SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Informants, lab evidence and defenses

Entrapment in Michigan Drug Cases: How the Michigan Test Works

Key points

  • In Michigan, the judge, not the jury, decides entrapment at a separate evidentiary hearing held outside the jury's presence.[1]
  • The defendant must prove entrapment by a preponderance of the evidence, but does not have to admit the charged crime to raise it.[1]
  • Under People v Jade (2026), charges must be dismissed if either prong is met: unlawful inducement, or reprehensible police conduct that cannot be tolerated.[2]
  • Michigan's test focuses on police conduct rather than the defendant's predisposition, while the federal test asks about inducement and predisposition.[3][4]
  • Police merely offering an opportunity to commit a crime, including undercover buys, is not entrapment.[5]

Entrapment is a defense that police, or people working for them, created a crime rather than detected one. In Michigan the judge decides it, not the jury, at a separate hearing, and the defendant must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence.[1] As of November 2026, the leading case is People v Jade, decided by the Michigan Supreme Court on July 31, 2026, which applies a two-prong test under which either prong requires dismissal.[2]

This page explains the test and the procedure as the courts state them. It does not predict how any case will come out; each claim depends on its own facts.

The two prongs of Michigan's test

Michigan applies "a two-prong, modified objective test for entrapment under which a defendant is entitled to dismissal of charges if either prong is satisfied."[2]

  1. Unlawful inducement. Courts examine whether police conduct went beyond merely offering an opportunity to commit a crime and instead involved tactics that could have induced or instigated the crime by a hypothetical law-abiding person in the defendant's circumstances who was not otherwise ready and willing to commit it.[2]
  2. Reprehensible conduct. Entrapment also occurs when government actors engage in conduct so egregious that it "cannot be tolerated" because letting the conviction stand would endorse a misuse of governmental power.[2]

The Court said this second prong reflects the core idea that "entrapment doctrine exists to ensure that law enforcement agents detect crime rather than manufacture it."[2] The judges' benchbook, quoting People v Juillet (1991), describes the objective test as focusing "primarily on the investigative and evidence-gathering procedures used by the governmental agents," to decide whether the police conduct had as its "probable and likely outcome the instigation rather than the detection of criminal activity."[6]

Police conduct, not predisposition

Michigan's test is a "modified objective" test.[2] In Jade, the Supreme Court explained that Michigan adopted an objective test in People v Turner (1973), drawing on Justice Stewart's dissent in United States v Russell, which argued against the "subjective" predisposition approach used by the federal majority.[3] The Court said entrapment law "must focus on law enforcement's conduct rather than a defendant's innocence or predisposition," because "[p]ermissible police activity does not vary according to the particular defendant concerned."[3]

The factors courts weigh

To assess inducement, courts use twelve factors from People v Johnson (2002), reaffirmed in Jade:[7]

  • Appeals to the defendant's sympathy as a friend.[7]
  • Whether the defendant had been known to commit the crime charged.[7]
  • Long time lapses between the investigation and the arrest.[7]
  • Inducements that would make the crime unusually attractive to a hypothetical law-abiding citizen.[7]
  • Offers of excessive consideration or other enticement.[7]
  • A guarantee that the acts alleged as crimes were not illegal.[7]
  • Whether, and how much, government pressure existed.[7]
  • Sexual favors.[7]
  • Threats of arrest.[7]
  • Government procedures that tended to escalate the defendant's criminal culpability.[7]
  • Police control over any informant.[7]
  • Whether the investigation was targeted.[7]

The Court cautioned that "these factors are not mere boxes to be checked."[7] Jade also addressed escalation: where the record shows a defendant was willing to commit only a materially less serious offense than the one charged, trial courts must consider whether law enforcement escalated the conduct to the more serious charged offense.[7]

What courts have said is not entrapment

Police presenting a defendant with the opportunity to commit the crime is "insufficient to support a finding of entrapment," and officials may use deceptive methods so long as the activity "does not result in the manufacturing of criminal behavior."[5] In People v Vansickle (2013), officers posing as patients bought marijuana from a registered patient at a dispensary; the Court of Appeals found no entrapment because they did not appeal to his sympathy, offer unusually attractive inducements or excessive consideration, or pressure him, and "merely provided [him] with an opportunity to commit the crime."[5]

The Supreme Court made the same point in Jade: "Law enforcement can conduct undercover operations without entrapping suspects," but operations must not involve conduct that contravenes Michigan's entrapment law.[8] How controlled buys fit in is covered in controlled buys.

Informants and entrapment

An informant's conduct can count as police conduct, but only if there is a sufficient agency relationship.[9] In People v Akhmedov (2012), the Court of Appeals found no entrapment in three drug deals because police were not involved with the informant during the weeks the informant groomed the defendant; police "do not commit entrapment when they do not become involved with the informant until after the criminal transaction is complete."[9] See confidential informants.

