SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Civil demand letters and civil liability

Civil Lawsuits for Theft in Michigan: Statutory Conversion and Treble Damages

Key points

  • MCL 600.2919a lets a person damaged by another person's stealing, embezzling or converting property to his or her own use recover 3 times actual damages, plus costs and reasonable attorney fees.[1]
  • The same remedy reaches a person who buys, receives, possesses or conceals stolen, embezzled or converted property, but only if that person knew it was stolen, embezzled or converted.[2]
  • The Michigan Supreme Court held that statutory conversion "to the other person's own use" is not coextensive with common-law conversion and requires use for a purpose personal to the defendant.[3]
  • Trebling is not automatic: the Court of Appeals held a court "cannot simply order treble damages" on a finding of statutory conversion and left the question to the jury.[4]
  • Restitution paid in a criminal case is set off against compensatory damages the victim later recovers in a civil case.[5]

This page explains the civil lawsuit Michigan law gives a theft victim against the person who took the property and against people who knowingly received it. It covers what each side has to show, why "treble damages" is a ceiling and not a fixed bill, the deadline question, how employers use the statute after embezzlement, and how a civil case fits with criminal restitution.

What the statute covers

The statute is MCL 600.2919a. Subsection (1) says a person damaged by either or both of two kinds of conduct "may recover 3 times the amount of actual damages sustained, plus costs and reasonable attorney fees."[1] The two kinds of conduct are:

  • Another person's "stealing or embezzling property or converting property to the other person's own use."[1]
  • Another person's "buying, receiving, possessing, concealing, or aiding in the concealment of stolen, embezzled, or converted property" when that person "knew that the property was stolen, embezzled, or converted."[2]

Knowledge appears in the words of the second group.[2] The Michigan Supreme Court has said a claim under the first group "also accrues to the victim of" another person's "stealing or embezzling" property, and that a corporation counts as a "person" who can bring or face such a claim.[6]

Subsection (2) says the remedy "is in addition to any other right or remedy the person may have at law or otherwise."[7] The full section has only those two subsections.[8] The Penal Code adds that its silence about civil liability for a crime "does not affect any right to recover" damages for the same act.[9]

The 2005 change: the thief is covered, not only the receiver

As first enacted in 1976, the statute gave treble damages only against a person who knowingly bought, received or helped conceal stolen, embezzled or converted property; in the Supreme Court's words, "its terms did not provide a separate remedy against a converter."[3] 2005 PA 44 amended the section, effective June 16, 2005, and the new wording "applies to causes of action that arise after the effective date."[10] An article saying a business cannot use this statute against the employee who took the money is describing the law before that date.[10][3] The timeline of Michigan theft law changes lists this and other dates.

Statutory conversion and common-law conversion

Conversion is also a claim under Michigan common law, separate from the statute. The Supreme Court described common-law conversion as "any distinct act of dominion wrongfully exerted over another's personal property in denial of or inconsistent with his rights therein."[3]

In Aroma Wines & Equipment, Inc v Columbian Distribution Services, Inc (2015), the Court held that "converting property to [that] person's own use," as used in the statute, "is not coextensive with common-law conversion," and that the Legislature created "a separate statutory cause of action for conversion" in addition to the common-law claim.[3] The statutory claim "requires a showing that the defendant employed the converted property for some purpose personal to the defendant's interests, even if that purpose is not the object's ordinarily intended purpose."[3]

Because the statutory claim is in addition to the common-law one, a plaintiff can bring both.[3][7] The common-law claim asks whether the defendant wrongfully exercised control over the property.[3] The statutory "own use" claim adds the personal-purpose showing, and it is the statutory claim that carries the possibility of tripled damages, costs and attorney fees.[3][1] The criminal side of the same idea is on the larceny by conversion page.

