Key points
- Evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment is generally inadmissible in a criminal case, but there are exceptions and situations where the exclusionary rule does not apply.[1]
- Only a person whose own rights were violated can seek suppression, and that person has the burden of showing a reasonable, personal expectation of privacy.[2]
- When police searched without a warrant, it is the prosecutor's burden to justify the search.[3]
- Michigan adopted the good-faith exception in People v Goldston in 2004, so evidence from a defective warrant may still be used if officers relied on it in objectively reasonable good faith.[4]
- In a felony case, either side can seek leave to appeal a ruling on evidence before trial, and the trial court generally must pause the case while the application is pending.[5][6]
A motion to suppress asks the judge to keep evidence out of the case because police obtained it unlawfully. The starting rule is that evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment is generally inadmissible as substantive evidence in a criminal case, but there are exceptions and situations where the exclusionary rule does not apply.[1] The motion generally must be made before trial.[7]
This page explains who can bring the motion, who must prove what, how hearings work, and the exceptions that limit suppression. Whether a particular search was lawful is covered in the search pages, starting with search and seizure in drug cases.
What a motion to suppress can reach
The exclusionary rule covers evidence and observations from an unconstitutional search, and also evidence and testimony that are the indirect products of it, known as "fruit of the poisonous tree."[8] Its purpose is to deter police misconduct.[8]
Statements are challenged too. A statement taken in violation of Miranda or involuntarily can be challenged at what Michigan courts call a Walker hearing, where the prosecution bears the burden of showing the confession is admissible.[9] Statements made during an unlawful detention must be suppressed unless the connection is broken, and in People v Sanders (2026) the Michigan Supreme Court applied that rule to statements made while a person was held without a prompt judicial probable cause determination.[10][11] See Miranda rights in drug cases.
Standing: whose rights were violated?
A defendant may use the exclusionary rule only if his or her own Fourth Amendment rights were violated; there is "no automatic standing."[2] The person attacking the search has the burden of showing that his or her reasonable and personal expectation of privacy was infringed.[2]
Two examples show how this works. The US Supreme Court has held that an overnight guest is protected against unreasonable searches of the host's home, and in People v Mahdi (2016) the Court of Appeals found that a defendant who lived in his mother's apartment and could control the area searched had a legitimate expectation of privacy there.[12] Searches of shared cars and homes are discussed further in vehicle searches and home searches.
Who must prove what
| Situation | The rule |
|---|---|
| Search without a warrant | "It is the prosecutor's burden to justify a warrantless search."[3] |
| Search with a warrant | The affidavit supporting the warrant is presumed valid.[13] |
| Claim that the affidavit was false | The defendant must show by a preponderance of the evidence that the affiant knowingly and intentionally, or with reckless disregard for the truth, included false material necessary to the probable cause finding; the same rule applies to material omissions.[14] |
| Claim of an invalid Miranda waiver | The prosecution must prove a voluntary, knowing and intelligent waiver by a preponderance of the evidence.[9] |
| Standing | The defendant must show his or her own reasonable expectation of privacy.[2] |
Challenging a warrant affidavit: Franks and veracity hearings
A defendant is entitled to an evidentiary hearing to show that a warrant affidavit is void after making "a substantial preliminary showing of a deliberate falsehood or reckless disregard for the truth by the affiant," and that takes "more than a mere desire to cross examine."[13] This is called a Franks hearing, after Franks v Delaware.[13] The Michigan Supreme Court has also held that a trial judge has discretion to hold a hearing on the truthfulness of an affidavit even without the substantial preliminary showing Franks requires.[15]
If the defendant proves the falsehood, the court sets aside the false material, and the warrant is still valid "if enough substance remains to support a finding of probable cause."[14] When only part of a warrant is invalid, courts sever the tainted portion and keep evidence validly seized under the rest.[16] Informant-based affidavits have their own rules, covered in confidential informants and drug search warrants.
