SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Drug law basics: schedules, possession and use

What Counts as "Possession" of Drugs in Michigan: Actual, Constructive and Joint Possession

Key points

  • Possession does not mean ownership: it means actual physical control, or the right to control a substance even when it is in another room or place.[1]
  • Possession can be sole or joint, and more than one person can possess the same drugs at once.[1][2]
  • Being present where drugs are found is not enough; the prosecution must show some additional connection between the person and the drugs.[3]
  • The prosecutor must prove the person knew he or she possessed a controlled substance, and for schedule 1 or 2 narcotics and cocaine the jury must also find the weight.[4]
  • A person who claims a prescription or other exception carries the burden of proving it.[5][6]

In Michigan, a person "possesses" drugs when he or she has actual physical control of them or the right to control them, even if they are in another room or place.[1] Possession does not require ownership, and it can be shared by two or more people, but being near drugs, or merely knowing about them, is not enough.[1][3]

These rules come from the model criminal jury instructions and from appellate cases. This page explains what the courts have said. Whether the evidence in a particular case proves possession is decided case by case, by a judge or jury.

What the prosecutor has to prove

MCL 333.7403(1) makes it a crime to knowingly or intentionally possess a controlled substance, a controlled substance analogue or a prescription form, unless it was obtained under a valid prescription or practitioner's order or is otherwise authorized.[7] Under Michigan's model jury instruction, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that:[4]

  1. The defendant possessed the named controlled substance.[4]
  2. The defendant knew that he or she possessed a controlled substance.[4]
  3. For a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic drug or cocaine, the substance (or the mixture it was in) weighed the amount charged.[4]

Model instructions are not statutes, and courts adapt them to the case. The weight element is explained on the drug weight page.

Actual and constructive possession

Actual possession means the person has actual physical control of the substance. The jury instruction gives the example of the judge holding a pen.[1]

Constructive possession is the right to control the drug even though it is somewhere else.[1] The Michigan Supreme Court has said constructive possession exists when the totality of the circumstances shows a "sufficient nexus" between the person and the drugs; in People v Wolfe that meant he knew the cocaine was there and had the right to exercise control over it.[8]

The instruction also draws a line that matters in many cases: it is not enough that the defendant merely knew about the drugs. The defendant possessed them only if he or she had control of them or the right to control them, alone or with someone else.[1]

Sole and joint possession

Possession may be sole, where one person alone possesses the drugs, or joint, where two or more people each share possession.[1] The Michigan Supreme Court has held that possession need not be exclusive, and that a person can constructively possess drugs an agent is bringing to him, such as drugs the person has already paid for (People v Konrad).[2]

Joint possession still needs proof. The Court of Appeals has held that something more than mere association must be shown: the prosecution must show an additional independent factor linking the defendant to the drugs.[9]

Why "mere presence" is not possession

A person's presence, by itself, at a location where drugs are found is insufficient to prove constructive possession; some additional connection between the person and the drugs must be shown.[3] The rule matters most for people who share homes, cars and workplaces with others. It does not mean that a person found near drugs cannot be charged, only that the prosecution must prove more than presence.

Knowing what the substance was

Michigan courts define possession as dominion or right of control over the drug "with knowledge of its presence and character."[10] The Court of Appeals has said constructive possession requires proof that the defendant knew of the substance's character.[10] The jury instruction's second element, that the defendant knew he or she possessed a controlled substance, carries the same idea into the trial.[4]

Situations the courts have addressed

Each of these cases turned on its own evidence. They show what courts have looked at; they do not predict how another case will come out.

  • An apartment (People v Wolfe, 1992). Constructive possession was supported by evidence that the defendant arranged a meeting at the apartment, was the only person found with a key, was connected to a sale from the apartment that evening, and admitted knowing crack cocaine was there.[11]
  • A home shown by mail and clothing (People v Hardiman, 2002). The Michigan Supreme Court overruled the old rule against basing a conviction on an "inference upon an inference" and held that courts view all the evidence, direct or circumstantial, in the light most favorable to the prosecution when reviewing its sufficiency; mail at the apartment, a dress in the closet and other circumstances supported constructive possession.[12]
  • A car with two occupants (People v Cohen, 2011). Residue-covered paraphernalia on the center console, in clear view and reach of both the driver and the passenger, gave officers probable cause to believe both jointly possessed it.[13] The ruling concerned probable cause for the arrest; the court stated that close proximity to contraband in plain view is evidence of possession.[13]
  • A garage (People v Meshell, 2005). The court repeated that mere presence in the garage where methamphetamine was found was not enough, but found a sufficient connection where the defendant was alone in the garage while methamphetamine was being made and was seen walking out of it.[14]
  • Drugs bought through someone else (People v Konrad, 1995). Evidence that the defendant had paid for drugs that an agent was bringing to him permitted the conclusion that they were his.[2]

Search questions, such as whether police were allowed to look in the car or the apartment in the first place, are a separate issue covered in search and seizure in drug cases, vehicle searches and home searches.

