SHShawn HaffCriminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Legal Resource Library · Sentencing and restitution

Probation Violations in Michigan Theft and Retail Fraud Cases

Key points

  • Michigan caps jail for technical probation violations: 5, 10 and 15 days for misdemeanor probationers and 15, 30 and 45 days for felony probationers, for a first, second and third violation; the caps do not apply to probation for listed domestic violence and stalking offenses.[1][2]
  • A court may not revoke probation for a technical violation unless the probationer has already been sanctioned for 3 or more technical violations and commits a new one.[3]
  • At a violation hearing the state must prove the violation by a preponderance of the evidence, and the probationer has the right to a lawyer, appointed if the probationer cannot afford one.[4][5]
  • Jail or revocation for unpaid restitution or costs requires a finding that the probationer could pay and did not make a good-faith effort.[6][7]

Probation is one of the sentences available in theft and retail fraud cases. A probation period may not exceed 2 years for a misdemeanor or 3 years for a felony, though a felony term can be extended up to 2 times by 1 year each.[8][9] Michigan law treats violations in two groups: "technical" violations of the probation rules, which carry capped jail sanctions and can lead to revocation only after repeated violations, and other violations such as new crimes or absconding.[1][10][3]

This page explains how violations are classified, how a violation case starts, what happens at the hearing, the possible outcomes, and the special rules for unpaid restitution and costs. The terms and conditions of probation themselves are on the sentencing page.

The legislative starting point

The probation statute says "the granting of probation is a matter of grace," and that revocation and incarceration "should be imposed only for repeated technical violations, for new criminal behavior, as otherwise allowed in section 4b of this chapter, or upon request of the probationer."[11] The court rules on violations, MCR 6.445 and 6.450, also govern district court misdemeanor cases.[12]

Technical and nontechnical violations

A "technical probation violation" is a violation of the terms of a probation order that is not on the statute's list of exclusions, "including missing or failing a drug test."[10]

TypeExamples from the statuteJail limit for the violation itself
TechnicalMissing or failing a drug test, or another breach of the order that is not excluded[10]Misdemeanor probation: 5, 10, then 15 days. Felony probation: 15, 30, then 45 days.[1]
Not technical (partial list)Violating a no-contact order with a named individual; violating a state law, whether or not a new offense is charged; absconding[10]The capped sanctions are written for technical violations; the court's general options are described below[1][13]

The court may not revoke probation for a technical violation unless the probationer has already been sanctioned for 3 or more technical violations and then commits a new one.[3]

The same statute adds several details. For a fourth or later technical violation, the jail sanction may be any number of days up to the remaining eligible jail sentence (or, on felony probation, jail or prison sentence). A jail sanction for a first, second or third violation may be extended to not more than 45 days if the probationer is awaiting placement in a treatment facility and has no safe alternative place to wait. Technical violations that arise out of the same transaction count as a single violation. A probationer arrested and held for a technical violation must be brought to a hearing as soon as possible and, if the hearing is not held within the applicable jail sanction, must be returned to community supervision. These caps and the revocation limit do not apply to probation for listed domestic violence and stalking offenses.[2]

How a violation case starts

For a technical violation, there is a rebuttable presumption that the court will issue a summons or an order to show cause rather than an arrest warrant.[3] The court rule puts it more firmly: the court "must issue a summons, rather than a bench warrant," for a technical violation unless it states on the record a specific reason to suspect the probationer is an immediate danger, has left court-ordered inpatient treatment without permission, or failed to appear on a summons already issued.[14] For a nontechnical violation, the court may issue either a bench warrant or a summons on probable cause.[14]

Acknowledging a technical violation in writing

Instead of starting a violation proceeding, the court may allow a probationer to acknowledge a technical violation in writing without a hearing.[15] After an acknowledgment, the court may not impose incarceration or revoke probation for it, but it may count the acknowledgment toward the number of technical violations, and the acknowledgment may delay eligibility for early discharge.[15]

The arraignment and the hearing

At the arraignment on an alleged violation, the court must make sure the probationer receives written notice of the violation, say whether it is charged as technical or nontechnical and the maximum possible jail or prison sentence, and advise the probationer of the right to contest the charge at a hearing and to a lawyer, appointed at public expense if the probationer wants one and cannot afford to hire one.[5] The statute separately entitles the probationer to "a written copy of the charges" and a revocation hearing.[16]

  • Custody limit: a probationer held in custody must have the hearing within the permissible jail sentence for the violation and no later than 14 days after arrest, or be released pending the hearing.[17]
  • New criminal charge: if the alleged violation is a crime that is being prosecuted separately, the court may postpone the hearing until that prosecution ends.[17]
  • Evidence: the evidence must be disclosed to the probationer, who may be present, present evidence, and examine and cross-examine witnesses; the court need not apply the rules of evidence except those on privileges.[4]
  • Burden of proof: "The state has the burden of proving a violation by a preponderance of the evidence."[4]

The statute describes revocation hearings as "summary and informal and not subject to the rules of evidence or of pleadings applicable in criminal trials."[16]

Possible outcomes

If the court finds a violation, or the probationer pleads guilty to one, the court "may continue probation, modify the conditions of probation, extend the probation period, or revoke probation and impose a sentence of incarceration pursuant to law."[13] Limits on those choices include:

  • Technical violations carry the capped jail sanctions in the table above, and revocation is available only after 3 or more prior sanctioned technical violations.[1][3]
  • Felony probation may be extended not more than 2 times, for not more than 1 additional year each time.[9]
  • If probation is revoked, the court "may sentence the probationer in the same manner and to the same penalty as the court might have done if the probation order had never been made."[16] For a felony, that includes the guidelines analysis on the sentencing guidelines page.[18]
  • The court may not sentence a probationer to prison without considering a current presentence report.[13]

HYTA assignments, which are made without entering a judgment of conviction, and delayed sentences work differently: each has its own rules for what follows a violation, covered on the HYTA page and the delayed sentence page.