Timing and the hearing
- Before trial. Generally, a motion to suppress must be made in advance of trial, and the court need not allow an untimely motion when the facts were known to the defendant beforehand.[7]
- An evidentiary hearing. A defendant is generally entitled to an evidentiary hearing when admissibility is challenged on constitutional grounds, but no hearing is required where the defendant fails to give factual support for the claim.[7]
- The preliminary exam record. If the parties agree, the motion may be decided on the transcript of the preliminary examination.[7]
- The defendant's testimony. If the defendant testifies at the suppression hearing, that testimony is not admissible at trial on the question of guilt.[7]
- The judge decides. The court decides whether evidence is admissible, and in doing so is not bound by the rules of evidence except those on privilege.[17]
Exceptions that limit suppression
Suppression does not follow automatically from a violation; it turns on the culpability of the police and whether exclusion would deter wrongful police conduct.[8] The main exceptions and limits are:
- Good faith. Michigan adopted the good-faith exception in People v Goldston (2004): evidence obtained through a defective warrant is admissible when officers relied on the warrant in objective good faith.[4] The decision is reported at 470 Mich 523.[4]
- When good faith does not apply. Reliance is not reasonable if the magistrate was misled by information the affiant knew was false or would have known was false but for reckless disregard of the truth, if the magistrate wholly abandoned the judicial role, if the affidavit was "bare bones," or if the warrant was so facially deficient that officers could not reasonably presume it valid.[18]
- An officer's own legal mistake. In People v Lucynski (2024), the Michigan Supreme Court said that a seizure based on an officer's unreasonable interpretation of the law warrants exclusion, and that the good-faith exception typically applies where the officer's conduct results from someone else's error.[19]
- Inevitable discovery. Tainted evidence may be admitted if the prosecution proves by a preponderance of the evidence that it would inevitably have been found without the misconduct, but the doctrine cannot excuse a warrantless search merely because police had probable cause and could have gotten a warrant.[20]
- Independent source. Evidence seized under a valid warrant issued after an unlawful entry is admissible when the probable cause came from information independent of the entry.[21]
- Attenuation. Courts weigh how close in time the discovery followed the illegality, any intervening circumstances, and, particularly, the purpose and flagrancy of the misconduct.[22]
- Knock-and-announce. In Hudson v Michigan (2006), a case from Michigan, the US Supreme Court held that the exclusionary rule does not apply to violations of the knock-and-announce requirement.[23]
- Statutory violations. For a violation of a statute rather than the Constitution, exclusion "is not the go-to, or default, remedy."[24] The Michigan Supreme Court has held that neither a failure to meet the informant requirements of MCL 780.653 nor a technical violation of the warrant-return statute, MCL 780.655, by itself requires suppression.[25][26]
Michigan's Constitution contains a clause on this subject, but its effect is limited. Article 1, § 11 says it shall not be construed to bar from evidence "any narcotic drug, firearm, bomb, explosive or any other dangerous weapon, seized by a peace officer outside the curtilage of any dwelling house," and the Michigan Supreme Court reads that clause as restricting the exclusionary rule for those items unless the federal constitution requires exclusion.[27] The Legislature's annotation to the section also notes that this sentence was held invalid as conflicting with the Fourth Amendment in decisions from 1969 and 1970.[28] Either way, the clause does not allow evidence that the Fourth Amendment requires to be excluded.[27]
After the judge rules
Either side can seek review before trial. In felony cases, under MCR 6.126, when the court decides the admissibility of evidence and the prosecutor or the defendant files an application for leave to appeal, the court must stay the case while the Court of Appeals decides the application, unless it finds the evidence clearly cumulative or the appeal frivolous.[5][6] If the prosecutor appeals and the defendant is in jail, the defendant may ask the court to reconsider pretrial release.[5]
Under MCL 770.12, if double jeopardy would not bar further proceedings, the prosecution may appeal by leave from a circuit court order that is not a final judgment, and of right from a final judgment or order.[29] On appeal, the trial court's findings of fact are reviewed for clear error and its final ruling on the motion is reviewed de novo.[7]
The same procedures appear in other kinds of cases; the drunk driving guide explains motions to suppress in OWI cases. How suppression fits with other defenses is surveyed in defenses to drug charges, and where the motion falls in the timeline is shown in the drug case court process.
Common questions
When does a motion to suppress have to be filed?
Generally, a motion to suppress evidence must be made before trial, and a court need not allow a late motion when the facts behind it were known to the defendant beforehand and could have been raised.[7] A defendant is generally entitled to an evidentiary hearing on a constitutional challenge that is supported by facts, and the parties may agree to decide the motion on the preliminary examination transcript.[7]
Who has to prove whether the search was legal?
It depends on the search. The person challenging a search must first show that his or her own reasonable expectation of privacy was infringed.[2] For a search without a warrant, the Michigan Supreme Court has said it is the prosecutor's burden to justify it.[3] For a search with a warrant, the affidavit is presumed valid, and a defendant attacking it as false must prove the falsehood by a preponderance of the evidence.[13][14]
If the warrant was defective, is the evidence automatically thrown out?
No. Under the good-faith exception Michigan adopted in People v Goldston (2004), evidence obtained through a defective warrant is admissible if the officers relied on it in objective good faith.[4] That reliance is not reasonable if the magistrate was misled by knowing or reckless falsehoods, abandoned the judicial role, or issued the warrant on a bare-bones affidavit, or if the warrant is so facially deficient that officers could not reasonably presume it valid.[18]
Can I challenge a search of someone else's car or home?
Only if the search violated your own rights; there is no automatic standing.[2] The US Supreme Court has held that an overnight guest is protected against unreasonable searches of the host's home, and the Court of Appeals found that a defendant who lived in his mother's apartment and could control the area searched had a legitimate expectation of privacy there.[12]
Can the prosecutor appeal if the judge suppresses the evidence?
