SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Paraphernalia, overdose protections and related charges

Michigan's Overdose Good Samaritan Law

Key points

  • A person who seeks medical help for his or her own drug overdose or other perceived medical emergency, or is brought for help while incapacitated by one, and a person who in good faith seeks help for someone else in that situation or goes with that person to a health facility, are not in violation of Michigan's drug possession or use statutes for personal-use amounts when the evidence comes from seeking that help.[1][2][3]
  • Seeking medical assistance means reporting an overdose or other medical emergency to law enforcement, 9-1-1, a poison control center or a medical provider, or helping someone report it.[4]
  • The protection does not prevent investigation, arrest, charging or prosecution for any other crime, such as delivery, and is not a ground to suppress evidence in those cases.[5][6][7]
  • Since 4 January 2017 the law covers people of all ages and all controlled substances; the first version, in effect from 15 March 2016, covered only people under 21 and overdoses from prescription drugs that are controlled substances.[8][9]
  • The Court of Appeals has held that the person must raise the exemption as an affirmative defense with prima facie evidence, that personal use means what that person regularly takes, and that whether there was an overdose is judged by the person's condition when 911 was called.[10][11][12]

Michigan's overdose Good Samaritan law says that a person who seeks medical help for his or her own drug overdose or other perceived medical emergency, or is brought for help while incapacitated by one, and a person who in good faith seeks help for someone else in that situation or goes with that person to a health facility, are not in violation of the drug possession or use statutes for an amount sufficient only for personal use when the evidence was obtained because help was sought.[1][2][3] It does not shield anyone from other charges, such as delivery, and it is not a ground to suppress evidence in those cases.[5][6][7]

If someone may be overdosing, the first step is to call 911. The law described on this page is built around that kind of call: reporting an overdose to the 9-1-1 system counts as seeking medical assistance.[4]

Who is protected?

The protection appears in two places: the possession statute, MCL 333.7403(3), and the use statute, MCL 333.7404(3).[1][3] Each one lists two kinds of people who "are not in violation" of that section.[3]

PersonWhen the protection applies
The person who needs helpSeeks medical help for himself or herself, or is incapacitated and is presented for help by someone else, because of a drug overdose or other perceived medical emergency from using a controlled substance or analogue[1]
The person who helpsIn good faith tries to get medical help for another person, or goes with that person to a health facility or agency[2]

For both, two more conditions apply. The drugs must have been an amount sufficient only for personal use, and the evidence of the violation must have been obtained as a result of seeking, or being presented for, medical help.[1][2]

Key terms in the statute

  • "Seeks medical assistance" means reporting a drug overdose or other medical emergency to law enforcement, the 9-1-1 system, a poison control center or a medical provider, or helping someone report one.[4]
  • "Drug overdose" means a condition such as extreme physical illness, decreased consciousness, respiratory depression, coma, mania or death that results from using a controlled substance or analogue (or a substance it was combined with), or a condition that a layperson would reasonably believe to be a drug overdose that requires medical assistance.[13]
  • "An amount sufficient only for personal use" is not defined by a number in the statute; the Court of Appeals has held that it is decided case by case, as explained below.[10]

What the law does not cover

The statute states that the exemption does not prevent the investigation, arrest, charging or prosecution of a person for any other violation of Michigan law, and that it is not grounds to suppress evidence when other charges are prosecuted.[5] The use statute contains the same limit.[6]

  • Delivery and possession with intent to deliver are separate crimes under MCL 333.7401.[14] See drug delivery charges.
  • Delivering a schedule 1 or 2 drug other than marijuana that is consumed and causes a death is a separate felony punishable by up to life; see drug delivery causing death.[15][7]
  • Amounts larger than personal use fall outside the protection, even for the person who overdosed.[10]
  • Probation, parole and bond: sections 7403 and 7404 do not say whether conduct covered by the exemption can still be treated as a violation of probation, parole or bond conditions; their only mention of probation concerns discharge from lifetime probation imposed under the pre-2003 possession tiers.[16]

How Michigan courts have applied it

People v Morrison (2019): personal use and the burden

The Court of Appeals held that "an amount sufficient only for personal use" requires a factual decision about what amount a specific person regularly takes, based on that person's own habits.[10] If the person had an amount he or she would regularly take, the law protects the person; if the amount was larger, it does not.[10]

The court also held that the defendant has the burden to raise the Good Samaritan exemption as an affirmative defense by presenting prima facie evidence of its elements.[11] If the defendant does so, whether the amount of Xanax in that case was sufficient only for personal use is a question of fact for the jury; if not, the court decides the issue as a question of law.[11]

People v Meeker (2022): two separate protections

On remand from the Michigan Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals held that subsection (3)(a) applies to the person who overdosed and subsection (3)(b) to a separate person who seeks help, and that the helper's "good faith" is not a factor in deciding whether the person who overdosed was incapacitated.[17] The court found the defendant incapacitated even though body camera video showed him conscious and minimally responsive, because he was impaired and unfit for normal functioning; he had 0.38 grams of methamphetamine for personal use.[18]

People v Duha (2023): the moment of the 911 call

The Court of Appeals said the question is whether the person's condition, at the time 911 was called, was one that a layperson would reasonably believe to be a drug overdose requiring medical assistance.[12] The statute requires that the person needed medical assistance when presented for it, not that the person actually received treatment, and the fact that the defendant eventually woke up was irrelevant.[12]

Minors and parental notice

Each health facility or agency must develop a process for notifying the parent, guardian or custodian of an unemancipated minor under 18 who comes in, or is brought in while incapacitated, for emergency treatment under the Good Samaritan provisions.[19] A facility may not notify a parent about nonemergency treatment without the minor's consent.[19] Families can find more on the parents' guide to teen drug charges.

