SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · If you were stopped, cited or charged

Papers to Keep After a Retail Fraud or Theft Charge in Michigan

Key points

  • An appearance ticket is a numbered complaint or written notice directing a named person to appear in a named court at a set time, and the person receives the third copy.[1]
  • A store's civil demand letter is a separate civil claim; the statute's own wording says the civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution.[2][3]
  • A bond order can bar entering specified premises, and a restitution order stays in effect until it is paid in full.[4][5]
  • Years later, a set-aside application needs a certified record of each conviction, so the judgment of sentence, probation order or register of actions matters long after the case ends.[6][7]

A retail fraud or theft case produces papers from four places: the store, the police, the court, and later the Michigan State Police. Each paper rests on a specific rule, and several of them start a clock, such as the civil demand letter's 30 days, which run from the date it was mailed.[8] Keeping every paper in its original form, with the date it arrived, makes the rest of the case easier to follow, whether the case ends in a dismissal, a diversion program or a conviction.

Keep originals exactly as received, including envelopes, and do not alter, discard or clean up anything that could be evidence. Michigan law makes it a felony to knowingly and intentionally remove, alter, conceal, destroy or otherwise tamper with evidence to be offered in a present or future official proceeding.[9]

Papers from the store

PaperWhat it is and the rule behind it
Trespass warning or no-return noticeUnder Michigan's trespass law, entering a store after being forbidden by the owner, occupant or their agent, or staying after being told to leave, is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 30 days and $250.[10][11] The statute turns on having been "forbidden," so a written warning is a record of when and by whom.[10]
Civil demand letterA written demand from the merchant or its agent for the amounts in MCL 600.2953: the retail price of unrecovered or unsalable goods plus civil damages of 10 times the retail price, at least $50 and at most $200.[3][2] It may come by first-class mail, and paying within 30 days after mailing ends further civil liability to the merchant.[3][8]
Statements signed in the storeThe Michigan Supreme Court held in 1982 that store security acting on their own, without police involvement, need not give Miranda warnings before questioning.[12] A copy of anything signed shows what was said and when.

The demand letter is not a court judgment. Its statutory text says the recipient is not required to respond if he or she believes that he or she (or his or her minor child) is not guilty of retail fraud, or chooses not to respond, and warns that if the demand is not met the merchant is authorized to bring a civil action for the amounts plus the cost of the action, including reasonable attorney fees.[3] In that lawsuit the merchant still has to prove the act.[13] The civil demand letter guide and trespass notice guide go further.

Papers from the police

  • Appearance ticket. A numbered complaint or written notice signed by an officer, directing the named person to appear in a named court at a set time; the person gets the third copy.[1] Since April 1, 2021, officers generally must ticket and release for misdemeanors with a maximum of 1 year or less that are not serious misdemeanors, assaultive crimes, domestic violence or drunk driving.[14]
  • Interim bond receipt. If a person arrested without a warrant for a misdemeanor punishable by up to 1 year posts an interim bond with the officer, the officer's supervisor or the jail because no magistrate is available, the person must be given a receipt.[15]
  • Property papers. An officer who seizes property under a search warrant must give the person a copy of the warrant and a list (tabulation) of what was taken, or leave them at the place searched; the property is kept as long as needed as evidence for trial, and stolen or embezzled property is restored to its owner as soon as practicable.[16]
  • Fingerprint and photo instructions. Kent County's 61st and 63rd District Courts say defendants charged with offenses carrying 93 days or more must be photographed and fingerprinted through the Kent County Jail.[17]

The police report matters to the civil side too: a merchant can recover civil demand amounts only if a formal police report alleging retail fraud was filed with the local agency.[18] Missing a court date on a ticket now carries a rebuttable presumption of an order to show cause rather than an arrest warrant, so the ticket's date and court are worth keeping where they can be seen.[19] See appearance tickets for retail fraud.

