SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Informants, lab evidence and defenses

Controlled Buys in Michigan Drug Cases: What Courts Have Said

Key points

  • Delivery under Michigan law means an actual, constructive or attempted transfer of a controlled substance; the definition does not mention a sale or payment.[1]
  • There is no bright-line rule on how old a controlled buy can be before it is stale for a search warrant, and Michigan cases have found a single buy three days earlier stale on its facts.[2][3]
  • The Michigan Supreme Court held that police may record a defendant's conversations with an informant, with the informant's consent but no warrant, without violating the state or federal constitution.[4]
  • The Court of Appeals has held that a defendant's separate deliveries on different occasions may not be added together to support a conviction for a larger amount than any single delivery.[5]
  • Police merely offering an opportunity to commit a drug crime is not entrapment, though the courts look closely at inducement and escalation.[6][7]

A controlled buy is a drug purchase arranged and watched by police, made by an informant or an undercover officer. Michigan courts have addressed controlled buys in two main settings: as support for a search warrant, where timing matters, and as evidence of a delivery charge, where the prosecutor must still prove each element.[3][8]

This page summarizes what the statutes and courts say about that evidence. It does not describe how investigations are run, and it does not suggest ways to avoid one.

What the prosecutor must prove for delivery

For the person accused of selling, the offense at issue is delivery. Under MCL 333.7105(1), "delivery" means "the actual, constructive, or attempted transfer from 1 person to another of a controlled substance, whether or not there is an agency relationship."[1] The definition speaks of a transfer and does not mention a sale or payment.[1]

Under Michigan's model jury instruction, the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt:[8]

  1. That the defendant delivered the named controlled substance.[8]
  2. That the defendant knew he or she delivered a controlled substance.[8]
  3. For a schedule 1 or 2 narcotic or cocaine, that the substance or mixture weighed the amount charged.[8]

Because the statutory definition includes an attempted transfer, attempted delivery is not a separate lesser offense.[9] The instruction committee notes that, under McFadden v United States (2015), the prosecutor need not prove the defendant intended to deliver any particular controlled substance, only some controlled substance.[10] The amount is an element of a delivery offense, but knowledge of the amount is not.[11] The charges themselves are covered in drug delivery charges.

Can several buys be added together?

Weight is an element of schedule 1 or 2 narcotic and cocaine delivery charges, so this question matters.[8] In People v Collins (2012), the Court of Appeals held that a defendant's deliveries of 0.5 to 28 grams of heroin "on separate occasions may not be aggregated" to support a conviction for delivering 50 grams or more.[5] The weight tiers are explained in drug weight thresholds.

Controlled buys and search warrants

Police may rely on a controlled buy in an affidavit for a search warrant. When the information comes from an informant, MCL 780.653 requires facts showing personal knowledge and, for an unnamed informant, either credibility or reliability.[12] Credibility can be shown by corroboration of non-innocent details through police investigation, among other ways.[13] The informant rules are on the confidential informants page.

How old is too old?

There is "no bright-line rule" on how much time may pass between gathering the facts and presenting the affidavit, but the time "should not be too remote," and the test "is a flexible and reasonable one depending on the facts and circumstances of the particular case."[2] Two older Court of Appeals cases found drug information stale:[3]

  • People v David (1982): an affidavit alleging a single controlled buy three days before the warrant, with nothing to suggest the defendant would still have the marijuana when the warrant was executed.[3]
  • People v Broilo (1975): an affidavit alleging drug sales to an undercover officer more than a month before the warrant.[3]

Those results turned on their facts. A different standard applies to people on supervision: in People v Hines (2025), an informant's purchase from a parolee three weeks before his arrest supported a parole search under the "special needs" exception, which the court said "can be a low hurdle."[14] See probation and parole searches.

Anticipatory warrants

Some warrants are issued before the evidence arrives. In People v Kaslowski (2000), the Court of Appeals upheld an anticipatory warrant that let officers deliver a parcel containing drugs, and the US Supreme Court has held that anticipatory warrants do not violate the Fourth Amendment's warrant clause.[15]

A defendant who believes an affidavit misstated what happened during a buy can seek a hearing on a "substantial preliminary showing of a deliberate falsehood or reckless disregard for the truth."[16] See drug search warrants.