Yes, within limits. If double jeopardy would not bar further proceedings, the prosecution may appeal by leave from a circuit court order that is not a final judgment, and of right from a final order.[29] In a felony case, when either side files an application for leave to appeal an evidence ruling, the trial court must stay the case unless the evidence is clearly cumulative or the appeal frivolous, and a jailed defendant may ask the court to reconsider release.[5][6]
Sources
- In re Forfeiture of $176,598, 443 Mich 261, 265 (1993); Mapp v Ohio, 367 US 643 (1961); People v Hellstrom, 264 Mich App 187, 193–194 n 3 (2004) — Michigan Courts
- United States v Salvucci, 448 US 83, 85 (1980); People v Smith, 420 Mich 1, 28 (1984); People v Nash, 418 Mich 196, 204–205 (1983) — Michigan Courts
- People v Armstrong, ___ Mich ___ (2025), slip op at 11 — Michigan Courts
- People v Goldston, 470 Mich 523, 528–537 (2004); People v DeRousse, 341 Mich App 447, 465 (2022); United States v Leon, 468 US 897 (1984) — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.126 — Michigan Courts
- MCR 6.001(A), (B) — Michigan Courts
- People v Ferguson, 376 Mich 90, 93–95 (1965); People v Reynolds, 93 Mich App 516, 519 (1979); People v Johnson, 202 Mich App 281, 285 (1993); People v Kaufman, 457 Mich 266, 276 (1998); People v Walker (On Rehearing), 374 Mich 331, 338 (1965); People v Jones, 279 Mich App 86, 90 (2008) — Michigan Courts
- People v Bogucki, ___ Mich App ___ (2025); People v Lucynski (Lucynski III), ___ Mich ___ (2024); Herring v United States, 555 US 135 (2009) — Michigan Courts
- People v Walker (On Rehearing), 374 Mich 331, 338 (1965); Brown v Illinois, 422 US 590, 604 (1975); People v Daoud, 462 Mich 621, 634 (2000); Colorado v Connelly, 479 US 157, 168 (1986) — Michigan Courts
- People v Lewis, 160 Mich App 20, 25 (1987); People v Mallory, 421 Mich 229, 243 n 8 (1984) — Michigan Courts
- People v Sanders, ___ Mich ___ (2026); Riverside v McLaughlin, 500 US 44, 56 (1991) — Michigan Courts
- Minnesota v Olson, 495 US 91, 96–97 (1990); People v Mahdi, 317 Mich App 446, 460 (2016) — Michigan Courts
- People v Mullen, 282 Mich App 14, 23 (2008); Franks v Delaware, 438 US 154, 155–156 (1978); People v Bogucki, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
- People v Stumpf, 196 Mich App 218, 224 (1992); People v Kolniak, 175 Mich App 16, 22 (1989) — Michigan Courts
- People v Franklin, 500 Mich 92, 95, 110–111 (2017) — Michigan Courts
- People v Kolniak, 175 Mich App 16, 22–23 (1989) — Michigan Courts
- MRE 104(a); MRE 1101(b)(1) — Michigan Courts
- People v Czuprynski, 325 Mich App 449, 470–472 (2018); United States v Leon, 468 US 897, 923 (1984); People v Goldston, 470 Mich 523, 531 (2004); People v Bogucki, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
- People v Lucynski (Lucynski III), ___ Mich ___ (2024) — Michigan Courts
- People v Stevens (After Remand), 460 Mich 626, 637–638 (1999); Nix v Williams, 467 US 431, 443–444 (1984); People v Hyde, 285 Mich App 428, 442, 445 (2009) — Michigan Courts
- Murray v United States, 487 US 533, 537 (1988); People v Smith, 191 Mich App 644, 646 (1991); People v Bogucki, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
- Utah v Strieff, 579 US 232, 238–239 (2016); Brown v Illinois, 422 US 590, 603–604 (1975); People v Reese, 281 Mich App 290, 299 (2008) — Michigan Courts
- Hudson v Michigan, 547 US 586, 594, 599–600 (2006) — Michigan Courts
- People v Mazzie, 326 Mich App 279, 290 (2018); see also People v Hawkins, 468 Mich 488 (2003) (D-023), People v Sobczak-Obetts, 463 Mich 687 (2001) (D-035) — Michigan Courts
- People v Hawkins, 468 Mich 488, 510, 512 (2003) — Michigan Courts
- People v Sobczak-Obetts, 463 Mich 687, 712–713 (2001); People v Garvin, 235 Mich App 90, 99 (1999) — Michigan Courts
- Const 1963, art 1, § 11; People v Goldston, 470 Mich 523, 537–538 (2004) — Michigan Courts
- Const 1963, art 1, § 11 (History and Constitutionality notes as published by the Michigan Legislature) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 770.12(1)(a), (2)(a) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.