Unpaid restitution, fines and costs

Paying restitution, the crime victim assessment and the minimum state cost is a mandatory condition of every probation order.[19] Nonpayment is treated differently from other violations:

  • Restitution: a defendant "shall not be imprisoned, jailed, or incarcerated" for a probation violation or otherwise for failing to pay restitution unless the court finds the defendant has the resources to pay and has not made a good-faith effort.[6] The court must consider employment status, earning ability, financial resources and the willfulness of the failure to pay.[20]
  • Costs: the court may jail or revoke a probationer who fails to pay ordered costs only if the probationer can pay and has not made a good-faith effort.[7] Separately, as of November 2026, the sentencing statute's authority to add costs reasonably related to the court's actual operating costs runs "Until December 31, 2026."[21]
  • Court rule: no jail or prison for failing to pay fines, costs, restitution or other financial obligations without following the ability-to-pay steps in MCR 6.425(B) and (D).[13]
  • Wage assignment: when restitution is a probation condition, the court orders an employed defendant to make regularly scheduled payments, and missing 2 or more of them leads the court to order a wage assignment.[22]

Unpaid restitution can also keep probation open. A probationer who has made a good-faith effort to pay and is otherwise eligible for early discharge may be discharged or kept on probation, up to the maximum term for the offense, with continued restitution payments as the sole condition.[23] The restitution page and the fines and costs page explain those obligations.

Early discharge

After completing half of the original probation period, a probationer may be eligible for early discharge and must be told about that eligibility at sentencing.[24] Inability to pay fines, fees or costs does not by itself make a probationer ineligible if good-faith payment efforts were made, but before discharging someone who still owes restitution, the court must consider the effect on the victim.[23] Discharge does not relieve a probationer of court-ordered financial obligations.[23] A list of questions to raise about a pending violation is on the questions to ask a lawyer page.

Common questions

Can someone go to jail for a technical probation violation in Michigan?

Yes, but the statute caps the time. For a misdemeanor probationer the limits are 5, 10 and 15 days for a first, second and third technical violation; for a felony probationer they are 15, 30 and 45 days.[1] Revocation for technical violations is allowed only after 3 or more earlier sanctioned technical violations and a new one.[3]

What is the difference between a technical and a nontechnical probation violation?

A technical violation is a violation of the probation order that is not on the statute's excluded list, such as missing or failing a drug test.[10] The excluded list includes violating a no-contact order with a named person, violating a state law whether or not a new offense is charged, and absconding, among other items.[10] The probationer must be told which type is charged and the maximum possible sentence.[5]

Will the court issue a warrant for a missed probation appointment?

For a technical violation, the statute presumes a summons or order to show cause instead of an arrest warrant.[3] The court rule says the court must issue a summons rather than a bench warrant unless it states a specific reason on the record, such as an immediate danger, leaving court-ordered inpatient treatment, or failing to appear on an earlier summons.[14]

Is there a right to a lawyer at a probation violation hearing?

Yes. At the arraignment on the violation, the court must advise the probationer of the right to a lawyer's help at the hearing and at all court proceedings, and that a lawyer will be appointed at public expense if the probationer wants one and cannot afford to hire one.[5] The probationer may also contest the charge at a hearing.[5]

What can happen if probation is revoked?

If probation is revoked, the court may sentence the probationer "in the same manner and to the same penalty" as if the probation order had never been made.[16] The court may not send a probationer to prison without considering a current presentence report.[13] For felonies, the guidelines range is part of that sentencing.[18]

Sources

  1. MCL 771.4b(1) — Michigan Legislature
  2. MCL 771.4b(1)(a)(iv), (1)(b)(iv), (3), (4), (5), (6), (8) — Michigan Legislature
  3. MCL 771.4b(4), MCL 771.4b(7) — Michigan Legislature
  4. MCR 6.445(E)(1) — Michigan Courts
  5. MCR 6.445(B) — Michigan Courts
  6. MCL 780.766(14); MCR 6.425(D)(3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
  7. MCL 771.3(8) — Michigan Legislature
  8. MCL 771.1(1) — Michigan Legislature
  9. MCL 771.2(1) — Michigan Legislature
  10. MCL 771.4b(9) — Michigan Legislature
  11. MCL 771.4(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
  12. MCR 6.001(B) — Michigan Courts
  13. MCR 6.445(G) — Michigan Courts
  14. MCR 6.445(A) — Michigan Courts
  15. MCR 6.450(A)-(B) — Michigan Courts
  16. MCL 771.4(2), (4), (5) — Michigan Legislature
  17. MCR 6.445(C) — Michigan Courts
  18. MCL 769.34(3); People v Lockridge, 498 Mich 358 (2015) (as quoted in benchbook) — Michigan Legislature
  19. MCL 771.3(1) — Michigan Legislature
  20. MCL 780.766(11) — Michigan Legislature
  21. MCL 769.1k(1)(b)(iii) — Michigan Legislature
  22. MCL 780.766(18) — Michigan Legislature
  23. MCL 771.2(4)-(5) — Michigan Legislature
  24. MCL 771.2(2)-(3) — Michigan Legislature

This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.

Facing charges? Don’t wait. Call now.

The sooner I’m involved in your case, the more options I have to protect you. The consultation is free, and I answer 24/7.