Key points
- First-degree retail fraud, larceny of $1,000 to $20,000, and organized retail crime are Class E property offenses under the sentencing guidelines.[1][2]
- The recommended minimum range comes from a grid where the offense variable level meets the prior record variable level; the Class E grid runs from 0 to 3 months up to 24 to 38 months.[3][4]
- Offense variable 16 scores property value (0, 1, 5 or 10 points) and may count amounts from admitted but uncharged offenses or from charges dismissed under a plea agreement.[5][6]
- The guidelines are advisory: the court must determine the range and take it into account, and may depart if the departure is reasonable and the reasons are stated on the record.[7]
Michigan's sentencing guidelines produce a recommended range for the minimum sentence: the court identifies the offense category and class, scores the offense variables and prior record variables, and reads the range where those two levels meet on the grid for the offense class.[3] The guidelines are advisory, but the court must determine the range and take it into account.[7]
This page explains how the guidelines apply to theft felonies such as first-degree retail fraud, which is a Class E offense.[1] Sentencing options for second- and third-degree retail fraud, which are misdemeanors, are on the retail fraud sentencing page.[8][9] Nothing here predicts a sentence, because every score depends on the facts and the record.
Offense classes for selected theft felonies
Each listed felony appears with its offense category, offense class and statutory maximum in years, as in the entry "750.356c Property E Retail fraud — first degree 5."[1]
| Offense | Category and class | Statutory maximum (years) |
|---|---|---|
| First-degree retail fraud (MCL 750.356c) | Property, Class E | 5[1] |
| Larceny of $1,000 to $20,000, or with prior convictions (750.356(3)) | Property, Class E | 5[1] |
| Larceny of $20,000 or more, or with prior convictions (750.356(2)) | Property, Class D | 10[1] |
| Larceny in a building (750.360) | Property, Class G | 4[1] |
| Larceny from the person (750.357) | Person, Class D | 10[1] |
| Embezzlement by agent, $1,000 to $20,000 (750.174(4)) | Property, Class E | 5[10] |
| Embezzlement by agent, $100,000 or more (750.174(7)) | Property, Class B | 20[10] |
| Receiving or concealing, $1,000 to $20,000, or with priors (750.535(3)) | Property, Class E | 5[11] |
| Organized retail crime (752.1084) | Property, Class E | 5[2] |
| Identity theft, first offense (445.65) | Public order, Class E | 5[12] |
The table lists examples, not every theft felony. The guidelines apply to an attempt only if the attempt is itself a felony; an attempt to commit a Class E, F or G offense is scored as Class H, and the guidelines do not apply to an attempt to commit a Class H offense.[13]
Offense variables: what about the crime is scored
For all crimes against property, the court scores offense variables 1, 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 16, 19 and 20.[14] Two of them, described below, turn on the property involved and on any pattern of property crimes.