Papers from the court

  • The charge. At an arraignment on a misdemeanor in district court, the defendant is told the name of the offense and the maximum sentence, and the information may be given in writing that becomes part of the file.[20]
  • Release or bond order. Release on personal recognizance or an unsecured appearance bond is the default, unless the court finds that it will not reasonably ensure appearance or will present a danger to the public.[21] Conditions can include not entering specified premises or areas, and limiting or barring contact with a named person.[4][22]
  • Bond money receipts. If a defendant who posted a cash bond is later ordered to pay the minimum state cost and the crime victim assessment, the court must order them collected out of that bond.[23] When bond is discharged, any fine, costs or restitution the court has ordered are collected out of cash bail the defendant personally deposited.[24]
  • Appointed-lawyer forms. A defendant who asks for a lawyer and says he or she cannot afford one is screened for indigency, by the local appointing authority where one exists and otherwise by the court, and being able to post bond does not make the person ineligible.[25]
  • Written pleas. A district court may allow a not-guilty plea by a signed written statement, and in some cases a written guilty or no-contest plea.[26][27]
  • Plea agreement. In a misdemeanor plea, the court makes the plea agreement part of the record.[28]
  • Presentence report. When one is prepared, the court must give copies to the prosecutor and the defense at least two business days before sentencing.[29]
  • Judgment, probation order and restitution order. Every probation order includes paying restitution, the crime victim assessment and the minimum state cost.[30] Restitution is due immediately unless the court sets a period or installments.[31]
  • Deferral orders. When sentencing is delayed, the court must enter an order stating the reason.[32] A completed HYTA assignment ends with discharge and dismissal.[33]

Courts must make information about fines, costs and assessments imposed under MCL 769.1k available to the defendant, although not the calculation for the particular case.[34] Payment is due when imposed unless the court allows otherwise for good cause.[35] The fines and costs guide and the restitution guide explain the amounts.

Papers that matter years later

Some court papers come back into use long after the case closes:

  • Set-aside applications. An application must include a certified record of each conviction to be set aside and be signed under oath.[6] The State Police instructions name a certified judgment of sentence, probation order or register of actions, sent with fingerprints and a $50 fee.[7]
  • A later charge. In a later retail fraud case, a prior conviction may be proved by a copy of the judgment of conviction, a transcript, a presentence report or the defendant's own statement.[36]
  • Background checks. An employer must give a stand-alone written disclosure and get written permission before ordering a background report, and must give a copy of the report before taking adverse action based on it.[37][38]
  • Dismissals. A dismissal before trial takes the arrest off ICHAT; fingerprints and the arrest record are destroyed if the prosecutor agrees or neither the prosecutor nor the judge objects within 60 days.[39]

For the application itself, see the set-aside application checklist; for record searches, see checking your own record.

Keeping the file usable

A simple system works best. Keep one folder, paper or scanned, with a short log: what each paper is, who sent it, the date it was received and how (handed over, mailed, emailed). Keep envelopes with their letters. Write down the names of the court, the case number and any appointed lawyer's contact details on the inside cover. Make copies before handing anything over, and keep the originals unchanged.

The court's own records can fill gaps: corrections to a criminal history entry go to the agency that reported it, which is the arresting agency for an arrest, the prosecutor for a charge and the court for a court entry.[40] The deadlines calendar and the first-steps checklist show when each paper is likely to arrive.

Common questions

Should I throw away the civil demand letter if I am not paying it?

The letter and its envelope are the record of when the demand was mailed. The letter is a written demand that a merchant or its agent may send by first-class mail, and paying within 30 days after the mailing date ends further civil liability to the merchant.[3][8] The statutory text also says the recipient is not required to respond, and that the civil proceedings do not prevent criminal prosecution.[3] Keeping the letter and envelope preserves the dates.

Can I get a copy of the police report?

On request, the prosecuting attorney must give the defendant any police report and interrogation records concerning the case, except parts covered by limited exceptions such as a continuing investigation.[41] That rule also applies in misdemeanor cases; the separate mutual disclosure list in MCR 6.201(A) (witness names, recorded witness statements and a chance to inspect physical evidence) applies in a misdemeanor case only if the defendant requests it, and then the defense must comply too.[42][43] How quickly papers arrive varies by court and prosecutor.