Treble damages are a ceiling, not automatic

The statute says a damaged person "may recover" 3 times actual damages.[1] In Aroma Wines, the Court of Appeals held that a court "cannot simply order treble damages upon a finding of [statutory] conversion," and that a jury finding statutory conversion "must also determine whether to award treble damages."[4] The Supreme Court declined to review that part of the case.[4]

So the accurate description is that a court or jury may award up to three times actual damages, plus costs and reasonable attorney fees.[1][4] The multiplier applies to "actual damages sustained," which the plaintiff still has to prove.[1]

Deadlines to sue

MCL 600.2919a does not state its own time limit.[8] Two general limitation periods could matter, and the statute does not say which one applies:

  • Three years after the injury, for actions to recover damages "for injury to a person or property."[11]
  • Six years after the claim accrues, for "all other personal actions" not covered by a different period.[12]

If the person liable fraudulently concealed the claim or his or her identity, the action may be started within 2 years after the victim discovers, or should have discovered, the claim or the person, even if the normal period has run.[13] That rule can matter when embezzlement comes to light long after it happened. Because a single deadline cannot be stated with confidence, the dates in any real claim are a question for a lawyer. Criminal charging deadlines are separate and are on the theft statute of limitations page.

Employers after embezzlement

An employer whose employee took money or goods can use the "stealing or embezzling" wording of subsection (1)(a), and a corporate employer counts as a "person."[1][6] Self-help through payroll is limited. Except for deductions required or expressly permitted by law or a collective bargaining agreement, an employer "shall not deduct from the wages of an employee" without "the full, free, and written consent of the employee, obtained without intimidation or fear of discharge for refusal to permit the deduction."[14] Apart from exceptions the statute lists (such as payroll overpayments), a deduction for the employer's benefit needs written consent for each paycheck and may not reduce gross wages below the state minimum wage.[15]

A demand for repayment can also matter in a criminal case. In an embezzlement prosecution, an employee's "failure, neglect, or refusal" to pay or return entrusted money or property "upon demand is prima facie proof of intent to embezzle."[16] The two sides of that situation are on the employers' guide to employee theft and the page for an employee accused of embezzlement.

How a civil suit fits with restitution

A criminal case and a civil case can both follow the same theft, and Michigan law keeps them separate while preventing the same loss from being paid twice:

  • A restitution order "does not act as a bar to the recovery of damages in a civil action arising out of the same incident."[17]
  • Any amount paid under a restitution order "shall be set off against any amount later recovered as compensatory damages" in a civil case.[5]
  • A civil settlement between an embezzling employee and the employer "does not relieve the sentencing court of its statutorily mandated duty to order restitution."[18]
  • A court may not reduce restitution by the amount of an unpaid civil judgment; having both "does not mean that the victim will have a double recovery."[19]
  • For restitution in felony cases, "victim" includes a corporation or other business entity that suffers direct financial harm.[20]

A later set-aside of the conviction "does not affect the right of a victim of a crime to prosecute or defend a civil action for damages."[21] The restitution page explains how the criminal court sets the amount.

For the person being sued

A defendant can contest each part of the claim. Under subsection (1)(b), the plaintiff has to show the defendant knew the property was stolen, embezzled or converted.[2] Under the "own use" wording, the plaintiff has to show use for a purpose personal to the defendant.[3] Even if liability is found, trebling is for the fact-finder.[4]

When a criminal charge is pending, testimony in the civil case raises its own issues. The statute on witnesses says it does not require a witness "to give any answer which will have a tendency to accuse himself of any crime or misdemeanor."[22] In a civil case, though, the Fifth Amendment "does not forbid adverse inferences against parties to civil actions when they refuse to testify in response to probative evidence offered against them."[23] Courts may stay civil proceedings until the criminal case ends to protect the privilege against self-incrimination.[24] How these rules apply in a given case is a question for a lawyer.

Shoplifting accusations have a separate, smaller civil remedy: the retail fraud civil demand, with civil damages capped at $200.[25] That remedy is covered on the civil demand letter page. Fraud and intentional-tort actions generally may not be started in small claims, and the small claims page explains what that court can hear.[26]

Common questions

Can a Michigan business sue an employee for three times the amount embezzled?