When police or medics come into a home

Separate from the Good Samaritan law, Michigan courts allow a police officer or firefighter to enter a home without a warrant when it is reasonable to believe someone inside needs immediate medical assistance.[20] How that rule fits with drug searches is covered on home searches in drug cases.

How the law changed

LawEffectiveWhat it covered
2015 PA 22015 March 2016People under 21, and overdoses from a prescription drug that is a controlled substance or analogue[8]
2016 PA 307 and 3084 January 2017People of any age, and overdoses from any controlled substance or analogue[9]

Other changes over time are listed on the drug law changes timeline.

Naloxone and the Good Samaritan law

A related set of laws covers naloxone, the opioid overdose reversal drug. A person who administers an opioid antagonist to someone he or she believes is suffering an opioid-related overdose, acting in good faith and with reasonable care, is immune from criminal prosecution for that act under a separate statute.[21] Those rules are covered on naloxone (Narcan) laws, and treatment-related protections on seeking drug treatment.

What people commonly get wrong

  • "Calling 911 makes everyone immune from everything": the exemption covers possession and use for personal-use amounts, and other charges remain possible.[5][6][7]
  • "It only protects people under 21": that was the version in effect from 15 March 2016; since 4 January 2017 it covers all ages.[8][9]
  • "If the person woke up before help arrived, the law does not apply": the court in Duha judged whether there was an overdose by the person's condition when 911 was called, and called his eventually waking up irrelevant.[12]

Common questions

If I call 911 for a friend who is overdosing, can I be charged with possession?

Someone who in good faith seeks medical help for another person who is having a drug overdose or other perceived medical emergency, or goes with that person to a health facility, is not in violation of the possession or use statutes for a personal-use amount found because of the call or the trip.[2][3] If a charge is filed anyway, the Court of Appeals has held that the person must raise the exemption as an affirmative defense with prima facie evidence of its elements.[11] The protection does not cover other crimes, so a delivery charge, for example, is still possible.[5][6][7]

Does the person who overdosed also get protection?

Yes, under a separate subsection. A person who seeks medical help for himself or herself, or who needs help and is brought in by someone else because he or she is incapacitated by an overdose or perceived medical emergency, is covered for personal-use amounts.[1] The Court of Appeals has held that whether the person who overdosed was incapacitated does not turn on the good faith of the person who sought help.[17]

Does the person have to be unconscious for the law to apply?

No. In People v Meeker the Court of Appeals held that a man who was conscious and minimally responsive, but impaired and unfit for normal functioning, was incapacitated.[18] In People v Duha the court said the question is how the condition looked when 911 was called, and that the person eventually waking up was irrelevant.[12]

How much is an amount sufficient only for personal use?

The statute does not give a number. The Court of Appeals held in People v Morrison that it depends on what amount that specific person regularly takes, decided case by case.[10] If the amount is larger than what the person would regularly consume, the protection does not apply, and when the defendant presents prima facie evidence the question goes to the jury.[10][11]

Will a hospital tell a teenager's parents after an overdose?

Michigan requires each health facility or agency to develop a process for notifying the parent, guardian or custodian of an unemancipated minor under 18 who is treated for an emergency under this law.[19] The facility may not notify the parent about nonemergency treatment without the minor's consent.[19]

Sources

  1. MCL 333.7403(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 333.7403(3)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 333.7404(3)(a)-(b) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCL 333.7403(7)(b); MCL 333.7404(6)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  5. MCL 333.7403(5); MCL 333.7404(5) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 333.7404(5) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 333.7403(3), (5) — Michigan Legislature
  8. 2015 PA 220, amending MCL 333.7403(3) and 333.7404(3) — Michigan Legislature
  9. 2016 PA 307; 2016 PA 308; MCL 333.7403(3), 333.7404(3) — Michigan Legislature
  10. People v Morrison, 328 Mich App 647, 652 (2019) — Michigan Courts
  11. People v Morrison, 328 Mich App 647, 653-655 (2019) — Michigan Courts
  12. People v Duha, ___ Mich App ___ (2023) (Docket No. 363115, decided 14 December 2023; reported as 349 Mich App 317 per the MJI benchbook) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCL 333.7403(7)(a); MCL 333.7404(6)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 333.7401(1) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 750.317a — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 333.7403, 333.7404 (full text) — Michigan Legislature
  17. People v Meeker (On Remand), 340 Mich App 559, 565-568 (2022) — Michigan Courts
  18. People v Meeker (On Remand), 340 Mich App 559, 569-570 (2022) — Michigan Courts
  19. MCL 333.7403(4); MCL 333.7404(4) — Michigan Legislature
  20. People v Slaughter, 489 Mich 302, 316–317 (2011); People v Davis, 442 Mich 1, 14 (1993); City of Troy v Ohlinger, 438 Mich 477, 483–484 (1991) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCL 333.17744c — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.