Key points
- Embezzlement under MCL 750.174 is a trust-based theft by an agent, servant or employee, and amounts from separate incidents in a scheme or course of conduct against one employer may be added together with no time limit.[1][2]
- The model instruction says an intent to return or replace the money later is not a defense to embezzlement.[3]
- Apart from deductions required or expressly permitted by law or a collective bargaining agreement, an employer may not deduct a claimed loss from wages without the employee's full, free and written consent, given for each paycheck when the deduction benefits the employer.[4][5]
- A discharge for theft connected with the work disqualifies a person from unemployment benefits until he or she requalifies by completing 26 requalifying weeks, and benefits are also reduced by 13 weeks.[6][7]
An accusation of embezzlement or workplace theft can involve the employer, an investigator, the police, the prosecuting attorney, a civil court and the unemployment agency at the same time, and each one runs on different rules. This page explains what Michigan law says about each piece. It does not recommend whether to talk, sign, pay or resign; those choices depend on facts this page cannot know. The offense itself is explained on the embezzlement law page, and store-specific charges on store employee theft charges.
What embezzlement means, briefly
Embezzlement is committed by a person who, as the agent, servant or employee of another, or as a trustee, bailee or custodian, fraudulently disposes of or converts to his or her own use money or property of the principal that came into his or her possession or control through that relationship.[1] Among the elements in the model jury instruction are a relationship of trust, possession or control because of that relationship, a dishonest disposal, conversion, or taking or hiding with intent to convert, and an intent to defraud or cheat the principal.[8] The penalty depends on value: under $200 is a misdemeanor of up to 93 days, $200 to under $1,000 is a misdemeanor of up to 1 year, $1,000 to under $20,000 is a felony with a 5-year maximum, and higher amounts carry up to 10, 15 or 20 years; a prior conviction or a nonprofit or charitable victim can move an amount up a tier.[9][10][11][12][13][14]
- Adding amounts together. Amounts from separate incidents in a scheme or course of conduct within any 12-month period may be aggregated, and there is no time limit if the scheme targets only one person or entity.[2]
- Failure to repay on demand. An employee's failure or refusal to return entrusted money on demand is prima facie proof of intent to embezzle; the instruction tells jurors they may, but need not, draw that inference if the facts are not explained.[15]
- Intent to pay back later. The model instruction states that an intent to return or replace the money later does not provide a defense.[3]
Workplace interviews and statements
Miranda warnings are tied to custodial interrogation, which the U.S. Supreme Court defined as questioning initiated by law enforcement officers after a person is taken into custody or otherwise significantly deprived of freedom.[16] In People v Omell (1968), the Court of Appeals held that private investigators hired by an employer to look into a cash shortage did not have to give warnings before a confession letter was written.[17] That decision predates November 1, 1990, so it does not bind later Court of Appeals panels the way newer published decisions do.[18] In the retail setting, the Michigan Supreme Court noted decisions holding that private security guards who work in close connection with the police may be acting under color of state law.[19]
Whoever does the questioning, the Supreme Court in Impens quoted with approval the principle that the guarantee against self-incrimination prevents the state from using involuntary answers as evidence, whether obtained by government or private conduct.[20] A defendant's own statement offered against him or her by the prosecution is defined as not hearsay under the Michigan Rules of Evidence.[21] The under-investigation page covers the period before any charge.