Prescriptions and other exceptions

Possession is not a crime when the drug was obtained directly from, or under, a valid prescription or order of a practitioner acting in professional practice.[15] The Code also defines an "ultimate user" as someone who lawfully possesses a controlled substance for personal use, for a household member, or for an animal owned by the person or a household member.[16]

The prosecution does not have to disprove a prescription or other exception; the burden of proof is on the person claiming it.[5] The lead opinion in People v Pegenau (1994) said a defendant must offer more than his or her own assertion that a prescription existed, although paper documentation is not always required.[17] Under the current jury instruction, the defendant must prove the prescription by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not); if the jury finds it proved, the verdict must be not guilty.[6] More is on the prescription drugs page.

Related rules worth knowing

  • Attempt. Attempted possession carries the same maximum as possession under MCL 333.7407a.[18]
  • Possession versus intent to deliver. Intent to deliver is a separate, more serious charge; courts have inferred it from quantity, packaging and other circumstances of the arrest.[19] See possession with intent to deliver.
  • Overdose calls. A person who seeks or is brought for medical help because of a drug overdose or other perceived medical emergency, and a person who in good faith seeks help for someone else in that situation, are not in violation of the possession statute for a personal-use amount found as a result of seeking help.[20][21] See the Good Samaritan law.
  • Penalties. What possession is punished by depends on the drug and, for narcotics and cocaine, the weight.[22][23][24] See drug possession penalties.

Common misunderstandings

  • "They were not mine, so I cannot be charged." Possession does not necessarily mean ownership; the question is control or the right to control.[1]
  • "Knowing the drugs were there makes me guilty." The jury instruction says merely knowing about the drugs is not enough without control or the right to control.[1]
  • "Everyone in the room possesses whatever is found." Presence alone does not prove constructive possession, and joint possession needs an additional independent factor.[3][9]

For how these elements are argued at trial and the other defenses that exist, see drug trials and jury instructions and defenses to drug charges.

Common questions

Drugs were found in a car I was in, but they were not mine. Can I be charged?

Ownership is not the test; control or the right to control is.[1] At the same time, presence alone where drugs are found does not prove possession, and joint possession needs more than association with the person who has the drugs.[3][9] In one case, drug paraphernalia on the center console within clear view and reach of both people gave officers probable cause to believe both jointly possessed it.[13]

My roommate's drugs were found in our apartment. Does that make me guilty of possession?

Not by itself. The Michigan Supreme Court held that presence at a place where drugs are found is not enough, and that constructive possession needs a sufficient connection under the totality of the circumstances.[3][8] Evidence such as control of the home, a key, a connection to a sale or an admission of knowing the drugs were there has supported constructive possession.[11] Possession can also be joint.[1]

What if I did not know the drugs were there?

Knowledge is part of the offense. The statute covers only knowing or intentional possession, the jury instruction requires proof that the person knew he or she possessed a controlled substance, and the courts describe possession as control with knowledge of the drug's presence and character.[7][4][10] Whether the evidence proves that knowledge is a question of fact in each case.

I told the officer I had a prescription. Is that enough?

A valid prescription is an exception to the possession offense, but the person claiming it must prove it.[15][5] The Supreme Court's lead opinion in People v Pegenau said a defendant must offer more than his or her own assertion, though paper documentation is not always required.[17] The jury instruction places the burden on the defendant by a preponderance of the evidence.[6]

Is attempted possession a lesser crime?

Not in its maximum. Under MCL 333.7407a, attempting to commit an offense in the Public Health Code's part on controlled-substance crimes (part 74) is punishable by the penalty for the crime attempted, and the same rule applies to soliciting or inducing someone else to commit one.[18][25]

Sources

  1. M Crim JI 12.7 — Michigan Courts
  2. People v Konrad, 449 Mich 263, 271-274 (1995) — Caselaw Access Project
  3. People v Wolfe, 440 Mich 508, 519-520 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
  4. M Crim JI 12.5 and Use Note 2 — Michigan Courts
  5. MCL 333.7531(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  6. M Crim JI 12.4a (adopted June 2018, citing People v Robar, 321 Mich App 106 (2017)) — Michigan Courts
  7. MCL 333.7403(1) — Michigan Legislature
  8. People v Wolfe, 440 Mich 508, 520-521 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
  9. People v Williams, 188 Mich App 54, 57 (1991) — Caselaw Access Project
  10. People v Cohen, 294 Mich App 70, 76 (2011); People v McGhee, 268 Mich App 600 (2005) — Caselaw Access Project
  11. People v Wolfe, 440 Mich 508, 521-523 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
  12. People v Hardiman, 466 Mich 417 (2002) — Caselaw Access Project
  13. People v Cohen, 294 Mich App 70, 77 (2011) — Caselaw Access Project
  14. People v Meshell, 265 Mich App 616, 621-622 (2005) — Caselaw Access Project
  15. MCL 333.7403(1); MCL 333.7404(1) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 333.7109(8) — Michigan Legislature
  17. People v Pegenau, 447 Mich 278 (1994) (lead opinion of Mallett, J.) — Caselaw Access Project
  18. MCL 333.7407a(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  19. People v Wolfe, 440 Mich 508, 524 (1992) — Caselaw Access Project
  20. MCL 333.7403(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 333.7403(3)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(i) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 333.7403(2)(a)(v) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 333.7403(2)(b)(ii) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCL 333.7407a(2)-(3) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.