What paper proves a case was dismissed?

The court's order of dismissal. When charges are dismissed before trial, the arrest record must come off the State Police public ICHAT search, and fingerprints and the arrest record are destroyed if the prosecutor agrees or neither the prosecutor nor the judge objects within 60 days after the order.[39] A copy of that order helps if an old entry still appears.

Why keep payment receipts after the case is over?

A restitution order is a judgment and lien that stays effective until satisfied in full, and the victim or prosecutor can enforce it like a civil judgment.[5] A set-aside does not cancel restitution, and an automatically set-aside conviction can be reinstated if the court finds no good-faith effort to pay it.[44][45] Receipts show what was paid.

Do I need court papers to check my own record later?

Not to search, but they help read the results. The State Police ICHAT search is name-based and costs $10 per search, while a fingerprint-based check of one's own record costs $30 and shows public and nonpublic entries.[46][47] Wrong entries are corrected through the agency that reported them: police, prosecutor or court.[40]

Sources

  1. MCL 764.9f(1) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCR 6.106(D)(2) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCL 780.766(13) — Michigan Legislature
  6. MCL 780.621(1); MCL 780.621d(7) — Michigan Legislature
  7. Michigan State Police, "Conviction Set Aside Public Information" — Michigan State Police
  8. MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 750.483a(5)(a), (6) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 750.552(1)(a)-(b) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 750.552(3) — Michigan Legislature
  12. Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
  13. MCL 600.2953(4) — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 764.9c(4); MCL 764.9c (History: Am. 2020, Act 393, Eff. Apr. 1, 2021) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 780.581(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 780.655(1)-(3) — Michigan Legislature
  17. 61st District Court, Criminal Division; Kent County, 63rd District Court — Criminal; MCL 750.356d(4) — grcourt.org
  18. MCL 600.2953(8) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 764.9e(2); MCL 764.9e (History) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCR 6.610(D)(1) — Michigan Courts
  21. MCR 6.106(B)-(C) — Michigan Courts
  22. MCR 6.106(D)(2)(m) — Michigan Courts
  23. MCL 769.1j(4); MCL 780.905(5) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 765.15(2) — Michigan Legislature
  25. MCR 6.005(A)-(B); MCR 6.001(B) — Michigan Courts
  26. MCR 6.610(D)(4) — Michigan Courts
  27. MCR 6.610(F)(7) — Michigan Courts
  28. MCR 6.610(F)(5)-(6) — Michigan Courts
  29. MCR 6.425(B); MCR 6.610(G)(1)(b) — Michigan Courts
  30. MCL 771.3(1) — Michigan Legislature
  31. MCL 780.766(10) — Michigan Legislature
  32. MCL 771.1(2) — Michigan Legislature
  33. MCL 762.14(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  34. MCL 769.1k(7) — Michigan Legislature
  35. MCR 1.110 — Michigan Courts
  36. MCL 750.356c(4)(a)-(d); MCL 750.356d(7)(a)-(d) — Michigan Legislature
  37. 15 USC 1681b(b)(2)(A) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  38. 15 USC 1681b(b)(3)(A) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  39. MCL 28.243(8) — Michigan Legislature
  40. Michigan State Police, Search, Expunge, Modify, or Update Criminal History Records ("Procedure to correct a criminal history record") — Michigan State Police
  41. MCR 6.201(C)(1)-(5) — Michigan Courts
  42. MCR 6.610(E) — Michigan Courts
  43. MCR 6.201(A)(1)-(6) — Michigan Courts
  44. MCL 780.622(7) — Michigan Legislature
  45. MCL 780.621h(2), (3) — Michigan Legislature
  46. Michigan State Police, "Find out what remains on your record"; Criminal History Records page — Michigan State Police
  47. Michigan State Police, "Find out what remains on your record" — Michigan State Police

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.