Key points
- Under MCL 600.2953(1), a merchant may claim the full retail price of property that was not recovered or came back unsalable, plus civil damages of 10 times the retail price, but not less than $50 and not more than $200.[1]
- If the merchandise was recovered in salable condition, there is no retail-price amount to pay; the civil damages part can still be claimed.[1][2]
- Costs of the lawsuit, including reasonable attorney fees, come into play only if the demand is not met and the merchant sues, and that provision does not apply if, before trial begins, the person pays the merchant in cash the amount demanded.[2][3]
- These figures have not changed since January 1, 1999, the effective date of the statute's only amendment.[4]
A Michigan store can demand two things after alleged retail fraud: the full retail price of merchandise that was not recovered or came back unsalable, and civil damages of 10 times the retail price, but never less than $50 or more than $200.[1] If the demand is not met and the store sues, a person found liable can also be ordered to pay the costs of the lawsuit, including reasonable attorney fees.[2]
The formula is in MCL 600.2953, Michigan's civil demand statute, which has not been amended since January 1, 1999.[4] This page walks through the formula with examples using the statute's own numbers. What the letter must say is on the civil demand letter page, and what happens if a person pays or does not pay is on the do you have to pay page.
The formula, piece by piece
Subsection (1) makes a person who commits an act that could be charged as retail fraud liable to the merchant "for the full retail price of unrecovered property or recovered property that is not in salable condition, and civil damages of 10 times the retail price of the property, but not less than $50.00 and not more than $200.00."[1] That sentence contains two separate amounts.
1. The retail price of goods the store did not get back in sellable shape
The first amount is the full retail price, and it applies only to property that was not recovered or that was recovered but is no longer in salable condition.[1] The statutory letter puts this as a choice for unrecovered goods: "Return the property in salable condition or pay to us" the full retail price "or the remaining balance of the full retail price of the property."[5] A separate check box covers "the full retail price of the recovered property that is not in salable condition."[5]
2. Civil damages: 10 times the price, between $50 and $200
The second amount is civil damages equal to 10 times the retail price of the property involved, with a $50 minimum and a $200 maximum.[1] This amount is listed in the statute in addition to the retail-price amount, so it does not disappear because the goods were recovered.[1]
Worked examples using the statute's numbers
The examples below apply the statutory formula to round numbers. They are arithmetic, not predictions of what any store will ask for; a letter may check fewer boxes than the statute allows.[5]
| Situation | Retail-price amount | Civil damages (10 times price, $50 to $200) | Maximum the statute allows before any lawsuit |
|---|---|---|---|
| $3 item, recovered in salable condition | $0 (recovered and salable) | 10 x $3 = $30, raised to the $50 minimum | $50[1] |
| $12 item, recovered in salable condition | $0 | 10 x $12 = $120 | $120[1] |
| $40 item, recovered in salable condition | $0 | 10 x $40 = $400, cut to the $200 maximum | $200[1] |
| $40 item, not recovered | $40 | $200 (maximum) | $240[1] |
| $75 item, recovered but damaged and unsalable | $75 | $200 (maximum) | $275[1] |
Two patterns follow from the formula. Once the retail price reaches $20, ten times the price is $200 or more, so the civil damages sit at the $200 cap; and below $5, ten times the price is under $50, so the $50 floor applies.[1] For property recovered in salable condition, the civil damages are the whole amount the statute allows before a lawsuit.[1]
What changes if the demand is not met
If a person who committed the act does not comply with the written demand, subsection (4) makes that person liable for the full retail price (unless the property was recovered in salable condition), the same civil damages of 10 times the retail price within the $50 to $200 range, "and costs of the action, including reasonable attorney fees."[2] The civil damages range does not grow; the added items are the costs of the lawsuit and reasonable attorney fees.[2]
Liability under subsection (4) is written for "A person who commits an act described in subsection (1)," and the statutory letter describes the lawsuit as one "to determine your legal responsibility."[2][5] A letter is a demand, not a court finding.
Subsection (5) adds that if, after a suit is filed and before trial starts, the person pays the merchant "in cash the amount demanded," subsection (4) does not apply.[3]
Paying within 30 days
A person who complies with the written demand within 30 days after the date it was mailed "shall incur no further civil liability to the merchant from the act of retail fraud."[6] The statutory letter makes the same promise: if unrecovered property is returned and the amounts are paid within 30 days after mailing, the merchant "will not take any further civil action."[5] That release is civil only; the letter itself says the civil proceedings "do not prevent criminal prosecution."[5] The civil demand and criminal case page covers that point.
