SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · The court process

Arraignment and Bond in Michigan Drug Cases

Key points

  • An arrested person must be taken before a court for arraignment without unnecessary delay and is entitled to a lawyer's help there, with two narrow exceptions.[1]
  • Unless the court finds it will not ensure appearance or will endanger the public, release must be on personal recognizance or an unsecured appearance bond.[2]
  • Release conditions can include no alcohol or illicit use of controlled substances, drug testing or monitoring, and treatment, including substance abuse treatment.[3]
  • Money deposited on bail that the defendant executed (signed) is applied first to fines, costs and statutory assessments, and only the balance is returned.[4]
  • Violating a release condition can lead to an arrest warrant, revocation of release and forfeiture of the bail or surety bond.[5]

The arraignment is the first court date in a Michigan drug case: the judge or magistrate tells the accused the charge and the maximum penalty and decides whether, and on what terms, the person will be released before trial.[6][7][8] In drug cases, release conditions can include no alcohol or illicit drug use, drug testing, and treatment.[3]

This page explains the arraignment itself, the release options, the conditions courts may set in drug cases, and how bond is changed or revoked. The steps that follow are on the drug case court process, step by step.

When does the arraignment happen?

Unless released beforehand, an arrested person must be taken without unnecessary delay before a court for arraignment.[1] The person is entitled to a lawyer's help at the arraignment unless he or she makes an informed waiver of counsel, or the court issues a personal bond and will not accept a guilty or no-contest plea at the arraignment.[1]

A person arrested without a warrant for a misdemeanor can in some cases post an interim bond with police. But if the arresting officer believes the person is under the influence of alcohol or a controlled substance, the person is held until in a proper condition to be released or until the next session of court.[9]

What happens right after a drug arrest, before the first court date, is covered on arrested for drugs: what happens next.

What the judge does at the arraignment

Felony drug charges

At a felony arraignment in district court, the court must tell the accused the nature of the charge, its maximum possible prison sentence and any mandatory minimum, decide what form of pretrial release is appropriate, and make sure the accused has had biometric data collected as required by law.[6] The magistrate also sets the dates for the probable cause conference and the preliminary examination.[10] The court may not question the accused about the alleged offense or ask the accused to enter a plea.[6]

Misdemeanor drug charges

At a district court arraignment on a misdemeanor, the defendant must be told the name of the offense, the maximum sentence permitted by law, and the right to a lawyer at all court proceedings, to an appointed lawyer where the rule applies, and to a jury trial when required by law.[7] An indigent defendant has a right to an appointed lawyer whenever the offense requires a minimum jail term on conviction or the court determines it might sentence to jail, even if suspended.[7]

In every case, the decision whether a defendant is indigent must be made no later than the defendant's first appearance in court.[11] A defendant who receives food assistance, Medicaid or certain other public assistance, lives in public housing, earns less than 140 percent of the federal poverty guideline, or is receiving residential treatment in a substance abuse facility is rebuttably presumed to have a substantial financial hardship under the indigent defense statute.[12]

The three release options

The pretrial-release rule, MCR 6.106, governs misdemeanor cases in district court as well as felony cases.[13] Under it, the court must order that, pending trial, the defendant be:[8]

  1. held in custody, but only as that rule allows;[8]
  2. released on personal recognizance or an unsecured appearance bond; or[8]
  3. released on conditions, with or without money bail (10 percent, cash or surety).[8]

Personal recognizance means release on the defendant's own promise to appear; the rule lists it, with the unsecured appearance bond, separately from release with money bail.[8]

The court rule allows outright denial of release only for a defendant charged with murder or treason; with a violent felony while on probation, parole or pretrial release for another violent felony, or after two or more violent-felony convictions in the 15 years before the offense; or with first-degree criminal sexual conduct, armed robbery or kidnapping to extort, and in each case only with the required findings.[14] Drug possession and delivery offenses are not named on that list.[14] Michigan's bail statute also says that, except as otherwise provided by law, a person accused of a crime is entitled to bail, and the amount shall not be excessive.[15]

Personal recognizance is the starting point

If the defendant is not held in custody under those exceptions, the court must order release on personal recognizance or an unsecured appearance bond, on condition that the defendant appear as required, not leave the state without the court's permission, and not commit any crime while released.[2] The court may set other terms only if it decides that release will not reasonably ensure the defendant's appearance or will present a danger to the public.[2]

Release conditions courts may set in drug cases

When conditional release is ordered, the conditions the rule lists include these.[3][16]

  • Not using alcohol or illicitly using any controlled substance.[3]
  • Taking part in a substance abuse testing or monitoring program.[3]
  • Taking part in a specified treatment program for any physical or mental condition, including substance abuse.[3]
  • Following restrictions on personal associations, place of residence, place of employment, or travel.[16]
  • Surrendering a driver's license or passport, and keeping a specified curfew.[16]
  • Not possessing a firearm or other dangerous weapon, and not entering specified premises or areas.[16]
  • Making reports to a court agency as the court or the agency specifies.[16]

The rule lists other conditions as well, so this list is not complete. The written release order shows exactly which conditions apply in a given case, and reading it closely matters because each condition is something the court can enforce.

The rule's text bars "illicitly" using a controlled substance.[3] How that wording applies to marijuana used legally by adults or under a medical card is covered on marijuana use on probation or bond.