Recordings of conversations with an informant

In People v Collins (1991), the Michigan Supreme Court addressed recorded conversations between a defendant and a police informant, monitored with the informant's consent but without a warrant.[4] It found it "well settled" that such participant monitoring does not offend the Fourth Amendment, declined to read the Michigan Constitution more strictly, and overruled People v Beavers (1975).[4] The US Supreme Court has likewise held that there is no reasonable expectation of privacy in statements made to an undercover informant.[17]

The court rule on discovery, which applies in misdemeanor as well as felony cases, requires the prosecutor, on request, to provide any written or recorded statements by the defendant pertaining to the case, along with police reports and any agreement for testimony.[18][19]

Informant testimony and related evidence at trial

When an informant who took part in a buy testifies, the jury may be given cautionary instructions. Michigan's addict-informer instruction tells jurors to examine an addicted informer's testimony closely and consider whether other evidence supports it, and an instruction on agreements for testimony limits how jurors use a witness's deal with the prosecutor.[20][21]

When the informant does not testify, an officer may describe the informant's tip to explain how and why police acted, but not to prove the tip true.[22]

Evidence of earlier deals raises its own issues. In People v Plomb (2025), an informant who took part in a controlled buy testified, after defense questions, that he had bought drugs from the defendant before.[23] The Court of Appeals held that asking an informant with a history of methamphetamine use and possession how he was familiar with methamphetamine did not open the door to the defendant's prior bad acts, and that the trial court erred by not meaningfully assessing that evidence under MRE 403 and 404, although the defendant could not show a different outcome was more probable without it.[23]

How the substance from a buy is identified at trial is covered in drug lab testing and chain of custody.

Is a controlled buy entrapment?

A controlled buy is not entrapment just because police set it up. The Court of Appeals has said that police presenting a defendant with the opportunity to commit the crime is insufficient to support a finding of entrapment, and that officials may use deceptive methods so long as they do not manufacture criminal behavior.[6] In People v Vansickle (2013), officers posing as patients at a dispensary "merely provided [the defendant] with an opportunity to commit the crime," without appeals to sympathy, unusual inducements or pressure.[6]

Michigan's test still asks real questions about police conduct. Under People v Jade (2026), a court considers whether police tactics could have induced a hypothetical law-abiding person in the defendant's circumstances, not otherwise ready and willing, to commit the crime, or whether the conduct was so reprehensible it cannot be tolerated.[24] The listed factors include whether there was police control over an informant and whether government procedures tended to escalate the defendant's criminal culpability.[7] An informant's conduct counts as police conduct only if there is a sufficient agency relationship.[25]

Federal law takes a different approach, but it too allows an agent to "offer the opportunity to buy or sell drugs, and, if the offer is accepted, make an arrest on the spot or later."[26] The full test is on the entrapment defense page, and the general rules for excluding evidence are in motions to suppress.

Common questions

Is one controlled buy enough to get a search warrant?

It depends on the facts and on timing. There is no bright-line rule on how old the information may be; the test is flexible and depends on the case.[2] In People v David (1982), an affidavit describing a single controlled buy three days earlier was stale because nothing suggested the defendant would still have the marijuana.[3] An affidavit relying on an informant must also meet MCL 780.653.[12]

Can police record my conversations with an informant without a warrant?

In People v Collins (1991), the Michigan Supreme Court held that police electronic monitoring of conversations between a defendant and a police informant, done with the informant's consent but without a warrant, does not violate the Fourth Amendment or the Michigan Constitution, and it overruled an earlier case that had required a warrant.[4]

Does it count as delivery if no money changed hands?

Michigan defines delivery as the actual, constructive or attempted transfer of a controlled substance from one person to another, whether or not there is an agency relationship; the definition does not mention payment.[1] The jury instruction requires proof that the defendant delivered the substance and knew it was a controlled substance, plus the weight for schedule 1 or 2 narcotic and cocaine charges.[8]

Is it entrapment if police set up the buy?