Small claims and the $7,000 limit
A store's civil-demand lawsuit "may be brought in the small claims division of the district court or in any other court of competent jurisdiction."[7] If the amount demanded exceeds the small claims limit, the case may still be filed there, but the recovery cannot exceed that limit.[7] The small claims limit has been $7,000 since January 1, 2024.[8] The small claims page explains how those cases run.
Amounts people confuse with the civil demand
| Amount | Who sets it | How it is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Civil demand (MCL 600.2953) | The statute; the merchant demands it and must sue if unpaid | Retail price of unrecovered or unsalable goods plus 10 times the retail price, $50 to $200[1] |
| Criminal fine | The sentencing judge, within the statutory maximum | For third-degree retail fraud, up to $500 or 3 times the value, whichever is greater[9] |
| Restitution | The sentencing judge, as part of a criminal sentence | Return of the property, or its fair market value on the date of loss or of sentencing, whichever is greater, less the value of anything returned[10] |
| Bad-check civil demand (a different statute) | MCL 600.2952 | The check amount plus a $25 processing fee if paid within 7 days after mailing (not counting weekends and holidays), or plus $35 within 30 days; different amounts apply in a lawsuit[11][12] |
Figures quoted online for other states, or civil damages above $200, do not come from Michigan's statute, whose civil damages cap is $200.[1] The civil demand is also separate from any criminal penalty; the statute imposes it "In addition to applicable penal sanctions."[1] For the criminal side, see fines and costs in theft cases and restitution.
Parents and minors
A merchant "may recover damages in an amount allowable under this section" from the parent or parents of an unemancipated minor who lives with them and who commits an act described in subsection (1).[13] The amount is the same formula; the parents of minors page explains the conditions.
One more condition: the price-marking exception
A merchant "shall not recover civil damages" for an item if the merchant violated the item-pricing section cross-referenced in subsection (9) and the accused person did not cause that violation.[14] That cross-referenced section was repealed in 2011 by 2011 PA 15, which has its own definition of when a price is "displayed," so how subsection (9) applies today is unsettled.[15][16] The civil demand letter page explains this in more detail.
Common questions
How much can a store ask for in a Michigan civil demand letter?
The statute allows the full retail price of property that was not recovered or is no longer salable, plus civil damages of 10 times the retail price of the property, with a floor of $50 and a ceiling of $200.[1] If the store sues after the demand is not met, a person found liable can also owe the costs of the action, including reasonable attorney fees.[2]
The store got the item back undamaged. Why is it still asking for money?
The retail-price part of the statute covers only property that was not recovered or that was recovered but is not in salable condition.[1] The separate civil damages part, 10 times the retail price with a $50 minimum and $200 maximum, is written as an amount in addition to that, and the post-lawsuit provision charges the retail price "unless the property was recovered in salable condition" while still listing civil damages.[1][2]
Can the amount grow if the demand is not paid?
The civil damages stay within the same $50 to $200 range.[2] What the statute adds after noncompliance is "costs of the action, including reasonable attorney fees," and only for a person who committed the act.[2] If the merchant files suit and the person pays the amount originally demanded in cash before trial begins, that subsection does not apply.[3]
Is a civil demand the same as restitution?
No. Restitution is ordered by the criminal court at sentencing and, for lost property, is measured by return of the property or, if that is impossible, impractical or inadequate, the greater of its fair market value on the date of loss or on the date of sentencing.[10] The civil demand statute uses the full retail price plus fixed-range civil damages, and applies in addition to any criminal penalty.[1]
Does the small claims limit cap what a store can recover?
Only if the store sues in small claims. A civil-demand case may be filed in small claims or in any other court with jurisdiction; in small claims, recovery cannot exceed that division's limit, which has been $7,000 since January 1, 2024.[7][8]
Sources
- MCL 600.2953(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953, History — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(6) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.8401 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(3); MCL 780.826(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2952(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2952(4)-(5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2953(9) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 445.353 (repealed); 2011 PA 15, enacting section 1; MCL 600.2953(9) — Michigan Legislature
- 2011 PA 15, sec 2(e) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.