Money bail: how it is set and posted

Money bail may be required only if the court determines, for reasons it states on the record, that the defendant's appearance or the protection of the public cannot otherwise be assured.[17] The factors the court weighs in setting release terms include the defendant's prior record, court appearance history, history of substance abuse or addiction, the seriousness of the charge and likely sentence, finances, and ties to the community; the court must state its reasons on the record if it orders money bail, but need not make a finding on each factor.[18] In fixing the amount, the bail statute requires findings on the record on the seriousness of the offense, the protection of the public, the accused's prior record and dangerousness, and the likelihood of appearing at trial.[19]

When money bail is set, it can be posted as a cash deposit of 10 percent of the full amount, cash for the full amount, or a surety bond from a court-approved surety for one-quarter of the full amount.[20]

Money deposited on bail that the defendant executed (signed) is applied first to any fine, costs or statutory assessments imposed, and any balance is returned.[4] For a 10 percent deposit for a crime governed by MCL 780.66, a section of Michigan's law on bail for traffic offenses and misdemeanors, the court returns 90 percent and keeps 10 percent when the defendant is discharged from all obligations, but must return the entire deposit if the defendant was not convicted of the charged crime.[4][21]

Violating bond, and asking to change it

If the defendant fails to comply with the conditions of release, the court may issue a warrant for the defendant's arrest, revoke the release order, and declare the bail money or surety bond forfeited.[5] Because the rule turns on the conditions of release, the written order is the place to check what is and is not allowed.[5] Testing and violations after a conviction are a separate subject, covered on drug probation and testing.

Before the arraignment in circuit court, any court where the case is pending may modify a prior release decision, on a party's motion or on its own, if it finds a substantial reason; from that arraignment onward, the court may decide release anew and modify the earlier decision.[22] The party seeking the change has the burden of going forward.[22] A party can also ask the court with appellate jurisdiction to review a release decision by filing a motion, and there is no fee for that motion; the reviewing court may change the decision only on finding an abuse of discretion.[23][17]

In felony cases, the probable cause conference is another chance to raise bond: it includes discussions about bail and an opportunity to petition the magistrate for a bond modification.[24] That conference and the exam that follows are covered on the preliminary examination in felony drug cases.

Practical points for the first court date

Because the indigency decision must be made no later than the first court appearance, information about income, public assistance, public housing or residential treatment bears on it at the arraignment.[11][12] The first steps checklist covers the papers involved in the first weeks of a case, and questions to ask a lawyer covers what to raise about bond and conditions. Bond in another kind of criminal case is discussed on the domestic violence guide's page on bond conditions.

Common questions

Will I have to post money bail on a drug charge in Michigan?

Not necessarily. Unless the court decides that release on personal recognizance or an unsecured bond will not reasonably ensure appearance or will present a danger to the public, it must release the defendant that way.[2] If the court does order money bail, it must state its reasons on the record.[18] The bail statute also requires findings on the seriousness of the offense, public protection, the prior record and the likelihood of appearing.[19]

Can a judge order drug testing as a bond condition?

Yes. When conditional release is ordered, the court may require the defendant not to use alcohol or illicitly use any controlled substance, to take part in a substance abuse testing or monitoring program, and to take part in a specified treatment program.[3] If the defendant fails to comply with release conditions, the court may issue a warrant, revoke the release order and declare the bail forfeited.[5]

Can a judge refuse to release someone charged with a drug crime?

The court rule allows outright denial of release only for listed charges: murder or treason, certain violent felonies in repeat or on-release situations, and first-degree criminal sexual conduct, armed robbery or kidnapping to extort, with required findings.[14] Drug possession and delivery are not named on that list.[14] Michigan law also says that, except as otherwise provided by law, an accused person is entitled to bail that is not excessive.[15]

Do I get my bond money back if the case is dismissed?

Money deposited on a bond the defendant signed is first applied to any fine, costs or statutory assessments, and the balance is returned.[4] For a 10 percent deposit for a crime governed by MCL 780.66, part of Michigan's law on bail for traffic offenses and misdemeanors, the court keeps 10 percent when the defendant is discharged, but must return the entire deposit if the defendant was not convicted of the charged crime.[4][21] The court clerk can say how the court will apply any money posted.

How can bond conditions be changed after arraignment?

Before the circuit court arraignment, any court handling the case may modify release on a party's motion or on its own if it finds a substantial reason; from the circuit arraignment on, the court may decide release anew.[22] The party asking for the change has the burden of going forward.[22] In felony cases, the probable cause conference includes discussions about bail and a chance to ask for a bond modification.[24]

Sources

  1. MCR 6.104(A) — Michigan Courts
  2. MCR 6.106(C) — Michigan Courts
  3. MCR 6.106(D)(2)(b)-(d) — Michigan Courts
  4. MCR 6.106(I)(1), (3) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCR 6.106(I)(2) — Michigan Courts
  6. MCR 6.104(E) — Michigan Courts
  7. MCR 6.610(D)(1), (2) — Michigan Courts
  8. MCR 6.106(A) — Michigan Courts
  9. MCL 780.581(1)–(3) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 766.4(1); MCR 6.104(E)(4) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 780.991(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 780.991(3)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCR 6.001(B) — Michigan Courts
  14. MCR 6.106(B)(1), (2) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCR 6.106(B)(1); MCL 765.6(1) — Michigan Courts
  16. MCR 6.106(D)(2)(a), (e)-(g), (k), (l) — Michigan Courts
  17. MCR 6.106(E), (H)(1) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCR 6.106(F)(1), (2) — Michigan Courts
  19. MCL 765.6(1)(a)-(d) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCR 6.106(E)(1)(a); MCL 765.6(2) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCL 780.66(1), (6); 1966 PA 257 (heading) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCR 6.106(H)(2)(a)-(c) — Michigan Courts
  23. MCR 6.106(H)(1), (2) — Michigan Courts
  24. MCL 766.4(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.