides a medical marijuana defense, the judge or the jury?
It depends on which protection is claimed. Immunity under section 4 of the medical marijuana law is decided by the judge before trial, with the defendant proving each element by a preponderance of the evidence.[9] The section 8 defense must be raised in a pretrial motion to dismiss; if the defendant makes a prima facie showing but material facts are disputed, the defense goes to the jury.[34][35]
Does calling 911 for an overdose protect me from drug charges?
Michigan's overdose law protects a person who seeks medical help for himself or herself, or in good faith for someone else, because of a drug overdose or other perceived medical emergency from controlled-substance use, from the possession offense for a personal-use amount when the evidence came from seeking that help.[44][45] It does not prevent investigation, arrest or prosecution for any other violation, and it is not grounds to suppress evidence in another prosecution.[46]
Can the weight of the drugs be challenged?
The weight tiers count any mixture containing the drug, not its purity.[4][22] The benchbook reports that the Court of Appeals in People v Barajas required a mixture to be reasonably homogeneous or uniform, but in affirming, the Michigan Supreme Court said that analysis was limited strictly to the facts of that case.[23] The Court of Appeals has also held that separate deliveries on different occasions cannot be aggregated to support a conviction for a larger amount.[7]
Sources
- M Crim JI 12.7 — Michigan Courts
- People v Wolfe, 440 Mich 508, 520–521 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 12.5 and Use Note 2 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(i) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.7531(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Robar, 321 Mich App 106, 133–134, 142 (2017) — Michigan Courts
- People v Collins, 298 Mich App 458, 463 (2012) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Ferguson, 376 Mich 90, 93–95 (1965); People v Reynolds, 93 Mich App 516, 519 (1979); People v Johnson, 202 Mich App 281, 285 (1993); People v Kaufman, 457 Mich 266, 276 (1998); People v Walker (On Rehearing), 374 Mich 331, 338 (1965); People v Jones, 279 Mich App 86, 90 (2008) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 212, 216-217 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026), slip op at 4, 19; People v D'Angelo, 401 Mich 167, 177–180, 183 (1977) — michbar.org
- In re Forfeiture of $176,598, 443 Mich 261, 265 (1993); Mapp v Ohio, 367 US 643 (1961); People v Hellstrom, 264 Mich App 187, 193–194 n 3 (2004) — Michigan Courts
- People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167920), slip op at 2–3; People v Johnson, 466 Mich 491, 498 (2002); People v Turner, 390 Mich 7, 20–22 (1973) — michbar.org
- M Crim JI 12.2 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 12.3 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.7403(1) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Williams, 188 Mich App 54, 57 (1991) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Cohen, 294 Mich App 70, 76 (2011); People v McGhee, 268 Mich App 600 (2005) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 12.2, Use Note; McFadden v United States, 576 US 186 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 626–627 (2001) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Wolfe, 440 Mich 508, 524 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Hubbard, 209 Mich App 234, 241 (1995) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 333.7403(2)(a); People v Barajas, 198 Mich App 551 (1993), aff'd 444 Mich 556 (1994) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Barajas, 198 Mich App 551, 555–557 (1993), aff'd 444 Mich 556, 557 (1994); People v Hunter, 201 Mich App 671, 675 (1993) — Michigan Courts
- People v Barajas, 198 Mich App 551 (1993), aff'd 444 Mich 556 (1994) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCR 6.202(C)(1)–(4) — Michigan Courts
- Melendez-Diaz v Massachusetts, 557 US 305, 307–308, 311, 329 (2009); Bullcoming v New Mexico, 564 US 647, 651–652, 661–664 (2011) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.7531(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Pegenau, 447 Mich 278 (1994) (lead opinion of Mallett, J.) — Caselaw Access Project
- M Crim JI 12.4a (adopted June 2018, citing People v Robar, 321 Mich App 106 (2017)) — Michigan Courts
- People v Baham, 321 Mich App 228, 240–244 (2017); People v Pearson, 157 Mich App 68, 72 (1987) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.27951; 2018 Initiated Law 1 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.27952 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.27955(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.26428(b); People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 411, 415 (2012) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 416 (2012); People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 227 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- People v Bogucki, ___ Mich App ___ (2025); People v Lucynski (Lucynski III), ___ Mich ___ (2024); Herring v United States, 555 US 135 (2009) — Michigan Courts
- People v Goldston, 470 Mich 523, 528–537 (2004); People v DeRousse, 341 Mich App 447, 465 (2022); United States v Leon, 468 US 897 (1984) — Michigan Courts
- People v Stevens (After Remand), 460 Mich 626, 637–638 (1999); Nix v Williams, 467 US 431, 443–444 (1984); People v Hyde, 285 Mich App 428, 442, 445 (2009) — Michigan Courts
- People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 394-396, 401 n 41 (2012) — Michigan Courts
- People v Kolanek, 491 Mich 382, 401-403 (2012) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hartwick, 498 Mich 192, 217-218 (2015) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.27954(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Woods, 241 Mich App 545, 548–549, 558 (2000); People v Zitka, 325 Mich App 38, 52 (2018) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.7403(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.7403(3)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.7403(5); MCL 333.7404(5) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Morrison, 328 Mich App 647, 653-655 (2019) — Michigan Courts
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.