How entrapment is raised and decided

A common belief, listed among the Michigan drug law myths, is that the jury decides whether someone was entrapped. In Michigan state court, that is not how it works.[1] The procedure is:

  1. Raising it. The defendant raises entrapment, as Jade did by moving to dismiss the charges.[8] It can be raised before or during trial.[10]
  2. A separate hearing. The trial court must hold an evidentiary hearing outside the jury's presence, and both the prosecution and the defendant may present evidence.[10]
  3. The burden. The defendant bears the burden of proving entrapment by a preponderance of the evidence, and need not admit the charged crime.[1]
  4. Protection for hearing testimony. Testimony at the entrapment hearing is inadmissible in the prosecution's case-in-chief for any purpose except impeachment.[1]
  5. Findings and result. The judge must make findings of fact, and if the judge concludes the defendant was entrapped, the case must be dismissed and the defendant discharged.[10]

Where the hearing falls in the life of a case is shown in the drug case court process.

The federal entrapment test

Federal drug prosecutions use a different test. The US Supreme Court has consistently held that a valid federal entrapment defense has two related elements, "government inducement of the crime, and a lack of predisposition on the part of the defendant to engage in the criminal conduct," and that entrapment is "generally one for the jury, rather than for the court."[4] In Jacobson v United States (1992), the Court held that once the government has induced a person to break the law and entrapment is at issue, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was disposed to commit the act before first being approached by government agents.[11] The same opinion said an agent "may offer the opportunity to buy or sell drugs, and, if the offer is accepted, make an arrest on the spot or later."[11] See federal drug charges.

Entrapment by estoppel

A separate defense with a similar name applies when an official told a person that conduct was legal. Entrapment by estoppel applies where the defendant proves by a preponderance of the evidence that a government official told the defendant certain conduct was legal, the defendant actually relied on that statement, and the reliance was in good faith and reasonable.[12] It does not apply when someone who should know better relies unreasonably, or when the statement was merely vague or contradictory.[12]

Entrapment in other kinds of stings is discussed in the sexual misconduct guide's page on entrapment in sex stings, and other defenses to drug charges in defenses to drug charges.

Common questions

Who decides entrapment in Michigan, the judge or the jury?

The judge. Under the procedure from People v D'Angelo, reaffirmed in People v Jade (2026), the trial judge decides entrapment at a separate evidentiary hearing outside the jury's presence.[1] The hearing must be held whether the issue is raised before or during trial, both sides may present evidence, and the judge must make findings of fact.[10]

Do I have to admit to the crime to claim entrapment?

No. The Michigan Supreme Court said in Jade that the defendant need not admit the charged crime to assert the defense.[1] Testimony given at the entrapment hearing is inadmissible in the prosecution's case-in-chief for any purpose except impeachment.[1] The defendant still bears the burden of proving entrapment by a preponderance of the evidence.[1]

Is it entrapment if an undercover officer offered to buy drugs from me?

Not by itself. Michigan courts have held that police presenting a defendant with an opportunity to commit a crime is insufficient for entrapment, and that deceptive methods are allowed so long as they do not manufacture criminal behavior.[5] The question is whether police went further, using tactics that could have induced a hypothetical law-abiding person to commit the offense, or conduct so reprehensible it cannot be tolerated.[2]

What happens if the judge finds entrapment?

If the trial court concludes the defendant was entrapped, the case must be dismissed and the defendant discharged.[10] Under the Jade test, a defendant is entitled to dismissal if either the inducement prong or the reprehensible-conduct prong is satisfied.[2] If the judge rejects the claim, the case continues.

How is the federal entrapment defense different?

Federal courts use a predisposition test. The US Supreme Court has said a valid federal entrapment defense has two elements, government inducement and a lack of predisposition, and that entrapment is generally a question for the jury.[4] Once inducement is at issue, the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was disposed to commit the act before agents first approached.[11]

Sources

  1. People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026), slip op at 4, 19; People v D'Angelo, 401 Mich 167, 177–180, 183 (1977) — michbar.org
  2. People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167920), slip op at 2–3; People v Johnson, 466 Mich 491, 498 (2002); People v Turner, 390 Mich 7, 20–22 (1973) — michbar.org
  3. People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167920), slip op at 17–18; People v Turner, 390 Mich 7, 20–22 (1973); United States v Russell, 411 US 423 (1973) — michbar.org
  4. Mathews v United States, 485 US 58 (1988) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  5. People v Fyda, 288 Mich App 446, 456, 460 (2010); People v Vansickle, 303 Mich App 111, 113–117 (2013) — Michigan Courts
  6. People v Juillet, 439 Mich 34, 53–54 (1991) — Michigan Courts
  7. People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026), slip op at 4, 24; People v Johnson, 466 Mich 491, 498–499 (2002) — michbar.org
  8. People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167920), slip op at 1, 31 — michbar.org
  9. People v Akhmedov, 297 Mich App 745, 754–756 (2012) — Michigan Courts
  10. People v D'Angelo, 401 Mich 167, 177–178, 183–184 (1977); People v Juillet, 439 Mich 34, 61 (1991) — Michigan Courts
  11. Jacobson v United States, 503 US 540 (1992) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  12. People v Woods, 241 Mich App 545, 548–549, 558 (2000); People v Zitka, 325 Mich App 38, 52 (2018) — Michigan Courts

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.