It can ask for that. MCL 600.2919a lets a person damaged by another person's "stealing or embezzling property" recover 3 times actual damages, plus costs and reasonable attorney fees, and a corporation counts as a person for this purpose.[1][6] That wording applies to claims that arose after June 16, 2005.[10] Tripling is not automatic: in the Aroma Wines case, the Court of Appeals held that the jury must decide whether to award treble damages.[4]

Are treble damages automatic in a Michigan theft lawsuit?

No. The statute says a damaged person "may recover 3 times the amount of actual damages sustained."[1] The Court of Appeals held that a court "cannot simply order treble damages upon a finding of [statutory] conversion" and that the jury must decide whether to award them; the Michigan Supreme Court declined to review that point.[4] Up to three times actual damages is the accurate way to describe the remedy.

How long does a theft victim have to file a civil suit in Michigan?

MCL 600.2919a does not state its own deadline.[8] Michigan has a 3-year limitation period for injury to property and a 6-year catch-all for other personal actions, and the statute itself does not say which applies.[11][12] If the person liable fraudulently concealed the claim, suit may be filed within 2 years after it was or should have been discovered.[13] A lawyer can say which period fits a given claim.

If I already paid restitution, can the victim still sue me?

A restitution order in a criminal case "does not act as a bar to the recovery of damages in a civil action arising out of the same incident."[17] But any restitution actually paid is set off against compensatory damages the victim later recovers in a civil case.[5] A set-aside of the conviction does not affect the victim's right to bring or defend a civil action for damages either.[21]

Can someone who bought stolen goods be sued for treble damages?

Yes, if the statute's knowledge element is met. Subsection (1)(b) covers "buying, receiving, possessing, concealing, or aiding in the concealment of stolen, embezzled, or converted property" when the person "knew that the property was stolen, embezzled, or converted."[2] Before 2005 the statute reached only people in that group, not the person who did the stealing.[3]

Sources

  1. MCL 600.2919a(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 600.2919a(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
  3. Aroma Wines & Equipment, Inc v Columbian Distribution Services, Inc, 497 Mich 337 (2015) — Caselaw Access Project
  4. Aroma Wines & Equipment, Inc v Columbian Distribution Services, Inc, 303 Mich App 441, 449-450 (2013), lv den in part 497 Mich 864 (2014), as described in 497 Mich 337 (2015) — Caselaw Access Project
  5. MCL 780.766(9); MCL 780.826(9); MCL 769.1a(9) — Michigan Legislature
  6. Aroma Wines & Equipment, Inc v Columbian Distribution Services, Inc, 497 Mich 337 (2015) (footnote) — Caselaw Access Project
  7. MCL 600.2919a(2) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 600.2919a (full text) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 750.4 — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 600.2919a, History and Compiler's Notes; 2005 PA 44, enacting section 1 — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 600.5805(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCL 600.5813 — Michigan Legislature
  13. MCL 600.5855 — Michigan Legislature
  14. MCL 408.477(1) — Michigan Legislature
  15. MCL 408.477(2) — Michigan Legislature
  16. MCL 750.174(10) — Michigan Legislature
  17. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co v Collins, 143 Mich App 661, 663 (1985); Pilgrim’s Rest Baptist Church v Pearson, 310 Mich App 318, 325-326 (2015) — Michigan Courts
  18. People v Bell, 276 Mich App 342 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
  19. People v Dimoski, 286 Mich App 474 (2009) — Caselaw Access Project
  20. MCL 780.766(1) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 780.622(5) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 600.2154 — Michigan Legislature
  23. Phillips v Deihm, 213 Mich App 389, 400-401 (1995) — Michigan Courts
  24. Landis v North American Co, 299 US 248, 254-255 (1936), as applied in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook — Michigan Courts
  25. MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
  26. MCL 600.8424(1) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.