Not by itself. Police presenting a person with the opportunity to commit a crime is not enough for entrapment, and deceptive methods are allowed so long as they do not manufacture criminal behavior.[6] Under People v Jade (2026), a court asks whether police tactics could have induced a hypothetical law-abiding person to commit the offense, or whether police conduct was so reprehensible it cannot be tolerated.[24]

Can several small buys be combined into one larger weight charge?

In People v Collins (2012), the Court of Appeals held that a defendant's deliveries of 0.5 to 28 grams of heroin on separate occasions could not be aggregated to support a conviction for delivering 50 grams or more.[5] The amount is an element of a delivery offense, though the prosecutor need not prove the defendant knew the amount.[11]

Sources

  1. MCL 333.7105(1) — Michigan Legislature
  2. People v Mushlock, 226 Mich 600, 602 (1924); People v Smyers, 47 Mich App 61, 73 (1973); United States v Frechette, 583 F3d 374, 378 (CA 6, 2009) — Michigan Courts
  3. People v David, 119 Mich App 289, 296 (1982); People v Broilo, 58 Mich App 547, 550–552 (1975) — Michigan Courts
  4. People v Collins, 438 Mich 8 (1991), overruling People v Beavers, 393 Mich 554 (1975) — Caselaw Access Project
  5. People v Collins, 298 Mich App 458, 463 (2012) — Caselaw Access Project
  6. People v Fyda, 288 Mich App 446, 456, 460 (2010); People v Vansickle, 303 Mich App 111, 113–117 (2013) — Michigan Courts
  7. People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026), slip op at 4, 24; People v Johnson, 466 Mich 491, 498–499 (2002) — michbar.org
  8. M Crim JI 12.2 — Michigan Courts
  9. M Crim JI 12.2 and Use Note; MCL 333.7105(1) — Michigan Courts
  10. M Crim JI 12.2, Use Note; McFadden v United States, 576 US 186 (2015) — Michigan Courts
  11. People v Mass, 464 Mich 615, 626–627 (2001) — Caselaw Access Project
  12. MCL 780.653(a), (b) — Michigan Legislature
  13. People v Sherbine, 421 Mich 502, 510 n 13, 511 n 16 (1984), overruled on other grounds by People v Hawkins, 468 Mich 488 (2003) — Michigan Courts
  14. People v Hines, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
  15. People v Kaslowski, 239 Mich App 320, 324–329 (2000); United States v Grubbs, 547 US 90, 94–95, 99 (2006) — Michigan Courts
  16. People v Mullen, 282 Mich App 14, 23 (2008); Franks v Delaware, 438 US 154, 155–156 (1978); People v Bogucki, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
  17. United States v White, 401 US 745, 751–753 (1971); Smith v Maryland, 442 US 735 (1979); United States v Miller, 425 US 435 (1976); Carpenter v United States, 585 US 296, 309–310 (2018); Chatrie v United States, 609 US ___ (2026) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCR 6.201(C), (G), (I) — Michigan Courts
  19. MCR 6.610(E) — Michigan Courts
  20. M Crim JI 5.7 and Use Note; People v Griffin, 235 Mich App 27, 40 (1999) — Michigan Courts
  21. M Crim JI 5.13 — Michigan Courts
  22. People v Chambers, 277 Mich App 1, 11 (2007); People v Henry (After Remand), 305 Mich App 127, 154 (2014) — Michigan Courts
  23. People v Plomb, ___ Mich App ___ (2025) — Michigan Courts
  24. People v Jade, ___ Mich ___ (2026) (Docket No. 167920), slip op at 2–3; People v Johnson, 466 Mich 491, 498 (2002); People v Turner, 390 Mich 7, 20–22 (1973) — michbar.org
  25. People v Akhmedov, 297 Mich App 745, 754–756 (2012) — Michigan Courts
  26. Jacobson v United States, 503 US 540 (1992) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911. For confidential help with alcohol or drug use, the SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.