SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

The Preliminary Examination in Michigan Felony Drug Cases

Key points

  • The preliminary exam is set 5 to 7 days after the probable cause conference, which is set 7 to 14 days after the felony arraignment.[1]
  • If the judge finds probable cause that a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it, the judge must bind the defendant over for trial.[2]
  • A defendant may waive the exam only with the prosecutor's consent, and a waiver leads to bindover on the charge in the complaint.[3]
  • Reports of properly performed drug field tests and State Police lab reports are admissible at the exam without the author testifying, but either side may subpoena the author on a showing that live testimony is relevant.[4]
  • There is no preliminary exam for a misdemeanor tried in district court.[5]

A preliminary examination is a hearing in district court where a judge decides whether there is probable cause to believe a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it; if there is, the defendant is bound over for trial in circuit court.[2][6] It happens only in felony cases, because there is no preliminary examination for a misdemeanor tried in district court.[5]

This page explains when the exam happens, how a drug charge is tested there, what the judge can decide, and what can follow. The steps before it are on arraignment and bond, and the full path of a case is on the drug case court process.

When the preliminary exam happens

At the felony arraignment, the magistrate sets a probable cause conference 7 to 14 days later and a preliminary exam 5 to 7 days after the conference.[1] The conference includes plea discussions, bail and bond-modification requests, and stipulations about the case.[7] If no plea agreement is reached and the exam has not been waived, it is held as scheduled unless it is adjourned, and with the court's approval the parties may agree to hold it earlier than 5 days after the conference.[8]

The exam must be held on the date the court set at arraignment unless the court adjourns it.[9] The court may adjourn it for a reasonable time if the parties consent, but over a party's objection only on a finding of good cause on the record.[9] In Allegan County's 57th District Court, for example, the probable cause conference is held the week before the preliminary exam in all felony matters.[10] Scheduling practice varies by court, so the notice from the court is the best guide to a particular date.

Probable cause, not guilt

At the exam the question is probable cause: whether there is probable cause to believe both that a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it.[2] Guilt is the question at trial, where jurors are told the defendant is presumed innocent and the prosecutor must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt.[11]

The judge's finding leads to one of three results.[2][12]

  • Bindover. If the judge finds probable cause that a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it, the judge must bind the defendant over for trial.[2] The magistrate must then bind the defendant to appear within 14 days for arraignment in circuit court, or may conduct that arraignment as the court rules allow.[13]
  • Misdemeanor. If the judge finds probable cause only for an offense the district court can hear, the case proceeds as if the defendant had been charged with that offense from the start.[2] A judge who finds no probable cause for the felony may also reduce the charge to an offense that is not a felony.[12]
  • Discharge. If the judge finds no probable cause that an offense was committed or that the defendant committed it, the judge must discharge the defendant, or reduce the charge to a non-felony.[12] A discharge is without prejudice: the prosecutor may start a new prosecution for the same offense, but must present additional evidence at the new exam, which is generally held before the same judicial officer.[12]

How a drug charge is tested at the exam

A verbatim record must be made of the exam, and both the prosecutor and the defendant may subpoena and call witnesses, offer evidence, and examine and cross-examine witnesses.[14] The court must conduct the exam under the Michigan Rules of Evidence.[14] A statute adds an important exception for reports, explained in the next section.

Because the judge must find probable cause that the charged offense was committed, the elements of that offense frame the hearing. For possession, the model jury instruction lists that the defendant possessed the named controlled substance, knew it was a controlled substance, and, for narcotic and cocaine charges, that the mixture weighed the charged amount.[15] Possession can be actual physical control or the right to control the substance, alone or jointly with someone else, and merely knowing about a drug is not enough.[16] Possession with intent to deliver adds that the defendant intended to deliver the substance to someone else.[17] These elements are explained on what counts as drug possession and possession with intent to deliver, and the weight tiers on drug weight thresholds.

Lab reports and field tests at the exam

Under MCL 766.11b, the rules of evidence apply at the preliminary exam, except that listed reports are not excluded by the rule against hearsay and are admissible at the exam without testimony from the author, the records keeper, or other foundation.[4] The list includes a report of properly performed drug field testing to establish that a substance is a controlled substance, and reports by public agencies, such as a State Police forensic technician's findings or a laboratory report, but not the police investigative report.[4][18]

The magistrate must let either the prosecutor or the defense subpoena and call the person whose hearsay was introduced, on a satisfactory showing that live testimony will be relevant to the probable cause decision.[4]

This shortcut applies at the preliminary exam. For trial, the prosecutor must serve the lab report on the defense within 14 days after receiving it, and a timely written objection keeps the report from coming in under the court rule's shortcut without the analyst.[19][20] Testing, chain of custody and the analyst's testimony are covered on drug lab testing and chain of custody.

Excluding evidence at the exam and afterward

If, during the exam, the judge decides that offered evidence is excludable, the judge must exclude it on a motion or objection.[21] The decision to admit or exclude evidence at the exam does not prevent either party from asking the trial court to decide the same question.[21] A motion to suppress generally must be made before trial, and the parties may stipulate to decide it on the record of the preliminary exam.[22] Search challenges are explained on motions to suppress drug evidence.