Offense variable 16: property value
| Value of property obtained, damaged, lost or destroyed | Points |
|---|---|
| More than $20,000, or significant historical, social or sentimental value | 10[5] |
| $1,000 or more but not more than $20,000 | 5[5] |
| $200 or more but not more than $1,000 | 1[5] |
| Less than $200, or no property obtained, damaged, lost or destroyed | 0[5] |
The value used for offense variable 16 is not limited to the charged count. The court may consider money or property involved in admitted but uncharged offenses or in charges dismissed under a plea agreement, and in "multiple offender or victim cases" may add up the aggregate value, including uncharged offenses.[6] Restitution follows a narrower rule: it cannot be based solely on uncharged conduct.[15]
Offense variable 16 has other items besides value. It assigns 10 points where wanton or malicious damage occurred beyond what was necessary to commit the crime and no charge has been or will be brought for it, and the court assigns only the single item with the highest points. Lost or destroyed property is scored at its value; damaged property is scored at the amount needed to restore it to its condition before the offense.[16]
Offense variable 13: a pattern of property crimes
Offense variable 13 adds 5 points if the offense was part of a pattern of felonious criminal activity involving 3 or more crimes against property, and all crimes within a 5-year period, including the sentencing offense, are counted whether or not they led to a conviction.[17]
Prior record variables: the defendant's history
The court scores all prior record variables and totals them to find the prior record variable level.[3] Three of them are described below:
- Prior record variable 2 counts prior low-severity felony convictions, including crimes in Classes E, F, G and H: 5 points for one, 10 for two, 20 for three, and 30 for four or more.[18]
- Prior record variable 5 counts prior misdemeanor convictions that are offenses against a person or property, controlled substance offenses or weapon offenses: from 2 points for one up to 20 points for seven or more; a prior used to raise the current offense to a felony is not counted.[19]
- Prior record variable 6 scores the defendant's relationship to the criminal justice system, such as 10 points if on probation, a delayed sentence or bond for a felony, and 5 points for a misdemeanor; delayed sentence status includes a HYTA assignment.[20]
Two rules apply across prior record variables 1 to 5. A conviction is not used if 10 or more years passed between the discharge date from it and the commission of the next offense that resulted in a conviction.[21] And "conviction" includes an assignment to youthful trainee status and a conviction set aside under the set-aside law.[21]
Reading the grid
The recommended minimum sentence is "shown as a range of months or life" at the intersection of the two levels on the grid for the offense class.[3] For Class E, which includes first-degree retail fraud, the ranges run from 0 to 3 months at the lowest levels to 24 to 38 months at the highest.[4]
When the upper limit of the recommended range is 18 months or less, the statute says the court "shall impose an intermediate sanction" unless it states on the record reasonable grounds for up to 12 months in county jail or for a prison sentence.[22] That wording has not changed, but the criminal benchbook reports that after Lockridge the Court of Appeals held in People v Schrauben (2016) that "a trial court may, but is no longer required to, impose an intermediate sanction if the upper limit of the recommended minimum sentence range is 18 months or less."[23] An intermediate sanction is probation or any lawful sanction other than jail or prison, such as community service, a fine, house arrest or electronic monitoring.[24] When the upper limit is above 18 months and the lower limit is 12 months or less, the statute allows either a minimum prison term within the range or an intermediate sanction with up to 12 months in jail, absent a departure.[22]
Advisory status and limits on the court
- Advisory guidelines: under People v Lockridge (2015), as described in the criminal benchbook, the guidelines are advisory only, and since March 24, 2021, MCL 769.34(3) allows a departure that is reasonable when the reasons are stated on the record.[7]
- Review of within-range sentences: as described in the benchbook, People v Posey (2023) held that a within-guidelines sentence is reviewed for reasonableness, with a nonbinding rebuttable presumption of proportionality that the defendant must rebut.[25]
- Two-thirds rule: the court "shall not impose a minimum sentence, including a departure, that exceeds 2/3 of the statutory maximum sentence."[26] For a 5-year (60-month) maximum, two-thirds is 40 months.[26][27]
Habitual offender rules and the retail fraud bar
A prosecutor may seek a habitual offender sentence for a defendant with prior felonies. The maximum term can rise to 1.5 times the normal maximum for a second felony and twice the maximum for a third, and a fourth felony can bring up to life if the new offense carries 5 years or more, or up to 15 years if it carries less.[28] The prosecutor must file written notice within 21 days after arraignment on the information (or after the information is filed, if arraignment is waived), and the judge, not a jury, decides whether the priors exist.[29] Habitual status also raises the upper limit of the guidelines range by 25%, 50% or 100% for a second, third or fourth felony.[30]
Retail fraud has its own limit. If a first-degree retail fraud sentence (MCL 750.356c) is enhanced by prior convictions, those prior convictions "shall not be used to further enhance the sentence" under the habitual offender sections.[31] The larceny statute contains the same bar.[32] The prior convictions page explains when priors raise the degree.
