Key points
- At a preliminary examination, a properly performed field test report and lab reports, including State Police forensic reports, can be admitted without the author testifying.[1]
- For trial, the prosecutor must serve the lab report within 14 days of receiving it, and the defense has 14 days from the notice to file a written objection.[2][3]
- If no timely objection is filed, the lab report is admissible as if the analyst had testified in person.[3]
- Drug-analysis certificates are testimonial, so they cannot be used at trial unless the analyst testifies or the defendant had an earlier chance to cross-examine.[4]
- A break in the chain of custody does not require automatic exclusion; it generally affects the weight of the evidence, not its admissibility.[5]
In a Michigan drug case, the prosecution must prove that the substance was a controlled substance, and for schedule 1 or 2 narcotic and cocaine charges, that it weighed the amount charged.[6][7] At the preliminary examination, field test and lab reports can be admitted without the person who wrote them, but at trial the defendant has the right to confront the analyst, and Michigan's court rules set a 14-day window to insist on it.[1][4][3]
This page covers how test results reach the courtroom and what the law says about chain of custody. It does not discuss testing methods or error rates, which are matters for expert evidence in a particular case.
Field tests and lab reports at the preliminary exam
The preliminary examination is a hearing in felony cases where a judge decides whether there is probable cause to send the case to circuit court.[8] Under MCL 766.11b, certain reports are admissible at that hearing without testimony from the person who prepared them, including:[1]
- A report of the results of properly performed drug field testing, to establish that the substance tested is a controlled substance.[1]
- A report prepared by a law enforcement officer or other public agency (other than the police investigative report), including the findings of a State Police forensic science technician and a laboratory report.[1]
That shortcut is for the preliminary exam. The hearing itself is explained in the drug preliminary examination.
The lab report rule for trial: MCR 6.202
MCR 6.202 applies to criminal trials in both district and circuit court, and it is one of the rules that governs misdemeanor cases.[2][9] An older statute on technicians' reports, MCL 600.2167, was repealed effective May 20, 2014, and MCR 6.202 now governs the admissibility of forensic laboratory reports.[10]
The rule works in steps:
- Service. Within 14 days after receiving a forensic laboratory report (and certificate, if any), the prosecutor must serve a copy on the defense and file a proof of service with the court.[2]
- Notice. If the prosecutor intends to offer the report at trial, notice of that intent must be included with the report.[3]
- Objection. The defense may file a written objection with the court and serve it on the prosecutor within 14 days of receiving the notice.[3]
- Effect. If a written objection is filed, the report and certificate are not admissible under the rule's shortcut.[3] If no timely objection is made, they are admissible as if the analyst had personally testified.[3]
- Extensions. For good cause the court shall extend the time to object, and compliance with the rule is good cause for adjourning the trial.[3]
A common misunderstanding is that the analyst always has to appear. Under this rule, the right to live testimony is protected by a timely objection, and without one the report comes in as if the analyst testified.[3]
The analyst's certificate
The analyst who conducts the analysis and signs the report generally must complete a certificate stating that he or she is qualified by education, training and experience; the name and location of the lab; that the analysis is part of his or her regular duties; and that the tests followed industry-approved procedures or standards and the report accurately reflects the findings.[11] An analyst at a lab accredited by a national or international body that substantially meets those requirements may provide proof of the lab's accreditation instead.[11]
The right to confront the analyst
The US Supreme Court has applied the Confrontation Clause to forensic lab reports in three cases:
- Melendez-Diaz v Massachusetts (2009): state analysts' sworn statements that seized material was a certain quantity of drugs were testimonial and could not be admitted unless the analysts testified or the defendant had an earlier chance to cross-examine them.[4]
- Bullcoming v New Mexico (2011): the in-court "surrogate testimony" of a scientist who did not sign the report or perform or observe the test was not enough.[4]
- Smith v Arizona (2024): an absent analyst's report and notes are testimonial if they have an evidentiary purpose focused on court, though some lab records, such as those kept for accreditation, internal quality control or as reminders to self, would not be.[12]
Chain of custody
"Chain of custody" is the record of who handled an item of evidence from seizure to trial. To admit physical evidence, the party offering it must show that the object was involved in the matter and that its condition is substantially the same.[5] Another common belief is that any gap in the chain gets the drugs thrown out. Michigan courts have held otherwise: a court is not required to exclude evidence automatically because of a break in the chain of custody, and a break "affects the weight of the evidence, not its admissibility."[5] Admitting evidence despite alleged deficiencies in how it was collected and preserved is not an abuse of discretion "as long as there is no missing vital link in the chain of custody or there is no sign of tampering."[5]
The Confrontation Clause still applies to the chain. In People v Washington (2024), the Michigan Supreme Court held that testimony offered to establish chain of custody is not an exception to the Confrontation Clause: the prosecution decides which steps need proof, but that testimony must be introduced live if the defendant objects.[13]
Because a break in the chain generally goes to the weight of the evidence, it is something the defense may raise before the jury.[5] How juries are instructed is covered in drug trials and jury instructions.