The employer's investigation file and your personnel record
Under the Bullard-Plawecki Employee Right to Know Act, an employer with reasonable cause to believe an employee is engaged in criminal activity that might damage its property or disrupt its business may keep a separate investigation file.[22] The employee must be notified that an investigation was or is being conducted when it is complete or after 2 years, whichever comes first, and if no disciplinary action is taken, the file and all copies must be destroyed when the investigation is complete.[22]
Separately, an employer with 4 or more employees must, on a written request describing the record, let a current or former employee review his or her personnel record, generally not more than twice a year; the separate investigation file is excluded from that record.[23]
Repayment, promissory notes and wage deductions
Employers sometimes present repayment agreements during an investigation. The law on several related points is fixed:
- Wages. Apart from deductions required or expressly permitted by law or a collective bargaining agreement, an employer may not deduct any amount from wages without the employee's full, free and written consent, obtained without intimidation or fear of discharge.[4] A deduction for the employer's benefit needs consent for each paycheck and may not reduce pay below minimum wage.[5]
- Compounding. Michigan's compounding statute makes it a crime for a person who knows of an offense punishable by imprisonment in the state prison to take money, a reward or a promise of one on an agreement, express or implied, not to prosecute it or not to give evidence of it; where the offense is not punishable by death or life imprisonment, it is a misdemeanor of up to 1 year or $1,000.[24] The section's text is directed at the person who takes the money and does not address ending a prosecution.[24]
- Settlements and restitution. In People v Bell, an embezzlement case, the Court of Appeals held that a civil settlement between the employee and the employer did not relieve the sentencing court of its duty to order restitution.[25]
- The prosecutor's role. A judge or magistrate may not issue a warrant or summons for a theft offense without the prosecuting attorney's written authorization or security for costs.[26] In a felony case, before finalizing a dismissal, plea or pretrial diversion, the prosecutor must offer the victim a chance to consult; for that right the statute defines a victim as an individual harmed by the crime, and it adds businesses only for listed restitution provisions.[27][28][29]
Civil claims by the employer
A person damaged by another's stealing, embezzling or converting property may recover 3 times the actual damages, plus costs and reasonable attorney fees, in addition to any other remedy.[30][31] Trebling is not automatic; the Court of Appeals has held the jury must decide whether to award treble damages.[32] Restitution paid in a criminal case is set off against compensatory damages the victim later recovers in a civil case.[33]
When a civil case and a criminal case overlap, a witness need not give answers that tend to incriminate, but in a civil case a party's refusal to testify may support an adverse inference, and courts may stay civil proceedings until the criminal case ends.[34][35][36] See civil lawsuits for theft.
Unemployment benefits
Under the Michigan Employment Security Act, a person is disqualified from benefits if suspended or discharged for misconduct connected with the work, discharged for theft connected with the work, or convicted within 2 years of the discharge date of theft from the employer or a lesser included offense.[6] The disqualification begins the week of the act or discharge and lasts until the person requalifies.[6] A theft disqualification requires 26 requalifying weeks and reduces benefits by 13 weeks; a misconduct disqualification requires earning at least 17 times the weekly benefit rate in covered work.[7]
If charges are filed: restitution and records
Restitution is mandatory for losses caused by the course of conduct that gives rise to the conviction, and an employer can be a victim.[37][38] The Michigan Supreme Court held in People v McKinley (2014) that it cannot be based solely on uncharged conduct, although the Court of Appeals has held that a defendant may agree, as part of a plea agreement, to pay restitution on dismissed charges.[39][40] See restitution in theft cases.
- Set-aside. Felony embezzlement is a "crime of dishonesty" excluded from automatic set-aside.[41][42] An application to set aside one felony may be filed 5 years after the latest of sentencing, probation, parole or imprisonment.[43]
- Background checks. Michigan employers other than law enforcement agencies may not ask about or keep records of a misdemeanor arrest, detention or disposition that did not result in a conviction; the protection does not cover a felony charge before conviction or dismissal.[44]
- Banks. Without FDIC consent, a person convicted of an offense involving dishonesty or breach of trust, or who entered a pretrial diversion for one, may not work for an insured bank.[45]
- Licenses. Michigan may not issue a real estate broker's license to a person convicted of embezzlement, and a felony of a financial nature such as embezzlement bars an insurance producer license regardless of date.[46][47]
More on these effects is on the pages for jobs and professional licenses.
Common questions
Does an employer's investigator have to read me my rights?
Miranda warnings attach to custodial interrogation, defined as questioning initiated by law enforcement officers.[16] In People v Omell, a 1968 embezzlement case, the Court of Appeals held a private investigator hired by an employer was not required to give the warnings.[17] Court of Appeals decisions from before November 1, 1990 do not bind later panels the way newer published decisions do.[18]
If I pay the money back, will the case be dropped?