Where this fits in a felony case
Felony sentencing is conducted by a circuit judge, and a presentence report is required first.[33][34] Probation is available for felonies other than a short list of offenses such as murder and armed robbery, for up to 3 years, which the court may extend not more than 2 times by up to 1 year each.[35][36] For the full felony timeline, see what to expect in a felony theft case, the first-degree retail fraud page and the penalties chart. Probation violations, which can lead to resentencing, are covered on the probation violations page.
Common questions
Does a first-degree retail fraud conviction mean prison in Michigan?
The statute allows up to 5 years in prison, but that is a maximum.[27] First-degree retail fraud is a Class E offense, and the Class E grid includes ranges as low as 0 to 3 months.[1][4] When the top of the recommended range is 18 months or less, the statute calls for an intermediate sanction, such as probation, unless the court states reasonable grounds for jail or prison.[22][24] Because the guidelines are advisory, the Court of Appeals has held that a court may, but is no longer required to, impose an intermediate sanction in that situation.[23]
Are the Michigan sentencing guidelines mandatory?
No. Citing People v Lockridge (2015), the criminal benchbook explains that a sentencing court must determine the guidelines range and take it into account, but the guidelines are advisory only.[7] Since 2020 PA 395 took effect on March 24, 2021, the statute provides that a court may depart if the departure is reasonable and the reasons are stated on the record.[7]
Can an old theft conviction still raise the guidelines score?
For prior record variables 1 to 5, a conviction is not used if 10 or more years passed between the discharge date from that conviction and the commission of the next offense that resulted in a conviction.[21] For scoring purposes, "conviction" includes a HYTA assignment and a conviction that was set aside.[21]
Can the prosecutor use the habitual offender law on top of a first-degree charge based on priors?
Not with the same priors. If a first-degree retail fraud sentence is enhanced by one or more prior convictions, those priors "shall not be used to further enhance the sentence" under the habitual offender sections 10, 11 or 12.[31] The larceny statute contains the same rule.[32]
Do thefts that were never charged affect the guidelines?
They can affect offense variable 16. The statute allows the court to consider money or property involved in admitted but uncharged offenses or in charges dismissed under a plea agreement.[6] Offense variable 13 also counts all crimes within a 5-year period, including the sentencing offense, whether or not they resulted in a conviction.[17] Restitution follows a different rule.[15]
Sources
- MCL 777.16r — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.17d — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.21(1)(a)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.66 — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.46(1)(d)-(g) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.46(2)(a), (c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 769.34(3); People v Lockridge, 498 Mich 358 (2015) (as quoted in benchbook) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356d(4) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.16i — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.16z — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.17d; MCL 777.14h — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.19(1), (3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.22(2) — Michigan Legislature
- People v McKinley, 496 Mich 410 (2014) — Caselaw Access Project
- MCL 777.46(1)(a)-(c), (2)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.43(1)(f), MCL 777.43(2)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.52(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.55(1)-(2) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.56(1)(c)-(d), (3)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.50(1), (4)(a) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 769.34(4)(a), (c) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Schrauben, 314 Mich App 181, 195-196 (2016), overruled in part on other grounds by People v Posey, 512 Mich 317 (2023) (as described in the Criminal Proceedings Benchbook, Vol. 3, §1.9) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 769.31(b) — Michigan Legislature
- People v Posey, 512 Mich 317 (2023) (as described in benchbook) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 769.34(2)(b) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 769.10(1)(a); MCL 769.11(1)(a); MCL 769.12(1)(b)-(c) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 769.13(1)-(2), (5) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 777.21(3) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 750.356c(6); People v Eilola, 179 Mich App 315, 325 (1989) (as described in CRIMV2) — Michigan Courts
- MCL 750.356(8), (9) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 600.8311(d)-(f) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 771.14(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 771.1(1) — Michigan Legislature
- MCL 771.2(1) — Michigan Legislature
This page is general legal information about Michigan law, published by the office of Attorney Shawn Haff. It is not legal advice and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts — check the sources linked above and talk to a licensed Michigan attorney about your situation. In an emergency, call 911.