Weight and mixtures
For narcotics and cocaine, the weight tiers use the weight of the whole mixture containing the drug, not the pure drug, so purity does not change the tier.[14] The MJI benchbook reports that the Court of Appeals in People v Barajas defined a "mixture" as one that is "reasonably homogeneous or uniform," but the Michigan Supreme Court, in affirming, said that analysis was limited strictly to the facts of that case.[15] The amount is an element of a delivery charge, but the prosecutor does not have to prove the defendant knew the amount.[16] The tiers are explained in drug weight thresholds.
Defense inspection and testing
Under MCR 6.201(A), each party, on request, must give the other a description of and an opportunity to inspect any tangible physical evidence it may introduce at trial; on good cause shown, the court may order that a party be given the opportunity to test the evidence without destroying it.[17] In a misdemeanor case, that subrule applies only if the defendant requests discovery under it, and if the prosecutor complies, the defendant must comply too.[18] Service of lab reports themselves is governed by MCR 6.202, described above.[2]
What happens to the drugs
Items seized under a search warrant are kept as long as needed to be produced or used as evidence at trial.[19] A schedule 1 controlled substance possessed or sold in violation of the law is contraband and is summarily forfeited to the state.[20]
Under MCL 333.7527, the prosecutor may move before trial for an order permitting destruction of seized drug evidence. If the defendant objects, specific objections must be filed within 21 days after receiving the motion, or the objection is waived, and before any hearing the defense must have an adequate opportunity to inspect or test the evidence.[21] The court may order destruction after a hearing if it finds on the record that destruction is warranted, and the police agency must make an accurate photographic record before destroying the evidence.[21]
Lab issues are one of several possible lines of defense; others are surveyed in defenses to drug charges. Evidence from controlled buys is discussed in controlled buys, and excluding unlawfully seized evidence in motions to suppress.
Common questions
Does the lab analyst have to come to court in a Michigan drug case?
At trial, the Confrontation Clause bars a sworn drug-analysis certificate unless the analyst testifies or the defendant had a prior chance to cross-examine, and another scientist cannot stand in for the analyst.[4] Michigan's court rule adds a procedure: if the defense files a timely written objection, the report is not admissible under the rule's shortcut.[3] At the preliminary exam, lab reports can come in without the author.[1]
What happens if the 14-day objection deadline is missed?
Under MCR 6.202(C), if no objection is made within the time allowed, the lab report and certificate are admissible as if the analyst had personally testified.[3] The same rule says the court shall extend the objection period for good cause, and that compliance with the rule is good cause for adjourning the trial.[3]
Can a field test be used as evidence?
At a preliminary examination, a report of the results of properly performed drug field testing is admissible without the testimony of its author to establish that a substance is a controlled substance.[1] That statute governs the preliminary exam. At trial, forensic laboratory reports are governed by MCR 6.202 and the Confrontation Clause.[2][4]
Is drug evidence thrown out if there is a gap in the chain of custody?
Not automatically. Michigan courts have held that a break in the chain of custody generally goes to the weight of the evidence, not its admissibility, and that admitting evidence is not an abuse of discretion where no vital link is missing and there is no sign of tampering.[5] If the defendant objects, chain-of-custody testimony the prosecution offers must be given live.[13]
Can the defense test the drugs independently?
On request, each party must be given a description of, and an opportunity to inspect, tangible physical evidence the other side may use at trial (in a misdemeanor case, if the defendant requests discovery under that subrule), and on good cause the court may order an opportunity to test the evidence without destroying it.[17][18] If the prosecutor moves to destroy drug evidence before trial, the defense must have an adequate opportunity to inspect or test it before the hearing.[21]
Sources
- MCL 766.11b(1)(a), (d), (2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.202(A)–(B) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.202(C)(1)–(4) — Michigan Courts
- Melendez-Diaz v Massachusetts, 557 US 305, 307–308, 311, 329 (2009); Bullcoming v New Mexico, 564 US 647, 651–652, 661–664 (2011) — Michigan Courts
- People v Prast (On Rehearing), 114 Mich App 469, 490 (1982); People v Herndon, 246 Mich App 371, 405 (2001); People v Ramsey, 89 Mich App 260, 267 (1979); People v Muhammad, 326 Mich App 40, 59 (2018) — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 12.5 and Use Note 2 — Michigan Courts
- M Crim JI 12.2 — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.110(E), (F) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.001(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 600.2167 (repealed); MCR 6.202 — Michigan Legislature
- MCR 6.202(D) — Michigan Courts
- Smith v Arizona, 602 US 779, 783, 802 (2024) — Michigan Courts
- People v Washington, 514 Mich 583, 598 (2024) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 333.7403(2)(a); People v Barajas, 198 Mich App 551 (1993), aff'd 444 Mich 556 (1994) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Barajas, 198 Mich App 551, 555–557 (1993), aff'd 444 Mich 556, 557 (1994); People v Hunter, 201 Mich App 671, 675 (1993) — Michigan Courts
- People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 626–627 (2001) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCR 6.201(A)(6) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.610(E) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.655(2), (3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.7525(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 333.7527(1)-(5) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.