If the trial court later finds, on a proper motion, that the rules on how the exam is conducted, on excluding evidence, or on the probable cause and discharge decisions were violated, it must dismiss the information or send the case back to district court for further proceedings.[23]

Waiving the preliminary exam

A defendant may waive the preliminary exam only with the prosecuting attorney's consent, and after a waiver the court must bind the defendant over for trial on the charge in the complaint or any amended complaint.[3] If the probable cause conference is waived, the parties must tell the court whether they will hold the exam, waive it, or enter a plea.[24]

The drug court statute protects a person who waived the exam and pleaded guilty as part of a drug court application but was not admitted: that person must be allowed to withdraw the plea and is entitled to a preliminary exam.[25] More on that program is on drug treatment court.

Because the prosecutor must consent, a waiver is not a choice the defendant can make alone.[3] This page does not recommend either holding or waiving the exam.

Special limits in the largest narcotic and cocaine cases

MCL 333.7415 restricts what can happen at the exam for charges under the (i) and (ii) tiers of the narcotic and cocaine delivery and possession statutes, which today are 1,000 grams or more and 450 to under 1,000 grams, or conspiracy to commit one.[26][27][28][29][30] After arraignment on such a warrant, the examining magistrate may not dismiss on the prosecutor's motion unless the dismissal is with prejudice, and may not let the prosecutor reduce the charge if, at the end of the exam, it appears one of those offenses was committed and there is probable cause to charge the defendant.[26] The limits that apply to pleas after the circuit arraignment are on plea agreements in drug cases.

Common questions

Who can call witnesses at the preliminary exam?

Both sides. The court must allow the prosecutor and the defendant to subpoena and call witnesses, offer evidence, and examine and cross-examine witnesses, and a verbatim record must be made.[14] When a report comes in without its author under MCL 766.11b, either side may subpoena and call the author on a satisfactory showing that live testimony will be relevant to the probable cause decision.[4] Which witnesses to call is a decision for each side.

Can the lab report be used at the preliminary exam if the chemist does not come to court?

Yes. Under MCL 766.11b, a report of properly performed drug field testing and lab reports, including State Police forensic reports, are not excluded by the hearsay rule and are admissible at the exam without the author's testimony.[4] Either side may subpoena the author on a satisfactory showing that live testimony will be relevant to the probable cause decision.[4] Trial rules on lab reports are different.[20]

What happens if the judge does not find probable cause?

The judge must either discharge the defendant or reduce the charge to an offense that is not a felony.[12] A discharge is without prejudice, so the prosecutor may start a new prosecution for the same offense; at the new exam the prosecutor must present additional evidence, and the exam is generally held before the same judicial officer.[12]

Can the preliminary exam be postponed?

The exam must be held on the date set at arraignment unless the court adjourns it.[9] If both sides consent, the court may adjourn it for a reasonable time; if a party objects, the court may adjourn only after finding good cause on the record.[9] With the court's approval, the parties may also agree to hold the exam earlier than 5 days after the probable cause conference.[8]

Is a preliminary exam the same as a trial?

No. At the exam the judge decides only whether there is probable cause to believe a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it.[2] At a trial, the jury is told that the prosecutor must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt and that the defendant is presumed innocent.[11]

Sources

  1. MCL 766.4(1); MCR 6.104(E)(4) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCR 6.110(E), (F) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCR 6.110(A) — Michigan Courts
  4. MCL 766.11b(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 600.8311(e) — Michigan Legislature
  6. Kent County, "District Courts in Kent County"; Barry County, Circuit Court — kentcountymi.gov
  7. MCL 766.4(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 766.4(4) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCR 6.110(B)(1) — Michigan Courts
  10. Allegan County, 57th District Court — Criminal Division — allegancounty.org
  11. M Crim JI 3.2 and Use Note — Michigan Courts
  12. MCR 6.110(F) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCL 766.13 — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCR 6.110(C) — Michigan Courts
  15. M Crim JI 12.5 and Use Note 2 — Michigan Courts
  16. M Crim JI 12.7 — Michigan Courts
  17. M Crim JI 12.3 — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 766.11b(1)(a), (d), (2) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCR 6.202(A)–(B) — Michigan Courts
  20. MCR 6.202(C)(1)–(4) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCR 6.110(D)(2) — Michigan Courts
  22. People v Ferguson, 376 Mich 90, 93–95 (1965); People v Reynolds, 93 Mich App 516, 519 (1979); People v Johnson, 202 Mich App 281, 285 (1993); People v Kaufman, 457 Mich 266, 276 (1998); People v Walker (On Rehearing), 374 Mich 331, 338 (1965); People v Jones, 279 Mich App 86, 90 (2008) — Michigan Courts
  23. MCR 6.110(H) — Michigan Courts
  24. MCL 766.4(2) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 600.1068(5) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 333.7415(1) — Michigan Legislature
  27. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(i) — Michigan Legislature
  28. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(ii) — Michigan Legislature
  29. MCL 333.7401(2)(a)(i) — Michigan Legislature
  30. MCL 333.7401(2)(a)(ii) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.