The model instruction states that an intent to return or replace the money later is not a defense to embezzlement.[3] Charging runs through the prosecuting attorney, whose written authorization (or security for costs) a warrant or summons needs.[26] In a felony case, the prosecutor must offer an individual victim a chance to consult before finalizing a dismissal, plea or diversion.[27][28] If there is a conviction, the Court of Appeals has held restitution is not open to plea negotiation.[48]
Can my employer keep my final paycheck to cover the loss?
Except for deductions required or expressly permitted by law or a collective bargaining agreement, a Michigan employer may not deduct any amount from wages without the employee's full, free and written consent, obtained without intimidation or fear of discharge.[4] A deduction for the employer's benefit needs written consent for each paycheck and cannot reduce pay below the state minimum wage.[5]
Can I see what my employer has in my file?
An employer with 4 or more employees must, on a written request describing the record, let a current or former employee review his or her personnel record, generally not more than twice a calendar year.[23] A separate file kept on an investigation of suspected criminal activity is not part of the personnel record.[23][22]
How long does a prosecutor have to file an embezzlement charge?
Embezzlement, like retail fraud and larceny, is not among the offenses with special limitation periods, so it falls under Michigan's general rule that a charge must be filed within 6 years after the offense; filing a complaint or warrant counts, and time the accused does not usually and publicly live in Michigan is not counted.[49][50][51][52] Amounts taken from one employer as part of a scheme or course of conduct may be added together to set the charge level, with no 12-month limit when the scheme targets only that one victim.[2]
Sources
- MCL 750.174(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(8) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 27.1, Use Note 4 (citing People v Butts, 128 Mich 208 (1901)) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 408.477(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 408.477(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 421.29(1)(b), (i), (k), (n); MCL 421.29(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 421.29(3)(d), (3)(g), (4)(g) — Michigan Legislature
- M Crim JI 27.1 — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.174(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(3)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(4)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(5)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(6) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(7) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.174(10); M Crim JI 27.2 — Michigan Legislature
- Miranda v Arizona, 384 US 436, 444 (1966) — Michigan Courts
- People v Omell, 15 Mich App 154 (1968) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCR 7.215(J)(1) — Michigan Courts
- Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) — Caselaw Access Project
- Grand Rapids v Impens, 414 Mich 667 (1982) (quoting In re Deborah C, 30 Cal 3d 125, 132 (1981)) — Caselaw Access Project
- MRE 801(d)(2)(A)-(D) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 423.509(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 423.501(2)(a)-(c); MCL 423.503 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.149 — Michigan Legislature
- People v Bell, 276 Mich App 342 (2007) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 764.1(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.756(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.752(1)(m)(i); MCL 780.766(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2919a(1)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2919a(2) — Michigan Legislature
- Aroma Wines & Equipment, Inc v Columbian Distribution Services, Inc, 303 Mich App 441, 449-450 (2013), lv den in part 497 Mich 864 (2014), as described in 497 Mich 337 (2015) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 780.766(9); MCL 780.826(9); MCL 769.1a(9) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.2154 — Michigan Legislature
- Phillips v Deihm, 213 Mich App 389, 400-401 (1995) — Michigan Courts
- Landis v North American Co, 299 US 248, 254-255 (1936), as applied in the Crime Victim Rights Benchbook — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.766(2); MCL 780.826(2); MCL 769.1a(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.766(1); MCL 780.826(1)(b); MCL 769.1a(1)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- People v McKinley, 496 Mich 410 (2014) — Caselaw Access Project
- People v Foster, 319 Mich App 365, 379, 383 (2017) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 780.621g(10) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621g(15) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 780.621d(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 37.2205a(1), (2) — Michigan Legislature
- 12 USC 1829(a)(1) — Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- MCL 339.2505(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 500.1239(1)(d), (1)(e)(iii), (2)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Ronowski, 222 Mich App 58 (1997) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 767.24(10) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 767.24(1)-(10) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 761.1(g) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 767.24(11) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.